S.P.I. Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No. 6)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

S.P.I. Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No. 6) [2008] FCA 710

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) ss 44, 58, 106
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats (2001) 208 CLR 199 cited
Federal Commissioner of Taxation v United Aircraft Corporation (1943) 68 CLR 525 cited
SPI Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No. 4) [2007] FCA 1025 cited

S.P.I. SPIRITS (CYPRUS) LIMITED and SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL B.V. v DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED and FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT; FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT and FEDERAL PUBLIC UNITARY ENTERPRISES EXTERNAL ECONOMIC UNION SOJUZPLODOIMPORT (FGUP VO) v SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL B.V. and DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED

NSD 1816 OF 2004

EDMONDS J
22 MAY 2008
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1816 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

AND:

S.P.I. SPIRITS (CYPRUS) LIMITED
First Applicant

SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL B.V.
Second Applicant

DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED
First Respondent

FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT
Second Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

AND:

FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT
First Cross-Claimant

FEDERAL PUBLIC UNITARY ENTERPRISES EXTERNAL ECONOMIC UNION SOJUZPLODOIMPORT (FGUP VO)
Second Cross-Claimant

SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL B.V.
First Cross-Respondent

DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED
Second Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE OF ORDER:

22 MAY 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The motion by notice dated and filed 21 February 2008 for orders including an order that the cross-claimants have leave to file a Second Further Amended Cross-Claim in the form identified in Ex. 1 be dismissed.

2.The cross-claimants pay the applicants’ costs of the motion.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1816 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

S.P.I. SPIRITS (CYPRUS) LIMITED
First Applicant

SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL B.V.
Second Applicant

DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED
First Respondent

FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT
Second Respondent

AND:

FEDERAL TREASURY ENTERPRISE (FKP) SOJUZPLODOIMPORT
First Cross-Claimant

FEDERAL PUBLIC UNITARY ENTERPRISES EXTERNAL ECONOMIC UNION SOJUZPLODOIMPORT (FGUP VO)
Second Cross-Claimant

SPIRITS INTERNATIONAL B.V.
First Cross-Respondent

DIAGEO AUSTRALIA LIMITED
Second Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE:

22 MAY 2008

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
(ON NOTICE OF MOTION)

INTRODUCTION

  1. On 1 April 2008, I heard a motion by notice dated and filed 21 February 2008 for orders including an order that the first and second cross-claimants (collectively ‘FKP’) have leave to file and serve a Second Further Amended Cross-Claim (‘SFACC’) in the form identified in the affidavit of Paul Gerard O’Shanassy sworn 21 February 2008 (Ex. 1 – ‘the draft SFACC’).  If granted, this would have the effect of inserting paras [60] to [77] into the substantive pleading in the Further Amended Cross-Claim (‘FACC’) and of inserting paras 4A to 4C into the prayers for relief in the FACC.  In summary, FKP seeks leave to amend the FACC so as to essentially incorporate a constructive trust claim in respect of the trade mark applications referred to in [7] below.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The trade marks that are the subject of this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read S.P.I. Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No. 6) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 710
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case S.P.I. Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd v Diageo Australia Ltd (No. 6) involves a dispute between S.P.I. Spirits (Cyprus) Ltd and Diageo Australia Ltd over trade marks, specifically those incorporating the words STOLICHNAYA, STOLI, or MOSKOVSKAYA. The plaintiffs, S.P.I. Spirits, seek to establish their ownership of these trade marks and challenge the claims of Diageo Australia Ltd and its predecessor, VAO-SPI, which asserts its own succession in title to the original entity, Sojuzplodoimport. The dispute also includes a claim regarding trade mark applications made by Diageo Australia Ltd and its related company. The legal issues before the court include the validity of the trade mark ownership claims and the enforceability of a constructive trust over the trade mark applications.

The court was required to determine whether the cross-claimants, S.P.I. Spirits, had the right to amend their cross-claim to include a constructive trust over the trade mark applications. This required consideration of whether such a trust could legally exist over the applications themselves, rather than just the trade marks they sought to register. The court also had to assess the practicality and enforceability of the proposed relief, such as the assignment of trade mark applications, in light of statutory provisions and common law principles.

The court concluded that the proposed amended pleading was flawed because it was arguable that no property existed in the trade mark applications themselves. This was a critical factor in dismissing the motion, as the entire constructive trust claim and the corresponding prayers for relief were based on the existence of such property. Furthermore, the court noted that statutory provisions do not allow for the assignment of trade mark applications, which undermined the feasibility of the relief sought. Therefore, the court found sufficient grounds to dismiss the motion and deny the requested leave to amend the cross-claim.

The court ordered that the motion by notice dated and filed 21 February 2008 for leave to file a Second Further Amended Cross-Claim be dismissed. Additionally, the cross-claimants were ordered to pay the applicants’ costs of the motion.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The motion by notice dated and filed 21 February 2008 for orders including an order that the cross-claimants have leave to file a Second Further Amended Cross-Claim in the form identified in Ex. 1 be dismissed.

2. The cross-claimants pay the applicants’ costs of the motion.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 1 April 2008, I heard a motion by notice dated and filed 21 February 2008 for orders including an order that the first and second cross-claimants (collectively ‘FKP’) have leave to file and serve a Second Further Amended Cross-Claim (‘SFACC’) in the form identified in the affidavit of Paul Gerard O’Shanassy sworn 21 February 2008 (Ex. 1 – ‘the draft SFACC’). If granted, this would have the effect of inserting paras [60] to [77] into the substantive pleading in the Further Amended Cross-Claim (‘FACC’) and of inserting paras 4A to 4C into the prayers for relief in the FACC. In summary, FKP seeks leave to amend the FACC so as to essentially incorporate a constructive trust claim in respect of the trade mark applications referred to in [7] below.BACKGROUND The trade marks that are the subject of this proceeding are set out in Annexure A to the FACC. They include trade marks (registered in the name of Spirits) comprising or incorporating the words STOLICHNAYA, STOLI or MOSKOVSKAYA, referred to in the pleadings as the Stolichnaya Label Mark, the Stolichnaya Word Mark, the Stoli Word Mark, the Ohranj Label Mark, the Ohranj Word Mark, the Blue Salyt Mark, the Moskovskaya Label Mark and the Moskovskaya Word Mark (‘the currently disputed marks’). The primary relief sought in respect of the currently disputed marks is a declaration that one or the other of FKP is the owner of such marks and the recordal of that cross-claimant as the registered owner of those trade marks: prayers 2 and 3 of the FACC. In general terms, the claim to ownership by one or the other of FKP rests upon proving the falsity of the claim made by the second applicant’s (‘Spirits’’) predecessor in title, referred to in the pleadings as VAO-SPI, that it was the successor in title to the entity referred to in the pleadings as Sojuzplodoimport: paras [13], [14], [21] – [27] and [32] – [39] of the FACC. Spirits, in its Defence to the FACC dated 16 September 2005, supports the claim made by VAO-SPI that it was the successor in title to Sojuzplodoimport. Spirits also alleges, further or in the alternative, that it took the relevant trade marks as a bona fide purchaser for value without notice of any wrongdoing by VAO-SPI: [63], [64] and [65] of the FACC. The latter allegation is traversed generally by para [18] of FKP’s Reply dated 12 August 2005. Between 7 August 2002 and 22 September 2006, Spirits made trade mark applications, or via its related company, Spirits Intellectual Property BV, requests for extension to Australia of the protection resulting from the international registration of trade marks, as set out in Annexure B to the SFACC, numbering eighteen in total (‘trade mark applications’). All the trade mark applications incorporate the words STOLI, STOLICHNAYA or MOSKOVSKAYA and are presently proceeding in the name of Spirits. Fifteen of the trade mark applications (Nos. 932465, 932471, 934031, 1111247, 1122391, 1122393, 1122394, 1122406, 1122410, 1122496, 1122497, 1137290, 1137291, 1137285 and 1137288) have been examined and accepted by the Registrar of Trade Marks and subsequently opposed by FKP. Three are still under examination (Nos. 1074353, 1164631 and 1078834).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

EDMONDS J
That, in my view, would be sufficient to reject the amendment – no other basis of the constructive trust claim is relied on – and dismiss the motion; there is a further difficulty with the amended pleading, which, on its own, would not persuade me to reject it, but which reinforces the view I have reached. It is strongly arguable there is no property in the trade mark applications, as distinct from the trade marks the subject of the applications, and the amended pleadings (claiming a constructive trust in the trade mark applications) and prayers for relief (seeking a declaration of constructive trust in respect of, and orders for the assignment of right title and interest in, the trade mark applications) are predicated on the subsistence of property in the trade mark applications. So much is implicit in the declaration sought in proposed prayer 4A and the orders sought in proposed prayers 4B and 4C. Indeed, arguably, prayer 4B is incapable of performance because while subs 106(1) of the Act provides that ‘a trade mark whose registration is being sought may be assigned with or without the goodwill associated with that trade mark’ (compare the position at common law); the Act does not contemplate the assignment of trade mark applications. The fact that a s 106 assignment may permit the assignee to prosecute the application for registration begs the point.CONCLUSION As already indicated, there were at least two other grounds upon which the proposed amended pleading was opposed. On the view I take, it is not necessary to consider these. The motion must be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EDMONDS J