[2004] QDC 519
DISTRICT COURT
CIVIL JURISDICTION
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No DB2001 of 2003
SVEN TONY HOLST Plaintiff
and
PHILLIP NICHOLS First Defendant
and
FEREL ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
(ACN 095 220 901) Second Defendant
BRISBANE
..DATE 23/11/2004
ORDER
CATCHWORDS: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 188 - application by individual defendant to withdraw admission that he acted on his own behalf (as well as for a company to be formed) - withdrawal permitted (with order for indemnity costs against defendants) as trial was no longer imminent - trial dates and request for trial date had been vacated.
HIS HONOUR: This is an application by the defendants (or the first defendant Mr Nichols at least) to withdraw an admission made in the defendants' pleading of an allegation in Mr Holst's statement of claim to the effect that when Mr Nichols acted he did so on his own behalf as well as on behalf of the defendant company.
The assumption has been that for the moment the company has no or negligible assets which might be available to meet a judgment. It, along with Mr Nichols, mounts a counterclaim which over-tops Mr Holst's claim. The application under rule 188 is for the Court's leave which the rule makes necessary for the withdrawal of that admission.
The consequence of its withdrawal is that the plaintiff will be returned to his original situation of having to prove a personal liability in Mr Nichols and will lose the benefit he has had for some time of an admission in that regard.
The issue was canvassed before me some weeks ago on the eve of trial when application was made by new solicitors on the defence side to vacate trial dates. The former solicitors were exercising a lien on documents.
It appeared to me futile to require the trial to proceed given that it seemed to me that a renewed application for adjournment before the trial Judge would almost certainly be successful.
I fixed new trial dates with a view to getting finalization of the matter which, although important to the parties, considered objectively does not involve enormous amounts of money, except perhaps for legal costs. Unfortunately, the matter could not go ahead. The parties blame each other for that. The likelihood is that the defendants bear a greater responsibility.
Her Honour Judge O'Sullivan on the 2nd of November vacated the trial dates set by me, also the request for trial date. She ordered that the first and second respondents file an application for leave to withdraw admission on or before the 15th of November 2004. When the matter was last before me I had done my best to make it clear that the admission could not be withdrawn except pursuant to leave.
There is no application filed, but I see no reason why the liberty to apply granted by her Honour could not be availed of as it has been. Indeed, the same approach was taken on the 2nd of November 2004 by her Honour utilising…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Holst v Nichols & Ferel Enterprises Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] QDC 519
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered several factors, including the timing of the application and the implications for both parties. The application was made late in the proceedings, and the trial dates had already been vacated. The plaintiff had prepared for the trial based on the assumption that the admission stood, and the court had to balance this against the defendants' right to have their case properly presented. The court also noted that the defendants had not provided any new evidence to support their claim that the admission was made in error. The court referenced several precedents, including Saeedi v Patterson, Cassie v Bogdan, and Ridolfi v Regato Farms Pty Ltd, to frame its decision. Ultimately, the court found that the discretion to allow or refuse the withdrawal of the admission was broad and unfettered, and that the interests of judicial determination of disputes according to their merits should take precedence.
The court granted leave to the defendants to withdraw the admission, recognizing that the trial was no longer imminent and that the plaintiff had been induced to organize his affairs based on the assumption that the admission stood. To compensate the plaintiff for the disruption and wasted effort, the court ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiff's costs of the application and the costs occasioned by the withdrawal of the admission on an indemnity basis. This means that the defendants are liable for the plaintiff's legal costs associated with the application and the costs incurred due to the withdrawal of the admission, reflecting the court's view that the plaintiff should not bear the burden of the defendants' late application.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case has a history of delays, adjournments, and changes in legal representation. The plaintiff had previously been advantaged by the defendants' admission, but this benefit was lost when the trial was vacated. The first defendant, Nichols, argues that he did not understand the admission when it was made and that it was intended that the Team be operated through a corporate structure. The Court considered the broad and unfettered discretion it has in such matters, as well as the principle that the interests of the judicial determination of disputes according to their merits should be prioritised. The Court ultimately decided to grant the defendants' application to withdraw the admission, as the trial was no longer imminent, and ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiff's costs of the application and the costs occasioned by the withdrawal of the admission on an indemnity basis.
The matter before the Court is an application by the first defendant, Mr Phillip Nichols, and the second defendant, Ferel Enterprises Pty Ltd, to withdraw an admission made in their pleadings that Mr Nichols acted on his own behalf as well as for the company when certain actions were taken. This application arises out of a larger dispute between the plaintiff, Sven Tony Holst, and the defendants. The application is governed by rule 188 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, which necessitates leave from the Court to withdraw an admission. This application follows the vacating of trial dates and a request for trial date by Her Honour Judge O'Sullivan on 2nd November 2004, who also ordered the defendants to file an application for leave to withdraw the admission by 15th November 2004. The matter was stood down to allow Mr Nichols to attend and provide evidence in the form of an affidavit, which was cross-examined by the plaintiff's counsel. The Court considered relevant authorities, including Chesterman J's decision in Cassie v Bogdan, which permitted the withdrawal of an admission despite it being made at a late stage. The Court ultimately acceded to the application, allowing the defendants to withdraw the admission, but ordered the first defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of the application and the costs occasioned by the withdrawal of the admission on an indemnity basis.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court should grant the defendants' application to withdraw an admission under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 188.
2. Whether the withdrawal of the admission should be permitted given that the trial was no longer imminent.
3. How to appropriately recompense the plaintiff for the loss of the benefit of the admission.
4. Whether the costs of the application and the costs occasioned by withdrawal of the admission should be awarded on an indemnity basis.
Held
1. Whether the Court should grant the defendants' application to withdraw an admission under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 188.
The Court granted the defendants' application to withdraw the admission, allowing them to no longer be bound by the admission made in the pleadings.
2. Whether the withdrawal of the admission should be permitted given that the trial was no longer imminent.
The Court permitted the withdrawal of the admission as the trial was no longer imminent, and the plaintiff had been induced to organize his affairs based on the admission.
3. How to appropriately recompense the plaintiff for the loss of the benefit of the admission.
The Court left the issue of recompense to be determined by the parties' representatives and the Court, suggesting that it would usually be addressed through costs orders.
4. Whether the costs of the application and the costs occasioned by withdrawal of the admission should be awarded on an indemnity basis.
The Court awarded the costs of the application and the costs occasioned by the withdrawal of the admission on an indemnity basis under rule 704.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Queensland District Court, in Holst v Nichols & Ferel Enterprises Pty Ltd, granted the defendants' application to withdraw an admission under Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r 188. The primary issue was whether the Court should allow the defendants to retract an admission made by the first defendant, Mr. Nichols, that he acted on his own behalf as well as for the defendant company. The Court considered the application against the backdrop of the trial being no longer imminent and the potential repercussions for the plaintiff, Mr. Holst.
The Court acknowledged that the admission, if withdrawn, would require the plaintiff to prove Mr. Nichols' personal liability, an advantage he had previously enjoyed. The defendants argued that the admission was made in error, and they sought to retract it on the grounds that the trial was no longer imminent. The Court recognized that the discretion to allow or refuse withdrawal of an admission is broad and usually not disturbed on appeal, as underscored in cases like Ridolfi v Regato Farms Pty Ltd and Cassie v Bogdan. The Court also referred to Queensland v JL Holdings Pty Ltd, which emphasizes the importance of judicial determination of disputes according to their merits over procedural efficiency.
In assessing the application, the Court scrutinized the timing of the application and the potential prejudice to the plaintiff. The Court concluded that since the trial was no longer imminent, the factor of an impending trial did not hold the same weight. The plaintiff had organized his affairs and planned for the trial based on the admission, and the withdrawal would induce him to reorganize. However, the Court found that there was sufficient time for the plaintiff to regroup and that the Court could devise ways to compensate for any harm caused, typically through costs orders.
Regarding the appropriate recompense for the plaintiff, the Court noted that the plaintiff had been induced to organize his affairs based on the admission. Given that the trial was no longer imminent, the Court believed there was time for the plaintiff to regroup and that the costs mechanism would usually address any harm caused. The Court also ordered that the costs of the application and the costs occasioned by the withdrawal of the admission be awarded on an indemnity basis, aligning with rule 704.
In sum, the Court permitted the withdrawal of the admission, emphasizing the broad discretion afforded to Judges in such matters and the importance of judicial determination of disputes according to their merits. The Court also awarded indemnity costs to the plaintiff, reflecting the impact of the withdrawal on the plaintiff's preparation and the need to compensate for any incurred harm.