Russell v Desi Nominees Pty Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Russell v Desi Nominees Pty Limited [2023] FCA 1249    

File number(s): ACD 60 of 2023
Judgment of: CHEESEMAN J
Date of judgment: 18 October 2023
Date of publication of reasons: 19 October 2023
Catchwords: EQUITY – where the plaintiff seeks an interlocutory injunction against a grantee from exercising a power of sale arising from a guarantee – where the contract giving rise to the power of sale is alleged to be liable to be set aside in accordance with the principles in Garcia v National Australia Bank Ltd [1998] HCA 48; 194 CLR 395 or pursuant to the Australian Securities and Investments Commissions Act 2001 (Cth) – where the existence of a prima facie case is conceded for the purpose of this application – where there is a question as to the substance of the usual undertaking as to damages – where the plaintiff seeks to sell the secured property herself – Held: application dismissed with costs.
Cases cited:

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill[2006] HCA 46; 227 CLR 57

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Hadfield [2004] NSWCA 350

Garcia v National Australia Bank Ltd [1998] HCA 48; 194 CLR 395

Heavener v Loomes [1924] HCA 10; 34 CLR 306, 326

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v Apple Inc [2011] FCAFC 156; 217 FCR 238

Division: General Division
Registry: Australian Capital Territory
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 70
Date of hearing: 17, 18 October 2023
Counsel for the plaintiff: Mr D Allen
Solicitor for the plaintiff: Baker Deane & Nutt Lawyers
Counsel for the defendants: Mr R Size
Solicitor for the defendants HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

 

ORDERS

ACD 60 of 2023
BETWEEN:

MELISSA RUSSELL

Plaintiff

AND:

DESI NOMINEES PTY. LIMITED ACN 008 601 330

First Defendant

ROVERA INVESTMENT FUND PTY LTD ACN 151 726 073

Second Defendant

SOFIA (ACT) PTY LIMITED ACN 151 041 262 (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

CHEESEMAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 OCTOBER 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Prayers 1 and 2 in relation to interlocutory relief contained in the originating process dated 16 October 2023 be dismissed.

2.Subject to further order, the proceeds of any sale of the shares numbered 11 to 20 in Pialligo Horticulture Pty Ltd ACN 139 772 464 (Lot 2 shares), net of the amount required to discharge the first registered mortgage and the costs of selling the Lot 2 shares, be held in the defendants’ solicitors’ controlled monies account for a period of 21 calendar days from the date of receipt of the proceeds before being released to the defendants.

3.The defendants keep the plaintiff informed in relation to the sale of the Lot 2 shares and the timing of the receipt of any proceeds.

4.Liberty to apply on 2 days’ notice, such liberty to be exercised either before the relevant duty Judge or the docket Judge once a docket Judge has been…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell v Desi Nominees Pty Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 1249
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Russell v Desi Nominees Pty Limited, Melissa Russell sought an interim injunction against Desi Nominees Pty Limited, Rovera Investment Fund Pty Ltd, and Sofia (ACT) Pty Limited, to prevent the sale of shares in Pialligo Horticulture Pty Ltd that gave her the exclusive right to occupy a residential property in Pialligo, Australian Capital Territory. The defendants argued that the guarantees and security interests were valid and enforceable, and sought to sell the shares to recover their debt. The legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff had a prima facie case, whether damages would be an adequate remedy, and whether the balance of convenience favoured granting the injunction.

The court found that the defendants had conceded the existence of a prima facie case for the purposes of the interlocutory application. However, the court was not persuaded that damages would not be an adequate remedy, as the plaintiff's concern was that the shares might be sold at an undervalue to a related party, which did not rise above suspicion. The court also found that the balance of convenience did not favour granting the injunction, as the plaintiff had not provided a sufficient undertaking as to damages.

Accordingly, the court dismissed the application for an interlocutory injunction and made orders to preserve the net proceeds of any sale of the shares in the defendants' solicitors' controlled monies account for a limited period of time to enable the plaintiff to bring a freezing order application if she wished to pursue that course. The court also ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendants' costs of the interlocutory application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Prayers 1 and 2 in relation to interlocutory relief contained in the originating process dated 16 October 2023 be dismissed.

2. Subject to further order, the proceeds of any sale of the shares numbered 11 to 20 in Pialligo Horticulture Pty Ltd ACN 139 772 464 (Lot 2 shares), net of the amount required to discharge the first registered mortgage and the costs of selling the Lot 2 shares, be held in the defendants’ solicitors’ controlled monies account for a period of 21 calendar days from the date of receipt of the proceeds before being released to the defendants.

3. The defendants keep the plaintiff informed in relation to the sale of the Lot 2 shares and the timing of the receipt of any proceeds.

4. Liberty to apply on 2 days’ notice, such liberty to be exercised either before the relevant duty Judge or the docket Judge once a docket Judge has been identified.

5. The proceeding be referred to the National Operations Registrar for allocation to a docket Judge.

6. The proceeding be listed for case management at a time to be advised by the Associate to docket Judge.

7. The plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the interlocutory application heard on 17 and 18 October 2023.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons concern an inter partes application for an interim injunction to restrain the sale by auction of shares conferring the right to exclusive occupation of Crown leasehold property located in the Australian Capital Territory. I made orders on 18 October 2023, inter alia, dismissing the application. These are my reasons for doing so. BACKGROUND Melissa Russell (nee Awburn), the plaintiff, owns shares in Pialligo Horticulture Pty Ltd ACN 139 772 464 and is married to John Russell. Those shares, pursuant to the Constitution of Pialligo Horticulture, grant the plaintiff an exclusive right to occupy, use and enjoy the leasehold property described as Lot 2, 18 Kallaroo Road, Pialligo ACT 2609. Lot 2 is one of four adjoining lots in which Pialligo Horticulture holds an interest pursuant to a Crown lease. There are four shareholders in Pialligo Horticulture. Each shareholder has corresponding exclusive rights conferred in relation to one of the lots, with such rights being conferred by the Constitution. I will refer to the plaintiff’s shares as the Lot 2 shares. The plaintiff’s evidence is that in about 2010, her husband set up Pialligo Horticulture as the company that owned the land located at 18 Kallaroo Road, Pialligo. She said her husband used the main commercial lot to operate the Pialligo Estate business. An orchard, olive grove and winery are located on the Pialligo Estate lot, and are referred to as “the farm”. The remaining three lots were residential. The plaintiff says she did not take too much notice of “the lease agreements and things.” The current directors of Pialligo Horticulture, [REDACTED], are the owners directly or indirectly of the two residential lots other than Lot 2. Her husband was previously a director of Pialligo Horticulture. The plaintiff has never been a director of Pialligo Horticulture. The plaintiff deposes that her husband organised a loan with St George (now part of Westpac) and “all that sort of thing” to fund the purchase, of what she refers to as Lot 2. The plaintiff says that Lot 2 was intended to be “the house lot for our family” and that they had obtained development approval for plans to build. She says that after financial setbacks, including the effect of the COVID‑19 pandemic on the Pialligo Estate business, “there was a real strain on everything and we couldn't build”. She says that:… in order to get an extension to the DA we dug a third of a basement so that some work had been done. That was fenced off and has remained fenced off since. The lot has just been sitting there. There is a big electric gate for access to the residential lots next to the Pialligo Estate lot. The people living at Lot 1 have access to the electronic gate. Another lender has taken possession of the commercial lot that had the Pialligo Estate business. This lot has not been maintained for 6 months, it is on the market and currently for sale. The first three defendants, Desi Nominees Pty Limited ACN 008 601 330, Rovera Investment Fund Pty Ltd ACN 151 726 073 and Sofia (ACT) Pty Limited ACN 151 041 262 are the grantees of security interests in the Lot 2 shares created under three Specific Security Agreements (SSAs) executed in 2020 and 2022 and of guarantees and indemnities included in certain loan agreements executed by the plaintiff as guarantor in 2020 and amended with the signed consent of the plaintiff in 2022. The fourth defendant, MilDesi Security Holdings Pty Limited ACN 636 039 766, is a non-trading entity created as the security trustee for the first to third defendants collectively.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Depending on the nature of the plaintiff’s claim, the plaintiff must show that: there is a serious question to be tried as to the plaintiff's entitlement to relief (a prima facie case); the plaintiff is likely to suffer injury for which damages will not be an adequate remedy; and the balance of convenience favours the granting of an injunction. These are the organising principles, to be applied having regard to the nature and circumstances of the case, under which issues of justice and convenience are addressed. O’Neill at [19]. EVIDENCE The plaintiffs relied on the following materials: (1)the affidavit of the plaintiff, affirmed on 16 October 2023 and the accompanying exhibit MR-1 thereto; (2)the affidavit of Brett Barton, licensed real estate agent, sworn on 16 October 2023; (3)the affidavit of Stan Platis, licensed real estate agent, sworn on 16 October 2023; (4)exhibit 1 being company searches of the defendants, extracted on 31 August 2023; (5)exhibit 2 being a letter from St. George to the plaintiff dated 18 July 2023;(6)exhibit 3 being an email from Jarrad Martin of St. George Bank to the plaintiff dated 15 August 2023 at 9:53am. The Defendants relied on the following materials: (1)the affidavit of Liam Patrick Gilligan, solicitor, affirmed on 17 October 2023 and its annexures thereto; and(2)the affidavit of Stephen James Coyle, solicitor on record for the defendants, affirmed on 17 October 2023 and its annexures thereto. There was no cross-examination. CONSIDERATIONInjunctionPrima facie case As mentioned, the defendants conceded the existence of a prima facie case for the purposes of the interlocutory application. The requirement to establish a prima facie case is a relatively low bar. I will return to the issue of prima facie case when considering the balance of convenience. Live issues It emerged in the course of the hearing, as the evidence evolved, that the principal issues in dispute were: (1)whether damages would be an adequate remedy for the plaintiff if she is ultimately successful in her substantive claim;(2)whether the usual undertaking as to damages proffered by the plaintiff was sufficient to support the grant of the injunction sought; and(3)whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an injunction. Whether damages are an adequate remedy The thrust of the plaintiff’s submission was that the plaintiff’s claim for final relief is for the SSAs and guarantees to be set aside against her, not for compensation. Counsel for the plaintiff submitted that if the auction is permitted to proceed then the plaintiff’s right to conduct the sale as owner of the shares will be destroyed. The plaintiff submitted that if the shares are sold by the defendants via the online auction process, then the plaintiff will be prejudiced by having to establish that the defendants had acted recklessly or otherwise not in good faith in exercising their purported power of sale, in addition to establishing that the SSA and guarantees should be set aside. As mentioned above, the plaintiff’s concern is that the defendants will “sell the property for $1.3 million and a dollar to someone associated to themselves”. In effect, the complaint is that the shares might be sold at an undervalue to a related party and that she would face difficulties in proving that to be the case at a future time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For this reason, I indicated that if an injunction was not granted, I would be minded to order that the net proceeds of any sale of the Lot 2 shares be held in the defendants’ solicitors’ controlled monies account for a limited period of time to enable the plaintiff to bring a freezing order application if she wishes to pursue that course. An order in the nature of a freezing order is not an order that the Court would lightly make without a proper evidentiary basis. Having decided that it was not appropriate to grant the interlocutory injunction, I made orders preserving the net proceeds of sale for a limited period in the defendants’ solicitors’ controlled monies account and related orders of a mechanical nature.CONCLUSION At the conclusion of the hearing, I made orders in accordance with the reasons I have set out above. The plaintiff did not proffer any reason as to why costs should not follow the event. Accordingly, I also ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of the interlocutory application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There was no cross-examination. CONSIDERATIONInjunctionPrima facie case As mentioned, the defendants conceded the existence of a prima facie case for the purposes of the interlocutory application. The requirement to establish a prima facie case is a relatively low bar. I will return to the issue of prima facie case when considering the balance of convenience. Live issues It emerged in the course of the hearing, as the evidence evolved, that the principal issues in dispute were: (1)whether damages would be an adequate remedy for the plaintiff if she is ultimately successful in her substantive claim;(2)whether the usual undertaking as to damages proffered by the plaintiff was sufficient to support the grant of the injunction sought; and(3)whether the balance of convenience favoured the grant of an injunction. Whether damages are an adequate remedy The thrust of the plaintiff’s submission was that the plaintiff’s claim for final relief is for the SSAs and guarantees to be set aside against her, not for compensation. Counsel for the plaintiff submitted that if the auction is permitted to proceed then the plaintiff’s right to conduct the sale as owner of the shares will be destroyed. The plaintiff submitted that if the shares are sold by the defendants via the online auction process, then the plaintiff will be prejudiced by having to establish that the defendants had acted recklessly or otherwise not in good faith in exercising their purported power of sale, in addition to establishing that the SSA and guarantees should be set aside. As mentioned above, the plaintiff’s concern is that the defendants will “sell the property for $1.3 million and a dollar to someone associated to themselves”. In effect, the complaint is that the shares might be sold at an undervalue to a related party and that she would face difficulties in proving that to be the case at a future time. I am not persuaded by the plaintiff’s submissions. The plaintiff deposes to her intention to sell the shares through her desired marketing and share sale process. This is not a case where the plaintiff asserts that there is some unique feature of Lot 2, which if transferred through the sales of the shares cannot be properly compensated by a monetary sum. Her concern is that the shares may be sold at an undervalue. On the whole of the evidence led on this application, I do not regard her concern in relation to the property being sold to a related party at undervalue to rise above suspicion. The obligations of a mortgagee exercising a power of sale were summarised in Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Hadfield [2004] NSWCA 350 at [14], (Bryson JA with whom Giles and Tobias JJA agreed):14. Exercise of the power of sale is undertaken by a mortgagee in the interest of the mortgagee, although the mortgagee is confined to exercise of the power in good faith for the purpose for which it was conferred; the mortgagee cannot act for any extraneous purpose or bye-motive, and cannot sacrifice the interest of the mortgagor; to do so would be to depart from good-faith exercise of the power, and from the concept of a sale in the exercise of the power. The sale must bona fide be a sale, not a sacrifice, and the mortgagee cannot be indifferent to the price provided only that its debt is paid. In the pursuit of its own interest the mortgagee is entitled to choose the time at which it sells the property.