Robertshaw Controls Company v G.S.A Industries Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

PATENTS ACT 1952

DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

Re: Australian Patent Application No. 516290 in the Name of          ROBERTSHAW CONTROLS COMPANY and Section 82 Opposition by         G.S.A. INDUSTRIES LIMITED

Background

The history of this action is set out below:

.The Office advertised the acceptance of 516290 on 28 May 1981;

.Actrol Industries Pty Ltd lodged notice of opposition under s.59 on 27 August 1981 : I heard the opposition and issued a decision on 4 November 1983 allowing the applicant 60 days in which to propose amendments to remove the grounds of objection under s.40 and s.48, which I had found;

.Robertshaw filed a s.77 request on 7 December 1983;

.The Office advertised acceptance of that request on 27 September 1984;

.Actrol filed notice of opposition under s.82 on 20 December 1984;  I heard this opposition and issued a decision on 25 March 1986 refusing the s.77 in its entirety, but allowing Robertshaw 30 days to seek leave to amend the complete specification;

.Robertshaw lodged a second s.77 request on 17 April 1986;

.The Office advertised acceptance of this second request on 19 June 1986;

.G.S.A. Industries Limited filed notice of opposition under s.82 on 17 September 1986;

.I heard this second s.82 opposition in Canberra on 26 June 1990 and issue this decision as a result.

At the hearing, Mr J.C. Campbell QC, assisted by Mr M.R.J. Ellicott of counsel, and Mr C. Macauley, patent attorney of Callinans, represented the applicant.  Dr J.McL. Emmerson QC assisted by Mr C.A. Spence of counsel, and Mr T.J. Collins, patent attorney of Phillips, Ormonde & Fitzpatrick, represented the opponent.

The Specification as Accepted

The specification as accepted describes the invention as relating to temperature and pressure responsive safety relief valves for water heaters.  Typically, the valve is inserted in  a port of a hot water tank and the pressure side of the valve mechanism is subject to pressure from stagnant or non-circulating water.  The valve body is of an elbow construction having a side relief port.  The body has an internal wall separating the relief port from the inlet port and has an orifice in the internal wall which is sealed by a resiliently biased closure member.  A push rod which acts on the closure member extends to a thermostatic element that projects out of the inlet port, remotely from the body, into the liquid within the water heater. 
         The specification states that a common failing of this construction is that, after prolonged use, scale and deposits
are formed within the pressure cavity side of the valve to an extent sufficient to obstruct the orifice and prevent the valve from relieving the heater contents when excessive temperature or pressure occurs.
         The specification goes on to explain that:            

"some valves have been designed for positioning in the water circulation lines of a water heater and, to this end, have been provided with inlet and outlet ports for connection in the piping of the heater.  Typical of these are shown…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robertshaw Controls Company v G.S.A Industries Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1990] APO 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute between Robertshaw Controls Company and G.S.A Industries Limited pertains to Australian Patent Application No. 516290, which was opposed by G.S.A Industries Limited under Section 82 of the Patents Act 1952. This case involved multiple stages of opposition and amendment requests, with the final decision rendered by a Delegate of the Commissioner of Patents. The central issue in this case revolved around the allowance of proposed amendments to the patent claims, which were deemed necessary to address prior objections. The court was required to determine whether the proposed amendments were allowable under Sections 78, 40, and 78(4) of the Patents Act, and whether they complied with the requirements for non-obviousness and clarity.

The court's reasoning focused on whether the proposed amendments introduced new matter not disclosed in the original specification, whether they fell within the scope of the original claims, and whether they complied with the requirement for a fair basis in the specification. The delegate considered the submissions from both parties and the declarations of experts in the field. The delegate found that the proposed amendments did not introduce new matter in substance, as they were aimed at clarifying the original disclosure and correcting obvious mistakes. Furthermore, the delegate concluded that the amendments were clear and understandable to a person skilled in the art, and provided a fair basis for the claims. The delegate also noted that the amendments did not contravene the requirement for non-obviousness, as they were based on the principles of the invention and the means to achieve it.

The court ultimately decided that the proposed amendments were allowable, and the opposition by G.S.A Industries Limited failed on all counts. The delegate awarded costs against G.S.A Industries Limited, reflecting the unsuccessful nature of their opposition. This decision confirms the importance of allowing patent applicants the opportunity to refine their claims and specifications in response to prior objections, as long as the amendments remain within the scope of the original disclosure and comply with the statutory requirements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established