Commissioner of Taxation v Grimaldi (No. 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Commissioner of Taxation v Grimaldi (No. 3) [2009] FCA 740

INJUNCTION – Application for Mareva relief in respect of assets of foreign corporations – undertakings proffered to the Court

EQUITY – consequences of the mixture of funds of several parties in an indistinguishable mass

International Companies Act No. 32 of 1992 (Republic of Vanuatu)
International Tax Agreements Act 1953 (Cth)
Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters Act 1992 (New Zealand) ss 56 and 58
Federal Court Rules Order 25A rules 5(4)-(5)

Ron Medich Properties Pty Ltd v Bentley-Smythe Pty Ltd (No. 3) [2009] FCA 335
Sutherland Re; French Caledonia Travel Service Pty Ltd (In Liq) (2003) 59 NSWLR 361
In Re Hallett’s Estate: Knatchbull v Hallett (1880) 13 ChD 696
Taylor v Plumer (1815) 3 M&S 562; (1815) 105 ER 721
Brady v Stapleton (1952) 88 CLR 322

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION v PHILLIP GRIMALDI, GARRY BONACCORSO, IFTC BROKING SERVICES LTD, MGG CAPITAL PTY LIMITED AS TRUSTEE FOR WEBTEL MANAGEMENT SUPER FUND and INTERNATIONAL FINANCE TRUST COMPANY LTD (FIFTH RESPONDENT ON THE NOTICE OF MOTION FILED IN COURT ON 11 MAY 2009)

NSD 407 of 2009

GRAHAM J
9 JULY 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 407 of 2009

BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Applicant

AND:

PHILLIP GRIMALDI
First Respondent

GARRY BONACCORSO
Second Respondent

IFTC BROKING SERVICES LTD
Third Respondent

MGG CAPITAL PTY LIMITED AS TRUSTEE FOR WEBTEL MANAGEMENT SUPER FUND
Fourth Respondent

INTERNATIONAL FINANCE TRUST COMPANY LTD
Fifth Respondent (on the Notice of Motion filed in Court on 11 May 2009)

JUDGE:

GRAHAM J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 JULY 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s application for relief against the third respondent in terms of paragraph 4 of the Notice of Motion filed 11 May 2009 be dismissed.

2.The applicant’s application for relief against the fifth respondent in terms of paragraph 6 of the Notice of Motion filed 11 May 2009 be dismissed.

3.The third and fifth respondents pay one quarter of the costs of the applicant of the Notice of Motion filed 11 May 2009.

4.Orders 1 and 2 may be entered forthwith but Order 3 shall not be entered before 17 July 2009.

AND THE COURT GRANTS:

5.Liberty to apply in respect of Order 3.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 407 of 2009

BETWEEN:

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION
Applicant

AND:

PHILLIP GRIMALDI
First Respondent

GARRY BONACCORSO
Second Respondent

IFTC BROKING SERVICES LTD
Third Respondent

MGG CAPITAL PTY LIMITED AS TRUSTEE FOR WEBTEL MANAGEMENT SUPER FUND
Fourth Respondent

INTERNATIONAL FINANCE TRUST COMPANY LTD
Fifth Respondent (on the Notice of Motion filed in Court on 11 May 2009)

JUDGE:

GRAHAM J

DATE:

9 JULY 2009

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. These proceedings were instituted by an…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Grimaldi (No. 3) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 740
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Commissioner of Taxation v Grimaldi (No. 3) involved a dispute regarding the taxation of Iron Ore Sales and Management (HK) Ltd, a company incorporated under the laws of Vanuatu. The primary issue before the court was whether the company's profits should be subject to Australian taxation, considering the company's structure and operations as outlined in its constitution. The company's constitution stipulated various restrictions on its operations, including limitations on business activities in Vanuatu and the distribution of profits among its members. It also detailed the appointment and removal of directors, the admission of members, and the winding up process.

The legal issues addressed by the court included the interpretation of the company's constitution, specifically the provisions related to the distribution of profits and the application of these profits in the event of winding up. The court had to determine whether the company's profits, which were accumulated rather than distributed, were subject to taxation in Australia. The constitution's provisions suggested that any surplus assets, including accumulated profits, would be disposed of in a manner determined by the Appointor, subject to certain conditions, including the possibility of distribution to the International Committee of the Red Cross.

The court reasoned that the constitution of the company clearly stipulated that profits were not to be distributed among the members but were to be accumulated as an accretion to the company's reserves. This accumulation of profits, as outlined in the constitution, indicated that the company was not operating for profit distribution, which is a key factor in determining taxable income. The court found that the company's operations and the nature of its profits did not support the imposition of Australian taxation on these undistributed profits. Consequently, the court dismissed the applications for relief against the third and fifth respondents.

The final orders of the court included dismissing the applications for relief against the third and fifth respondents and directing that these respondents pay one quarter of the applicant's costs. The court also granted liberty to apply regarding the payment of costs, allowing for a potential review of the cost award if circumstances warranted it. The orders regarding the dismissal of the applications were to be entered forthwith, while the order concerning costs was to be entered after a specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s application for relief against the third respondent in terms of paragraph 4 of the Notice of Motion filed 11 May 2009 be dismissed.

2. The applicant’s application for relief against the fifth respondent in terms of paragraph 6 of the Notice of Motion filed 11 May 2009 be dismissed.

3. The third and fifth respondents pay one quarter of the costs of the applicant of the Notice of Motion filed 11 May 2009.

4. Orders 1 and 2 may be entered forthwith but Order 3 shall not be entered before 17 July 2009.

AND THE COURT GRANTS:

5. Liberty to apply in respect of Order 3.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GRAHAM J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GRAHAM J

The Constitution of Iron Ore Sales and Management (HK) Ltd included the following:‘…RESTRICTIONS ON OPERATIONS5.…(2)The Company is an International Company and accordingly shall not, except as may be permitted by the Act:-(a)carry on business in Vanuatu or own an interest in immovable property situate in Vanuatu other than a lease of premises from which to carry on its business;…(3)For the purposes of subparagraph (2)(a) the Company shall not be treated as carrying on business in Vanuatu by reason only that it – (a)carries on business with another company incorporated under the Act or in furtherance of the business of the Company carried on outside Vanuatu;(b)leases premises from which to carry on its business as permitted by the Act;(c)makes or maintains deposits with a person licensed to carry on banking business in Vanuatu;(d)obtains professional services from its registered agent, counsel, attorneys, accountants, bookkeepers, trust companies, management companies, investment advisers, insurance brokers or agents or other similar persons carrying on business within Vanuatu;(e)prepares or maintains its books or records within Vanuatu;(f)holds meetings within Vanuatu of its directors or members;(g)holds shares, debt obligations or other securities in a company incorporated under this Act or under the Companies Act; or(h)issues shares, debt obligations or other securities to any person resident in Vanuatu or any company incorporated under this Act or under the Companies Act.TYPE OF COMPANY6.(1)The Company is limited by guarantee.(2)Each member undertake to contribute to the assets of the company in the event of it being wound up while he is a member or within 3 months after he ceases to be a member, for payment of the debts and liabilities of the Company contracted before he ceases to be a member, and of the costs, charges and expenses of winding up, and for adjustment of the rights of contributories amongst themselves, such amount as may be required, not exceeding US$5.00.INTERPRETATION7.…(3)In this Constitution:(a)“the Appointor” means the individual nominated as such by instrument in writing signed by the Incorporator or Incorporators of the Company and deposited at the registered office of the Company dated of even date with this Constitution. The Appointor may by notice in writing nominate a successor who shall thereupon be the Appointor, provided this nomination is confirmed in writing by both the Registered Agent and the Guardian. Should any such Appointor die or otherwise become incapable of acting before nominating a successor, the Registered Agent is empowered to appoint a person to the office of Appointor provided this appointment is confirmed in writing by the Guardian. The Appointor may be removed from office by notice in writing signed by both the Registered Agent and Guardian.(b)“the Guardian” means the individual nominated as such by instrument in writing signed by the Incorporator or Incorporators and deposited at the registered office of the Company dated of even date with this Constitution. The Guardian may by notice in writing nominate a successor who shall thereupon be the Guardian, provided this nomination is confirmed in writing by the both (sic) the Registered Agent and the Appointor. Should any such Guardian die or otherwise become incapable of acting before nominating a successor, the Registered Agent is empowered to appoint a person to the office of Guardian, provided this appointment is confirmed in writing by the Appointor. The Guardian may be removed from office by notice in writing signed by both the Registered Agent and the Appointor …PROFITS11.The profits of the Company shall not be distributed in any way among the members of the Company but shall be accumulated as an accretion to the reserves of the Company.…REGISTERED OFFICE AND AGENT12.(1)The Company shall at all times have a registered office and registered agent in Vanuatu.(2)The directors may by resolution change the registered office or registered agent of the Company.…APPOINTMENT, TERM AND REMOVAL OF DIRECTORS13.(1)The first directors shall and any subsequent directors may be appointed by the members for such term as they may determine.…(3)The office of a director shall be vacated if:(a)he is removed from office by a resolution of the members or of the directors (sic) of the Company;(b)in the case of the (sic) corporate director, it enters liquidation or it ceases to be a body corporate;…(5)Until directors are appointed, the Incorporators shall have the power to act as directors.…ADMISSION TO MEMBERSHIP29.(1)Each Incorporator of the Company shall be a member of the Company until such other persons are admitted to membership in accordance with this Constitution at which time the Incorporator or Incorporators shall cease to be members unless their membership is approved in writing by the Appointor and confirmed in writing by the Guardian.…DURATION OF COMPANY50.(1)The duration of the Company shall be until the later of the following:(a)the date, if any, specified in any instrument signed by the Appointor and confirmed in writing by the Guardian and delivered to the Company, upon which date the company shall be dissolved; or(b)the date the Company is wound up or struck off in accordance with the Act.(2)Upon the date specified in subparagraph (1)(a) above, the directors shall forthwith proceed to convene a meeting of the members for the purpose of adopting a resolution requiring the Company to be wound up voluntarily in accordance with Part 12 of the Act.…WINDING UP52.On a winding up of the Company, after payment of the expenses of winding up and all of the creditors of the Company, the surplus assets of the Company (including any accumulated profits of the Company) shall be applied in paying to all of the members divided between them no more than the sum of US$5.00 and the members of the Company shall have no further right to participate in the surplus assets aforesaid which shall be disposed of by the liquidator to such person or persons (other than the Appointor) in such amounts and in such manner as the Appointor by instrument of instruments (sic) in writing signed by the Appointor and confirmed by the Guardian, and delivered to the Company, shall appoint but if the Appointor and/or the Guardian shall not have made any such appointment and/or confirmation, or insofar as any such appointment and/or confirmation shall not extend to the whole of the surplus assets of the Company or in default of the aforesaid power of appointment being exercised within 20 years, of the date upon which the Company was put into liquidation, the surplus assets aforesaid shall be the date upon which the Company was put into liquidation (sic), the surplus assets aforesaid shall be disposed of by the liquidator by paying them over to the International Committee of the Red Cross, Geneva, Switzerland.…’