SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Rubin v Bank of Queensland Ltd [2010] QSC 175
PARTIES:
HELEN STONE RUBIN
(plaintiff)
v
BANK OF QUEENSLAND LIMITED
ACN 009 656 740
(defendant)FILE NO:
BS 9120 of 2009
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Application
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court of Queensland
DELIVERED ON:
25 May 2010
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
4 December 2009
JUDGE:
Daubney J
ORDER:
1. The defendant, by its appropriate officer or officers, file and serve an affidavit deposing to whether any documents:
(a) within the scope of paragraphs 1(i), 1(iii), 1(iv), 1(v), 1(vi), 1(ix) of the application, or
(b) comprising reports to ASIC pursuant to s 912D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that relate to the defendant’s Kirwan branch Storm customers in 2005,
are in the possession or under the control of the defendant or the circumstances in which those documents cease to exist or passed out of the control of the defendant;
2. Paragraph 1(vii) of the application be dismissed;
3. The defendant shall disclose to the plaintiff any documents in its possession or under its control which record, comprise or evidence any:
(a) compliance checks and reports;
(b) internal and external audit reports;
(c) operational risk reports; and
(d) fraud/investigations/financial crime reports
that relate to the defendant’s Kirwan branch Storm customers in 2005.
4. Paragraph 1(x) of the application be dismissed.
5. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff any document in its possession or under its control detailing the results of the credit risk review undertaken in or about September 2006 by Angela Morrison and/or Petar Bicanic, Manager, Credit Risk Review, Home and Consumer, in relation to the North Ward branch but only insofar as such documents refer to or relate to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan.
6. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff any documents in the possession or under the control of the defendant detailing the results of the credit risk review undertaken in or about February 2008 by Alan Butler or anyone reporting to him but only insofar as such documents refer to or relate to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan.
7. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff any documents in the possession or under the control of the defendant which:
(a) detail the results of informal credit risk reviews conducted by Alan Butler or anyone reporting to him relating to the defendant’s Kirwan branch Storm customers in 2005;
(b) detail the results of informal credit risk reviews conducted by Alan Butler or anyone reporting to him relating to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan between 2006 and 2008.
8. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff the report of Alan Butler, former head of portfolio management and financial crime, dated in or about 2006, but only insofar as such report refers to or relates to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan.
9. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rubin v Bank of Queensland Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2010] QSC 175
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the relevance of the documents to the allegations in the pleadings. It was necessary to determine if the documents sought by the plaintiff were directly relevant to the issues in the case and if they should be disclosed. The court assessed the scope of the application and the necessity of the documents for the plaintiff’s case. It was held that the plaintiff was entitled to certain documents related to compliance checks, audits, risk reports, and credit risk reviews. These documents were deemed relevant to the plaintiff’s allegations concerning the bank’s management of Storm customers.
The court ordered the defendant to disclose specific documents, including those detailing compliance checks, internal and external audit reports, operational risk reports, and fraud investigations. The defendant was also ordered to disclose documents relating to credit risk reviews conducted by specific individuals at particular branches. Some requests for disclosure were dismissed as they were not deemed directly relevant to the issues in the case. The costs of the application were reserved.
The final orders included directions for the defendant to file affidavits regarding specific documents and to disclose various reports and reviews related to Storm customers at the relevant branches. Certain requests for disclosure were dismissed as irrelevant. The costs associated with the application were reserved for further determination.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The defendant, by its appropriate officer or officers, file and serve an affidavit deposing to whether any documents:
(a) within the scope of paragraphs 1(i), 1(iii), 1(iv), 1(v), 1(vi), 1(ix) of the application, or
(b) comprising reports to ASIC pursuant to s 912D of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) that relate to the defendant’s Kirwan branch Storm customers in 2005,
are in the possession or under the control of the defendant or the circumstances in which those documents cease to exist or passed out of the control of the defendant;
2. Paragraph 1(vii) of the application be dismissed;
3. The defendant shall disclose to the plaintiff any documents in its possession or under its control which record, comprise or evidence any:
(a) compliance checks and reports;
(b) internal and external audit reports;
(c) operational risk reports; and
(d) fraud/investigations/financial crime reports
that relate to the defendant’s Kirwan branch Storm customers in 2005.
4. Paragraph 1(x) of the application be dismissed.
5. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff any document in its possession or under its control detailing the results of the credit risk review undertaken in or about September 2006 by Angela Morrison and/or Petar Bicanic, Manager, Credit Risk Review, Home and Consumer, in relation to the North Ward branch but only insofar as such documents refer to or relate to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan.
6. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff any documents in the possession or under the control of the defendant detailing the results of the credit risk review undertaken in or about February 2008 by Alan Butler or anyone reporting to him but only insofar as such documents refer to or relate to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan.
7. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff any documents in the possession or under the control of the defendant which:
(a) detail the results of informal credit risk reviews conducted by Alan Butler or anyone reporting to him relating to the defendant’s Kirwan branch Storm customers in 2005;
(b) detail the results of informal credit risk reviews conducted by Alan Butler or anyone reporting to him relating to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan between 2006 and 2008.
8. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff the report of Alan Butler, former head of portfolio management and financial crime, dated in or about 2006, but only insofar as such report refers to or relates to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan.
9. The defendant disclose to the plaintiff any report of Geoffrey O’Sullivan or anyone reporting to him regarding the credit risk review dated in or about January 2009 and all preceding drafts of that report, but only insofar as such report and such drafts refer to or relate to the defendant’s North Ward branch Storm customers managed by Mr Matthew Buchanan.
10. Paragraph 1(xvi) of the application be dismissed.
11. The costs of and incidental to this application be reserved.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi