Rossang Pty Ltd v Lakoteh Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Rossang Pty Ltd v Lakoteh Pty Ltd [2022] QSC 201

PARTIES:

ROSSANG PTY LTD

(applicant)

v
LAKOTEH PTY LTD

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 7448 of 2022

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

7203 of 2022

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

20 September 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

29 July 2022

JUDGE:

Hindman J

ORDER:

1.    It is declared that under clause 2 of the Agreement, the Respondent is obligated to transfer to the Applicant (or the Applicant’s nominee) the Respondent’s half interest in Lot 1 Survey Plan 313498 Title Reference 51262260 being Unit 1, 13-15 The Esplanade, Maroochydore and Lot 702 Survey Plan 305316 Title Reference 51262528 being Unit 702, 13-15 The Esplanade, Maroochydore (the Applicant’s Landowner Retention Lots).

2.   It is ordered that the Respondent transfer to the Applicant (or the Applicant’s nominee) the Applicant’s Landowner Retention Lots.

3.    The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRCTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – where the applicant and respondent had entered into a partnership to conduct real estate ventures – where the partnership generally operated on a 50/50 basis – where the partnership acquired a property for development and entered into a development agreement with a third party developer – where the development is completed, the development agreement completely performed, and the agreement between the partners is performed but for (relevantly) the transfer of real estate between the partners – where the respondent contends the balance of the agreement should not be performed as to do so would render the partnership unable to meet its contended obligation to the respondent – whether the respondent is obligated to perform the balance of the agreement – whether specific performance should be ordered

Partnership Act 1891 (Qld), s 47

Phillips v Spinaze [2005] QSC 268
XL Insurance Co Se v BNY Trust Company of Australia Ltd [2019] NSWCA 215

COUNSEL:

P Travis for the applicant

G J Barr for the respondent

SOLICITORS:

Elliott May Lawyers for the applicant

Greenhalgh Pickard Solicitors for the respondent

Introduction

  1. The applicant (Rossang) applies for a declaration and orders for specific performance requiring the respondent (Lakoteh) to transfer its half-interest in certain real estate to Rossang.  The dispute arises out of a partnership between the parties and the partnership’s involvement in a property development. 

  2. There are no disputed facts.  The resolution of the dispute turns on the proper construction of an agreement between the parties regarding the Development, in particular clause 2.8 of the Agreement concerning the Landowner Advance.

    Background facts

  3. In 2013, Rossang and Lakoteh entered into a partnership for the purpose of conducting real estate ventures on the Sunshine Coast (the Partnership).  There was no written partnership agreement.  Generally, the Partnership operated on a 50/50 basis.  The persons acting for Rossang and Lakoteh about the Partnership were Mr Williamson for Rossang and Mr Bolton for Lakoteh, directors of the respective companies.  

  4. The Partnership acquired development…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rossang Pty Ltd v Lakoteh Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Rossang Pty Ltd v Lakoteh Pty Ltd, the Federal Court was called upon to determine the obligations of the parties under an agreement concerning a real estate development. Rossang and Lakoteh had entered into a partnership to conduct real estate ventures, operating on a 50/50 basis. The partnership had acquired a property for development and had entered into a development agreement with a third-party developer. The dispute centred on the proper interpretation of the agreement between Rossang and Lakoteh, specifically clause 2.8 concerning the Landowner Advance. The key issue was whether Lakoteh was obligated to transfer certain lots to Rossang as part of their agreement, and if specific performance should be ordered to enforce the remaining obligations.

The court examined the agreement between Rossang and Lakoteh and found that all other aspects of the agreement had been performed, except for the transfer of certain lots and cash. The court held that the language of the agreement clearly obligated Lakoteh to transfer the lots to Rossang, and that the winding up of the partnership did not preclude the enforcement of these obligations. The court further determined that there was no impediment to ordering specific performance of the remaining obligations in the agreement, as there was no suggestion that the partnership would be adversely affected financially.

Consequently, the court declared that Lakoteh was obligated to transfer the specified lots to Rossang and ordered Lakoteh to do so. The court also ordered Lakoteh to pay Rossang’s costs of the proceeding. The decision hinged on the clear obligations set out in the agreement and the readiness of Rossang to perform its part of the agreement. The court's ruling ensured that the partnership's obligations were fulfilled as per the terms of their agreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. It is declared that under clause 2 of the Agreement, the Respondent is obligated to transfer to the Applicant (or the Applicant’s nominee) the Respondent’s half interest in Lot 1 Survey Plan 313498 Title Reference 51262260 being Unit 1, 13-15 The Esplanade, Maroochydore and Lot 702 Survey Plan 305316 Title Reference 51262528 being Unit 702, 13-15 The Esplanade, Maroochydore (the Applicant’s Landowner Retention Lots).

2. It is ordered that the Respondent transfer to the Applicant (or the Applicant’s nominee) the Applicant’s Landowner Retention Lots.

3. The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

There are no disputed facts. The resolution of the dispute turns on the proper construction of an agreement between the parties regarding the Development, in particular clause 2.8 of the Agreement concerning the Landowner Advance.Background facts In 2013, Rossang and Lakoteh entered into a partnership for the purpose of conducting real estate ventures on the Sunshine Coast (the Partnership). There was no written partnership agreement. Generally, the Partnership operated on a 50/50 basis. The persons acting for Rossang and Lakoteh about the Partnership were Mr Williamson for Rossang and Mr Bolton for Lakoteh, directors of the respective companies. The Partnership acquired development land located at 13-15 The Esplanade, Maroochydore in 2013. Each partner contributed equally to that acquisition. The Partnership borrowed $1,680,000 from National Australia Bank (NAB) to assist in the acquisition. NAB took a mortgage over the development land. The development to be carried out on the development land comprised the construction of nineteen residential units, two retail tenancies and associated carparking (the Development). The Development was known as “Essence of Cotton Tree”. To progress the Development, the Partnership entered into two agreements: (a)on 25 July 2019, the Partnership and Forrman Pty Ltd (the Developer) entered into an agreement for the construction of the Development (the Development Agreement); (b)also on 25 July 2019, the partners and Mr Williamson personally entered into an agreement entitled Agreement Regarding Essence Cotton Tree (the Agreement). The Agreement attaches a copy of the Development Agreement at Schedule 1. The recitals to the Agreement disclose that: (a)the Partnership owns the development land; (b)the Partnership proposes to enter into the Development Agreement with the Developer; (c)under the Development Agreement, the Partnership will be entitled to retain ownership of certain property in the Development and receive payments from the receipts in respect of the Development, as provided for in the Development Agreement; (d)Mr Williamson had advanced a loan to the Partnership; (e)the Partnership agreed to share and distribute the benefits referred to in (c) above as set out in the Agreement. The Development was completed, the Development Agreement completely performed, and the Agreement partly performed. What is in dispute As yet unperformed under the Agreement is the transfer of a real estate interest from Lakoteh to Rossang of certain lots in the Development (the Applicant’s Landowner Retention Lots) (which are the focus of this proceeding), and the transfer from the Rossang to Lakoteh of certain lots in the Development (the Respondent’s Landowner Retention Lots) as well as cash from the Partnership account to Lakoteh (the Landowner’s Entitlement). Rossang says (and it is not disputed) that it stands ready, willing and able to do all that is necessary to make the transfers, so that the transfers to Lakoteh are not in issue. The obstacle to performance of the Agreement is that Lakoteh refuses to transfer the Applicant’s Landowner Retention Lots to Rossang.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

All other aspects of the Agreement having been performed, the balance of the Agreement should be ordered to be performed. The winding up of the Partnership is no bar to that occurring. Conclusion The consequence of the above is that orders should be made as follows: 1.It is declared that under clause 2 of the Agreement, the Respondent is obligated to transfer to the Applicant (or the Applicant’s nominee) the Respondent’s half interest in Lot 1 Survey Plan 313498 Title Reference 51262260 being Unit 1, 13-15 The Esplanade, Maroochydore and Lot 702 Survey Plan 305316 Title Reference 51262528 being Unit 702, 13-15 The Esplanade, Maroochydore (the Applicant’s Landowner Retention Lots).2.It is ordered that the Respondent transfer to the Applicant (or the Applicant’s nominee) the Applicant’s Landowner Retention Lots.3.The Respondent pay the Applicant’s costs of the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

If no such liability was created (and continues to exist), then there does not seem to be (based on the submissions of the parties) any other impediment to ordering the specific performance of the remaining obligations in the Agreement. To so order would not adversely affect the winding up of the Partnership as there is no suggestion that the Partnership is insolvent if it does not have the above liabilities to the partners. The operation of the Development Agreement As above, the Agreement attaches the Development Agreement as a schedule and it picks up language and definitions from the Development Agreement. Accordingly, it is convenient to commence with an analysis of the operation of the Development Agreement, which will assist to inform the operation of the Agreement. The Development Agreement in its recitals notes that: (a)the Partnership is the owner of the development land; (b)the Partnership wishes to engage the Developer to complete the Development on the terms of the Development Agreement. The key aspects of the operation of the Development Agreement are as follows. The Developer is to finance and construct the Development. Lots in the Development are to be sold (excluding some lots which the Landowner retains) and the proceeds from the Development are to be distributed in an identified way. The monies and other benefits that the Partnership obtains by participation in the Development comprised and were paid as follows. First, the Partnership was to receive a payment from the Developer shortly after the Development Agreement was entered into of approximately $282,000, representing reimbursement of costs the Partnership had already incurred about the Development (clause 11.4 and Schedule 4) (Landowner Reimbursement). The Landowner Reimbursement was paid by the Developer to the Partnership on 23 August 2019. Second, the Partnership was to receive loan from the Developer shortly after the Development Agreement was entered into of $1,680,000, which amount was required to be used to pay out the existing debt (secured by mortgage on the development land) that the Partnership owed to NAB (clause 11.3) (Landowner Advance). The Landowner Advance was required to be repaid by the Partnership to the Developer. The terms of the Landowner Advance were: “11.3Landowner Advance[1][1]Landowner Advance was defined in clause 1.2 to mean a loan from the Developer to the Landowner (the Partnership) of $1,680,000 on the terms in clause 11.3.The Developer agrees to lend the Landowner Advance to the Landowner, subject to and in accordance with the following terms: (a) subject to clause 11.3(c) and clause 11.3(d), the Developer will make the Landowner Advance available to the Landowner on or before the date five Business Days after the Effective Date;(b)proceeds of the Landowner Advance must be applied only in repayment of amounts owed by the Landowner to the Existing Mortgagee and secured by the Existing Mortgage;(c)the Landowner Advance may, at the Developer’s discretion, be paid directly to the Existing Mortgagee in which case the Landowner Advance will be deemed to have been made available to the Landowner in accordance with this clause 11.3;(d)provision of the Landowner Advance is subject to and conditional upon receipt by the Developer of a release in respect of the Existing Mortgage and any Security Interest held by the Existing Mortgagee in respect of Project Assets, in form and substance satisfactory to the Developer;(e)no interest will accrue or be payable in respect of the Landowner Advance under this agreement;(f)the Landowner must repay to the Developer the Landowner Advance:(1) if this agreement terminates or is terminated …; and[2](2) otherwise, in accordance with clause 14.5(d).”[2]The Development Agreement was not terminated so this subclause does not apply.