Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd V Fingal Glen Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 102 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

RIVIERA HOLDINGS PTY LTD v FINGAL GLEN PTY LTD

[2013] SASC 77

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Nicholson

28 May 2013

EQUITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - GENERALLY

EQUITY - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - PENALTY - RELIEF AGAINST PENALTY AND FORFEITURE

REAL PROPERTY - TORRENS TITLE - LEASES - DETERMINATION - FORFEITURE AND RELIEF AGAINST FORFEITURE

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - DISCHARGE, BREACH AND DEFENCES TO ACTION FOR BREACH - OTHER MATTERS

Fingal Glen Pty Ltd held a 5 year lease of motel premises and a 5 year lease of adjacent carpark premises from Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd both of which commenced 6 October 2009. Each lease contained multiple rights of renewal. In breach of the leases, Fingal failed to pay rents for May 2012 and on 4 June 2012 Riviera served notices of forfeiture and re-entry. On 9 November 2012 orders were made in this Court in favour of Riviera, including a declaration that the leases had been terminated on 4 June 2012 and an order that Riviera was to have possession of the motel premises and the carpark premises. This judgment was stayed on conditions so as to enable Fingal to pursue its cross-claim for relief against forfeiture of its proprietary interests under the leases. By the time the cross-claim came on for hearing, Fingal had remedied the breaches. However, there had been an extensive history of non-compliance with lease obligations. During the trial an order for the winding up of and appointment of a liquidator to Fingal was made in the Federal Court.

Issues considered included: whether the lessor has now received all to which is it entitled under the leases; whether, if relief were to be granted, the lessee will be able to perform its financial obligations under the leases into the future; whether anticipated or actual appointment of a liquidator is a bar to relief; whether the nature and gravity of the breaches and their effect on the lessor is wholly disproportionate to the prejudice the lessee will suffer should relief not be granted; and whether the lessor will accrue a benefit or windfall if relief is refused.

Held: Relief against forfeiture allowed. In all the circumstances, it is just and equitable to grant relief.

Evidence Act 1929 s59J; Landlord and Tenant Act 1936 s9, s10; Corporations Act 2001 s459E; Commercial Tenancy Law 3rd ed 2009, LexisNexis Butterworths Australia, Bradbrook Croft and Hay at [19.1], referred to.
Jones v Dunkel (1959) 101 CLR 298; Shiloh Spinners v Harding [1973] AC 691; Legione v Hateley [1983] HCA 11, (1983) 152 CLR 406; O’Dea v Allstates Leasing System (WA) Pty Ltd [1983] HCA 3, (1983) 152 CLR 359; AMEV-UDC Finance Ltd v Austin [1986] HCA 63, (1986) 162 CLR 170; Stern v McArthur [1988] HCA 51, (1988) 165 CLR 489; Esanda Finance Corporation Ltd v Plessnig [1989] HCA 7, (1989) 166 CLR 131; Tanwar Enterprises Pty Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd V Fingal Glen Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SASC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd v Fingal Glen Pty Ltd, the dispute centred around the termination of two leases held by Fingal Glen Pty Ltd from Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd, one for motel premises and another for adjacent carpark premises. Both leases had been in effect since 6 October 2009 and contained provisions for renewal. Fingal Glen Pty Ltd fell into arrears by failing to pay rent for May 2012, leading Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd to serve notices of forfeiture and re-entry on 4 June 2012. The court subsequently declared the leases terminated and ordered Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd to take possession of the premises, though the order was stayed to allow Fingal Glen Pty Ltd to pursue a cross-claim for relief against forfeiture. By the time the cross-claim was heard, Fingal Glen Pty Ltd had remedied the breaches but had a history of non-compliance with the lease terms. During the trial, an order for the winding up of Fingal Glen Pty Ltd was made in the Federal Court.

The legal issues before the court included the extent to which a court can consider other breaches of covenant by the lessee when deciding whether to grant relief against forfeiture, and whether the appointment of a liquidator for Fingal Glen Pty Ltd barred relief against forfeiture. The court examined whether it was just and equitable to grant relief against forfeiture, taking into account Fingal Glen Pty Ltd's extensive history of non-compliance and the consequences of refusal of relief. The court concluded that although Fingal Glen Pty Ltd faced significant future challenges, Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd had received all that it was entitled to under the leases, and it was just and equitable to grant relief against forfeiture. The court found that the appointment of a liquidator did not bar relief in the circumstances of this case.

The court's reasoning hinged on the balance between the substantial detriment to Fingal Glen Pty Ltd if relief were not granted and the gravity of the breach upon which Riviera Holdings Pty Ltd relied. The court accepted that it was entitled to consider Fingal Glen Pty Ltd's overall conduct when deciding whether relief should be granted. Given the circumstances, the court determined that it was just and equitable to grant relief against forfeiture, finding no unconscionable conduct by Fingal Glen Pty Ltd warranting refusal of relief.

ORDERS:
The court granted relief against forfeiture, allowing Fingal Glen Pty Ltd to retain its proprietary interests under the leases. The court held that it was just and equitable to grant relief in all the circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held: Relief against forfeiture allowed. In all the circumstances, it is just and equitable to grant relief.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

NICHOLSON J
Where a landlord relies on a single non-payment of rent for its entitlement to forfeit, the extent to which and the purpose for which a court might have regard to other breaches of covenant by the lessee in considering whether to grant relief against forfeiture is not entirely settled.[142] Nevertheless, for present purposes I am prepared to accept that a court is entitled to and should have regard to all of Fingal’s conduct towards Riviera when ultimately deciding whether or not it would be just and equitable to grant relief.[143] In my consideration of this question, in the present case, I have had regard to all of the criticisms of the conduct of Fingal, particularly, in its capacity as tenant levelled by Riviera. [142] See, for example, Pioneer Quarries (Sydney) Pty Ltd v Permanent Trustee Co of NSW Ltd (1970) 2 BPR 9562, Tutita Pty Ltd v Ryleaco Pty Ltd (1989) 4 BPR 9635, Hayes v Gunbola (1986) 4 BPR 9247; (1988) NSW ConvR 55-375, Stieper v Deviot Pty Ltd (1977) 2 BPR 9602, Lo Giudice v Biviano (No 2) [1962] VR 420, Cicinave Pty Ltd v Jasco Pty Ltd (1989) 5 BPR 11,139, Jam Factory Pty Ltd v Sunny Paradise Pty Ltd & Ors [1989] VR 584, Mineaplenty Pty Ltd v Trek31 Pty Ltd [2006] NSWSC 1203 at [68]. [143] This is the more general (and most generous from a landlord’s perspective) test posed by Hodson J in Gill v Lewis [1956] 2 QB 1 and adopted by Ormiston J in Jam Factory Pty Ltd v Sunny Paradise Pty Ltd & Ors [1989] VR 584 at 591.Conclusion There is no doubt that if relief were to be granted Fingal would face significant challenges in the future including, but not limited to, (i)the clause 14.3.3.3 issue;(ii)the threat to its rights of renewal posed by clause 12.6.1;(iii)the ongoing challenges (for the liquidator at present) of running a financially successful motel business; and(iv)a landlord determined to fasten on any (lawful) reason to have Fingal removed as tenant as soon as possible. Nevertheless, I am satisfied that Riviera has now received all to which it is entitled under the leases and that there are sufficiently good prospects that it will continue to be paid rent and outgoings and other amounts due under the leases on time into the future. When I weigh up the potentially very substantial and irretrievable detriment to Fingal in the event that relief were not to be granted as against the gravity of the breach upon which Riviera relied when exercising its right of forfeiture and re-entry, all of the other conduct of Fingal complained about and the consequences thereof for Riviera, I am satisfied that it is just and equitable to grant relief against forfeiture. There is insufficient about Fingal’s conduct as tenant (in the wider sense) and in the many criticisms levelled against Fingal and Mr Buff by Riviera, when all the circumstances are considered, to cause me to refrain from exercising the discretion to grant relief. I do not find the appointment of the liquidator, in the circumstances of this case, to be a bar to relief. This is not a case which falls within that very limited category of cases where relief should be refused even though rent and other expenses have been brought up to date. It is not a case where it should be characterised as unconscionable on the part of Fingal to apply for and obtain relief against forfeiture. Indeed, it is a case where equity should exercise its traditional function of intervening to prevail upon the conscience of Riviera. It should do so to prevent Riviera from relying on a strict application of the law and taking advantage of Fingal’s breaches so as to unjustly acquire significant benefits at Fingal’s expense.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: NICHOLSON J