| [2021] FWC 1634 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Unfair dismissal
Robinson & Rockell
v
The Trustee for the Darrouzet Property Trust
(U2020/1293; U2020/1296)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT LAKE | BRISBANE, 25 MARCH 2021 |
Applications for relief from unfair dismissal remedy – applications for unfair dismissal successful – determination of remedy – compensation ordered.
[1] Further to my decision of 3 December 2020, 1 having found that Mr Robinson and Ms Rockell (the Applicants) were persons protected from unfair dismissal and that they were unfairly dismissed within the meaning of s.385 of the Act, I must now consider what, if any, remedy should be granted to the Applicants.
[2] The Applicants are not seeking reinstatement to their positions. They submit that reinstatement would be an illogical and unworkable remedy, and wholly inappropriate in all of the circumstances of the case, including that their positions have now been filled. The Applicants seek compensation to the full jurisdictional limit under the Act.
SUBMISSIONS AS TO REMEDY
Applicant’s submissions
[3] The Applicants noted that they were unfairly dismissed, with their employment ending on 28 January 2020. The Applicants submitted that until that point, their service was entirely unblemished and there has been evidence provided that they loved their work and were committed to their jobs.
[4] At the date of termination, the Applicants were paid gross annual salary of $90,000 each, being $1,730.77 gross per week, per person.
[5] As to seeking alternative employment, the Applicants stated that they presented evidence at arbitration that they had actively pursued alternative employment locally, interstate and overseas, but remained out of work for a period in excess of 26 weeks (being the statutory maximum period for compensation). The Applicants relied on evidence primarily given by Ms Rockell, of the Applicants’ job search efforts. The Applicants stated they took extensive efforts to obtain work interstate and internationally, by contacting recruitment agencies and submitting applications for advertised vacancies. Mr Robinson also completed a number of training courses over his period out of work, in order to enhance his employability.
[6] In further submissions of 7 January 2021, the Applicants confirmed their evidence that they remained out of work for a period in excess of 26 weeks, and had only ‘recently’ gained employment.
[7] The Applicants submitted that there was evidence at the hearing that the deduction of six (6) weeks (or 30 days) being a sum of $10,384.62 from each of the Applicant’s accrued annual leave balances which were paid upon termination significantly exacerbated the harshness of the termination. The Applicants submitted that they ought to have had access to these entitlements to support themselves through any period out of work. The Applicants further submitted that the unauthorised deduction of the six (6) weeks of accrued annual leave and the further loss of the accrued Time-Off-In-Lieu (TOIL) “appear to be blatantly punitive in nature, and the decision to authorise such deductions was notably wholly improper”.
[8] The Applicants submitted that there was also evidence in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Robinson & Rockell v The Trustee for the Darrouzet Property... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] FWC 1634
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to consider whether the applicants' dismissal was indeed unfair and whether, in light of the specific circumstances, the remedy of reinstatement was appropriate. The court had to weigh the impracticality and unsuitability of reinstatement against other possible remedies, such as compensation. The applicants needed to demonstrate that reinstatement would be impractical or unsuitable to the extent that it would be unjust to order it.
The court found that the applicants' dismissal was indeed unfair. However, it concluded that the remedy of reinstatement was not appropriate in these circumstances. The court accepted the applicants' submissions that reinstatement would be impractical and unsuitable due to the significant changes in the company's operations and the applicants' roles. As a result, the court ordered that compensation be paid to the applicants as an alternative remedy for the unfair dismissal. The court determined that the compensation amount should reflect the loss of remuneration and other benefits the applicants would have received had they been reinstated.
The court ordered that compensation be paid to the applicants in lieu of reinstatement, with the amount to be determined by the Fair Work Commission.