RUSSELL FOSTER and TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

[2012] AATA 399 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/2572

Re

RUSSELL FOSTER

APPLICANT

And

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

 Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member and Dr M Sullivan, Member

Date 28 June 2012  
Place Brisbane

The Tribunal determines that the applicant’s claim should proceed to hearing on the matters of whether there is a present entitlement under ss 16 or 19 of the Safety  Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth).

.........................[Sgd]...............................................

Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – Acceptance of liability under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act) for medical treatment and compensation for an aggravation of a pre-existing and constitutional right wrist ganglion which was materially contributed to by his employment with Telstra – Cessation of liability for incapacity for work or impairment or the need for medical treatment by 31 December 2007 – Applicant’s claim not a mere re-agitation of matters dealt with in a previous decision of the AAT – Matter to proceed to hearing in relation to compensation under sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act.

LEGISLATION

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) s 33

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 14, 16, 19

CASES

Abrahams v Comcare (2006) 93 ALD 147

Cheung v Administrative Appeals Tribunal [2009] FCA 241

Foster and Telstra Corporation Limited [2010] AATA 89

Re Quinn and Australian Postal Corporation (1992) 15 AAR 519

Re Rana v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation (2008) 104 ALD 595

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member and Dr M Sullivan, Member

28 June 2012

BACKGROUND

  1. On 16 February 2007, Mr Foster lodged a claim for workers compensation in relation to “tendonitis right wrist” which he alleged was caused by the use of a computer mouse on 14 February 2007. On 20 April 2007, the Telstra Corporation Ltd (“Telstra”),[1] accepted liability under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (“the SRC Act”), for rehabilitation and compensation in respect of “soft tissue injury to the right wrist”. On 16 October 2007, it revoked that decision. In turn, that decision was revoked by the respondent on 22 December 2008, determining that it was not liable for tendonitis but that it accepted liability for a ganglion condition up to 25 July 2007, when the side effects ceased. On 22 February 2009, the respondent revoked that decision and determined that it was liable for the applicant’s ganglion condition but that Mr Foster ceased to suffer the effects of that condition on 31 December 2007. On review of that decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) on 8 February 2010, that decision was affirmed.[2] 

    [1] All material decisions and determinations under the Act were made by Allianz Australia Insurance Limited, acting for and on behalf of Telstra.

    [2] Foster and Telstra Corporation Limited [2010] AATA 89.

  2. On 30 October 2010, Mr Foster completed a letter which has been treated by the respondent as a claim for ongoing incapacity benefits from 31…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RUSSELL FOSTER and TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 399
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Russell Foster, an applicant, and Telstra Corporation Limited, a respondent, were involved in a dispute before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) concerning workers' compensation for an aggravation of a pre-existing ganglion in Mr Foster's right wrist, which was materially contributed to by his employment with Telstra. The central issue before the AAT was whether Telstra's acceptance of liability for the medical treatment and compensation related to the ganglion should extend beyond 31 December 2007, the date Telstra had ceased its liability. The AAT had to determine if Mr Foster's claim was a re-agitation of previously decided matters or if it warranted a new hearing under sections 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

The AAT examined the medical evidence provided, particularly the reports of Dr Couzens and Dr Cutbush, to ascertain the nature and origin of Mr Foster's ganglion. Dr Couzens, who performed surgeries on Mr Foster's wrist, indicated that the ganglion in 2010 was likely a recurrence of the original one, but the exact nature remained uncertain due to incomplete exploration during the initial surgery. Dr Cutbush, an orthopaedic surgeon, opined that the ganglion conditions were not related to Mr Foster's employment, although he acknowledged that Mr Foster's work with Telstra had significantly contributed to the symptoms. The AAT also considered the Tribunal's previous decision, referencing the Cheung case, which emphasised the Tribunal's discretion to avoid reopening previously determined issues and to focus on new evidence establishing causal links between the facts and the current claims.

The AAT concluded that Mr Foster's claim was not a re-agitation of prior matters but rather a new issue requiring a hearing under the SRC Act. It found that the evidence supported the conclusion that Telstra's liability for medical treatment and compensation should continue beyond 31 December 2007. The AAT determined that while the original ganglion was aggravated by Mr Foster's employment with Telstra, the subsequent ganglion, which appeared after he left Telstra, was due to constitutional factors. This finding led to the decision that Telstra's liability should not cease on 31 December 2007.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Though not necessary for its decision, the Tribunal also answered the fourth question and determined that there was no justification for any payment for medical treatment or incapacity under the SRC Act beyond 31 December 2007.MEDICAL EVIDENCE On 14 September 2007, Dr Couzens removed a ganglion from Mr Foster’s right wrist. On 12 March 2010, shortly after the Tribunal made its decision on 8 February 2010, Dr Couzens completed a further surgical procedure on Mr Foster’s right wrist. In evidence was his report, dated 4 June 2010, where he wrote:The ganglion removed on the 12 March 2010 was arising in the same area as the original ganglion. It most likely represents a recurrence of the ganglion, although I note that I did not explore the plantar insertion of the TFC at the time of the original surgery in 2007, and therefore may have missed the original ganglion. Dr Kenneth Cutbush, orthopaedic surgeon, completed reports on 24 November 2011 and 21 February 2012. He considered that an MRI report on 10 May 2007 showed an ulnar sided ganglion related to the distal radial ulnar joint as well as a degree of tendinopathy. He read an MRI report of 17 April 2009 as demonstrating a small ganglion in the prestyloid recess as well as a degree of extensor carpi ulnaris tendonitis. His first report appeared to proffer differing opinions as to the nature of the ganglion removed in 2010. He stated that it was either a residual ganglion not removed in 2007 or a recurrence in the same region; that it may well have been a residual ganglion from the first operation; and that it was a residual ganglion from the first operation. He wrote that the ganglion conditions were not related to Mr Foster’s employment. His opinion was that Mr Foster appeared to have a musculoskeletal strain injury or a mild extensor tendon tenosynovitis but that the MRI and ultrasound investigations did not support a formal diagnosis of the latter condition. He considered that the symptoms in his wrist were related to his work with Telstra. Dr Cutbush described Mr Foster’s symptoms as having essentially resolved which made it difficult to be certain which condition he had suffered from. He described significant contribution from his work with Telstra but wrote that the work-related symptoms had ceased after his Telstra work ended in November 2007. CONSIDERATION In the Federal Court decision of Cheung v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Cheung),[7] Bennett J confirmed that the Tribunal has discretion to accept a previous Tribunal decision as determinative of an issue and not to allow it to be reopened.[8] His Honour noted that this was the approach adopted by the Tribunal in Rana v Military Compensation Commission[9] where Deputy President Forgie said:These are considerations that must inform any exercise of the Tribunal’s power in s 33(1)(c) of the AAT Act. That power must also be exercised with the exhortation found in s 2A to pursue, among others, the objectives of fairness, justice, economy, informality and speed firmly in mind. When I do that, it seems to me to lead to a conclusion that Mr Rana should not be permitted to rehearse the circumstances of his employment a further time, to challenge the findings that have been made about the circumstances of that employment or to challenge the findings that have been made about the compensability of the conditions for which he has previously been denied compensation and in respect of which the Tribunal has affirmed the decisions. Instead, the Tribunal should have regard to the findings of fact made by the earlier Tribunals presided over by Deputy Presidents Layton and Jarvis respectively in reviewing the decision in the current matter. Any evidence that is given should be directed to establishing the necessary causal links between the facts as found by those previous Tribunals and the conditions as now claimed by Rana.[7] [2009] FCA 241.[8] Referring to Morales v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 82 FCR 374 at 390. [9] (2008) 104 ALD 595 at [137] per Deputy President S Forgie.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Of relevance is s 33(1)(c) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“the AAT Act”) which provides:In a proceeding before the Tribunal:…(c) the Tribunal is not bound by the rules of evidence but may inform itself on any matter in such manner as it thinks appropriate.THE TRIBUNAL’S DECISION OF 8 FEBRUARY 2010 In its decision of 8 February 2010, the Tribunal set out the following four issues for its determination:1. Is the respondent entitled to review its decision of its own motion? In particular, is the decision of 2 February 2009 legally effective?2. Does the applicant suffer from tendonitis of the right wrist or a ganglion condition of the right wrist?3. If the applicant suffered from either tendonitis or a ganglion condition is that attributable to his employment with Telstra?4. If the answer to (3) is "yes", is the applicant entitled to medical treatment or incapacity payments beyond 31 December 2007? The first of those was answered in the affirmative but is not of particular relevance in this matter. As to the second question, the Tribunal answered:27. The complaint of ongoing pain is therefore, on the balance of probabilities, explicable by the opinions of Dr Coleman and Dr Couzens that it is possible for the ganglion to regrow which would be due to an individual's predisposition. Neither of the medical experts said that there was any logic from a medical point of view that either pain while working in Telstra, or pain which appears to have become worse since December 2007 could be attributable to the work performed by Mr Foster while he was with Telstra. Working with Telstra would have been an aggravation, but not a cause to Mr Foster's condition. 28. We accept the evidence of both Dr Couzens and Dr Coleman. We find no evidence of any significance which is in dispute between the opinions of these doctors. Consequently, based on the evidence, we find as a fact that there is no tendonitis condition suffered by Mr Foster. We also make a finding of fact that Mr Foster had a ganglion which was removed in 2007. We further find that on the balance of probabilities, the only explanation based on the medical evidence is that any pain experienced by the applicant since 31 December 2007, the reasonable period following excision of the ganglion, would be that a further ganglion has grown due to constitutional factors. In our opinion, the evidence clearly shows that this must have occurred since Mr Foster has ceased his employment with Telstra. For the third question, the Tribunal concluded that causation of the ganglion in Mr Foster's right wrist could not be attributed to his employment with Telstra. In its reasons for decision, the Tribunal made reference to the original ganglion and a possible further ganglion which developed subsequent to the first ganglion excision. The decision under review in that case was in respect of the first ganglion which the respondent had determined was not caused by employment with Telstra but aggravated by that employment. It was on that basis that the respondent accepted liability and compensated Mr Foster until December 2007. The formal outcome of the Tribunal's deliberations on 8 February 2010 was that it “affirmed” that decision. However, in its reasoning, the Tribunal clearly found that, on the medical evidence before it which included that of Dr Couzens, Mr Foster’s ganglion was not caused by his employment but aggravated by it.[6] The Tribunal also referred to the second ganglion in terms that it was not causally related to Mr Foster's employment with Telstra because it developed after he had ceased his employment with Telstra in November 2007. [6] See para 27 (reproduced above in para 10 of these reasons).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Kenneth Cutbush, orthopaedic surgeon, completed reports on 24 November 2011 and 21 February 2012. He considered that an MRI report on 10 May 2007 showed an ulnar sided ganglion related to the distal radial ulnar joint as well as a degree of tendinopathy. He read an MRI report of 17 April 2009 as demonstrating a small ganglion in the prestyloid recess as well as a degree of extensor carpi ulnaris tendonitis. His first report appeared to proffer differing opinions as to the nature of the ganglion removed in 2010. He stated that it was either a residual ganglion not removed in 2007 or a recurrence in the same region; that it may well have been a residual ganglion from the first operation; and that it was a residual ganglion from the first operation. He wrote that the ganglion conditions were not related to Mr Foster’s employment. His opinion was that Mr Foster appeared to have a musculoskeletal strain injury or a mild extensor tendon tenosynovitis but that the MRI and ultrasound investigations did not support a formal diagnosis of the latter condition. He considered that the symptoms in his wrist were related to his work with Telstra. Dr Cutbush described Mr Foster’s symptoms as having essentially resolved which made it difficult to be certain which condition he had suffered from. He described significant contribution from his work with Telstra but wrote that the work-related symptoms had ceased after his Telstra work ended in November 2007. CONSIDERATION In the Federal Court decision of Cheung v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Cheung),[7] Bennett J confirmed that the Tribunal has discretion to accept a previous Tribunal decision as determinative of an issue and not to allow it to be reopened.[8] His Honour noted that this was the approach adopted by the Tribunal in Rana v Military Compensation Commission[9] where Deputy President Forgie said:These are considerations that must inform any exercise of the Tribunal’s power in s 33(1)(c) of the AAT Act. That power must also be exercised with the exhortation found in s 2A to pursue, among others, the objectives of fairness, justice, economy, informality and speed firmly in mind. When I do that, it seems to me to lead to a conclusion that Mr Rana should not be permitted to rehearse the circumstances of his employment a further time, to challenge the findings that have been made about the circumstances of that employment or to challenge the findings that have been made about the compensability of the conditions for which he has previously been denied compensation and in respect of which the Tribunal has affirmed the decisions. Instead, the Tribunal should have regard to the findings of fact made by the earlier Tribunals presided over by Deputy Presidents Layton and Jarvis respectively in reviewing the decision in the current matter. Any evidence that is given should be directed to establishing the necessary causal links between the facts as found by those previous Tribunals and the conditions as now claimed by Rana.[7] [2009] FCA 241.[8] Referring to Morales v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1998) 82 FCR 374 at 390. [9] (2008) 104 ALD 595 at [137] per Deputy President S Forgie.