S & a Gallo Pty Ltd v Hollowood Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

S & A GALLO PTY LTD & ORS v HOLLOWOOD PTY LTD & ORS

[2012] SASC 176

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

3 October 2012

MAGISTRATES - APPEALS AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - POWERS AND PRACTICE OF COURT ON HEARING - POINT NOT RAISED IN COURT BELOW

EQUITY - EQUITABLE REMEDIES - INJUNCTIONS - INTERLOCUTORY INJUNCTIONS - SERIOUS QUESTION TO BE TRIED

LANDLORD AND TENANT - RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL TENANCIES LEGISLATION

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - RULES OF CONSTRUCTION

This is an appeal from an order of a Magistrate dismissing the appellant’s application for interlocutory relief. The appellant is the lessee of shop premises in a shopping centre. The respondent companies are the lessors. The appellant fell substantially behind in payment of rent and other outgoings. The respondents threatened to terminate the lease and re-enter the premises. The appellant thereupon filed an application in the Magistrates Court seeking urgent interlocutory relief to maintain the status quo and enjoin the respondents from taking those steps. The Magistrate dismissed the interlocutory application on the basis that the appellant had failed to establish that there was a serious issue to be tried. It was from this decision that the appellant appealed to this Court.

During the hearing of the appeal, the appellant sought leave to amend the notice of appeal to raise for the first time that s38(1)(d) of the Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (“the Act”) operated to imply, in its lease, an obligation upon the respondents in the terms of that sub-section which obligation had not been observed by the respondents, thus giving rise to an entitlement in the appellant to claim compensation and an equitable set-off. The substantive claims otherwise relied on by the appellant in the Magistrates Court were abandoned.

Whether leave to amend the notice of appeal should be granted at such a late stage – whether the appellant has demonstrated a prima facie case to justify the preservation of the status quo pending trial – whether s38(1)(d) of the Act entitles the appellant, in the circumstances of the case, to make a claim for compensation against the respondents – whether a claim under s38(1)(d) of the Act would give rise to an equitable set off in favour of the appellant.

Held – appeal dismissed – the appellant’s oral application for leave to amend its notice of appeal refused – the appellant failed to establish a prima facie case pursuant to s38(1)(d) in the sense of a sufficient likelihood of success at trial – leave to amend at such a late stage if granted likely to cause significant prejudice to the respondents – the proposed amendment lacks utility because the appellant’s reliance on s38(1)(d) of the Act has no reasonable foundation – unnecessary in the circumstances of this case to consider balance of convenience factors.

Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) s68, s37, s38, s39, s40,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read S & a Gallo Pty Ltd v Hollowood Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 176
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of S & A Gallo Pty Ltd v Hollowood Pty Ltd, the primary dispute involves the interpretation and application of statutory provisions and equitable principles within the context of a landlord-tenant relationship. The matter was initially heard in the South Australian Magistrates Court and subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court of South Australia. The central issue before the court was whether the lessee could rely on a specific section of the Retail and Commercial Tenancies Act to establish a prima facie case for an interlocutory injunction. This injunction would have preserved the status quo pending a full trial.

The legal issues revolved around the interpretation of statutory language, specifically section 38(1)(d) of the Retail and Commercial Tenancies Act, and the application of equitable principles to determine if the lessee had demonstrated a serious question to be tried. The court needed to decide whether the lessee had shown a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits of its claim to justify the preservation of the status quo. Additionally, the court considered whether the lessee's reliance on this section was reasonable and whether the lessors had taken all reasonable steps as required by the statute.

The court concluded that the lessee's reliance on section 38(1)(d) was not founded on reasonable grounds and that it did not provide a valid basis for an interlocutory injunction. The lessee failed to establish a prima facie case that the lessors had failed to take all reasonable steps, thereby negating the likelihood of success at trial. The court also noted that the balance of convenience did not support granting the interlocutory relief. Furthermore, the court refused leave to amend the notice of appeal, reasoning that it would cause significant prejudice to the lessors and that the amendment would be futile given the evidentiary basis presented by the lessee. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Another difficulty would confront the lessee even in the event that the cause of action for compensation pursuant to s38 were available to it in the circumstances of this case. The lessors maintain that the affidavit evidence to this point is not sufficient to demonstrate a prima facie case to the effect that any equitable set off, if available, would be sufficient to exhaust the lessors’ otherwise uncontested claim for unpaid rent and outgoings. If so, a right to terminate and re-enter would still be available to the lessors. Given the conclusions I have reached, based on my reasons to this point, it is not necessary that I consider this matter any further.Conclusion I am satisfied that the lessee’s reliance on ss38(1)(d) of the Act is without any reasonable foundation. In my view, the sub-section does not operate, in the circumstances, to give the lessee a cause of action. Furthermore, and in any event, on the evidence available to this point, the lessee has not established a prima facie case that the lessors would be found to have failed “to take all reasonable steps” as required by ss38(1)(d). As ss38(1)(d) is the only basis on which interlocutory relief is claimed, the lessee has failed to establish a prima facie case in the sense of a sufficient likelihood of success at trial to justify the preservation of the status quo pending trial. Given this finding, it is unnecessary that I consider balance of convenience issues in any detail. On any analysis, given my findings as to the prima facie case issue, the balance of convenience in this case cannot support the granting of interlocutory relief. I recognise that it is less usual to refuse an application such as this on the prima facie case basis rather than on the balance of convenience basis. And, that a court, at the interlocutory stage, should avoid speculating about a party’s prospects of ultimately succeeding after a final hearing on all issues. Usually it is not possible for a Judge hearing such an interlocutory application to come to a firm view about a party’s prospects of success. However, there are occasions where such a firm view can be reached and, in my view, this is one of them.[47][47] See generally, for example, Chrisanthos Kostopoulos v GE Commercial Finance Australia Pty Ltd [2005] QCA 311 at [65]-[70] (Keane JA with whom McMurdo P and Dutney J agreed; remarks given in the context of an application for stay of execution of judgment pending appeal). Leave to amend the notice of appeal should be refused and for two reasons. First, to allow it at this late stage is likely to cause significant prejudice to the lessors. It could only be allowed on the assumption that the lessee would make out a prima facie case with respect to ss38(1)(d). If so, the lessors would have been prejudiced in their efforts to resist such a claim on a factual basis. Second, and in any event, the application for leave to amend lacks utility because on the evidentiary basis put forward by the lessee its reliance on ss38(1)(d) has no prospect of success. As a result, the appeal itself should also be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.