r .
| i | 9. | go3 |
| i |
CATCHWORDS
| ADMINISTRATIVE | - | LAW - judicial review - immigration - application |
| for | review of authorized | officer's | cancellation | of | return |
| endorsement - Act giving "absolute discretion" | - whether doctrine |
| of natural justice applies | - whether requirement of procedural |
| fairness observed. |
| 1977 s.5 | |
| Micrration Act 1958 s~.6(2),9,11A,llB,16(1) |
| PERCY ROJAS | v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION | A D ETHNIC AFFAIRS |
and JOHN DAVIDSON
No. G 476 of 1986
Woodward J.
Melbourne
10 November 1986
l
l
I
I
| IN THE FEDEXAL COURT | . | OF AUSTRALIA 1 | 1 |
| ! | NEW SOUTH | MALES DISTRICT REGISTRY ) | No. G 476 of 1986 |
)
|
1 I
I
-
| I | I |
| : | - | B |
I
| I | i |
| ! |
| I | Applicant | ROJAS | PERCY |
and
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION
| AND ETHNIC AFFAIRS | First.Respondent |
| J O H N DAVIDSON | Second Respondent |
1 i
| I | MINUTES OF ORDER |
| I |
| ! | COURT : Woodward J. | ||
| i | |||
| I | m: 10 November 1986 | ||
| I | |||
| I |
|
| THE COURT ORDERS | THAT: |
I I
| I | 1. | The injunction granted by Beaumont J on 17 October 1986 | ||
| I | ||||
| ||||
| i | 2. |
| ||
| I | ||||
| I |
| |||
| ||||
| 3. | Costs be costs in the cause. | |||
| i | ||||
| I |
| I | (m: | Settlement and entry of orders | is deal | ,t | with by 0.36 | of |
| the Federal Court Rules.) | ||||||
| ~ | ||||||
| i |
| i |
| I |
| IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA | 1 |
| 1 |
| NEW SOUTH EIALES DISTRICT REGISTRY ) | No. G 476 of 1986 |
1
| DIVISION | GENERAL | ) |
| I | - |
BETWEEN:
| PERCY ROJAS | Applicant |
and
MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION
| AND ETHNIC | AFFAIRS | First | Respondent | ! |
| JOHN DAVIDSON | econd | Respondent |
| COURT: Woodward | J. |
m: 10 November 1986
W: Melbourne
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT
| This is an application for | an interlocutory injunction |
| to prevent the removal | of the applicant from Australia until after | I - |
| l ' |
the hearing and determination of his main application. That
I
| originating | application | is | brought | under | the | Administrative |
Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 ("the Judicial Review Act")
| seeking a review of the decision of an authorized officer of the | . . | |
| ||
| L , |
| first | respondent o | cancel | the | return | endorsement | on | the |
| applicant's Bolivian passport, pursuant to the provisions of | the |
| Misration Act 1958 ("the Act"). |
| The basic facts | of the case are not in dispute. | The |
applicant is a Bolivian national. A number of members of his
- 2 -
family emigrated to Australia ten or more years ago. One of them,
| a brother, in late | 1982 | sponsored the applicant as a | potential |
| migrant to Australia. In doing | so | he stated that the applicant |
| had never been married. In fact the applicant had married some | - |
weeks before his brother signed the sponsorship form, but this
| news had apparently not reached the brother before | he sent the |
..
| completed form | to the applicant in Bolivia. |
| The applicant noted | his brother's… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rojas, P. v Minister for Immigration & Ethnic Affairs and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1986] FCA 503
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court examined the legislative framework, particularly the provisions of the Migration Act that grant the Minister or an authorized officer absolute discretion to cancel a visa or return endorsement. The solicitor for the respondents argued that this absolute discretion meant there was no obligation to afford natural justice to Rojas. Alternatively, it was argued that the requirements of natural justice had been met. The court found that while there was a requirement to observe natural justice, the statutory framework significantly circumscribed the procedural fairness requirements. The decision to cancel the return endorsement was based on information supplied by Rojas himself, and he had been given the opportunity to provide an explanation. The court concluded that the failure to give Rojas an opportunity to expand upon his explanation did not constitute a material procedural defect, and discharged the injunction.
The court's reasoning hinged on the statutory discretion granted under the Migration Act and the nature of the information used in the decision-making process. The court held that the requirements of procedural fairness were met, and Rojas's argument for a further extension of the injunction was not compelling enough to justify it. The injunction was discharged, and costs were awarded as agreed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi