Romanos v Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GLEESON CJ,
McHUGH, GUMMOW, KIRBY, HAYNE, CALLINAN AND HEYDON JJ

JOSEPH JOHN ROMANOS & ANOR  APPELLANTS

AND

PENTAGOLD INVESTMENTS PTY LIMITED & ANOR                RESPONDENTS

Romanos v Pentagold Investments Pty Limited [2003] HCA 58

7 October 2003
S356/2002

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of New South Wales made on 12 December 2001 and, in lieu thereof, order that:

(a)       the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs;

(b)       the cross-appeal to that Court be allowed with costs; and

(c)it be declared that the total sum of $50,000 paid as deposits under the contracts for sale is forfeited to the appellants.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales

Representation:

B A J Coles QC with D L Warren for the appellants (instructed by Robilliard Plowman Herat)

D P F Officer QC with R J Powell and S W Balafoutis for the respondents (instructed by Bolsters Solicitors)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

CATCHWORDS

Romanos v Pentagold Investments Pty Limited

Vendor and purchaser – Contracts for sale of land – Balance of deposit to be paid on approval of development application – Time of essence – Default by purchasers – Notice of termination – Balance of deposit paid following day – Specific performance – Whether unconscientious for vendors to exercise right of termination – Whether termination effective in absence of prior notice to purchasers requiring payment of deposit within reasonable time. 

Equity – Relief against forfeiture – Contracts for sale of land – Default by purchasers – Whether unconscientious for vendors to exercise right of termination – Whether default occasioned by "accident" – Whether relief on the ground of "accident" available in face of essential time stipulation.

  1. GLEESON CJ, McHUGH, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND HEYDON JJ.   This appeal was heard consecutively with that in Tanwar Enterprises Pty Ltd v Cauchi[1], and what follows should be read with our reasons for judgment in Tanwar.  However, the decision against which this appeal is brought appears also to have challenged the orthodox view among conveyancers[2] that failure in timely payment of a deposit entitles the vendor to terminate, leaving the purchaser with no right to insist on future performance of the contract.

    [2]Butt, "Purchasers relieved against loss of contract", (2002) 76 Australian Law Journal 347 at 350.

  2. On 15 September 1999, contracts were exchanged for the sale of three adjoining parcels of land at Harris Park, near Parramatta.  The parcels of land may be identified as Nos 44, 46 and 48 Wigram Street.  The vendor of No 44 was the first appellant, Mr Romanos.  The vendor of the other two parcels was Mrs Teresa Romanos.  Mrs Romanos died on 23 September 2001 and her executor, Mr Romanos, is the second appellant.  The total purchase price was $1,875,000; for each of Nos 44 and 46, the price was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Romanos v Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] HCA 58
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Romanos v Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd* involved a dispute between vendors, Mr and Mrs Romanos, and purchasers, Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd and Maroon Bros Investments Pty Ltd, concerning contracts for the sale of three adjoining parcels of land. The purchasers intended to develop the land for residential units, with the balance of the deposit payable upon the approval of a development application. The contracts stipulated that time for payment of the deposit was of the essence, and the vendors sought to terminate the contracts due to the purchasers' failure to pay the balance of the deposit promptly after development approval was granted. The High Court of Australia heard the appeal from the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The central legal issues before the High Court were whether the purchasers were entitled to specific performance of the contracts despite their default in paying the balance of the deposit, and whether it was unconscionable for the vendors to exercise their right of termination. The court was required to consider whether the purchasers' failure to comply with the essential time stipulation for payment constituted "accident" or "exceptional circumstances" that would warrant equitable relief against forfeiture, particularly in the absence of a prior notice from the vendors requiring payment within a reasonable time.

The High Court allowed the vendors' appeal, setting aside the orders of the Court of Appeal. The Court reasoned that the purchasers, being legally advised investment companies, had accepted an essential time stipulation for the payment of substantial deposits. The purchasers failed to provide sufficient evidence to establish grounds for equitable relief, such as proving the precise reasons for their delay or demonstrating that the vendors' exercise of their legal rights was unconscionable. The primary judge had correctly declined to grant relief against forfeiture, finding no unconscionable conduct or exceptional circumstances. The High Court concluded that the purchasers were in breach of contract, entitling the vendors to terminate, and that the purchasers had not established a basis for equitable intervention.

Consequently, the High Court ordered that the appeal to the Court of Appeal be dismissed with costs, and the cross-appeal to that Court be allowed with costs. It was declared that the total sum of $50,000 paid as deposits under the contracts for sale was forfeited to the appellants (the vendors).

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of New South Wales made on 12 December 2001 and, in lieu thereof, order that:

(a) the appeal to that Court be dismissed with costs;

(b) the cross-appeal to that Court be allowed with costs; and

(c) it be declared that the total sum of $50,000 paid as deposits under the contracts for sale is forfeited to the appellants.

Background

Background to the litigation

There are points of similarity and of difference in the facts of the two cases. The essential difference is that, in the present case, the Court of Appeal allowed the appeal from the judgment of the primary judge, set aside his orders, granted relief against forfeiture, declared that the purchasers were entitled to have the subject agreements specifically performed and ordered specific performance in each case. From those orders, by special leave, the vendors have appealed to this Court.The facts On 15 September 1999, Mr and Mrs Romanos ("the vendors") entered into contracts of sale for three adjoining parcels of land in Harris Park, near Sydney, with Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd and Maroon Bros Investments Pty Ltd ("the purchasers"). Both of the purchasers are investment companies that wished to develop the land for the erection on it of twenty-four home units. The agreed price for the aggregate purchase was $1.875 million. Each contract stipulated that a deposit was payable on exchange amounting, in all, to $18,750. This sum represented one-tenth of the stipulated total deposit. The balance of nine-tenths of the deposit was payable in accordance with special condition 17(b) of each contract. That condition provided for payment upon the approval of a development application in respect of the land. By special condition 19 of each contract, the purchasers were obliged to keep the vendor advised of the progress of the development application and to inform the vendor "immediately approval is received". In fact, the local authority gave approval for the development on 24 November 2000. Notice of such approval was not received by the purchasers until Friday, 1 December 2000 at 5 pm. On the previous day, the purchasers gave notice to the vendors that they required completion of the contracts on 1 March 2001, having decided that they would settle whether or not development approval was obtained. Time for compliance with the payment of the deposit was made essential by cll 2.2 and 2.3 of the contracts. By cl 2.5 in each contract it was provided that, if any of the deposit was not paid on time, the vendor could terminate the contract. However, the vendor could only do so before the deposit was paid in full.The decision of the primary judge The primary judge held that, in the circumstances, compliance with the provisions of the contracts as to time would have been sufficient if the payment had been made "on the first reasonable possible day after notice of approval of the development application was in the hands of the [purchasers]"[11]. This meant, in his Honour's opinion, on Monday, 4 December 2000. In fact, the balance of the deposits was not paid on that day. Nor was it paid at any time before, on 19 December 2000, each of the vendors gave notice terminating the contracts. On the face of things, therefore, two legally advised investment companies, which had accepted an essential time stipulation for the payment of the remaining portions of substantial deposits, failed to comply with the legal obligations that they had accepted. At law, they were in breach of the contracts. Such breaches entitled the vendors to terminate the contracts. The vendors exercised that entitlement.[11]Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd v Romanos (2001) 10 BPR [97911] at 19,039 [9]; (2001) NSW Conv R ¶55-987 at 58,113.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

HUGH, GUMMOW, HAYNE AND HEYDON JJ (dissent) KIRBY J (dissent) CALLINAN J (dissent)
Time for compliance with the payment of the deposit was made essential by cll 2.2 and 2.3 of the contracts. By cl 2.5 in each contract it was provided that, if any of the deposit was not paid on time, the vendor could terminate the contract. However, the vendor could only do so before the deposit was paid in full.The decision of the primary judge The primary judge held that, in the circumstances, compliance with the provisions of the contracts as to time would have been sufficient if the payment had been made "on the first reasonable possible day after notice of approval of the development application was in the hands of the [purchasers]"[11]. This meant, in his Honour's opinion, on Monday, 4 December 2000. In fact, the balance of the deposits was not paid on that day. Nor was it paid at any time before, on 19 December 2000, each of the vendors gave notice terminating the contracts. On the face of things, therefore, two legally advised investment companies, which had accepted an essential time stipulation for the payment of the remaining portions of substantial deposits, failed to comply with the legal obligations that they had accepted. At law, they were in breach of the contracts. Such breaches entitled the vendors to terminate the contracts. The vendors exercised that entitlement.[11]Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd v Romanos (2001) 10 BPR [97911] at 19,039 [9]; (2001) NSW Conv R ¶55-987 at 58,113. There were a number of defects in the purchasers' case at trial. Despite their obligation to notify the vendors of the development approval, the purchasers did not assert in their evidence that they had signified the development approval to the vendors "immediately approval is received". Nor did they, in explicit evidence, prove the precise reason why they did not do this or pay the balance of the deposits on time. They did not prove exactly the sums that they had paid on the project before and after obtaining development consent. Nor did they prove the precise accretion in value of the consolidated property by virtue of the development approval that they had secured. At the trial, the purchasers did not argue that the vendors had waived compliance with the time stipulation. Nor did they contend that the vendors were estopped by their conduct from relying on the breach. They did submit that the vendors had affirmed the contracts after the termination. They argued that they had done so by the acceptance, by their agents, of the amount of the balance deposits tendered on the following day. The argument of waiver was rejected by the primary judge[12].[12]Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd v Romanos (2001) 10 BPR [97911] at 19,039 [8]. On the face of this evidence, or lack of it, the case for the purchasers appeared an unpromising one for the provision of equitable relief. The primary judge declined to grant relief against forfeiture. He was unconvinced that the exercise by the vendors of their legal rights amounted to "unconscionable conduct" or that the purchasers' failure to comply with the essential term as to time in each contract amounted to "exceptional circumstances", as required to attract equitable relief[13]. The primary judge therefore dismissed the purchasers' application. [13]Pentagold Investments Pty Ltd v Romanos (2001) 10 BPR [97911] at 19,039-19,040 [10]; (2001) NSW Conv R ¶55-987 at 58,113 citing Legione v Hateley (1983) 152 CLR 406; Ciavarella v Balmer (1983) 153 CLR 438; Stern v McArthur (1988) 165 CLR 489.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: