| [2022] FWC 711 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
| DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Barbara Roman
v
Mercy Hospitals Victoria Ltd
(U2021/11846)
| DEPUTY PRESIDENT COLMAN | MELBOURNE, 31 MARCH 2022 |
Application for an unfair dismissal remedy – refusal of hospital worker to provide evidence of vaccination status – government directions – incapacity to perform role – whether serious misconduct in failing to follow lawful and reasonable direction – valid reasons for dismissal – dismissal not unfair – application dismissed
This decision concerns an application for an unfair dismissal remedy made by Ms Barbara Roman under s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act). From 1999 until 2 December 2021, Ms Roman worked as a hospital services attendant for Mercy Hospitals Victoria Ltd (Mercy) at its Werribee hospital. Pursuant to Victorian government directions, Mercy was prohibited from allowing workers to attend for work from 15 October 2021 unless they had provided it with evidence that they had been vaccinated against COVID-19, had made an appointment to receive a vaccination, or had a medical exemption. Mercy directed its employees to provide such evidence. Ms Roman was dismissed on the ground that she had refused to follow Mercy’s direction. Ms Roman contends that the direction was unlawful or unfair, that Mercy did not have a valid reason to dismiss her, and that in any event her dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable. She seeks reinstatement or compensation.
Section 396 requires that I decide four matters before considering the merits of Ms Roman’s application. I am satisfied of the following. First, the application was made within the 21-day period required by s 394(2). Secondly, Ms Roman was a person protected from unfair dismissal. Thirdly, the dismissal was not a genuine redundancy. Fourthly, Mercy is not a small business employer, and the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code is therefore inapplicable.
Background
On 29 September 2021, the Acting Chief Health Officer of Victoria issued the COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination Directions (No 4) (No 4 Directions) under s 200(1)(d) of the Public Health and Wellbeing Act 2008 (Vic) (PHW Act). The No 4 Directions imposed obligations on the operators of specified facilities, including healthcare facilities such as Mercy, not to allow workers to attend for work on or after 15 October 2021 unless they had provided evidence to the employer of having been vaccinated against COVID-19, or of a booking to receive a vaccination by 29 October 2021. An exception applied for workers who provided a certificate that they were unable to receive a vaccination due to a medical contraindication. The No 4 Directions commenced on 29 September 2021. They were succeeded by other directions in very similar terms. The directions that applied on 2 December 2021 were the COVID-19 Mandatory Vaccination (Specified Facilities) Directions (No 13) (No 13 Directions). I refer to the various directions collectively as ‘the Directions’. Failure to comply with the Directions exposed an employer to substantial penalties.
Ms Roman’s role as a hospital services attendant required her to assist with the delivery of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Roman v Mercy Hospitals Victoria Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] FWC 711
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Deputy President of the Fair Work Commission found that the application was made within the 21-day period required by s 394(2). Ms Roman was a person protected from unfair dismissal. The dismissal was not a genuine redundancy. Mercy was not a small business employer, and the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code was therefore inapplicable. Mercy clearly had a valid reason to dismiss Ms Roman, because she was unable to do her job. Ms Roman had not provided Mercy with evidence that she had been vaccinated against COVID-19, or that she had an appointment to receive such a vaccination by the required date, or that she had a medical exemption. Mercy was therefore prohibited by law from allowing her to attend its premises for work. Mercy’s direction did not require Ms Roman to act unlawfully. In the present case, Mercy was required by law to ensure that Ms Roman did not attend its premises for work unless she had provided it with relevant vaccination-related evidence. Mercy directed Ms Roman to provide this evidence. This direction clearly appertained to her particular job; unless she followed the direction, she would not be able to do her job at all. In my opinion, a direction to an employee to do something that is a necessary condition for a state of capacity to do his or her job is a lawful direction. Whether it is also a reasonable one will depend on all the circumstances. In my view, in the circumstances of this case, Mercy’s direction was reasonable. Mercy had a second valid reason to dismiss Ms Roman, one which involved misconduct constituted by a refusal to follow a lawful and reasonable direction. Mercy had a third valid reason for dismissing Ms Roman. In cross-examination, Ms Daniela Roman conceded that, with her mother’s agreement, she had recorded the meeting on 2 December 2021 on her telephone without the approval of the other participants. Mercy learned of the recording only later when references to a purported transcript of the meeting appeared in Ms Roman’s F2 application. Ms Daniela Roman said that it was her understanding that in Victoria it was not illegal to record a discussion to which one is party without the knowledge of the other party, and that her mother had agreed to this course in order to protect her interests. Mercy had three valid reasons to dismiss Ms Roman. The FW Act required the Commission to take into account whether Ms Roman had been notified of a valid reason for dismissal and whether she was afforded an opportunity to respond to any reason related to capacity or conduct. Mercy’s correspondence with Ms Roman notified her of the proposed reason for dismissal related to her failure to follow a lawful and reasonable direction and gave her an adequate opportunity to respond. It also noted that the hospital had concerns that she had rendered herself unable to do her job. The latter was not a reason on which the employer ultimately relied. However the Deputy President concluded that incapacity was one of the valid reasons for dismissal. Ms Roman was, in substance, notified of this reason even though the employer did not rely on it at the time of dismissal. Ms Roman also had an opportunity to respond to this reason. In any event, whether Ms Roman should be regarded as having been notified of this reason and given a chance to respond to it did not affect the Deputy President’s overall assessment of this matter. Ms Roman was of course not notified or warned of the third valid reason for dismissal because Mercy was not aware of it until after the dismissal had occurred. Having regard to s 387 of the FW Act, the Deputy President considered that Ms Roman’s dismissal was not harsh, nor was it unjust or unreasonable. It was not unfair. The application was dismissed.