Saeedi v Patterson and Patterson

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
JACOBA PATTERSON (Plaintiffs)
BRISBANE
..DATE 25/05/98
COURT OF APPEAL [1998] QCA 181
PINCUS JA
McPHERSON JA
AMBROSE J
Appeal No 3325 of 1998
MAJID SAEEDI Applicant

(First

Defendant)

and

JOHN PATTERSON and Respondent

JUDGMENT against an order of the District Court made on 13 March 1998. The primary judge dismissed an application for leave to withdraw admissions made by the first defendant's entry of appearance and defence. His Honour also struck out an amended entry of appearance and defence insofar as it did not admit or deny any part of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the plaint and made an order for costs. The action relates to what is alleged to be faulty design and construction of a house built by the first defendant for the plaintiffs. In addition to the first defendant, a number of other parties are joined, including engineers and a local authority. It does not appear to be necessary to deal with the pleadings in detail to determine the question, which is whether leave to appeal should be granted. The dispute concerns the admissions (by the defence) of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the plaint.

It was alleged in paragraph 4 that there were implied terms of the contract to the effect that the design and construction of the dwelling would comply with the relevant laws of Queensland, that the first defendant would exercise due care, skill and diligence in constructing the dwelling and other terms of that sort.

Paragraph 5 which, as Mr Dunning, who appeared for the appellant first defendant, says, really followed on from paragraph 4, said that on certain dates in purported compliance with the terms, including the

2   JUDGMENT

implied terms of the contract, "the first defendant
and/or his servants or agents designed and constructed
the dwelling on the site and for the benefit of the
plaintiffs." The application to withdraw these
admissions was based on an affidavit by the first
defendant, Mr Saeedi, which disclosed that he was sent
the plaint, and later the defence, and he suggested
some alterations in the latter document; he also said
that he was not asked to check the defence against the
plaint and therefore did not understand, so the
affidavit said, that the defence made admissions or the
consequences of those admissions. On the face of it,
this is a little difficult to follow. It is clear that
he read the defence and so he must have seen that it
made admissions; it appears that his then solicitors or
counsel thought the admissions accorded with his
instructions. As for the consequences of the
admissions, it must surely have been evident to the
first defendant that the matters admitted would be no
longer in issue. Mr Dunning pointed out that it
appeared that the first defendant had not again
obtained the plaint to enable him to check the
admissions against the plaint, but it does not appear
to me that this is the fault of the plaintiffs.

The affidavit also asserted that the contract,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Saeedi v Patterson and Patterson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QCA 181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Saeedi v Patterson and Patterson, the appeal was brought against an order made by the District Court on 13 March 1998. The primary judge dismissed an application for leave to withdraw admissions made by the first defendant’s entry of appearance and defence. The appeal pertained to a dispute concerning the alleged faulty design and construction of a house built by the first defendant for the plaintiffs. The legal issue before the court was whether leave to appeal should be granted, specifically focusing on the admissions made in paragraphs 4 and 5 of the plaint. These paragraphs concerned implied terms in the contract for the design and construction of the dwelling, as well as the actions taken by the first defendant in constructing the dwelling.

The first defendant argued that he did not understand the consequences of the admissions made in his defence and sought to withdraw them. However, the court found that the first defendant had read the defence and should have been aware of the admissions made. The affidavit submitted by the first defendant did not provide sufficient detail to justify the sweeping withdrawal of admissions proposed. The primary judge was not satisfied that the making of the admissions was due to any misunderstanding of instructions or erroneous action, and it was not convinced that the withdrawal of the admissions was necessary for the first defendant to litigate matters genuinely in issue. The court held that there was no manifest injustice in the primary judge’s order, and therefore, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed with costs.

The judges unanimously agreed on dismissing the application with costs. The reasoning was that the first defendant’s affidavit lacked the necessary detail to substantiate the claim of misunderstanding or error in the making of the admissions. The court found the primary judge’s decision to be reasonable, and there was no evidence of manifest injustice that would warrant an appeal. The final order was that the application was dismissed with costs, as per the decision of the Court of Appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a dispute over the alleged faulty design and construction of a house built by the first defendant, Majid Saeedi, for the plaintiffs, John Patterson and Jacoba Patterson. The house was built in Brisbane, and the matter was heard in the Court of Appeal. The plaintiffs claimed that the first defendant had made admissions regarding the design and construction of the dwelling, which complied with the relevant laws of Queensland and that the first defendant would exercise due care, skill, and diligence in constructing the dwelling. The first defendant sought to withdraw these admissions, arguing that he did not understand the consequences of the admissions when they were made.

The matter came before the Court of Appeal as an appeal against an order made by the District Court on 13 March 1998. The primary judge dismissed an application for leave to withdraw admissions made by the first defendant's entry of appearance and defence. The primary judge also struck out an amended entry of appearance and defence insofar as it did not admit or deny any part of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the plaint and made an order for costs. The first defendant appealed against the order of the District Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether leave to appeal should be granted against an order of the District Court dismissing an application for leave to withdraw admissions made by the first defendant's entry of appearance and defence.
2. Whether the primary judge erred in striking out an amended entry of appearance and defence insofar as it did not admit or deny any part of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the plaint.
3. Whether the primary judge erred in making an order for costs against the first defendant.

Held
1. The court held that leave to appeal should not be granted against the order of the District Court dismissing the application for leave to withdraw admissions made by the first defendant's entry of appearance and defence.
2. The court held that the primary judge did not err in striking out an amended entry of appearance and defence insofar as it did not admit or deny any part of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the plaint.
3. The court held that the primary judge did not err in making an order for costs against the first defendant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal examined the application for leave to appeal against an order of the District Court which dismissed an application for leave to withdraw admissions made by the first defendant's entry of appearance and defence. The appeal hinged on whether the District Court judge erred in dismissing the application and in striking out the amended entry of appearance and defence. The plaintiffs argued that the first defendant misunderstood the implications of the admissions, but the Court found that the first defendant did not provide sufficient evidence to justify withdrawing the admissions. The Court found that the judge's decision was open to him, and no manifest injustice was evident from the judge's order. Furthermore, the Court held that the primary judge did not err in striking out the amended entry of appearance and defence as it did not admit or deny any part of paragraphs 4 and 5 of the plaint. Lastly, the Court upheld the order for costs made by the primary judge against the first defendant, finding no error in this aspect of the decision. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a party seeking to withdraw admissions in legal proceedings must provide a cogent and detailed explanation for the withdrawal, and the Court will not lightly overturn a primary judge's decision on such matters unless there is manifest injustice.