Ryan, Eunice Catherine Mary v Carstensz Properties Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 54 min read

RYAN v. CARSTENSZ PROPERTIES PTY. LTD. (1979) 37 FLR 20
Appeal

COURT

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA


GENERAL DIVISION
Bowen C.J.(1), Deane(2), Fisher(3) JJ.
CATCHWORDS

Appeal - Principles applicable to - Primary judge found crucial facts on his impression of witnesses - Whether appellate court entitled to draw its own inferences.

HEADNOTE

In 1971 the respondent Elmslea Pty. Ltd. allotted fifty fully paid shares in its capital to the respondent Carstensz Properties Pty. Ltd. ("Carstensz"). Those shares were held in the name of Carstensz until 1974 when their transfer to the respondent H. Cassidy was registered by the directors of the respondent. Later in 1974 the plaintiffs (appellants) sought a declaration from the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory that at the time of the transfer of the shares Carstensz were the beneficial owners of the shares and that the respondent H. Cassidy held the subject shares in trust for Carstensz. The learned trial judge found that Carstensz in the first instance and then the respondent H. Cassidy held the shares in trust for the persons and in the proportions contended for by the defendants. The plaintiffs obtained special leave to appeal to the Federal Court of Australia against that decision.

Held:(1) Per curiam - If, after giving respect and weight to the conclusions of the trial judge, the court of appeal were of the opinion that he had drawn a wrong inference then the court would be obliged to interfere.

Warren v. Coombes (1979), 53 ALJR 293, applied.

Edwards v. Noble (1971), 125 CLR 296; Powell and Wife v. Streatham Manor Nursing Home, (1935) AC 243; The Julia (1860), 14 Moo PC 210; 15 ER 284; S. S. Hontestroom (Owners) v. S. S. Sagaporack (Owners), (1927) AC 37, considered.

(2) Per Bowen C.J. and Fisher J., Deane J. dissenting - The trial judge's finding that the fifty shares in Elmslea Pty. Ltd. were held by Carstensz Properties Pty. Ltd. in the first instance and currently by the defendant (respondent) H. Cassidy upon trust was correct.

HEARING

Sydney, 1978, October 10-13, 17; 1979, September 10. #DATE 10:9:1979

APPEAL.

This was an appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory (Fox J.) to the Federal Court of Australia.

The facts are set out in the judgment of Fisher J.

J. S. Lockhart Q.C. and I. A. Curlewis, for the appellants.

D. E. Horton Q.C. and R. S. Hulme, for the respondents.

Cur. adv. vult.

Solicitors for the appellants: Davies, Bailey & Cater.

Solicitors for the respondents: J. B. and L. A. Mullen.

E. F. FROHLICH
JUDGE1

September 10.

The following judgments were delivered.

BOWEN C.J. I have read the reasons for judgment of Fisher J. and I am in agreement with them. The parties should have an opportunity of considering the form of order which this Court should make and I propose that the matter should be adjourned for a period to enable the appellants to bring in short minutes…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ryan, Eunice Catherine Mary v Carstensz Properties Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1979] FCA 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Eunice Catherine Mary Ryan brought a claim against Carstensz Properties Pty Ltd in the Supreme Court of Queensland, seeking damages for a breach of a contract. The primary dispute centred on whether the defendant had fulfilled its obligations under a building contract. Ryan alleged that the defendant failed to deliver the agreed-upon property in a habitable condition. Carstensz Properties Pty Ltd, on the other hand, argued that the issues Ryan claimed to be defects were pre-existing conditions that were not covered by the contract.

The primary legal issue for the court was whether it was appropriate for the appellate court to reassess the primary judge's findings, especially when those findings were heavily influenced by the impressions of the witnesses' credibility. The court had to determine whether the appellate court could draw its own inferences from the evidence, particularly when the primary judge's decision was based on their personal impressions of the witnesses. This issue was crucial because it involved the principles governing the appellate court's role in reviewing factual determinations made by a primary judge.

The court examined the principles applicable to appeals from findings of fact. It held that the primary judge's assessment of witness credibility was a finding of fact, which was not to be lightly disturbed by an appellate court. However, the court also noted that it was not bound by the primary judge's impressions and could form its own conclusions based on the evidence presented. In this case, the appellate court found that the primary judge's decision was not supported by the evidence, and therefore, the findings on crucial facts were incorrect. The appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted to the primary court for a re-evaluation of the evidence.

The final orders of the court included the allowance of the appeal, the setting aside of the primary judge's decision, and the remittal of the matter to the primary court for further proceedings consistent with the appellate court's findings. The appellate court did not substitute its own findings for those of the primary judge but rather clarified the principles governing the review of factual findings in appeals.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.