Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [2025] FCA 414

File numbers: NSD 689 of 2023
NSD 690 of 2023
NSD 691 of 2023
Judgment of: PERRAM J
Date of judgment: 24 April 2025
Date of publication of reasons: 28 April 2025
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where the Court has issued six subpoenas to produce documents to various third-parties including the respondents’ legal representatives at the appellant’s request – where the appellant has served the Second Respondent with a notice to produce – whether the subpoenas and notice to produce serve a legitimate forensic purpose
Cases cited:

Commissioner for Railways v Small (1938) 38 SR (NSW) 564; 55 WN (NSW) 215

Seven Network (Operations) Ltd v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd [2023] FCAFC 185

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Other Federal Jurisdiction
Number of paragraphs: 61
Date of hearing: 23 April 2025
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr A Moses SC with Mr T Scott
Solicitor for the Appellant: BlackBay Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr R Yezerski SC with Ms H Ryan
Solicitor for the Respondents: MinterEllison
Counsel for Mr Bartlett (Subpoena Recipient): Mr T D Blackburn SC
Solicitor for Mr Bartlett (Subpoena Recipient): K&L Gates
Counsel for Mr Levitan (Subpoena Recipient): Mr N M Bender SC
Solicitor for Mr Levitan (Subpoena Recipient): Lander & Rogers
Solicitor for the Australian Broadcasting Corporation (Subpoena Recipient): Mr C Jankie
Counsel for the Commonwealth Ms J Single SC
Solicitor for the Commonwealth Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

NSD 689 of 2023
BETWEEN:

MR BEN ROBERTS-SMITH

Appellant

AND:

FAIRFAX MEDIA PUBLICATIONS PTY LTD (ACN 003 357 720)

First Respondent

MR NICK MCKENZIE

Second Respondent

MR CHRIS MASTERS

Third Respondent

MR DAVID WROE
Fourth Respondent

INTERESTED PERSONS:

MR PETER BARTLETT

Other

MR DEAN LEVITAN

Other

ORDER MADE BY:

PERRAM J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 APRIL 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.In respect of the Notice to Produce dated 16 April 2025 and issued to the Second Respondent by the Appellant,

(a)paragraphs 2 to 3 and 5 to 10 be set aside;

(b)paragraph 1 be taken to have a date range of 1 August 2020 to 30 April 2021; and

(c)paragraph 4 be taken to have a date range of 1 August 2020 to 31 May 2021.

2.In respect of the Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17 April 2025 and issued to Mr Dean Levitan at the request of the Appellant, paragraphs 1 to 3 and 5 to 8 be set aside and paragraph 4 be taken to be limited to the date range of 1 August 2020 to 31 May 2021.

3.In respect of the Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17 April 2025 and issued to Mr Peter Bartlett at the request of the Appellant, paragraphs 1 to 3 and 5 to 8 be set aside and paragraph 4 be taken to be limited to the date range of 1 August 2020 to 31 May 2021.

4.The Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 414
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Roberts-Smith v Fairfax Media Publications Pty Ltd concerns an application by the respondents to set aside various subpoenas and a notice to produce, which the appellant sought to issue to various third parties. The respondents argue that the subpoenas and notice to produce do not serve a legitimate forensic purpose and are overly broad, potentially capturing documents not relevant to the issues at hand. The court was required to determine whether the subpoenas and notice to produce were valid and served a legitimate forensic purpose.

The court found that several paragraphs of the subpoenas and the notice to produce were too broad and did not serve a legitimate forensic purpose. The court set aside certain paragraphs and amended others to narrow the scope of the requests. Specifically, the court set aside paragraphs that sought documents beyond the relevant period and those that captured communications unrelated to the issues in the case. The court also clarified the date ranges for certain paragraphs to ensure they aligned with the relevant period for the issues being addressed. The court concluded that the subpoenas and notice to produce, as amended, served a legitimate forensic purpose and were therefore valid.

The court set aside certain paragraphs of the subpoenas and notice to produce and amended others to narrow their scope. The court also clarified the date ranges for some paragraphs to ensure they aligned with the relevant period for the issues being addressed. The court ordered that the time for compliance with the amended paragraphs be set at 5 pm on Monday, 28 April 2025, with liberty to apply. The respondents' costs of their interlocutory application were ordered to be costs in the cause.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In respect of the Notice to Produce dated 16 April 2025 and issued to the Second Respondent by the Appellant,

(a) paragraphs 2 to 3 and 5 to 10 be set aside;

(b) paragraph 1 be taken to have a date range of 1 August 2020 to 30 April 2021; and

(c) paragraph 4 be taken to have a date range of 1 August 2020 to 31 May 2021.

2. In respect of the Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17 April 2025 and issued to Mr Dean Levitan at the request of the Appellant, paragraphs 1 to 3 and 5 to 8 be set aside and paragraph 4 be taken to be limited to the date range of 1 August 2020 to 31 May 2021.

3. In respect of the Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17 April 2025 and issued to Mr Peter Bartlett at the request of the Appellant, paragraphs 1 to 3 and 5 to 8 be set aside and paragraph 4 be taken to be limited to the date range of 1 August 2020 to 31 May 2021.

4. The Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17 April 2025 and issued to the Australian Broadcasting Commission at the request of the Appellant be set aside.

5. The Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17 April 2025 and issued to Person 17 at the request of the Appellant be set aside.

6. The Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17 April 2025 and issued to Emma Roberts at the request of the Appellant be set aside.

7. The Subpoena to Produce Documents filed on 17 April 2025 and issued to Danielle Scott at the request of the Appellant be set aside.

8. The time for compliance with the paragraphs of the subpoenas and the notice to produce referred to in Orders 1, 2 and 3 that have not been set aside be amended to 5 pm on Monday 28 April 2025 with liberty to apply.

9. The costs of the Respondents’ Interlocutory Application lodged on 22 April 2025 be costs in the cause.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For the same reasons I have articulated in setting aside paragraphs 6, 7 and 8, I do not see how documents produced after 21 March 2025 could reasonably be expected to throw light on the four issues I have identified. The paragraphs will be set aside.Conclusions on the Notice to Produce to Mr McKenzie Paragraphs 2 to 3 and 5 to 10 of the notice to produce will be set aside. Paragraph 1 will be taken to operate as if the date range expressed in it was 1 August 2020 to 30 April 2021 and paragraph 4 will be taken to operate as if the date range were 1 August 2020 to 31 May 2021.The Subpoena to Mr Dean Levitan of MinterEllison Paragraph 1 of the subpoena is in these terms:All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages, notes of conversations or other documents by which Nick McKenzie provided you information in relation to the Appellant obtained from Emma Roberts or Danielle Scott in the period between 1 August 2020 and 27 July 2022. This paragraph has two defects. First, many of the communications passing between Mr McKenzie and Mr Levitan can be expected to be the subject of claims for legal professional privilege. Secondly, the paragraph on its face would require production of documents which have no relevance to the four issues I have identified because it is delimited only by the fact that it needs to be ‘in relation to the appellant’. The paragraph will be set aside. Paragraph 2 of the subpoena is in these terms:All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages or notes of conversations between you and Nick McKenzie in relation to information obtained from Danielle Scott or Emma Roberts in the period between 1 August 2020 and 27 July 2022. This appears to be substantively the same as paragraph 1. It will be set aside for the same reasons. Paragraph 3 of the subpoena is in these terms:All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages or notes of conversations between you and any of the following persons in relation to the Appellant:a. Emma Roberts;b. Danielle Scott;c. Person 17,the period between 1 August 2020 and 27 July 2022. This is overly broad. It catches any document concerning discussions between Mr Levitan and Ms Roberts which relate to the appellant. Since Ms Roberts provided the respondents with an outline of evidence it is apparent that this paragraph will result in a large amount of material which has nothing to do with the present issues. The same may be said of Ms Scott. In the case of Person 17, there is no basis in the evidence before me to think that Person 17 has been involved in the receipt or distribution of privileged material. The paragraph will be set aside. Paragraph 4 of the subpoena is in these terms:All notes of any meeting attended by Emma Roberts or Danielle Scott, on the one hand, and Nick McKenzie and any employee or partner of Minter Ellison, as well as any counsel briefed on the matter, on the other hand in the period between 1 August 2020 and 27 July 2022, including but not limited to the meeting on 14 March 2021.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This subpoena is in the same terms as the subpoena to Mr Dean Levitan and will be dealt with in the same way.The Subpoena to the Australian Broadcast Corporation For the reasons I have given in relation to paragraph 6 of the notice to produce to Mr McKenzie this subpoena will be set aside.The Subpoena to Person 17 Paragraphs 1 to 3 are in these terms:1.All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages or notes of conversations between you, or any person acting on your behalf, and Nick McKenzie, or any person acting on his behalf, in relation to the Appellant in the period between 1 August 2020 and 27 July 2022.2.All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages, notes of conversations or other documents exchanged between you, or any person acting on your behalf, and Nick McKenzie, or any person acting on his behalf from 21 March 2025 to date in relation to an audio recording of a conversation between you and Nick McKenzie.3.All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages, notes of conversations or other documents exchanged between you, or any person acting on your behalf, and Linton Besser, or any other employee of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation from 21 March 2025 to date concerning an audio recording of a conversation between you and Nick McKenzie. The four issues raised on the re-opening application do not concern communications involving Person 17. The re-opening application is concerned with communications between Mr McKenzie, on the one hand, and Ms Roberts and Ms Scott, on the other, which resulted in further communication between Mr McKenzie and MinterEllison. The subpoena will be set aside.The Subpoena to Ms Emma Roberts Paragraphs 1 to 4 of the subpoena are in these terms:1.All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages, notes of conversations or other documents by which you provided any information to Nick McKenzie in relation to the Appellant in the period between 1 August 2020 and 27 July 2022.2.All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages or notes of conversations between you and Danielle Scott in relation to the Appellant in the period between 1 August 2020 and 27 July 2022.3.All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages or notes of conversations between you and Nick McKenzie, or any person acting on his behalf, in relation to the Appellant in the period between 1 August 2020 and 27 July 2022.4.All letters, emails, text messages, WhatsApp or Signal messages or notes of conversations between you and Nick McKenzie, or any person acting on his behalf, in relation to these proceedings from 21 March 2025 to date. Paragraphs 1 to 3 catch any communications which merely relate to the appellant. For the reasons I have already given in relation to the notice to produce to Mr McKenzie, these paragraphs are far too broad and must be set aside. As I have also explained, I will not permit the subpoena machinery to be used to obtain documents generated in 2025 so paragraph 4 will be set aside.