Robinson v Sydney West Area Health Service

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

CITATION: Robinson v Sydney West Area Health Service [2007] NSWADT 77
DIVISION: Equal Opportunity Division
PARTIES: APPLICANT
Richelle Robinson
RESPONDENT
Sydney West Area Health Service
FILE NUMBER: 031119
HEARING DATES: 28 April 2006
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 17 July 2006
 
DATE OF DECISION: 

5 April 2007
BEFORE: Behrendt L - Judicial Member; Mooney L - Non Judicial Member; Lowe A - Non Judicial Member
CATCHWORDS: Disability Discrimination - Goods and Services - Indirect discrimination
MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter
LEGISLATION CITED: Anti-Discrimination Act 1977
CASES CITED: Bradley v State of New South Wales (No. 2) [2003] NSWADT 94
Byham v Preston City Council (1991) EOC 92-377
Dee v Commissioner of Police and Anor [2003] NSWADT 217
Dutt v Central Coast Area Health Service; Central Coast Area Health Service v Dutt [2003] NSWADTAP 3
Finance Sector Union v Commonwealth Bank of Australia (1997) EOC 92-889
Fricke v Corbett Research Pty Ltd [2004] NSWADT 128
Langley v Niland [1981] 2 NSWLR 104
Omeri v Quality Assurance Service Pty Ltd (2003) NSWADT 188
Razaghi v Director-General, NSW Department of Health & Anor [2002] NSWADT 4
Robinson v Wentworth Area Health Service (No 2) [2005] NSWADT 220
Siddiqui v Australian Medical Council (2000) EOC 93-059
Strong v Hospitals Contribution Fund of Australia Limited [2004] NSWADT 176
Tabbouch v Noyeaux [2003] NSWADT 6
Wollongong City Council v Bonella & ors and Bonella & ors v Wollongong City Council EOD [2002] NSWADTAP 26
REPRESENTATION:

APPLICANT
In person

RESPONDENT
E Brus, Barrister
ORDERS: 1. The Tribunal finds the Applicant’s complaint to have been substantiated; 2. The Respondent is to pay the Applicant $5 000 as damages; 3. The Respondent is enjoined from continuing or repeating the imposition of the requirement that to receive free doses of methadone, the applicant must attend the Woodlands Clinic every weekday during the morning. For example the Respondent could, if requested by the Applicant, provide the Applicant with an additional take home dose on any weekday that she attends the clinic for dosing, and with two additional take home doses on any Friday she attends the clinic for dosing, up to a maximum of four take home doses in any seven day period.

1 The applicant, Ms Richelle Robinson, lodged a complaint against the respondent, Wentworth Area Health Service, with the Anti-Discrimination Board on 10 May 2002 alleging indirect discrimination on the ground of disability in the provision of services.

2 Ms Robinson is addicted to methadone and is required to take a daily dose. This dose is administered by the Woodlands Clinic, located in the grounds of the Blue Mountains District ANZAC Memorial Hospital and was run by the Wentworth Area Health Service. At the time of the hearing in April 2006, there had been changes in the boundaries and the clinic fell under the Sydney West Area Health Service.

3 Ms Robinson’s complaint was that on 11 February 2002 the respondent implemented a policy that required her to attend the clinic daily in person to receive her dose. Dosing would be administered…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robinson v Sydney West Area Health Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWADT 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Robinson v Sydney West Area Health Service, the applicant, Robinson, brought a claim against the respondent, Sydney West Area Health Service, alleging discrimination on the basis of her disability. Robinson claimed that the respondent's policy of only providing free doses of methadone at the Woodlands Clinic every weekday morning constituted indirect discrimination. The case was heard and determined by the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (HREOC), which had jurisdiction over claims of discrimination under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth). The tribunal found in favour of the applicant and ordered the respondent to pay damages and change its policy.

The primary legal issue before the tribunal was whether the respondent's policy of providing free methadone doses only during weekday mornings at the Woodlands Clinic constituted indirect discrimination against Robinson, who was unable to attend the clinic every weekday due to her disability. The tribunal had to consider whether the policy had a disproportionately adverse effect on people with disabilities and whether the respondent had failed to take reasonable steps to accommodate Robinson's disability. The tribunal also had to consider what orders, if any, should be made to remedy the discrimination.

The tribunal found that the respondent's policy did have a disproportionately adverse effect on people with disabilities and that the respondent had failed to take reasonable steps to accommodate Robinson's disability. The tribunal noted that the policy placed a significant burden on people with disabilities who were unable to attend the clinic every weekday, and that the respondent had not offered any alternative arrangements to accommodate such people. The tribunal also found that the respondent's proposal to provide additional take-home doses was not sufficient to remedy the discrimination, as it did not address the underlying issue of the inflexible dosing schedule. Accordingly, the tribunal ordered the respondent to pay damages to Robinson and to change its policy to provide more flexible dosing arrangements.

In summary, the tribunal found that the respondent's policy of only providing free methadone doses during weekday mornings at the Woodlands Clinic constituted indirect discrimination against Robinson. The tribunal ordered the respondent to pay damages to Robinson and to change its policy to provide more flexible dosing arrangements. The tribunal also noted that the respondent's proposal to provide additional take-home doses was not sufficient to remedy the discrimination. The respondent was given the opportunity to request further information about the alternative dosing arrangements that could be offered to Robinson.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Tribunal finds the Applicant's complaint to have been substantiated; 2. The Respondent is to pay the Applicant $5 000 as damages; 3. The Respondent is enjoined from continuing or repeating the imposition of the requirement that to receive free doses of methadone, the applicant must attend the Woodlands Clinic every weekday during the morning. For example the Respondent could, if requested by the Applicant, provide the Applicant with an additional take home dose on any weekday that she attends the clinic for dosing, and with two additional take home doses on any Friday she attends the clinic for dosing, up to a maximum of four take home doses in any seven day period.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established