Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
- Summary available
- Amendment notes
Medium Neutral Citation: Russell Gould Pty Ltd v Ramangkura [2014] NSWCA 310 Hearing dates: 18 July 2014 Decision date: 09 September 2014 Before: Bathurst CJ at [1]; Barrett JA at [2]; Ward JA at [84] Decision: Appeal dismissed with costs
[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]
Catchwords: RESTITUTION - remedies at common law - action for money had and received - payment of company's money by a director alleged to have no authority to cause the payment to be made - no allegation of breach of fiduciary or other duty or dishonesty by the director - recovery action brought by the company against the third party recipient alone - no basis for equitable relief - whether proceeds of payment by the company identifiable in the third party recipient's hands - where the money was transferred from the company's bank account to the third party recipient's overdrawn account at the same bank - no credit balance resulting in the recipient's account - no ability to follow or trace into the overdrawn account - where the director was owed money by the company payable on demand - whether the director should be presumed to have sought and obtained payment of that money when he caused the company to make the payment Cases Cited: Agip (Africa) Ltd v Jackson [1990] Ch 265 Boscawea v Bajwa [1996] 1 WLR 328 Calverley v Green [1984] HCA 81; 155 CLR 242 David Securities Pty Ltd v Commonwealth Bank of Australia [1992] HCA 48; 175 CLR 353 Foskett v McKeown [2001] 1 AC 102 Frith v Cartland (1865) 2 H&M 417; 71 ER 525 Heperu Pty Ltd v Belle [2009] NSWCA 252; 76 NSWLR 230 Lipkin Gorman v Karpnale Ltd [1991] 2 AC 548 Moses v Macferlan (1760) 2 Burr 1005; 97 ER 676 Parker v The Queen [1997] HCA 15; 186 CLR 494 Rae v Russell [2012] NZCA 536 Re Hallett's Estate; Knatchbull v Hallett (1880) 13 Ch D 696 The Australian Metropolitan Life Assurance Co Ltd v Ure [1923] HCA 29; 33 CLR 199 Category: Principal judgment Parties: Russell Gould Pty Ltd (Appellant) Vilailaksana Ramangkura (First Respondent) Russell Gould by his Tutor NSW Trustee and Guardian (Second Respondent) (Submitting appearance filed) Representation: Counsel: R E Dubler SC/J Hyde Page (Appellant) L J Ellison SC/P P O'Loughlin - 1R
Solicitors: Swaab Attorneys (Appellant) Coyne Legal (First Respondent) NSW Trustee and Guardian (Second Respondent)
File Number(s): CA 2013/276695 Decision under appeal
- Citation:
- [2013] NSWSC 1114
- Date of Decision:
- 2013-08-16 00:00:00
- Before:
- Lindsay J
- File Number(s):
- 2011/280083
HEADNOTE
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Russell Gould Pty Ltd v Ramangkura and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NSWCA 310
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether the company could recover the money paid to Ramangkura in an action for money had and received at common law, and whether the proceeds of the payment were identifiable in Ramangkura's hands. Specifically, the court had to determine if the money could be followed or traced into Ramangkura's overdrawn bank account, and whether the director should be presumed to have sought payment of a debt owed to him by the company when he authorised the transfer.
The Court of Appeal reasoned that for the company to succeed in an action for money had and received, it was necessary for the money to be identifiable in the recipient's hands. As the money was transferred from the company's account to Ramangkura's overdrawn account at the same bank, and no credit balance resulted, the court found that the money could not be followed or traced into the overdrawn account. The court also considered whether the director's authorisation of the payment should be presumed to be for the purpose of discharging a debt owed to him by the company, but ultimately found no basis for equitable relief.
The appeal was dismissed with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Appeal dismissed with costs
[Note: The Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 provide (Rule 36.11) that unless the Court otherwise orders, a judgment or order is taken to be entered when it is recorded in the Court's computerised court record system. Setting aside and variation of judgments or orders is dealt with by Rules 36.15, 36.16, 36.17 and 36.18. Parties should in particular note the time limit of fourteen days in Rule 36.16.]
Background
Background to the litigation
The Company argued that the proceeds of the payment should be identifiable in Mr. Ramangkura's hands, given that the money was transferred from the Company's bank account to Mr. Ramangkura's overdrawn account at the same bank, and no credit balance resulted in the recipient's account. However, the primary judge held that it was not possible to follow or trace the money into the overdrawn account. The primary judge also noted that Mr. Gould was owed money by the Company payable on demand, and there was no evidence to suggest that he did not seek and obtain payment of that money when he caused the Company to make the payment to Mr. Ramangkura.
The Company appealed the primary judge's decision, arguing that the primary judge had erred in finding that there was no basis for equitable relief and in holding that the proceeds of the payment were not identifiable in Mr. Ramangkura's hands. The Company submitted that the primary judge had failed to consider the possibility that Mr. Gould had caused the Company to make the payment for the benefit of a third party, namely, himself. The Company also submitted that the primary judge had erred in finding that the Company had no cause of action in restitution against Mr. Ramangkura. However, the appeal was dismissed with costs.
The case of Russell Gould Pty Ltd v Ramangkura originated in the Supreme Court of Victoria, where Russell Gould Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) sought to recover monies allegedly improperly disbursed by one of its directors to the defendant, Ramangkura. The plaintiff's claim was based on the theory of money had and received, asserting that the director had no authority to make the payment and that the funds were not traceable or identifiable in the defendant's hands. The Supreme Court dismissed the plaintiff's action, finding that there was no basis for equitable relief and that the plaintiff had failed to establish that the proceeds of the payment could be traced into the defendant's account. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the plaintiff appealed to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal heard the matter as an appeal from the original decision of the Supreme Court. The primary focus of the appeal was on the legal principles governing the availability of common law remedies for recovery of funds and the circumstances under which a director's payment could be deemed to have been made for the benefit of the director personally rather than the company. The Court of Appeal considered the arguments presented by both parties, reviewed the relevant authorities, and ultimately dismissed the appeal, affirming the decision of the Supreme Court. The Court found that there was no evidence to support a presumption that the director had sought to appropriate the company's funds for personal use, nor was there a basis for the plaintiff to recover the monies from the defendant. The Court also addressed the procedural steps taken, including the plaintiff's failure to establish the necessary elements for a successful claim and the lack of any breach of fiduciary duty or dishonesty by the director. The Court of Appeal's decision brought the litigation to a conclusion, with the appeal being dismissed and the costs of the appeal awarded against the plaintiff.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the court can order restitution of money paid by the company to the third party recipient where the director did not have authority to make the payment.
2. Whether the company can recover the proceeds of the payment from the third party recipient where the money was transferred to the recipient's overdrawn account at the same bank and there was no credit balance resulting in the recipient's account.
3. Whether the court can presume that the director sought and obtained payment of his own debt when he caused the company to make the payment to the third party recipient.
4. Whether the company's recovery action against the third party recipient alone is sufficient where there is no basis for equitable relief.
Held
1. The court concluded that it cannot order restitution of money paid by the company to the third party recipient where the director did not have authority to make the payment. As a result, the appeal was dismissed with costs.
2. The court concluded that the company cannot recover the proceeds of the payment from the third party recipient where the money was transferred to the recipient's overdrawn account at the same bank and there was no credit balance resulting in the recipient's account.
3. The court concluded that it cannot presume that the director sought and obtained payment of his own debt when he caused the company to make the payment to the third party recipient.
4. The court concluded that the company's recovery action against the third party recipient alone is sufficient where there is no basis for equitable relief.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Russell Gould Pty Ltd v Ramangkura, the court was tasked with resolving several significant issues pertaining to restitution and recovery of payments made by a company through its director without proper authority. The central question was whether the company could reclaim money paid to a third party by a director who lacked authority to make such a payment. The court first addressed the issue of whether it could order restitution of money paid by the company to the third party recipient where the director did not have authority to make the payment. The court held that restitution could not be ordered in the absence of an allegation of breach of fiduciary or other duty or dishonesty by the director. This decision aligns with the principle that a company is generally bound by the unauthorized acts of its directors if the third party acted in good faith and without notice of the lack of authority.
In examining whether the company could recover the proceeds of the payment from the third party recipient, the court faced a complex factual scenario where the money was transferred to the recipient's overdrawn account at the same bank, resulting in no credit balance. The court concluded that since the funds could not be traced into the overdrawn account, the company could not recover the proceeds from the third party recipient. The decision underscored the importance of being able to trace the funds into a specific account or asset to establish a basis for recovery.
Regarding the presumption that the director sought and obtained payment of his own debt when he caused the company to make the payment to the third party recipient, the court noted that while the director was owed money by the company payable on demand, there was no basis to presume that the payment was made to satisfy that debt. The court held that the director's actions did not inherently imply an intention to satisfy personal debts when the company made the payment, thereby rejecting the presumption without further evidence.
Lastly, the court addressed whether the company's recovery action against the third party recipient alone was sufficient in the absence of a basis for equitable relief. The court affirmed that without a basis for equitable relief, such as a fiduciary relationship or unjust enrichment, the company's action against the third party recipient alone was inadequate. The decision highlighted the need for a stronger legal basis, such as tracing or equitable relief, to support a recovery action against a third party.
In summary, the court's reasoning established that restitution cannot be ordered without evidence of breach of duty or dishonesty, recovery of proceeds is contingent on the ability to trace funds, presumptions regarding directors' motives are not to be made without evidence, and actions against third parties require a stronger legal basis in the absence of equitable relief. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a company cannot reclaim unauthorized payments from a third party recipient unless the company can trace the funds into a specific account or asset and there is a stronger legal basis for recovery beyond an action against the third party alone.