RUSSELL FOSTER and TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

[2012] AATA 702  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/2572

Re

RUSSELL FOSTER

APPLICANT

And

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member and
Dr G J Maynard, Brigadier (Rtd), Member

Date 11 October 2012  
Place Brisbane

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

....................[Sgd]................................................

Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – Acceptance of liability under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) for medical treatment and compensation for an aggravation of a pre-existing and constitutional right wrist ganglion – Cessation of liability for incapacity for work or impairment or the need for medical treatment by 31 December 2007 – Development of new ganglion unrelated to previous condition or employment – Decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 5B, 14, 16, 19

CASES

Cheung v Administrative Appeals Tribunal (2009) 176 FCR 20

Foster and Telstra Corporation Limited [2010] AATA 89

Re Quinn and Australian Postal Corporation (1992) 15 AAR 519

Re Rana and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Corporation (2008) 104 ALD 595

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr R G Kenny, Senior Member and Dr G J Maynard, Brigadier (Rtd), Member

11 October 2012

BACKGROUND

The Tribunal decision of 8 February 2010

  1. On 8 February 2010, the Tribunal affirmed the respondent’s decision of 2 February 2009 that it was liable with respect to Mr Foster’s ganglion of the right wrist but concluded that Mr Foster ceased to suffer the effects of that condition by 31 December 2007.[1] The Tribunal determined that the ganglion was aggravated but that this was not caused by his work with Telstra Corporation Limited (“Telstra”). Mr Foster did not request a review of that decision, the effect of which was that, from 1 January 2008, Mr Foster had no entitlement to compensation under ss 16 or 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“the Act”). The Tribunal also determined that Mr Foster did not suffer from tendonitis and that any pain experienced by him since 31 December 2007 was due to a further ganglion which had developed due to constitutional factors after he ceased his employment with Telstra in November 2007.

    [1] Foster and Telstra Corporation Limited [2010] AATA 89.

    The present claim

  2. In a letter dated 30 October 2010, Mr Foster claimed ongoing incapacity from his original injury after 31 December 2007 and sought reimbursement of medical costs associated with a surgical procedure to remove a ganglion from his right wrist on 12 March 2010. On 25 March 2011, the respondent determined that there was no present entitlement under ss 16 or 19 of the Act in relation to a ganglion of the right wrist. In a reviewable decision, dated 11 May 2011, it varied that decision and decided:

    ·on 14 February 2007, Mr Foster sustained an aggravation of a pre-existing and constitutional right wrist ganglion which was materially contributed to by his employment with Telstra; and

    ·by 31 December 2007, the right wrist aggravation ceased to result in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read RUSSELL FOSTER and TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 702
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved Russell Foster and Telstra Corporation Limited, centering on the acceptance of liability under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) for medical treatment and compensation concerning an aggravation of a pre-existing wrist ganglion. Foster argued that his employment with Telstra had aggravated a pre-existing condition, while Telstra contended that any new ganglion developed in 2010 was unrelated to his employment. The court was required to decide whether Telstra was liable for compensation regarding the 2010 ganglion and if Foster's employment had contributed to its development or aggravation.

The primary legal issue was whether Telstra's liability extended to the 2010 ganglion, given that the 2007 ganglion was acknowledged to have been aggravated by Foster's employment but resolved by 31 December 2007. The court also had to determine if there was any relationship between the 2007 and 2010 ganglions and whether Foster's employment contributed to the 2010 ganglion. The medical evidence played a crucial role in this determination, with the court considering reports from Dr. Couzens, Dr. Coleman, and Dr. Cutbush. The court's analysis focused on whether the 2010 ganglion was a new condition unrelated to Foster's employment, as Telstra asserted, or if there was any employment-related contribution to it.

The court found that while Telstra was liable for the 2007 ganglion, which had been aggravated by Foster's employment, there was no evidence to suggest that Foster's employment contributed to the 2010 ganglion. The medical evidence supported the conclusion that the 2010 ganglion was unrelated to Foster's employment and was likely a new condition. The court relied on the testimonies of the medical experts, who indicated that the 2010 ganglion was not related to the 2007 ganglion, and any connection was speculative at best. The court affirmed the decision of the Tribunal that Telstra was liable for the 2007 ganglion but ceased to be liable for any effects after 31 December 2007.

The court's decision was to affirm the Tribunal's decision of 11 May 2011, maintaining that Telstra was liable for the 2007 ganglion but not for any subsequent conditions, including the 2010 ganglion. The court found no evidence to support Telstra's liability for the 2010 ganglion or any ongoing effects after 31 December 2007. The decision underscores the importance of medical evidence in determining the relationship between employment and specific conditions, and it highlights the court's role in reviewing such evidence to make informed judgments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Foster said that he accepted the decision of the Tribunal on 8 February 2010 that he no longer suffered the effects of the compensable injury constituted by the ganglion removed in 2007. His concern was with the ganglion removed in 2010. When the Tribunal decided Mr Foster’s application for review on 8 February 2010, it made findings that Mr Foster did not suffer from tendonitis; that Mr Foster suffered from a ganglion which was removed in 2007 and which, while not caused by his work with Telstra, was aggravated by that work; that pain associated with that ganglion was resolved by 31 December 2007; and that the ganglion removed in 2010 was unrelated to Mr Foster’s employment. We have had the benefit of hearing from Dr Couzens, Dr Coleman and Dr Cutbush and we are satisfied that their evidence supports the findings of the Tribunal on 8 February 2010 and its decision to affirm the respondent’s decision of 2 February 2009 that it was liable with respect to Mr Foster’s ganglion of the right wrist but that Mr Foster ceased to suffer the effects of that condition by 31 December 2007. On the material before us, we affirm the reviewable decision of 11 May 2011. DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr John Cameron, neurologist, completed a report on 27 October 2008. He noted the presence of the ganglion and concluded that it was unlikely to have been caused by Mr Foster’s clerical duties. He also concluded that he had been unable to find evidence that Mr Foster suffered from obvious tendonitis.CONSIDERATION There is no evidence that Mr Foster’s employment may have caused the 2007 ganglion but some evidence that the condition may have been aggravated by it. That has been conceded by Telstra in the decision under review. The medical evidence does not support Mr Foster’s contention that the ganglion removed by Dr Couzens in March 2010 was related to his earlier ganglion. The highest level at which Dr Couzens was prepared to accept such a relationship was in terms of “possibility” with the likelihood being that it was a new condition. While we have noted Mr Foster’s reference to evidence given by Dr Couzens in other cases, we are satisfied that reliance should be placed on the evidence he has given in relation to the specific circumstances of Mr Foster. We are satisfied that the ganglion is a disease, as defined in s 5B of the Act, and that Telstra will be liable, under ss 14, 16 and 19 of the Act, to compensate Mr Foster in relation to the ganglion removed in 2010 if it was contributed to, to a significant degree, by his Telstra employment. We are satisfied that there is no evidence to support any degree of such contribution or of any relationship between it and the earlier ganglion removed in 2007. We note that Mr Foster’s employment with Telstra ceased in November 2007. Nor is there evidence of tendonitis in Mr Foster’s right arm with the preponderance of evidence describing a possible muscle strain, with any employment‑related contribution to that condition ceasing after he stopped working with Telstra in November 2007. Mr Foster said that he accepted the decision of the Tribunal on 8 February 2010 that he no longer suffered the effects of the compensable injury constituted by the ganglion removed in 2007. His concern was with the ganglion removed in 2010. When the Tribunal decided Mr Foster’s application for review on 8 February 2010, it made findings that Mr Foster did not suffer from tendonitis; that Mr Foster suffered from a ganglion which was removed in 2007 and which, while not caused by his work with Telstra, was aggravated by that work; that pain associated with that ganglion was resolved by 31 December 2007; and that the ganglion removed in 2010 was unrelated to Mr Foster’s employment. We have had the benefit of hearing from Dr Couzens, Dr Coleman and Dr Cutbush and we are satisfied that their evidence supports the findings of the Tribunal on 8 February 2010 and its decision to affirm the respondent’s decision of 2 February 2009 that it was liable with respect to Mr Foster’s ganglion of the right wrist but that Mr Foster ceased to suffer the effects of that condition by 31 December 2007. On the material before us, we affirm the reviewable decision of 11 May 2011. DECISION