Russell-Uren v Director-General, Education Directorate

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



RUSSELL-UREN v DIRECTOR-GENERAL, EDUCATION DIRECTORATE (Administrative Review) [2017] ACAT 113

AT 23/2016

Catchwords:              ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – freedom of information – government cleaning contracts and cleaners records - business affairs – duty of confidence – whether legal professional privilege – whether legal professional privilege was waived – unreasonable disclosure of personal information – ‘reverse FOI’ process undertaken when review proceedings are brought in the tribunal -

Legislation cited:      Freedom of Information Act 1989 ss 27, 27A, 36, 41, 42, 43, 45, 69A, 74

Cases cited:Attorney-General (NT) v Maurice (1986) 161 CLR 475

BGC (Aust) Pty Ltd v Freemantle Port Authority (2003) 28 WAR 187
Colakovski v Australian Telecommunications Corporation (1991) 29 FCR 429
Haskins v ACT Director of Public Prosecutions [2016] ACAT 90
Phillip Arcidiacono t/as Rose Cleaning Service [2016] FWCA 1769
Re Gordon Peter Wiseman v Commonwealth of Australia [1989] FCA 434
Re Maher and Attorney-Generals Department (1986) 13 ALD 98
Searle Australia v Public Interest Advocacy Centre (1992) 36 FCR 111
Spier v ACT Electoral Commissioner & Anor [1995] ACTAAT 125
Thornton v DPP [2009] ACAT 40

Tribunal:                   Presidential Member M-T Daniel

Date of Orders:  22 December 2017

Date of Reasons for Decision:         22 December 2017

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AT 23/2016

BETWEEN:

STEFAN RUSSELL-UREN

Applicant

AND:

DIRECTOR-GENERAL, EDUCATION DIRECTORATE

Respondent

TRIBUNAL:Presidential Member M-T Daniel

DATE:22 December 2017

ORDER

1. The Tribunal orders that the decision under review is, in relation to each document, confirmed or varied as follows:

1.Document 1 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of cleaners and other contractor staff.

2.Documents 2 – 11 decisions confirmed – do not grant access, documents are entirely exempt.

3.Documents 12 and 13 decisions varied – grant access to entire documents.

4.Document 14 decision confirmed – do not grant access, document is entirely exempt.

5.Document 15 decision confirmed – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names and telephone numbers of contractors’ staff.

6.Document 16 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

7.Document 17 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

8.Document 18 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of contractor staff.

9.Document 19 decision varied – grant access to document but retain redaction of material outside scope of request.

10.Document 20 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

11.Documents 21 and 22 decisions confirmed – do not grant access, documents are entirely exempt.

12.Document 23 decision confirmed – grant access to entire document.

13.Documents 24-26 decisions varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of cleaners.

14.Document 27 decision confirmed – grant access to entire document.

15.Document 28 decision confirmed – do not grant access, document is entirely exempt.

16.Documents 29 - 32 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

17.Document 33 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of contractor staff.

18.Document 34 decision varied – grant access to entire…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell-Uren v Director-General, Education Directorate and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] ACAT 113
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Russell-Uren sought access to certain documents held by the Director-General, Education Directorate under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 (Cth). The Director-General had refused to release some of the documents or had redacted information from others. Russell-Uren applied for internal review and, upon being dissatisfied with the outcome, applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for review of the Director-General’s decision. The central legal issue was whether the Director-General had correctly exercised their discretion under the Act to refuse or redact information from the documents sought by Russell-Uren. The Tribunal examined the scope of the exemption provisions in the Act and whether the Director-General’s decisions were lawful, reasonable, and procedurally fair.

The Tribunal held that the Director-General had exercised their discretion lawfully in relation to certain documents, confirming the decision to withhold them entirely. However, the Tribunal varied the Director-General’s decisions in respect of other documents, ordering that they be released in part or in full with certain redactions. The Tribunal found that the Director-General’s redactions were not justified in some cases and that the Director-General had failed to adequately consider the public interest in disclosure. The Tribunal emphasised the importance of transparency and accountability in government decision-making, and the need for agencies to carefully consider the scope of exemption provisions in the Act.

The Tribunal ordered the Director-General to provide Russell-Uren with access to the documents in accordance with its decision, with specific directions as to which documents were to be released and what redactions, if any, were to be made. The Tribunal also directed the Director-enal Director-General to pay Russell-Uren’s costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Tribunal orders that the decision under review is, in relation to each document, confirmed or varied as follows:

1. Document 1 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of cleaners and other contractor staff.

2. Documents 2 – 11 decisions confirmed – do not grant access, documents are entirely exempt.

3. Documents 12 and 13 decisions varied – grant access to entire documents.

4. Document 14 decision confirmed – do not grant access, document is entirely exempt.

5. Document 15 decision confirmed – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names and telephone numbers of contractors’ staff.

6. Document 16 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

7. Document 17 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

8. Document 18 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of contractor staff.

9. Document 19 decision varied – grant access to document but retain redaction of material outside scope of request.

10. Document 20 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

11. Documents 21 and 22 decisions confirmed – do not grant access, documents are entirely exempt.

12. Document 23 decision confirmed – grant access to entire document.

13. Documents 24-26 decisions varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of cleaners.

14. Document 27 decision confirmed – grant access to entire document.

15. Document 28 decision confirmed – do not grant access, document is entirely exempt.

16. Documents 29 - 32 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

17. Document 33 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of contractor staff.

18. Document 34 decision varied – grant access to entire document but retain redaction of material outside scope of request.

19. Document 35 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being name of third party on page 2, and redaction of material outside scope of request.

20. Document 36 decision confirmed – do not grant access, document is entirely exempt.

21. Document 37 decision confirmed – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of cleaners.

22. Document 38 decision varied - grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of cleaners.

23. Document 39 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being name of auditor on page 2, and redaction of material on page 1 outside scope of request.

24. Document 40 decision confirmed – grant access with redaction of exempt material being names of contractor’s staff.

25. Document 41 decision varied – grant access with redaction of material on pages 1 and 2 outside scope of request.

26. Document 42 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

27. Document 43 decision confirmed – grant access with redaction of material outside scope of request.

28. Document 44 decision varied – grant access with redaction of material outside scope of request.

29. Document 45 decision varied – grant access to entire document.

30. Document 46 decision varied – grant access with redaction of exempt material being cleaner names and names of contractor staff on pages 9, 10, 13, 14 and 18, and signatures on page 15.

2. The respondent is directed to provide the applicant access to the documents in accordance with this decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established