Rossi v Qantas Airways Limited (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Rossi v Qantas Airways Limited (No 3) [2021] FCA 942

File number: NSD 1549 of 2019
Judgment of: BANKS-SMITH J
Date of judgment: 9 August 2021
Date of publication of reasons: 10 August 2021
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - application by respondent on first day of trial for trial to be adjourned part‑heard on completion of the allocated four days - where witness unavailable by reason of hospital admission - submission that witness's evidence critical to respondent's case - whether unfair prejudice to applicant in delaying completion of proceeding - whether unfair prejudice to respondent in proceeding without witness's evidence - application allowed
Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 173

Magi Enterprises Pty Ltd v Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 340

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 41
Date of hearing: 9 August 2021
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms K Edwards with Ms A Costin
Solicitor for the Applicant: Harmers Workplace Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms E Raper SC with Mr A Smorchevsky
Solicitor for the Respondent: Ashurst Australia

ORDERS

NSD 1549 of 2019
BETWEEN:

SARA ROSSI

Applicant

AND:

QANTAS AIRWAYS LIMITED

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BANKS-SMITH J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 AUGUST 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.By 4.30 pm AEST on 11 August 2021 and subject to further order, the respondent provide a medical certificate from one of Mr John McCristal's medical practitioners stating:

(a)the medical basis upon which Mr McCristal is unable to attend court (via internet video connection) and give evidence in this matter during the dates of 9 to 12 August 2021;

(b)the length of time during which it is currently expected that Mr McCristal will be unable to give such evidence; and

(c)whether, if Mr McCristal remains in [redacted] Private Hospital beyond 23 August 2021, he will be permitted by the hospital to have access to online facilities so that he can give his evidence by internet video connection.

2.Liberty to apply.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BANKS-SMITH J:

  1. This matter was listed for hearing on 8 March 2021 on the allocated trial dates of 9‑12 August 2021.  An issue has arisen with respect to a witness, Mr John McCristal, who was due to be called by the respondent, Qantas Airways Limited.  It appears that Mr McCristal will not be available to be called by Qantas in the allocated trial dates, for reasons explained below.

  2. This proceeding relates to the capacity of the applicant, Ms Sara Rossi, at the time of entry into a deed of settlement with Qantas in 2008.  Mr McCristal acted for Ms Rossi at that time.  This short precis is sufficient to indicate that Mr McCristal's evidence is likely to be of significance for Qantas.

  3. Over the last nine months, the parties and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rossi v Qantas Airways Limited (No 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 942
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rossi v Qantas Airways Limited (No 3) involved a dispute between the plaintiff, Ms Rossi, and the defendant, Qantas Airways Limited. The primary issue before the court was whether the trial should be adjourned part-heard on the completion of the allocated four days due to the unavailability of a critical witness, Mr John McCristal, who was admitted to hospital. Ms Rossi argued that if Mr McCristal did not give evidence, the trial would likely finish within the allocated four days, and the delay caused by his absence was due to inadequate steps taken by Ashurst, Qantas's solicitors, to ascertain the reasons for his hospital admission and his inability to give evidence via video-link.

The court had to decide whether it was in the interests of justice to adjourn the trial part-heard, allowing Mr McCristal to give evidence at a later date, or to proceed without his evidence. The court considered the potential prejudice to both parties and concluded that the interests of justice favoured the respondent's proposal. The court found that Qantas, through Ashurst, had taken all reasonable steps to address Mr McCristal's unavailability and that the inability to communicate directly with him had complicated attempts to obtain an explanation and medical evidence for his non-attendance. Furthermore, the court noted that the trial might not be finished within the four allocated days even without Mr McCristal's evidence.

The court ordered that by a specified time, Qantas must provide a medical certificate from one of Mr John McCristal's medical practitioners, detailing the medical basis for his inability to attend court, the expected duration of his inability to give evidence, and whether he would be permitted access to online facilities if he remained in hospital beyond a certain date. The court also granted liberty to apply for further orders if necessary.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. By 4.30 pm AEST on 11 August 2021 and subject to further order, the respondent provide a medical certificate from one of Mr John McCristal's medical practitioners stating:

(a) the medical basis upon which Mr McCristal is unable to attend court (via internet video connection) and give evidence in this matter during the dates of 9 to 12 August 2021;

(b) the length of time during which it is currently expected that Mr McCristal will be unable to give such evidence; and

(c) whether, if Mr McCristal remains in [redacted] Private Hospital beyond 23 August 2021, he will be permitted by the hospital to have access to online facilities so that he can give his evidence by internet video connection.

2. Liberty to apply.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The matter was raised at the commencement of the first day of the trial. Having heard submissions from the respective parties, I determined that the trial should proceed in the manner suggested by Qantas. These are my reasons for that decision.Evidence Qantas relies on three affidavits that explain the situation with respect to Mr McCristal. The following matters are based on those affidavits. Mr McCristal is a solicitor, but he does not work for the solicitors on the record in these proceedings, and nor is he affiliated in any way with Qantas. He is represented by K&L Gates, or at least they are retained in some manner to communicate on his behalf at present. Qantas relies on affidavits of Olivia McIntosh, a solicitor employed by its solicitors, Ashurst Australia, and an affidavit of Christien Corns of K&L Gates. Ms McIntosh deposes that she is one of the lawyers at Ashurst with carriage of this matter. Ms McIntosh says that she attended a witness conference with Mr McCristal by video-link shortly prior to 23 July 2021 and that she did not have any concerns as to his availability to give evidence during the scheduled trial dates. Ms McIntosh said that on or around 23 July 2021 she was informed by Mr McCristal that he would be unavailable for a witness conference prior to the hearing of this matter on account of a planned hospital admission, but that he would be discharged from hospital on 6 August 2021, and that he would be able to give evidence at the hearing listed to commence on 9 August 2021. Mr McCristal told Ms McIntosh of the reason for his hospital admission, but told her he did not wish to have the reason disclosed to others. The reason has not been disclosed to Ms Rossi or the Court. Ms McIntosh became aware of the intervening difficulty with Mr McCristal's attendance at trial on 4 August 2021, when she received a message to call 'Julie' at Mr McCristal's law firm. Ms McIntosh said she called Julie that day, and was told that John McCristal 'was unwell', 'he is in hospital', and 'his stay in hospital has been extended for two weeks'. Julie told Ms McIntosh that Mr McCristal was expected to be discharged from hospital on or around Monday 23 August 2021. Ms McIntosh spoke to Julie again that day and asked her to confirm whether Mr McCristal was able to give evidence from hospital. Julie told her that the matter was not clear to her and she had no way of contacting Mr McCristal to check. Julie told Ms McIntosh that before he had called her that day (presumably 4 August 2021), she had not heard from him for two weeks. Ms McIntosh then called the hospital where Julie had informed her Mr McCristal had been admitted, and left a message with a staff member who indicated she would pass a message on to one of Mr McCristal's treating practitioners to contact Ms McIntosh. Ms McIntosh said that subsequent to that call, she has not received any communication from Mr McCristal or any of his treating practitioners, and nor was she aware of any such communication having been received by anyone else at Ashurst.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Against the backdrop of those authorities, it was submitted on behalf of Ms Rossi that:(a)if Mr McCristal does not give evidence, then the trial is likely to finish within the allocated four days because the cross-examination of Ms Rossi would necessarily be condensed;(b)there is no appropriate explanation for the delay by Ashurst on 4 and 5 August 2021 in ascertaining the reason for Mr McCristal's admission for treatment or why he could not give evidence by video from the hospital;(c)there is no evidence that Ashurst, having known from 23 July 2021 that Mr McCristal would be having treatment, took proper steps to ascertain whether his estimated discharge date was realistic or likely to be the subject of any extension, or sought appropriate information from his treating practitioners;(d)whilst the evidence discloses that Mr McCristal currently has no access to the internet and so cannot participate by video‑link, it does not address the underlying reason why he is currently undergoing medical treatment and why he has chosen to extend the period of that treatment until after the trial;(e)there is no evidence Mr McCristal was told he would be required for cross‑examination at the trial, and no evidence that he was aware of the importance of his evidence;(f)Mr McCristal previously was said to be unavailable for the trial in December 2020 due to ill-health, and that no evidence supporting that position was provided at the time; and(g)Qantas has not discharged its obligation to provide an explanation as to why the trial should be adjourned part-heard as proposed.Consideration Whilst I acknowledge the force of those submissions, it seems to me clear that the interests of justice favour Qantas's proposal that the trial commence and be adjourned part-heard on the fourth day of trial so that Mr McCristal can give evidence on a later date to be fixed. Closing submissions can then proceed. I have come to this view for the following reasons. First, whilst the Court is to be guided by the principles discussed in Aon, this is not an application for the trial to be adjourned as a whole. The potential prejudice to Ms Rossi in terms of delaying her own evidence and that of the other witnesses is mitigated by the proposal that the trial otherwise proceed. There is no inconvenience to other witnesses and the Court's allocated time will still be utilised. Second, there remains a real prospect, having regard to the number of proposed witnesses and foreshadowed objections to their evidence, that the trial may not be finished within the four allocated days in any event. It is therefore difficult to assess whether there is any prejudice to Ms Rossi caused by the proposal. To the extent that such prejudice is apparent during or after the four allocated trial days, there will be a further opportunity when the trial resumes for Ms Rossi to make submissions as to prejudice. Any such prejudice might be met, at least in some manner, by a costs order. Third, I consider that Qantas, through Ashurst, has done all that it reasonably could since the issue of Mr McCristal's inability to attend trial (by video-link) was disclosed to it. Ashurst acted quickly upon learning of the issue. Further, the inability to communicate directly with Mr McCristal has complicated Ms McIntosh's attempts to obtain an explanation and medical evidence that explains Mr McCristal's non-attendance. It is to be recalled that Ms McIntosh contacted the hospital and sought to have a practitioner contact her. Her call was not returned. I also infer that, as a solicitor who has sworn affidavit evidence for the purpose of this hearing, Mr McCristal should be well aware that there was a prospect he would be cross-examined, regardless of the absence of evidence of Ashurst expressly informing him of that fact. The conduct of the solicitors and the circumstances are quite distinguishable from those discussed in Magi Enterprises Pty Ltd v Luvalot Clothing Pty Ltd.