Cunningham v Gympie Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Cunningham v Gympie Regional Council [2021] QIRC 387

PARTIES:

Cunningham, Darren
(Applicant)

v

Gympie Regional Council
(Respondent)

CASE NO: B/2021/48
PROCEEDING: Application in existing proceedings
DELIVERED ON: 10 November 2021
HEARING DATES: On the papers
MEMBER: McLennan IC
HEARD AT: Brisbane

ORDERS:

1.       The Form 4 - Application in existing proceedings filed by the Applicant on 12 October 2021 is dismissed.

2.       The stay on the Notice of non-party disclosure dated 5 October 2021 is lifted pursuant to r 64G(2)(a) of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld).

3.       The South Burnett Regional Council is to disclose the documents sought in the Notice of non-party disclosure dated 5 October 2021 to the Respondent within 7 days.

CATCHWORDS: WORKERS' COMPENSATION APPEAL – DISCLOSURE – application to strike out Form 29 Notice of non-party disclosure – whether documents sought are relevant to issue in the proceeding – whether documents sought are already in the possession of the respondent

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) s 475, s 477

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld) r 64B, r 64E, r 64F, r 64G

Gympie Regional Council Certified Agreement 2018 cl 7

Queensland Local Government Industry (Stream A) Award 2017 cl 20

Commissioner of Police (NSW) v Tuxford [2002] NSWCA 139

Goldsmith v Sandilands [2002] HCA 31

Mullins v Workers' Compensation Regulator; Ex parte Drake International Pty Ltd (No 2) [2020] QIRC 003

Robson v REB Engineering Pty Ltd [1997] 2 Qd R 102

Rubin v Bank of Queensland Ltd [2010] QSC 175

Weston and Parer v State of Queensland (Department of Justice and Attorney-General) (No. 4) [2016] QIRC 75

Reasons for Decision

Background

  1. On 5 October 2021, Gympie Regional Council (the Respondent) filed a Form 29 Notice of non-party disclosure with the Industrial Registry (the Notice). 

  2. The Notice sought to compel South Burnett Regional Council (SBRC) to produce various documents relating to Mr Darren Cunningham's employment (the Applicant). The Respondent contends it requires the documents for the future substantive hearing of Mr Cunningham's claim to recover unpaid wages from the Respondent (the Proceeding).

  3. On 12 October 2021, Mr Cunningham objected to the production of all documents mentioned in the Notice pursuant to r 64E of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld) (the Rules) (the Objection).

  4. The Objection stayed the operation of the Notice by virtue of r 64F of the Rules.  

  5. Rule 64G of the Rules prescribes that "Within 7 days after service of an objection under rule 64E, the party may apply to the industrial tribunal for a decision about the objection." Pursuant to r 64G(2), the industrial tribunal may make an order it considers appropriate including, but not limited to, an order lifting the stay, varying the notice or setting aside the notice.

  6. The reasons for the Objection are contained within a Form 4 - Application in existing proceedings (the Application) in which Mr Cunningham seeks an order that "The Commission strike out the application for Non-party production filed by Gympie Regional Council as…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cunningham v Gympie Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QIRC 387
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cunningham v Gympie Regional Council, the applicant, Mr Cunningham, sought to strike out a Notice of non-party disclosure filed by the respondent, Gympie Regional Council, in relation to the applicant's claim for workers' compensation. The dispute centred on whether the documents sought by the respondent were relevant to the issues in the proceeding and whether they were already in the respondent's possession.

The legal issues before the court were whether the documents sought by the respondent were relevant to the issue in the proceeding and whether they were already in the respondent's possession. The court held that the documents were relevant to the issue of "double dipping" and that it was not guaranteed that SBRC had required a certificate from the respondent prior to allowing credit. Further, it was not guaranteed that SBRC had not waived the requirement for continuous service or had not voluntarily recognised all or any part of Mr Cunningham's sick leave entitlement. The court held that the provision of the requested documents would ensure that the matter of recognition of sick leave accruals could be considered.

The court rejected the grounds for the application to strike out the notice and lifted the stay on the notice of non-party disclosure. The court ordered that the South Burnett Regional Council was to disclose the documents sought in the notice within seven days. The court held that the respondent was engaging in a legitimate line of inquiry that would rationally affect the assessment of what order should be made in circumstances where the entitlement was made out on the facts. The court held that the status of recognition of such sick leave accruals was relevant to the commission's consideration of the substantive matter. The court held that if it was found that the entitlement had been transferred or there was some other special arrangement with SBRC with respect to the accrued leave, it would be unreasonable not to consider that information as that information may affect the court's view on whether it was appropriate to order the full amount of relief sought.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Form 4 - Application in existing proceedings filed by the Applicant on 12 October 2021 is dismissed.

2. The stay on the Notice of non-party disclosure dated 5 October 2021 is lifted pursuant to r 64G(2)(a) of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld).

3. The South Burnett Regional Council is to disclose the documents sought in the Notice of non-party disclosure dated 5 October 2021 to the Respondent within 7 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I disagree with Mr Cunningham that the information sought by the Respondent in order to satisfy their enquiry of "double dipping" is already in the Respondent's possession. That premise is based largely on the assumption that SBRC is operating in accordance with the Award. Although compliance with the Award is to be expected, it is not guaranteed that SBRC has required a certificate from the Respondent prior to allowing credit. Further, it is not guaranteed that SBRC has not waived the requirement for continuous service or has not voluntarily recognised all or any part of Mr Cunningham's sick leave entitlement.Conclusion For the reasons outlined above, the grounds for the Application to strike out the Notice are rejected. I will lift the stay and require SBRC to provide the documents subject of the Notice within 7 days from the release of this Decision. I order accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Goldsmith v Sandilands, the High Court of Australia considered when evidence becomes relevant:Evidence is relevant if it could rationally affect, directly or indirectly, the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue in the proceeding.[15][15] [2002] HCA 31. Mr Cunningham submits there is no allegation of "double dipping". Rather, the allegation is that the Respondent has not paid Mr Cunningham an accrued but unused amount of personal leave when he was made redundant, to which he is entitled.[16] In that regard, Mr Cunningham referred to Commissioner of Police (NSW) v Tuxford in which it was held:The opponents were not entitled to procure the issue of the subpoena for the purpose of fishing, that is, endeavouring not to obtain evidence to support their case, but to discover whether they had a case at all, or to discover the nature of the case of the defendant.[17][16] Applicant's Submissions, 18 October 2021, 3 [15]. [17] [2002] NSWCA 139. Mr Cunningham argues that if SBRC "has credited the Applicant any entitlement (which they have not) it would have been done so at its own volition, and not as a result of the crediting provision in the Award."[18] The Respondent argues that "if there has been any recognition of entitlements (compulsory or voluntary) it is a relevant matter for the Commission to consider."[19] The Respondent submits that despite multiple opportunities, Mr Cunningham has failed to conclusively answer whether any part of his accrued but untaken sick leave was recognised by SBRC.[20] [18] Applicant's Submissions in Reply, 1 November 2021, [15]. [19] Respondent's Submissions, 27 October 2021, 2 [9](a).[20] Ibid [9](c). I agree with the Respondent that the status of recognition of such sick leave accruals is relevant to the Commission's consideration of the substantive matter. As such, the provision of the requested documents will ensure that is either ruled out or can be considered.[21] The primary question to be decided is whether or not Mr Cunningham has an entitlement to the alleged unpaid amount. Should that question be answered in the affirmative, my mind will turn to a corresponding order granting the relief sought. Section 477(1) of the IR Act provides (emphasis added):[21] Ibid.(1) On hearing the application, the commission or magistrate—(a) must order the employer to pay the employee—(i) the amount the commission or magistrate finds to be payable and unpaid to the employee for the 6 years before the date of the application; and(ii) an amount the commission or magistrate considers appropriate, based on the return that would have accrued in relation to the contributions had it been properly paid to the approved superannuation fund; and(b) may make an order for the payment despite an express or implied provision of an agreement to the contrary; and(c)may order the payment to be made on the terms the commission or magistrate considers appropriate. If it is found that the entitlement has been transferred or there is some other special arrangement with SBRC with respect to the accrued leave, it would be unreasonable not to consider that information - as that information may affect my view on whether it is appropriate to order the full amount of relief sought. I accept that the Respondent is engaging in a legitimate line of inquiry that will rationally affect the assessment of what order should be made in circumstances where the entitlement is made out on the facts.