Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 8)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 8) [2023] QIRC 192

PARTIES:

Robertson, B
(Complainant)

v

McDonald's Australia Limited
(Respondent)

CASE NOS.:

AD/2021/7 and B/2023/27

PROCEEDING:

Applications in existing proceedings and General Application

DELIVERED ON:

23 June 2023

HEARING DATE:

12 April 2023

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

Merrell DP

Brisbane

ORDERS:

The orders contained in paragraph [66] of these reasons for decision.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – ENDING PROCEEDINGS EARLY – SUMMARY DISPOSAL – Complainant alleges age discrimination and the asking of unnecessary questions against the Respondent - pursuant to an order striking out the Complainant's further statement of facts and contentions, the Complainant filed and served a third statement of facts and contentions – Respondent subsequently made application seeking an order to strike out the Complainant's proceeding – principles to be considered in respect of an application to strike out a proceeding – whether Complainant's third statement of facts and contentions put the Respondent on notice of the case it has to meet – Complainant's third statement of facts and contentions did not put the Respondent on notice of the case it has to meet – no confidence that Complainant will file and serve a statement of facts and contentions that puts the Respondent on notice of the case it has to meet – proceeding dismissed – further applications made by the Complainant seeking certain relief dismissed because they are misconceived

LEGISLATION:

Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, s 13, s 14, s 15, s 23, s 114, s 122, s 123, s 124, s 128, s 133 and s 178

Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT), r 21

Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 451 and s 463

Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011, r 45

CASES:

Aon Risk Services Ltd v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27; (2009) 239 CLR 175

Fair Work Ombudsman v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (The Yatala Labour Prison Case)(No 2) [2023] FCA 429

Local Government Association of Queensland vQueensland Services, Industrial Union of Employees [2020] QIRC 068

Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited [2021] QIRC 344

Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 6) [2023] QIRC 093

Robertson v Queensland Farm Management and Training Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] QIRC 365

APPEARANCES:

The Complainant on his own behalf.

Mr J. McLean of Counsel instructed by Ms L. Dearlove of Colin Biggers & Paisley for the Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. In respect of Case No. AD/2021/7, being Mr Robertson's complaint of unlawful discrimination against McDonald's Australia Limited ('McDonald's), I have made a recent decision being Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 6)                    ('Robertson No. 6).[1]

    [1] [2023] QIRC 093 ('Robertson No. 6').

  2. These reasons should be read with paragraphs [1]-[14] and [46]-[56] of Robertson No. 6.

  3. In Robertson No.6, I made the following orders in respect of Case No. AD/2021/7:

    ·pursuant to s 451(2)(c) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 ('the IR Act'), Mr Robertson's statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 8) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QIRC 192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Robertson v McDonald's Australia Limited (No. 8) involved Mr Robertson, who alleged age discrimination and the asking of unnecessary questions against McDonald's. The dispute was heard in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal. Mr Robertson, who was self-represented, filed and served a third statement of facts and contentions after his previous statements had been struck out. McDonald's made an application to strike out Mr Robertson's proceeding, arguing that his third statement did not put McDonald's on notice of the case it had to meet. The tribunal had to decide whether the third statement met the requirements for a statement of facts and contentions, and whether it adequately notified McDonald's of the case it needed to defend.

The tribunal found that Mr Robertson's third statement of facts and contentions did not adequately notify McDonald's of the case it had to meet. It was inconsistent with the complaint that the Queensland Human Rights Commission had accepted. The tribunal held that Mr Robertson's status as a self-represented litigant did not excuse him from the requirement to properly notify McDonald's of the case it had to meet. The tribunal also noted that Mr Robertson had not sought to amend his complaint in line with s 178 of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991. The tribunal found that there was no confidence that Mr Robertson would file and serve a statement of facts and contentions that put McDonald's on notice of the case it had to meet. Consequently, the tribunal dismissed the proceeding.

Additionally, the tribunal dismissed further applications made by Mr Robertson as they were misconceived. The tribunal concluded that Mr Robertson's application for a declaration was not the appropriate remedy and that McDonald's, as a national system employer, was not subject to the Industrial Relations Act 2016 in respect of industrial matters. The tribunal also found that Mr Robertson was not directly affected by any declaration made by the Commission about the information McDonald's required applicants for employment to supply.

The tribunal ordered that Mr Robertson's proceeding in Case No. AD/2021/7 be dismissed, along with his applications in Case No. B/2023/27 and the existing proceedings. These orders were contained in paragraph [66] of the tribunal's reasons for decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

The orders contained in paragraph [66] of these reasons for decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Robertson then made a number of submissions that went to the merits of the complaints of discrimination he now wants to make against McDonald's. These matters went to, in general, the alleged use by McDonald's of a company, in respect of its recruitment processes, which uses technology such as artificial intelligence to determine the age characteristics of applicants for employment with McDonald's.Mr Robertson's third statement of facts and contentions As I stated in Robertson No. 6, a party's statement of facts and contentions must be drawn so as to allow the other party or parties, and the Commission, to know what the case is about, and to know, before the trial starts, the genuine issues that remain in dispute and that must be resolved.[7] [7] Robertson No. 6 (n 1), [26]. The fact that Mr Robertson is representing himself, while a misfortune, is not a privilege. Mr Robertson's status as a self-represented litigant does not relieve him of the requirement, imposed by the Commission by the directions orders that have been issued, to put McDonald's on notice of the case it has to meet by filing and serving a statement of facts and contentions the meets the above-mentioned purpose. Mr Robertson's third statement of facts and contentions suffers from the same kinds of vices as did his second statement of facts and contentions that I struck out in Robertson No. 6.[8][8] Robertson No. 6 (n 1) [35]-[40]. First, the complaint Mr Robertson made to, and which was accepted by, the QHRC, was about a written application for employment Mr Robertson made at a McDonald's restaurant in Mount Isa, being an application for which he was subsequently interviewed. This is made clear from the second and fourth pages of Mr Robertson's complaint to the QHRC made on 5 September 2020 as contained in the referral by the QHRC to this Commission. That referral also contains a subsequent email Mr Robertson sent to the QHRC on 10 December 2020. That email was sent in response to an earlier email from the QHRC to Mr Robertson seeking clarification about ambiguities in his complaint. The QHRC stated the complaint was ambiguous because Mr Robertson had mentioned a Bundaberg address. In that email Mr Robertson stated that '… it was a historical application in Mount Isa' and that '… Bundaberg was a time and place, where I consulted the online "careers page."' The third paragraph of Mr Robertson's third statement of facts and contentions seems to contend that the alleged unlawful discrimination arose following his consideration to make an application for employment at a McDonald's 'outlet' in Targo Street, Bundaberg, after he saw an employment vacancy sign at that 'outlet'. Mr Robertson contends that, despite considering making an online application, he made no application for employment at the McDonald's 'outlet' in Bundaberg. In this particular respect, Mr Robertson's third statement of facts and contentions does not concern the same factual complaint to the one accepted by the QHRC. In the absence of the Commission, pursuant to s 178 of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, allowing Mr Robertson to amend his complaint, Mr Robertson cannot allege a different case in this Commission. Mr Robertson has made no application to amend his complaint pursuant to s 178 of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the reasons that follow:·pursuant to s 451(2)(c) of the IR Act, I dismiss Mr Robertson's application made in Case No. B/2023/27; ·pursuant to s 451(2)(c) of the IR Act, I dismiss Mr Robertson's application in existing proceedings; and·pursuant to r 45(3)(a) of the Rules, I dismiss Mr Robertson's proceeding in Case No. AD/2021/7.Should the declaration sought by Mr Robertson in Case No. B/2023/27 be granted? In this application, for which relief is sought pursuant to s 463(1) of the IR Act, the decision sought by Mr Robertson is:That the deputy Merrell give a direction as to the respondent's recently introduced and mandatory D.O.B within the online "careers" application process.As to the standing of the question of D.O.B? The grounds of the application are: There are three significant problems with Mr Robertson's application. First, Mr Robertson, as articulated in this application, does not seek a declaration, but seeks an order from the Commission directing that McDonald's not require applicants for positions with it to give their date of birth in online applications for employment. Secondly, McDonald's is a national system employer and, in respect of industrial matters, is not subject to the IR Act. Section 463 of the IR Act, properly construed, only confers discretionary power on the Commission to make a declaration about '… an industrial matter' which can only concern an industrial matter as between employers and employees who are subject to the IR Act. Assuming that the issue at the heart of Mr Robertson's application is, in a general sense, an industrial matter because it concerns an employer and potential employees, it could not be an industrial matter for the purposes of the IR Act because it would concern a national system employer and potential national system employees. Thirdly, pursuant to s 464 of the IR Act, a declaration may be made by a person who may be directly affected by the declaration. In Local Government Association of Queensland vQueensland Services, Industrial Union of Employees,[4] a Full Bench of the Commission considered that the phrase '… directly affected' in s 464(d) of the IR Act meant the declaration having an immediate causal effect, other than an indirect or remote causal effect, on the applicant.[5] It seems to me, leaving aside the first two issues to which I refer above, that Mr Robertson would not be directly affected by any declaration made by the Commission about the information McDonald's requires applicants for employment to supply. At most, there may be an indirect effect on Mr Robertson if he was such an applicant. There is no evidence before me from Mr Robertson that he intends, at any time, in the immediate or near future, to make an online application for employment with McDonald's.[4] [2020] QIRC 068.[5] Ibid [40]-[46] (Vice President O'Connor, Industrial Commissioner Hartigan, as her Honour then was, and Industrial Commissioner McLennan). Section 464(d) of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 provides that an organisation of employees or employers who may be directly affected by the declaration may make an application for a declaration under s 463.