Ron Medich Properties Pty Ltd v Bentley-Smythe Pty Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ron Medich Properties Pty Ltd v Bentley-Smythe Pty Ltd (No 3) [2009] FCA 335

INJUNCTION – application for Mareva relief – effect non disclosure of material facts – general principles applicable to claims for interlocutory injunctive relief and Mareva relief in particular

Held:  application dismissed

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Limited (2001) 208 CLR 199 (cited)
Cardile v LED Builders Pty Limited (1999) 198 CLR 380 (cited)
Ausbro Forex Pty Ltd v Mare (1986) 4 NSWLR 419 (cited)
Patterson v BTR Engineering (Aust) Ltd (1989) 18 NSWLR 319 (cited)
Castlemaine Tooheys Ltd v South Australia (1986) 161 CLR 148 (cited)
Shercliff v Engadine Acceptance Corporation Pty Ltd (1978) 1 NSWLR 729 (cited)
Appleton Papers Inc v Tomasetti Paper Pty Ltd (1983) 3 NSWLR 208 (cited)
Reid v Howard (1995) 184 CLR 1 (cited)
Thomas A. Edison Limited v Bullock (1913) 15 CLR 679 (cited)
Garrard (T/as Arthur Anderson & Co) v Email Furniture Pty Ltd (1993) 32 NSWLR 662 (cited)

RON MEDICH PROPERTIES PTY LTD ACN 084 840 095 and KALMARN PTY LTD ACN 131 025 066 v BENTLEY-SMYTHE PTY LTD ACN 128 402 773, CONTROL RISKS INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD ACN 120 588 696, ACETT PTY LTD ACN 127 983 984, MICHAEL LOCH MCGURK and KIMBERLEY FRANCIS ANN MCGURK

NSD 224 of 2009

GRAHAM J
8 APRIL 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 224 of 2009

IN THE MATTER OF BENTLEY-SMYTHE PTY LTD ACN 128 402 773; CONTROL RISKS INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD ACN 120 588 696 AND ACETT PTY LTD ACN 127 983 984

BETWEEN:

RON MEDICH PROPERTIES PTY LTD ACN 084 840 095
First Plaintiff

KALMARN PTY LTD ACN 131 025 066
Second Plaintiff

AND:

BENTLEY-SMYTHE PTY LTD ACN 128 402 773
First Defendant

CONTROL RISKS INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD ACN 120 588 696
Second Defendant

ACETT PTY LTD ACN 127 983 984
Third Defendant

MICHAEL LOCH MCGURK
Fourth Defendant

KIMBERLEY FRANCIS ANN MCGURK
Fifth Defendant

JUDGE:

GRAHAM J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 APRIL 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Amended Interlocutory Process filed 26 March 2009 be dismissed.

2.The first plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the Interlocutory Process filed 18 March 2009, the Amended Interlocutory Process filed 26 March 2009 and the costs thrown away by the amendment of the Originating Process on 26 March 2009.

3.The said costs may be taxed and shall be payable forthwith.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 224 of 2009

IN THE MATTER OF BENTLEY-SMYTHE PTY LTD ACN 128 402 773; CONTROL RISKS INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD ACN 120 588 696 AND ACETT PTY LTD ACN 127 983 984

BETWEEN:

RON MEDICH PROPERTIES PTY LTD ACN 084 840 095
First Plaintiff

KALMARN PTY LTD ACN 131…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ron Medich Properties Pty Ltd v Bentley-Smythe Pty Ltd (No 3... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 335
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ron Medich Properties Pty Ltd v Bentley-Smythe Pty Ltd (No 3) involved a dispute between the parties regarding the ownership and disposition of certain properties and funds. The key issue before the court was whether the plaintiff was entitled to an account and payment of funds from the defendants, based on their involvement in transactions related to the acquisition and sale of properties. The court was tasked with determining the extent to which the plaintiff could claim rights over funds that had been used in the acquisition and subsequent sale of a property.

The court examined the nature of the obligations of candour and diligence imposed upon the parties, particularly the moving party. It was noted that such obligations do not differ whether the order sought is in the nature of an injunction or one that creates or confirms rights. The court assessed the evidence provided by both parties, focusing on the transactions involving the acquisition and sale of a shopping centre at Leichhardt and properties in Point Piper and Mowbray.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the specific terms of the contracts and the conduct of the parties. It found that the plaintiff had not made any monetary demand against the defendants but sought an account and an order for payment based on their respective roles in the transactions. The court concluded that the plaintiff's claims were not substantiated by the evidence, and thus dismissed the application. It further ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendants' costs associated with the proceedings.

In summary, the court's decision was that the plaintiff's application for an account and payment was dismissed, and it ordered the plaintiff to pay the defendants' costs of and incidental to the proceedings. These costs were to be taxed and payable forthwith.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Amended Interlocutory Process filed 26 March 2009 be dismissed.

2. The first plaintiff pay the defendants’ costs of and incidental to the Interlocutory Process filed 18 March 2009, the Amended Interlocutory Process filed 26 March 2009 and the costs thrown away by the amendment of the Originating Process on 26 March 2009.

3. The said costs may be taxed and shall be payable forthwith.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

In respect of an obligation of candour and diligence imposed upon a moving party no distinction exists between an order in the nature of an injunction and an order which creates or confirms rights which otherwise would not exist (per Mahoney AP in Garrard (T/as Arthur Anderson & Co) v Email Furniture Pty Ltd (1993) 32 NSWLR 662 at 677).The significant facts For the purposes of the application presently before the Court it is unnecessary to comprehensively state all the facts covered by the evidence. Suffice it to say that Mr Medich and Mr McGurk have had business dealings with one another since about 2006. The impression is that Mr Medich is a property investor and financier whereas Mr McGurk is more of an entrepreneur with involvement in property and other activities. It seems to be common ground that interests associated with Mr Medich own or have owned a shopping centre at Leichhardt and that he or interests associated with him own certain properties in Wolseley Road, Point Piper. It seems to be common ground, although it was not disclosed to Jacobson J, that Mr Medich or interests associated with him invested a vast amount of money, said to be $25 million, in a listed company, Amazing Loans Limited, which conducted a money lending business. In about mid 2007 Mr Medich appears to have taken a view that Mr Mathieson, the Chief Executive of Amazing Loans Limited, was steering the company in a direction which he found unacceptable. He sought to extricate himself from his investment in Amazing Loans Limited. Mr McGurk says, and it does not appear to have been denied, that Mr Medich entrusted him with the task of extricating Mr Medich from his investment in Amazing Loans Limited. It is said that the arrangement contemplated that the Medich interests would keep the $3 million which Mr Medich had already been able to recover but that, thereafter, monies recovered would be divided as to two thirds to the Medich interests and one third to the McGurk interests once recoveries had exceeded a $14 million threshold. On 12 March 2009 Mr Medich made a statement in which he said:‘McGurk helped me recover my investment in late 2007 …. Because I was under the belief that McGurk helped me recover my funds my confidence in him increased and I trusted him. I actually gave McGurk 3.8 million dollars to pay off mortgages over his home at Cranbrook Avenue Cremorne [apparently registered in the fifth defendant’s, Mrs McGurk’s, name] just before I recovered the money from Amazing Loans as his commission.’ In the foregoing context Mr Medich says that in or about October 2007 he had a discussion with Mr McGurk in relation to the possible acquisition and development of two properties, one at Mowbray in the State of Queensland and the other at Gerroa in the State of New South Wales. Thereafter on or about 19 May 2008 Mr McGurk had contact with Mr Medich in which Mr McGurk is said to have solicited the provision of $4.4 million from Medich interests to be employed in making a loan in respect of a property in Bower Street, Manly.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAHAM J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAHAM J

The contract of sale whereby the first plaintiff acquired the Mowbray property from the third defendant was itself dated 19 December 2007. It provided for a purchase price of $1,420,000 and the settlement statement indicated that after adjustments $1,481,643.00 was payable on settlement. The contract recorded that the third defendant was selling as mortgagee exercising power of sale under the mortgage registered as dealing number 710644880, which would appear to have been the second mortgage. Be that as it may, the plaintiff’s complaint is that, if the first plaintiff has already paid to acquire the mortgages and the third defendant, which used the first plaintiff’s money to do so, proceeded to sell the Mowbray property to the first plaintiff for $1,481,643.00, then there should have been a return of that amount to the first plaintiff as the beneficial owner of the interests in the mortgages which the third defendant had so acquired.Consideration It is important to note that no monetary demand has been made by the first plaintiff for the payment of a debt said to be owing by the second defendant or any other party to the first plaintiff. All that is sought is an account and an order for payment of such amount as may be found to be due upon the taking of that account. In Mr McGurk’s affidavit of 25 March 2009 he deposed, at paragraph 111, to a conversation between himself and Mr Medich to the following effect:McGurk: ‘Ron, I’ve got the money in Acett. What do you want to do?’Medich:‘Keep it for the time being. We will have to sort out all of this in the wash up of Amazing Loans and the acquisition of the interest in Bentley-Smythe Financial Services.’ In paragraph 9 of an affidavit sworn by Mr Medich on 26 March 2009 he deposed to only becoming aware that Mr McGurk was the sole officer and shareholder of the third defendant about a month ago. He says that until that time he was not aware that the third defendant was in any way related to Mr McGurk. However, it may be noted that the conversation to which Mr McGurk deposed has not as yet been put in issue. In relation to the $4.4 million made available by the first plaintiff to the first defendant on 21 May 2008 Mr McGurk’s evidence was set out at paragraphs 41-42 of his affidavit sworn 25 March 2009 as follows:‘41.In May 2008, I met with Mr Medich at his offices in Leichardt (sic). During this meeting, we said words to the effect:I said:“Ron, we now have all the money in from Amazing Loans and we are lucky to get an agreement to sell the balance of the shares to Mathieson. On any view, we have $35 million worth of benefit and a further $11.5 million potential benefit from the sale of the shares. I need to get some money from you as per our agreement.”Mr Medich:“Why don’t we wait for the sale to be finalised and we can finish it all at once?”I said:“No Ron. You’ve got the money in your superannuation fund. You’re fully aware that one third of that money is mine. I need money to live on, run my business and anything else I want to do.”Mr Medich:“How much do you want?”I said:“I want $5 million. I have a good deal which I can lend some money on with good returns and I want to get on with it. I don’t want to keep asking you for money. Now that we have the final portion away let’s just sort this out.”Mr Medich:“I will arrange for a transfer. How much do you need?”I said:“Send Bentley-Smythe $4.4million. That will get me moving and you can send me the balance when I get back from holidays as Mathieson’s other $3 million will have hit the bank by then and we can sort out the complete balance in December.”42.On 22 May 2008, Mr Medich caused $4,400,000 to be transferred to the First Defendant’s account with Suncorp.’