Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (Interlocutory Rulings)

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (Interlocutory Rulings) [2025] FCA 504

File number(s): NSD 689 of 2023
NSD 690 of 2023
NSD 691 of 2023
Judgment of: PERRAM J
Date of judgment: 30 April 2025
Date of publication of reasons: 23 May 2025
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where the respondents seek to strike out the appellant’s amended interlocutory application to re-open the evidence on his appeal which he filed one month after filing the initial application to re-open the evidence on his appeal and only three days before the hearing of that application – where some of the particulars in the amended notice of appeal attached to the application are not particularised – where the legal theory in the amended interlocutory application differs substantially from that of the initial application – where the appellant’s delay in raising the amended interlocutory application is unexplained – whether the amended interlocutory application should be struck out

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where the respondents’ solicitors at trial are the subject of subpoenas to give evidence in an interlocutory application filed while the Full Court’s judgment on the appeal was reserved – where the notice of appeal the subject of the interlocutory application makes no allegations against those solicitors – whether the subpoenas should be set aside

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where a witness’s affidavit concerning her dealings with a respondent and some of the respondents’ solicitors over four years was provided to the parties and the court less than two days before the relevant hearing – where the affidavit concerns matters beyond the scope of the application to be heard – where the affidavit attached as part of an exhibit material pertaining a confidential settlement of separate claims or proceedings – whether the affidavit should be struck out and removed from the court file – whether suppression and non-publication orders should issue regarding portions of the exhibit and the transcript of the hearing

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where a subpoena to give evidence to a witness was served three days before the hearing – where the subpoena was inconsistent with the timetable for evidence at the hearing – where the circumstances surrounding the subpoena raise fairness and confidentiality concerns – whether the subpoena should be set aside

Legislation:

Constitution s 72

Evidence Act (Cth) s 117, 119

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 14(3), 37AE, 37AF

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 1.21, 1.32, 6.01, 20.02

Cases cited: Roberts-Smithv Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 414
Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Other Federal Jurisdiction
Number of paragraphs: 87
Date of hearing: 30 April 2025
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr Moses SC with Mr N Olson and Mr T Scott
Solicitor for the Appellant: BlackBay Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr J Sheahan SC with Mr R Yezerski SC, Mr C Mitchell and Ms H Ryan
Solicitor for the Respondents: MinterEllison
Counsel for Mr Bartlett (Subpoena Recipient): Mr T D…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd (Interloc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 504
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The interlocutory ruling in Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd concerns several procedural issues arising from an ongoing defamation case involving the appellant, a high-profile individual, and the respondents, media publishers. The appellant, who sued for defamation based on articles suggesting he was guilty of domestic violence and hypocrisy, faced issues including the striking out of an amended interlocutory application, the setting aside of subpoenas, the removal of an affidavit from the court file, and the issuance of suppression orders. The amended interlocutory application, filed just three days before a hearing, sought to re-open evidence on the appellant’s appeal and contained particulars that were not sufficiently detailed. The court found the delay in filing the application unexplained and the legal theory substantially different from the initial application, leading to the decision to strike it out.

The legal issues before the court included whether the amended interlocutory application should be allowed given the unexplained delay and significant differences from the initial application, whether subpoenas issued to the respondents' solicitors should be set aside as they were filed after the Full Court’s judgment was reserved, whether an affidavit provided less than two days before the hearing should be removed from the court file due to its irrelevance and inadmissible form, and whether suppression orders should apply to certain portions of an exhibit and the transcript of the hearing. The court reasoned that the amended application’s delay and substantive differences warranted its dismissal, the subpoenas to the solicitors were unnecessary given the nature of the interlocutory application, the affidavit was oppressive and not relevant to the proceedings, and suppression orders were appropriate to protect sensitive information.

The court ordered the striking out of the amended interlocutory application, the setting aside of subpoenas to the respondents' solicitors, the removal of the affidavit from the court file, and the issuance of suppression and non-publication orders regarding certain parts of an exhibit and the hearing transcript. These rulings aimed to maintain procedural fairness, protect sensitive information, and ensure that the proceedings remained focused on relevant and admissible evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

On Wednesday 30 April 2025 I made orders setting aside three subpoenas, removing an affidavit from the Court file, prohibiting disclosure of portions of the relevant exhibit, and striking out the appellant’s amended interlocutory application. These are my reasons for making those orders.BACKGROUND The respondents published articles about the appellant in which, amongst other things, they suggested that he was guilty of domestic violence and was a hypocrite for publicly supporting Rosie Batty, a domestic violence campaigner. The appellant sued for defamation. The respondents pleaded justification and alleged that the appellant had an extra-marital affair with a woman known in these proceedings only as Person 17 and that during that affair he had punched her in the eye on the evening of 28 March 2018 at the Hotel Realm in Canberra. In 2021, whilst the trial was underway, the second respondent, Mr Nick McKenzie, endeavoured to persuade Person 17 that she should testify against the appellant. A telephone conversation took place between Mr McKenzie and Person 17 around March or April 2021. The telephone conversation was recorded. An affidavit filed by Mr McKenzie suggests that he will give evidence to the Full Court that he did not record it. The suggested inference from this will be that Person 17 was the person who recorded the conversation. Ultimately, Person 17 gave evidence for the respondents at the trial and testified that the appellant had punched her in the eye. The appellant denied this. The trial judge found the affair proved and that there had been an altercation between Person 17 and the appellant that evening at the Hotel Realm. He rejected the appellant’s version of what had happened but was nevertheless not satisfied that Person 17’s evidence was sufficiently reliable to justify the serious conclusion that the appellant had punched her in the eye. The respondents’ defence of justification in relation to the domestic violence allegations therefore failed and the appellant was therefore successful in the part of the case which concerned the allegations made by Person 17. However, this defeat for the respondents was eclipsed by their success in proving that the appellant had been involved in several murders in Afghanistan. In effect, whilst the respondents defamed the appellant by accusing him of domestic violence and hypocrisy, after it was established that he committed several murders, he had no reputation to be harmed by the unproven allegation that he was guilty of domestic violence and a hypocrite. The trial was conducted over 110 days. The appellant then appealed to the Full Court and the appeal was heard over 10 days in February 2024. Judgment was reserved on 16 February 2024. On 15 March 2025, a former solicitor for the appellant received an anonymous email from the email address ellroyferris@proton.me. Attached to the email was a short snippet from the recording of the conversation between Mr McKenzie and Person 17. During the recording Mr McKenzie appears to have made two statements of interest. First: ‘You know the fact they’ve actively like briefing us on his legal strategy in respect of you like yeah we … yeah we’re not learning like we anticipated most of it.’ Secondly: ‘I shouldn’t - I shouldn’t tell you. I’ve just breached my fucking ethics in doing that like this is where like, this has put me in a shit position now like. If Dean knew that and then you know I’d get my arse fucking handed to me on a platter like’.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The amendments in the balance of the amended interlocutory application are cognate to Particulars 35 and 36A. Thus, once the amendments to Particulars 35 and 36A are rejected, the other amendments fall away. For those reasons, I will disallow all of the amendments to the interlocutory application dated 27 March 2025. To regularise the file, I will strike the amended interlocutory application out since, shorn of its amendments, it serves no purpose. THE SUBPOENAS TO MR BARTLETT AND MR LEVITAN TO GIVE EVIDENCE As it now stands, Particular 35 contains no allegations against Mr Bartlett or Mr Levitan. It also does not allege that Mr McKenzie used the privileged material. It seems very unlikely that Mr Bartlett or Mr Levitan will be able to give evidence which will assist the appellant in proving what he alleges against Mr McKenzie. Also relevant is that what is before the Court is an application by the appellant to re-open his appeal. Before taking the unusual step of requiring the solicitors for the respondents to give evidence for the appellant in an interlocutory application filed after an appeal has been argued, I need to be persuaded that this serves a legitimate forensic purpose. I am not so persuaded. THE AFFIDAVIT OF PERSON 17 It is useful to restate the chronology concerning the subpoena to Person 17. The evidentiary timetable required the appellant to file any evidence in reply to the affidavit of Mr McKenzie by 22 April 2025. On the night of Sunday 27 April 2025 the Court was approached by the appellant’s solicitors via email to issue a subpoena to give evidence to Person 17. The request for leave to issue the subpoena was accompanied by a letter from Person 17’s solicitor saying that she, Person 17, did not agree with Mr McKenzie’s affidavit ‘in a number of respects’ and that she was ‘prepared to provide an affidavit in response subject to being served with a subpoena to give evidence’. On the morning of 28 April, I granted leave to issue the subpoena and the subpoena to Person 17 was made returnable before the Full Court on Thursday 1 May 2025. On the evening of Tuesday 29 April 2025, at 7.39 pm, the appellant’s solicitors received a copy of an affidavit of Person 17 dated 29 April 2025 from Person 17’s solicitors. Sixteen minutes later, at 7.55 pm, the appellant’s solicitors filed that affidavit in these proceedings. I have set out FCR r 6.01 at [36]. It allows the Court to strike out matter in a filed document that is scandalous, vexatious or oppressive, and to remove the document from the Court file. The filing of the affidavit of Person 17 is oppressive for three reasons. First, there is no prospect that the respondents can meet Person 17’s affidavit by the hearing on Thursday 1 May 2025. Secondly, the affidavit contains serious allegations against third parties which are not relevant to the dispute before the Court. Thirdly, it is in largely inadmissible form. For those reasons, I removed the affidavit from the Court file.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Apart from that, there is no evidence from the appellant’s side to support the submission. None of the appellant’s advisors have sworn that the matters in (a)-(d) are the reason the amended interlocutory application was filed. That in itself is a sufficient reason to reject the submission. It is possible to infer that the appellant’s advisors misconceived from the outset how Particular 35 (as initially postulated) operated and when confronted with an adverse judicial decision on 28 April 2025 determined it appropriate to amend. Conclusions on amended Particular 35 Each of these three reasons independently persuades me that it would be unjust for amended Particular 35 to remain on foot. The amendment should be disallowed pursuant to FCR r 1.32.The Discovery Issue at Particular 36A Amended Particular 36A is in these terms:36AThe Second Respondent failed to comply with his discovery obligations in accordance with the order for discovery made on 2 August 2019 by Besanko J and the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) by reason of his:(a)failing to discover communications with sources including Danielle Scott, Emma Roberts and Person 17, including communications conducted using the encrypted messaging application Signal, and failing to disclose the destruction or loss of such communications and to state when those documents were last in his control and what became of them, as required by r 20.17(2)(b);(b)failing to discover communications and documents relating to the receipt and transmission of screenshots, images and other media files obtained from Danielle Scott, Emma Roberts and Person 17 including the means by which such material was received and forwarded to his solicitors;(c)failing to discover file notes or records of the meeting held with Emma Roberts and Danielle Scott on 14 March 2021, or alternatively failing to disclose those documents and claim any privilege over them as required by r 20.17(2)(c); and(d)verifying by affidavit that his Lists of Documents were complete and accurate when, in truth, material categories of directly relevant documents were omitted, thereby providing a false and misleading verification contrary to r 20.22. This allegation was first put forward on Monday 28 April 2025 with the hearing scheduled to commence on Thursday 1 May 2025. The amendment should be disallowed under FCR r 1.32 for two reasons. First, the respondents cannot be expected to respond to this case on two days’ notice. Secondly, there is no evidence explaining why amended Particular 36A was not put forward sooner. Impossibility of responding in two days The appellant accepts in his written submissions that the respondents cannot reasonably be expected to meet this new case in the two days remaining before the hearing commences on Thursday 1 May 2025. He proposes that the hearing proceed on the two days allotted on all issues apart from amended Particular 36A and that the matter go over to a date in the week commencing Monday 12 May 2025 in relation to amended Particular 36A. The respondents would then be given an opportunity to meet the amended Particular 36A during the hiatus between the two hearings and further evidence and submissions could then take place at the resumed hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established