Rowe v The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   ROWE -v- THE ROMAN CATHOLIC ARCHBISHOP OF PERTH [2021] WASCA 93

CORAM:   MURPHY JA

MITCHELL JA

HEARD:   21 MAY 2021

DELIVERED          :   21 MAY 2021

PUBLISHED           :   25 MAY 2021

FILE NO/S:   CACV 25 of 2021

BETWEEN:   MICHAEL DAVID ROWE

Appellant

AND

THE ROMAN CATHOLIC ARCHBISHOP OF PERTH

First Respondent

REGISTRAR OF TITLES

Second Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram:   MASTER SANDERSON

Citation: ROWE -v- THE ROMAN CATHOLIC ARCHBISHOP OF PERTH [2020] WASC 487

File Number            :   CIV 2009 of 2020


Catchwords:

Practice and procedure - Interim order - Application for stay or interlocutory injunction pending determination of appeal - Judgment dismissing appellant's application to extend operation of caveat - Where appellant contended interlocutory injunction required because appeal and associated proceedings would be rendered nugatory - Balance of convenience - Grant of interlocutory injunction in the interests of justice

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Application for interlocutory injunction granted

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant : P J Hannon
First Respondent : E M Heenan
Second Respondent : No appearance

Solicitors:

Appellant : Pagin & Mak Lawyers
First Respondent : Irdi Legal
Second Respondent : No appearance

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Above All Rigging & Site Modifications Pty Ltd v Lang [No 2] [2015] WASC 415

Bashford v Bashford [2008] WASC 138

Carnie v Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd [1995] HCA 9; (1995) 182 CLR 398

Davies v Davies [2009] WASCA 238

Dunghutti Elders Council (Aboriginal Corporation) RNTBC v Registrar of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Corporations (No 3) [2011] FCA 1019

Eastland Technology Australia Pty Ltd v Whisson [2003] WASCA 307; (2003) 28 WAR 308

Rowe v Albany Chalets Pty Ltd [2015] WASC 85

Rowe v The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth [2020] WASC 487

Saunders v Vautier (1841) 4 Beav 115; 49 ER 282

Tradesman Technologies Pty Ltd v Ameduri [2012] WASCA 168

REASONS OF THE COURT:

Introduction

  1. We heard an application by the appellant (Fr Rowe) on 21 May 2021 for a stay of the primary orders, alternatively, an injunction restraining the first respondent (Archbishop) from dealing with the land the subject of the primary proceedings.

  2. The dispute relates to the land commonly known as 11 Hehir Street, Belmont in the state of Western Australia (Hehir Street land) over which Fr Rowe contended that he had a caveatable interest.  On 11 August 2020, Fr Rowe lodged a caveat in respect of the Hehir Street land (Caveat). 

  3. Fr Rowe commenced the primary proceedings (caveat proceedings) to extend the operation of the Caveat over the Hehir Street land.  On 6 April 2021, the master dismissed the application and published written reasons on 19 January 2021:  Rowe v The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth[1] (primary decision).

    [1] Rowe v The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth [2020] WASC 487.

  4. By his application, Fr Rowe…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rowe v The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] WASCA 93
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Rowe v The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Perth, the dispute centres on the interpretation and application of Canon Law and the implications it has on civil proceedings, specifically concerning property rights and the validity of a caveat. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The plaintiff, Fr Rowe, challenges the decision of the master to dismiss his application to extend the operation of a caveat on a property located at Hehir Street. The primary dispute involves the ownership and control of the property, with Fr Rowe asserting that the 'St Anne's community' has a legitimate claim over the property under Canon Law.

The legal issues before the court included whether the master erred in not considering the analogy between the main proceedings and the 'parishioners and parsons' reference in Carnie v Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd, which could have affected the assessment of Fr Rowe's caveatable interest. Another issue was whether the 'St Anne's community' could be considered as a quasi-parish holding ecclesiastical goods, thus entitling them to a constructive trust over the property. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the Archbishop's failure to apply for summary judgment within the stipulated time frame was a factor that should have influenced the extension of the caveat. Furthermore, the court examined whether rights under Canon Law could form part of a claim for equitable relief in civil courts.

The court found that the master did not err in law by failing to consider the analogy to the 'parishioners and parsons' reference, as it did not significantly impact the outcome of the case. The court held that the 'St Anne's community' was not a quasi-parish holding ecclesiastical goods, and therefore, Fr Rowe's claim for a constructive trust was not substantiated. The failure of the Archbishop to apply for summary judgment was deemed irrelevant to the decision on the caveat. Lastly, the court concluded that rights conferred under Canon Law do not automatically form part of a civil court claim and must be proven to have a substantive effect in the civil realm. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed, and the decision of the master was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ground 11 alleges the master erred in law in failing to consider the submission of Fr Rowe's counsel as to the analogy between the main proceedings and the 'parishioners and parsons' reference in Carnie v Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd.[25] The master thereby erred in his assessment of the strength of the caveatable interest claim in the Hehir Street land and the merits of the main proceedings.[25] Referring to Carnie v Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd [1995] HCA 9; (1995) 182 CLR 398, 429. Ground 12 alleges that the error in ground 7 caused the master to err in concluding that the status of 'St Anne's community' precludes the existence of a constructive trust in respect of the Hehir Street land, with the 'St Anne's community' as beneficiaries. Ground 13 alleges that even if the master was correct in finding that the 'St Anne's community' is not an unincorporated association, the master erred in law in concluding that status of the 'St Anne's community' as a 'collection of individuals' precludes the existence of a constructive trust in respect of the Hehir Street land, with the 'St Anne's community' as beneficiaries. Ground 14 alleges that the master erred in fact in finding that the 'St Anne's community' does not hold 'ecclesiastical goods' such as the Hehir Street land for the purposes of Canon Law. Accordingly, the master should have found that:1.the 'St Anne's community' is a 'quasi-parish';2.the Hehir Street Land (including the structures thereon such as St Anne's Church) formed part of the 'ecclesiastical goods' owned by that 'quasi-parish'; and3.Fr Rowe, although he did not own those 'ecclesiastical goods', is bound to administer those 'ecclesiastical goods' for the benefit of the St Anne's 'quasi-parish'. Ground 15 alleges that the master erred in law in not extending the operation of the Caveat pending the outcome of the main proceedings given:1.the Archbishop's failure to apply for summary judgment in the main proceedings within the time limit prescribed by the court;2.the Archbishop's acceptance that the balance of convenience favoured the extension of the operation of the Caveat; and3.the complexity of the legal arguments concerning the merits of the main proceedings as disclosed by the written submissions. Ground 16 alleges that the master erred in law in treating the failure of the Archbishop to apply for summary judgment in the main proceedings as irrelevant for the purpose of the primary decision. Fr Rowe alleges that the master should have held the failure formed a discretionary basis to extend the operation of the Caveat. Ground 17 alleges, in effect, that the master erred in law at [23] and [24] of the primary decision in finding rights conferred under Canon Law cannot form part of a claim for equitable relief in a civil court (rather than Canonial). Fr Rowe alleges that the master should have held the main proceedings relate to property rights which may be protected in a civil court even on reliance on Canon Law. Section 138A, s 138B, s 138C and s 138D of the Act provide:138A.Caveats to which s 138B to 138D applyA caveat that has not been lodged -(a)under section 30, 176 or 223A; or(b)by or on behalf of a beneficiary claiming under a will or settlement; or(c)under a court order; or(d)by the Registrar on the direction of the Commissioner; or(e)under any written law other than this Act; or(f)under any Commonwealth Act; or(g)by or on behalf, or with the consent, of the Minister for Lands,is a caveat for the purposes of sections 138B to 138D.138B.Requiring caveator to seek court order extending s 138A caveat(1)If a section 138A caveat has been lodged then the proprietor of the land … may apply … for the Registrar to serve the caveator with a notice to the effect that, unless the caveator takes the action referred to in subsection (2) within 21 days after the day on which the notice is served, the caveat will lapse.(2)If the notice referred to in subsection (1) is served on the caveator then the caveat lapses 21 days after the day on which the notice was served unless, before that time, the caveator has -(a)obtained from the Supreme Court an order extending the operation of the caveat -(i)for such further period as is specified in the order; or(ii)until the further order of the court;and(b)lodged with the Registrar a copy of the order.138C.Supreme Court's powers on application by caveator(1)A caveator who is served with a notice under section 138B(1) may apply to the Supreme Court, in accordance with rules of the court, for an order extending the operation of the caveat.(2)On the hearing of an application under subsection (1), the Supreme Court -(a)if satisfied that the caveator's claim has or may have substance -(i)may make an order extending the operation of the caveat for such period as is specified in the order; or(ii)may make an order extending the operation of the caveat until the further order of the court; or(iii)may make such other orders as it thinks fit concerning the caveat or the land in respect of which the caveat was lodged;and(b)if not satisfied that the caveator's claim has or may have substance, shall dismiss the application; and(c)may make such ancillary orders in relation to the application as it thinks fit.(3)An interim order under this section may be made ex parte unless the court orders otherwise.(4)The applicant shall ensure that the Registrar is served with a copy of each order made by the court on an application under subsection (1).138D.Restrictions on caveators lodging further s 138A caveats(1)If a section 138A caveat -(a)is withdrawn after a notice under section 138B(1) is served on the caveator but before the caveat could lapse under section 138B(2); or(b)has lapsed under section 138B(2); or(c)no longer has effect because of the operation of an order made, or a dismissal, under section 138C by the Supreme Court,then the caveator cannot lodge with the Registrar any further section 138A caveat in respect of the same land unless -(d)the consent of the proprietor to do so and, if the notice issued under section 138B(1) was issued on the application of a judgment creditor, the consent of the judgment creditor to do so are endorsed on the further caveat; or(e)the Supreme Court has made an order giving leave for the lodgment of the further caveat and a copy of that order has been served on the Registrar.(2)If a caveat has been withdrawn before a notice under section 138B(1), if any, is served on the caveator then nothing in subsection (1) prevents the caveator from lodging a further section 138A caveat in respect of the same land.