Robert Johnson v North West Supermarkets T/A Castlemaine Iga

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

[2018] FWC 679

The attached document replaces the document previously issued with the above code on 1 February 2018.

The wording “(change amount)” has been omitted from paragraph [31] on page 7.

Charlie Austin
Associate to COMMISSIONER CIRKOVIC

Dated 08/02/2018

[2018] FWC 679

FAIR WORK COMMISSION

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009

s.394—Unfair dismissal

Robert Johnson

v

North West Supermarkets T/A Castlemaine IGA-

(U2017/1404)

commissioner cirkovic

MELBOURNE, 1 FEBRUARY 2018

Application for an unfair dismissal remedy - compensation.

1. Background

  1. Mr Johnson was employed as a delicatessen assistant with North West Supermarkets Pty Ltd T/A Castlemaine IGA (the Respondent) from October 2008.[1] On 7 February 2017, he was summarily dismissed for theft after having taken two 100-gram samples of smoked salmon and prosciutto, along with a ham bone from the IGA.[2] The items in question were given to Johnson by Ms Penny Royal, his direct supervisor and manager.[3]

  1. Mr Johnson made an application for relief from unfair dismissal on 9 February 2017 (the Application).[4] On 1 June 2017, Deputy President Hamilton handed down a decision (First Instance Decision),[5] dismissing the Application.

  1. The Deputy President had found Mr Johnson to have taken the items of produce from the Castlemaine IGA where he worked. The Deputy President also found that, although Mr Johnson’s action was authorised by a supervisor, it breached company policy and constituted a valid reason for his dismissal. There was also evidence before the Deputy President that it had been the practice for at least 18 months that Ms Royal would bundle up excess produce or samples provided by potential suppliers, to give to staff members to take home at the end of a shift.[6] This practice was not limited to the deli section of the IGA, and a number of other managers would allow staff to take items home for no charge.[7]

  1. On 25 July 2017, a Full Bench of the Commission granted the Applicant permission to appeal the First Instance Decision[8] (the Permission Decision) on the basis that he had made out an arguable case that the proportionality of summary dismissal to the conduct in the case was not considered. In that respect, the Appeal Bench was satisfied that the appeal attracted the public interest as the decision at first instance was disharmonious with other decisions of the Commission which have emphasised the importance of proportionality being considered.

On 28 August 2017, the Full Bench allowed the Applicant’s appeal and set aside the First Instance Decision[9] (the Merits Decision). The reasons for allowing the Applicant’s appeal are encapsulated in the passage below:

“We have concluded that the Deputy President’s decision was affected by appealable error for the reason we identified in our decision on permission to appeal, namely the failure to consider the question of proportionality of summary dismissal to Mr Johnson’s conduct. This is an important consideration that bears on the question of whether or not the termination was harsh, unjust or unreasonable.[10] It will sometimes be possible to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Robert Johnson v North West Supermarkets T/A Castlemaine Iga and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FWC 679
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Fair Work Commission involved Robert Johnson, an employee, who brought an application against North West Supermarkets, trading as Castlemaine Iga, for unfair dismissal and compensation. Johnson alleged that he was dismissed without just cause or reason, contrary to the provisions of the Fair Work Act 2009. The Commission was tasked with determining whether the dismissal was indeed unfair and, if so, to what extent the compensation should be awarded.

The central legal issues the Commission had to address were whether the dismissal was carried out in accordance with the provisions of the Fair Work Act and whether the employer had a valid reason for terminating the employment. Specifically, the Commission needed to consider the employer's explanation for the dismissal, which centred around alleged misconduct and performance issues, and whether these constituted a valid reason for termination under the Act. Furthermore, the Commission had to examine the proportionality of the dismissal in the context of the employer's response to the alleged misconduct.

In examining the evidence, the Commission found that while the employer did have concerns regarding Johnson's performance and conduct, these did not justify the termination of his employment without a fair process. The employer failed to provide Johnson with adequate opportunities to address the concerns, nor did they follow the procedural fairness required by the Fair Work Act. The Commission concluded that the dismissal was indeed unfair due to the lack of procedural fairness and the employer's failure to mitigate the situation before resorting to termination. As a result, the Commission ordered compensation for Johnson, reflecting both lost wages and the distress caused by the unfair dismissal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established