HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Gibbs A.C.J., Stephen, Jacobs, Murphy and Aickin JJ.
RYDE MUNICIPAL COUNCIL v. MACQUARIE UNIVERSITY
19 December 1978
Local Government (N.S.W.)
Local Government (N.S.W.)—Rating—Exemption—Land vested in University used or occupied by it solely for its purposes—Land used or occupied by charity for its purposes—Building in University grounds let to shopkeepers—Convenience to staff and students of University—Whether building used by University or by charity—Whether use solely for the purposes of University—Local Government Act, 1919 (N.S.W.), s. 132.
Decisions
Dec. 19.
The following written judgments were delivered: -
GIBBS A.C.J. The respondent, Macquarie University, obtained from Waddell J. in the Supreme Court of New South Wales a declaration that certain land, which forms part of the land owned by the University and on which the University is situated, is not ratable under the Local Government Act, 1919 (N.S.W.), as amended ("the Act"). An appeal to the Court of Appeal was dismissed by a majority. The appellant, Ryde Municipal Council, now appeals to this Court by special leave. (at p635)
2. The grounds of the University extend over an area of some 336 acres. The land in question, known as the market, is more or less at the centre of that larger area and has a frontage to the north-western corner of the University court of approximately 202 ft. by a depth of about 72 ft. From the time when the University was first planned, it was intended that there should be a section of the University devoted to commercial and shopping facilities, and in order to achieve this object the land was made available to the Macquarie University Union, an association of members of the council, staff, graduates and students of the University. The objects of the Union include the promotion of the welfare of the University and the provision and maintenance for its members of a common meeting ground and social centre and such other facilities as may be necessary to secure the further objects of the Union. A two-level building was constructed on the subject land; this was done by the Union with the authority of the council of the University, and the construction was financed by a loan to the union which the University guaranteed. Thereafter, parts of the building were leased to various tenants. The leases were not put in evidence, but it appears that they were granted by the Union with the approval of the council. In the circumstances, it is not material whether the University itself let the premises or consented to the Union doing so. The tenants carry on business in the leased areas for various commercial purposes - there is a co-operative bookshop, a retail shop, a chemist shop, an office leased to the Australian Union of Students for the purposes of a travel centre, branches of two banks, a handicrafts and gift shop and an area occupied by the University Sports Association which also includes a shop. The shops operate with a view to profit but…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ryde Municipal council v Macquarie University and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1978] HCA 58
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the land occupied by the University was used exclusively for the purposes of a public hospital, a public charitable institution, or a public place of worship, thereby entitling it to an exemption from council rates under the relevant provisions of the *Local Government Act 1919* (NSW). Specifically, the Court had to determine the scope and application of the exemption provisions to land used for educational purposes by a university.
The High Court considered the nature of the University and its activities, noting that while it provided educational services, these were not exclusively for the purposes of a public hospital, charitable institution, or place of worship. The Court applied the principle of statutory interpretation that exemptions from taxation or rating are to be construed strictly. It was held that the University's land was not used exclusively for any of the specified exempt purposes, and therefore, the University was not entitled to the rate exemption. The appeal by the Council was allowed.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the High Court of Australia as an appeal by special leave from the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Initially, Macquarie University sought a declaration in the Supreme Court of New South Wales that certain land on its campus was not ratable under the Local Government Act, 1919 (N.S.W.). The Supreme Court granted the declaration, which was then appealed by Ryde Municipal Council to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal by a majority, leading to the current appeal by special leave to the High Court. Key procedural steps include the original application in the Supreme Court, the subsequent appeal to the Court of Appeal, and the current appeal to the High Court. The main issue revolves around the interpretation of the statutory exemption for land used or occupied by Macquarie University solely for its purposes.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the land in question is exempt from rates under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Local Government Act, 1919 (N.S.W.) as land used by Macquarie University solely for its purposes.
2. If so, whether the land in question is also exempt from rates under s. 132(1)(d) of the Act as land belonging to a public charity and used or occupied by the charity for its purposes.
3. Whether the term "solely" in s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act refers to the exclusive use by the University or the exclusive use for the University's purposes.
4. Whether the land in question is used by the University solely for its purposes under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
5. Whether the land in question is used for the purposes of the University within the meaning of s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
6. Whether the use of the land in question by the University is solely for its purposes under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
Held
1. Whether the land in question is exempt from rates under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Local Government Act, 1919 (N.S.W.) as land used by Macquarie University solely for its purposes.
- The Court concluded that the land in question is exempt from rates under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
2. If so, whether the land in question is also exempt from rates under s. 132(1)(d) of the Act as land belonging to a public charity and used or occupied by the charity for its purposes.
- The Court concluded that it is unnecessary to consider this issue since the land was found to be exempt under s. 132(1)(fii).
3. Whether the term "solely" in s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act refers to the exclusive use by the University or the exclusive use for the University's purposes.
- The Court concluded that the term "solely" refers to the exclusive use for the University's purposes.
4. Whether the land in question is used by the University solely for its purposes under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
- The Court concluded that the land in question is used by the University solely for its purposes under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
5. Whether the land in question is used for the purposes of the University within the meaning of s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
- The Court concluded that the land in question is used for the purposes of the University within the meaning of s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
6. Whether the use of the land in question by the University is solely for its purposes under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
- The Court concluded that the use of the land in question by the University is solely for its purposes under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the case of Ryde Municipal Council v Macquarie University, the High Court of Australia considered whether certain land owned by Macquarie University was exempt from rates under the Local Government Act, 1919 (N.S.W.). The court had to address several issues to determine the applicability of the statutory exemptions.
First, the court examined whether the land in question was exempt from rates under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Local Government Act as land used by Macquarie University solely for its purposes. The court interpreted the term "solely" in s. 132(1)(fii) as referring to the exclusive use for the University's purposes rather than the exclusive use by the University itself. The court held that the land was used by the University solely for its purposes as it provided facilities for staff and students, which facilitated the carrying out of the University's principal objects.
Second, the court considered whether the land was also exempt from rates under s. 132(1)(d) of the Act as land belonging to a public charity and used or occupied by the charity for its purposes. The court found that the land was not occupied or used by the University for its purposes, and therefore, this exemption was not available.
Third, the court determined whether the use of the land by the University was solely for its purposes under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Act. The court held that the University's purpose in providing commercial and shopping facilities on campus was not the deriving of rental income but rather the provision of facilities for staff and students. The receipt of rent by the University was considered incidental to the use of the land for the purposes of the University.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that land used by a university solely for its purposes under s. 132(1)(fii) of the Local Government Act, 1919 (N.S.W.) includes land made available for use by others for a particular purpose, even if the land is occupied by tenants. The court distinguished the present case from situations where the primary use of the land is to derive rental income, holding that incidental benefits such as rental income do not disqualify the land from being considered used solely for the purposes of the University.
The court followed the principle that a university's provision of facilities for its students and staff, even if conducted through leasing arrangements, can be considered a use of the land for the purposes of the University. This interpretation aligns with the broader purpose of universities to provide educational facilities and promote scholarship. The court departed from prior authority that held that leasing land for commercial purposes disqualifies it from being considered used solely for the purposes of a university, finding that such uses can be incidental to and promote the primary use of the land for university purposes.