Khao Thai Pty Ltd v Coles Myer Properties Holdings Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

CITATION: Khao Thai Pty Ltd -v- Coles Myer Properties Holdings Limited [2001] NSWADT 83
DIVISION: Retail Leases Division
PARTIES: APPLICANT
Khao Thai Pty Ltd
RESPONDENT
Coles Myer Properties Holdings Ltd
FILE NUMBER: 005024
HEARING DATES: 19 - 23/03/01, 5 - 6/04/01
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 04/06/2001
DATE OF DECISION:
05/21/2001
BEFORE: Donald B - Judicial Member
APPLICATION: Claim for declaration of rights, obligations and liabilities under a lease - Claim for payment of money - Claim for relief from payment of money
MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter
LEGISLATION CITED: Retail Leases Act 1994
CASES CITED: Taylor Farms v Kalcos (1999) BC 9900793
Waltons Stores Ltd v. Maher (1988) 76 ALR 513
Prasad v Fairfield City Council (2001) NSWADT 28
REPRESENTATION: APPLICANT
C Leggatt barrister
RESPONDENT
J Simpkins SC
ORDERS: 1. Declare that from November/December 1999, Coles Myer has not complied with its obligation under the lease to Khao Thai of Shop 24LP Sydney Central Plaza not to have more than one operator of Thai and Malaysian food in the Sydney Central Plaza Food Court.; 2. Declare that Khao Thai is obliged under the lease to pay outstanding Rent, Food Court Operating Costs and Marketing Fund Contributions (if any) and to continue paying those items.; 3. By consent declare that for so long as the current tax ruling remains applicable to the lease, the lessee is not obliged to pay GST in respect of the payments under the lease the subject of the ruling.; 4.Liberty to apply for further orders resulting from determinations in these reasons including orders as to damages and costs.; 5. Applications by each party otherwise dismissed.

1 Coles Myer owns the building now known as Sydney Central Plaza in the heart of the Pitt Street Mall retail shopping area of the Sydney CBD. The Food Court in the lower ground floor is probably one of the biggest and busiest in Sydney and NSW. Khao Thai leases a take-away food shop in the Food Court of Sydney Central Plaza. Coles Myer and Khao Thai are in an extensive and protracted dispute concerning the lease between them.

2 The dispute falls into three general areas:-

        (a) Khao Thai's claim that in breach of its rights, Coles Myer has permitted more than one operator of Thai and Malaysian food in the Food Court,
        (b) Coles Myer's claim for Turnover Rent and damages in relation to Khao Thai's failure to have kept proper records.
        (c) Khao Thai's claim for relief in relation to certain alleged financial obligations under the Lease.

3 Pursuant to my obligation under s.74 of the Act, I encouraged the parties during the hearing to use their best endeavours to settle the dispute having regard to my initial rulings and my observations during the hearing. Regrettably they were unable to reach agreement so it falls to the Tribunal to adjudicate the matter.

Chronological findings of fact

4 In November 1996 Mr. Thompson, the principal of Khao Thai, approached Coles Myer to begin negotiations for a tenancy in the proposed Food…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Khao Thai Pty Ltd v Coles Myer Properties Holdings Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWADT 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Khao Thai Pty Ltd brought an action against Coles Myer Properties Holdings Ltd in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, seeking a declaration that Coles Myer had breached the terms of a lease agreement by allowing more than one operator of Thai and Malaysian food in the Sydney Central Plaza Food Court, contrary to the lease's terms. Khao Thai also sought an order that it was obliged to continue paying rent, food court operating costs, and marketing fund contributions. Coles Myer, on the other hand, argued that the lease was terminated by a notice to terminate issued by Khao Thai, and that Khao Thai was not entitled to any relief.

The court had to determine whether Coles Myer had breached the lease by allowing more than one operator of Thai and Malaysian food in the Sydney Central Plaza Food Court. The court also had to determine whether Khao Thai was still bound by the lease's obligations, including the payment of rent, food court operating costs, and marketing fund contributions. Finally, the court had to determine whether Khao Thai was entitled to any relief, including damages or costs.

The court found that Coles Myer had breached the lease by allowing more than one operator of Thai and Malaysian food in the Sydney Central Plaza Food Court. The court also found that Khao Thai was still bound by the lease's obligations, including the payment of rent, food court operating costs, and marketing fund contributions. The court found that Khao Thai was not entitled to any relief, including damages or costs, as the lease had been terminated by a notice to terminate issued by Khao Thai. The court also found that for so long as the current tax ruling remains applicable to the lease, the lessee is not obliged to pay GST in respect of the payments under the lease the subject of the ruling. Liberty to apply for further orders resulting from determinations in these reasons including orders as to damages and costs was granted. Applications by each party otherwise dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Declare that from November/December 1999, Coles Myer has not complied with its obligation under the lease to Khao Thai of Shop 24LP Sydney Central Plaza not to have more than one operator of Thai and Malaysian food in the Sydney Central Plaza Food Court.; 2. Declare that Khao Thai is obliged under the lease to pay outstanding Rent, Food Court Operating Costs and Marketing Fund Contributions (if any) and to continue paying those items.; 3. By consent declare that for so long as the current tax ruling remains applicable to the lease, the lessee is not obliged to pay GST in respect of the payments under the lease the subject of the ruling.; 4.Liberty to apply for further orders resulting from determinations in these reasons including orders as to damages and costs.; 5. Applications by each party otherwise dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established