Rolfe v Katunga Lucerne Mill Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 55 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Rolfe v Katunga Lucerne Mill Pty Ltd [2005]  NSWCA 252

FILE NUMBER(S):
40509/04

HEARING DATE(S):               13 May 2005

JUDGMENT DATE: 28/07/2005

PARTIES:
Mark ROLFE (Appellant) 
KATUNGA LUCERNE MILL PTY LIMITED  (First Respondent) 
ROBANK FARM SUPPLIES PTY LIMITED  (Second Respondent) 

JUDGMENT OF:       Hodgson JA Santow JA McClellan AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 1495/03

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Hughes DCJ

COUNSEL:
B J GROSS, QC/ T BOYD  (Appellant) 
S A CAMPBELL, SC/ A J BOWEN  (Respondents) 

SOLICITORS:
Leitch Hasson Dent  (Appellant) 
Henry Davis York  (Respondents) 

CATCHWORDS:
PRODUCT LIABILITY - Sale of Goods - Merchantable quality - causation - no novus actus interveniens when plaintiff's horses poisoned by contaminated chaff from supplier in circumstances where plaintiff aware of rumours of possibility of contaminated product but not notified - Whether proper inference drawn from facts - Admissibility of evidence. 

LEGISLATION CITED:
Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW) ss19(1) and (2)

DECISION:

  1. Judgment and orders in the court below in favour of the respondents/defendants to be set aside. 

  2. In lieu thereof judgment for the appellant/plaintiff against the second respondent/defendant on the issue of liability, damages to be assessed. 

  3. Matter to be remitted to the District Court of New South Wales for: 
    (a)       a new trial on the issue of damages; 
    (b)       a determination of the cross-claim brought by the cross-claimant, Robank Farm Supplies Pty Limited, against the cross-defendant, Katunga Lucerne Mill Pty Limited. 

  4. The respondents/defendants to pay 80% of the appellant's costs of the appeal and of the trial in the court below. 

JUDGMENT:

- 40 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40509/04
DC 1495/03

HODGSON JA
SANTOW JA
McCLELLAN AJA

28 JULY 2005

Mark ROLFE v KATUNGA LUCERNE MILL PTY LIMITED & 1 Ors

Judgment

  1. HODGSON JA:  I agree with Santow JA. 

  2. SANTOW JA: 

    OVERVIEW 

    The appellant, a successful harness horse-trainer and driver, Mr Mark Rolfe, unsuccessfully sued Robank Farm Supplies Pty Limited (“Robank”), the second respondent, for damages as a consequence of being supplied contaminated chaff, itself sourced from a Victorian supplier, Katunga Lucerne Mill Pty Limited (“Katunga”), the first respondent.  The latter played no role in this appeal. 

  3. Before the trial judge, Hughes DCJ, the claim was based both on tort and contract, the latter relying upon an implied warranty as to the quality or fitness for purpose of the chaff supplied, and, though not expressly pleaded, its merchantable quality; see ss19(1) and (2) of the Sale of Goods Act 1923 (NSW).

  4. While written submissions and the grounds of appeal encompassed both alleged contract liability and tort liability, argument on appeal centred upon breach of the implied warranty of merchantable quality under s19(2) of the Sale of Goods Act.  It was common ground that the pleadings could, to the extent necessary, be amended to make that basis of claim explicit.  This obviated the need to consider further any grounds of appeal relating to fitness for purpose (s19(1) of the Sale…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rolfe v Katunga Lucerne Mill Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 252
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal from a decision concerning the sale of contaminated chaff. The appellant, Mr Mark Rolfe, a harness horse trainer, purchased chaff from Robank, a farm produce merchant, which had sourced the chaff from the respondent, Katunga Lucerne Mill Pty Ltd. Mr Rolfe's horses became poisoned by botulism toxin present in the chaff, leading to a contractual claim for breach of an implied warranty of merchantable quality under s 19(2) of the Sale of Goods Act.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the chaff supplied was of merchantable quality, and if not, whether the contamination and subsequent poisoning of Mr Rolfe's horses were a probable consequence of the breach. A further issue concerned the admissibility and weight of evidence relating to whether Mr Rolfe had been warned about potential problems with the chaff, and whether any such warning constituted a novus actus interveniens that broke the chain of causation.

The court considered the evidence regarding communications between Robank and Mr Rolfe. While Robank had received a call from a veterinarian on 17 August 1999, suspecting botulism linked to their feed, and a new batch of chaff arrived on 17 August, the court found it improbable that Mr Rolfe was informed of the potential contamination by that date. The court also examined conflicting evidence about a conversation on 20 August 1999 between Mr Rolfe and Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer of Robank. Mr Rolfe testified that he inquired about rumours of sick horses and was assured there was no problem with Robank's products. Mr van den Nieuwboer denied recalling such a conversation, stating he would have acknowledged a problem with the chaff if asked. The court ultimately concluded that it could not be established that Mr Rolfe was warned of the contamination by Robank prior to his horses becoming ill, and therefore, the chain of causation was not broken.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Robank acknowledged that if the appellant were successful on each of (a) and (b) above, it must succeed on its contractual claim for breach of an implied warranty of merchantable quality under s19(2). It was therefore upon these issues that the appeal was ultimately argued. SALIENT FACTS Set out below are the salient facts, indicating areas of factual dispute. Where appropriate I have made reference to findings of the trial judge. Mr Mark Rolfe was a harness horse-trainer, driver and owner. From 1998 he was conducting his training activities from a leased property at Ebenezer called “Cara Palida”. Mr Rolfe leased part of the property from Ms Elaine Bronson who lived on the premises. He was sometimes contacted through her, as he did not have a fixed-line telephone (though he did have a mobile phone, the number of which changed from time to time before August 1999). In his business Mr Rolfe employed a Mr Halliday as a stable-hand. Mr Rolfe did not live on the Ebenezer premises, which were horse stables and training facilities rather than domestic premises, although the trial judge stated “[I]t is not clear whether he lived on these premises.” (Red, 14D). As at August 1999, Mr Rolfe had in training at the property, eleven standard breed horses. Mr Rolfe sourced his feed supplies from Robank, a farm produce merchant, which operated a store in Ebenezer. The directors of Robank were Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer and his wife. Also working in the business were his son John van den Nieuwboer, and daughter Mrs Marianne Roughley. Robank also employed a Mr Andrew Palmer as a storehand and deliveryman. Robank had cash and account customers. On 5, 7, 10 and 16 August 1999, Mr Rolfe purchased from Robank on account a total of seven bags of chaff (at $17.50 per bag), part of a batch supplied to Robank by Katunga on Tuesday, 3 August 1999. This chaff was known variously as “Katunga Lucerne chaff” or “Victorian chaff”, and was distinguished from NSW Lucerne chaff. Mr Rolfe had formed a preference for the Katunga Lucerne chaff, because he believed it was of better quality than the NSW chaff. The bags of chaff bought by Mr Rolfe were contaminated with botulism toxin, as indeed was the batch out of which they came. On Tuesday 17 August 1999 or Wednesday 18 August 1999 a new batch of Katunga Lucerne Chaff from Katunga arrived at Robank and was being sold to purchasers who asked for it from sometime on Thursday 19 August 1999 (Black, 600O-S). On Tuesday 17 August 1999 Dr John Parbury, a Veterinary Surgeon, phoned Mr John van den Nieuwboer of Robank. According to the second respondent’s diary for 17 August 1999 Dr Parbury told him “Sue Jackson’s horse had died from (suspected) botulism which he thinks is linked to Robanks” (Blue, 590H-J, Black, 635F-H). This call was at 10 am (Black, 635B). Dr Parbury also told Mr John van den Nieuwboer that there was another client in the area that might also have the same problem and that he believed “also came from the feed” (Black, 635H-J). Dr Parbury did not tell him anything about what specific product he thought might be involved (Black, 635K).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Likewise, in terms of the second limb of that rule, had the parties directed their minds to the probable result of the breach of warranty of merchantable quality, the injuries suffered by Mr Rolfe’s horses was “such as may reasonably be supposed to have been in the contemplation of both parties, at the time they made the contract, as the probable result of the breach of it”. Grounds of appeal 8 and 9 – error in admitting evidence I should elaborate now on one aspect of the evidence that was the subject of grounds of appeal 8 and 9. The appellant contends that the trial judge erred in admitting evidence, which was objected to, from Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer of what he would have said in a conversation with the plaintiff in the store on 20 August 1999, when he denied and did not recollect any such conversation having taken place; ground 8. Ground 9 is that the trial judge “erred on the facts in concluding that Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer warned the plaintiff in a conversation on Friday 20 August 1999 that ‘there was a problem with the Katunga chaff’.” To place the matter in context, Mr Rolfe did give evidence that having heard on the rumour mill around Ebenezer from his landlady, Ms Bronson, that there was a rumour that a horse was ill, supposedly from eating some product provided by Robank, he went to Robank on 20 August 1999. His evidence was that he asked Frank (referred to by Mr Rolfe as “Frank Robanks”) whether the rumours that he had heard were true (Black, 172-175, 182-186). According to Mr Rolfe, Frank assured him that there was no problem with the products that he was selling out of his farm supplies and that he was endeavouring “to find the truth out in the rumour” (Black, 174R). Mr Rolfe denied that Frank told him in this conversation “we have been calling everyone to bring the product back” (Black, 174U). Mr Rolfe’s evidence was that Frank clarified the rumour that Mr Rolfe had heard as being untrue (Black, 188V). Frank van den Nieuwboer in examination-in-chief was asked about Mr Rolfe’s evidence that he had a conversation with him on Friday 20 August 1999. Frank said he could not recall any conversation on that day (Black, 554R). After Frank stated that on Friday 20 August 1999 his belief was "that he had a problem" about the Katunga Lucerne Chaff, he was asked, "On the Friday would you have assured anybody (that the Katunga feed was alright)?" This question was objected to by the plaintiff’s Senior Counsel. Following argument, the trial judge allowed the question (Black, 555G). Frank was then asked "On the Friday when you had been back from Gunnedah and you had that belief that you've told us about concerning the Katunga chaff, would you have assured anybody that the Katunga chaff was okay or all right? (Black, 555H-J). Frank said, "I still don't understand the question." There was then further discussion in the absence of the witness. The trial judge ruled that the question could be asked in view of Mr Rolfe's positive assertion that he had a conversation with Frank on Friday 20 August 1999, and allowed the question (Black, 556B-G). Counsel for the defendant then asked Frank van den Nieuwboer the following questions: “Q.Mr van den Nieuwboer, Mr Rolfe has given evidence in these proceedings that he had a conversation with you on the Friday after you got back from Gunnedah? A.(Witness nodded) Q.He has said that that conversation took place in your office at Robank Farm Supplies? A.I can't recall that, sir. Q.He says that he told you something along these lines: that he'd heard some rumours around Ebenezer that some horses were getting sick from a product supplied by Robanks. He says that you said to him at that time there's nothing wrong with the feed that you were selling. Now, my question is, did that happen? A.No, sir. Q. My question is, had somebody asked you on the Friday, after you got back from Gunnedah, whether there was a problem with one of the feeds you were supplying, what would you have said to them? A.I would have said there's a problem. Q.What would you have said the problem would be? A.Most problem - the chaff. Q.Would you have said which chaff? A.Yes, sir. Q.Which chaff would you have identified? A.Katunga chaff.” (Black, 556H-T).

Decision

Reasons for decision

The cross-examination of Mr Rolfe as to what Robank maintained was any contact with Mr Rolfe as part of the recall process proceeded as follows: (a)Initially in cross-examination of Mr Rolfe, it was suggested to him that "Isn’t it the case that Mr John van den Nieuwboer rang you on the Thursday before the 23rd (this would be Thursday 19 August 1999) to tell you that he thought there was a 'problem with the feed’?" to which Mr Rolfe replied "Not that I can recall, no" (Black, 167DE). (b)Later in cross-examination Mr Rolfe was reminded that he had been asked "Yesterday about John van den Nieuwboer contacting you on the 19th of August and you told me that you didn't remember such a conversation" and then asked "Could it be that another person from Robanks may have contacted you on the 19th of August 1999 about these matters” to which Mr Rolfe replied "I can't recall any conversation from Robanks or their employees on that day" (Black, 179N-P). (c)Finally, in cross-examination, it was put to Mr Rolfe that "Somebody from Robanks told you on the 19th that there was a problem with the Katunga product ...?" to which Mr Rolfe replied "Untrue" (Black, 190D-G).Conclusion Recognising the advantage the trial judge had of assessing the witnesses, and noting that Ms Bronson was not accepted as a reliable witness by the trial judge, nonetheless, in what is a matter of inference, on the evidence so far recounted, including the more objective information of the note in Exhibit AR (“Pick-up-can’t contact”), I would not accept that: (a)Ms Bronson was informed on the night in question (19 August 1999) of the possibility that the chaff was contaminated; (b)She must be taken to have passed on that information to Mr Rolfe; (c)Anyone from Robank spoke directly to Mr Rolfe with that warning including Andrew Palmer when visiting Mr Rolfe’s premises (subject to consideration below of the sign in the shop and the alleged conversation with Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer on Friday 19 August 1999); I do, however, accept that Mr Rolfe would more probably than not have known by Friday 20 August 1999 and before Monday 23 August 1999 “on the rumour mill around Ebenezer” that one horse had got sick from “a product supplied by Robanks”. Did Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer warn the plaintiff that there was a problem with the Katunga chaff? As to (c) above, Mr Rolfe denied that Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer gave him any such warning. Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer himself denied and had no recollection of any conversation with Mr Rolfe on Friday 20 August 1999 (Black, 554R). He asserted that there was no conversation with Mr Rolfe until when Mr Rolfe came into the store and told him about a horse that had got sick and died. Indeed, Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer was certain there were no such conversations between him and Mr Rolfe about the chaff before the horse died (Black, 556H-T). Concededly, an honest witness following a general practice of giving such a warning to those who asked might forget that someone asked, such as, here, Mr Rolfe. But Mr Frank van den Nieuwboer’s certainty that there was no such conversations at all with Mr Rolfe militates against his having forgotten that such a conversation had taken place. And if no conversation took place, he could not have given the warning, whatever his general practice; see further below, under “Grounds of appeal 8 and 9 – error in admitting evidence”.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.