Okami SA Newton Pty Ltd v Newton SC Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

OKAMI SA NEWTON PTY LTD v NEWTON SC PTY LTD

[2024] SASC 151

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stanley  

LANDLORD AND TENANT - TERMINATION OF THE TENANCY - FORFEITURE - RELIEF AGAINST FORFEITURE

LANDLORD AND TENANT - TERMINATION OF THE TENANCY - FORFEITURE - RELIEF AGAINST FORFEITURE - EQUITABLE RELIEF

LANDLORD AND TENANT - TERMINATION OF THE TENANCY - FORFEITURE - RELIEF AGAINST FORFEITURE - RELIEF UNDER STATUTE

This is an application for relief against forfeiture. On 24 February 2021 the applicant entered into a lease with G. & R. Difede Pty Ltd of a shop in the Newton Plaza Shopping Centre described as Shop 5, 297 Montague Road (the Lease).  The Lease commenced on 1 March 2021 for a term of ten years.  The applicant operates an all you can eat Japanese restaurant from the leased premises. On or about 20 December 2021, the respondent purchased the Newton Plaza Shopping Centre.  The Lease was assigned to the respondent.

The respondent is part of Revelop, a property development group which also owns the neighbouring Newton Village Shopping Centre. Revelop has plans to redevelop both properties to create a single, much larger shopping centre. The Lease provides that after a period of seven years the respondent could, inter alia terminate the Lease if it was proposing to substantially redevelop the premises.

On 19 September 2024, the respondent purported to terminate the lease for non-payment of rent. Lease payments have subsequently been brought up to date.

The applicant submits that it is entitled to relief against forfeiture. It submits inter alia that it is not hopelessly insolvent and that this matter does not fall within the limited category of cases in which the Court would decline to grant relief against forfeiture.

The respondent submits that relief should be refused as any relief would be futile on account of the applicant being hopelessly insolvent. The respondent also submits that a significant consideration for the Court is prejudice to third party rights.

After terminating the Lease, the respondent became aware that the applicant entered into a deed of company arrangement by the appointment of administrators on 19 January 2024 and subsequently entered into a restructuring plan on 12 March 2024. The respondent submits that it is also entitled to terminate the Lease on these grounds. It insists it will exercise its right to terminate the Lease on this basis if relief against forfeiture is granted. The applicant submits that to the extent the respondent has any right to terminate on this basis, that right is stayed by reason of the operation of s 454N of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

The issues to be determined are whether, in the circumstances, relief against forfeiture ought to be granted, and whether, any right of the respondent to terminate the lease on the grounds that the applicant entered into administration and restructuring is stayed pursuant to s 454N of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

Held, granting relief against forfeiture:

1.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Okami SA Newton Pty Ltd v Newton SC Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Okami SA Newton Pty Ltd v Newton SC Pty Ltd, the dispute concerns the termination of a tenancy and the issue of forfeiture, with the court considering the applicability of relief against forfeiture. The applicant, Okami SA Newton Pty Ltd, sought relief from forfeiture against the respondent, Newton SC Pty Ltd, which had terminated the lease of the applicant's business premises in Newton Plaza Shopping Centre. The primary focus of the case was the applicant's request for equitable and statutory relief against forfeiture, given the respondent's actions in terminating the lease and taking possession of the premises.

The legal issues before the court involved the interpretation of the lease agreement, the respondent's right to terminate the lease, and whether the respondent's actions amounted to an unconscionable exercise of power. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the applicant was hopelessly insolvent or whether granting relief against forfeiture would be futile. The applicant argued that the respondent's redevelopment plans, including the erection of fencing and the undertaking of redevelopment work, constituted a breach of the covenant of quiet enjoyment and obstructed access to the premises, thereby justifying relief against forfeiture.

The court found that the respondent had not demonstrated that the applicant was hopelessly insolvent or that granting relief against forfeiture would be futile. The judge concluded that the respondent's conduct in terminating the lease and forcing the applicant out was unconscionable. The court weighed the discretionary factors and decided to grant relief against forfeiture, considering the circumstances and the respondent's actions. The court directed the parties to provide submissions on the terms of the orders to be made and the issue of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Okami SA Newton Pty Ltd (the applicant) was a tenant of a unit within the Newton Plaza Shopping Centre, owned by Newton SC Pty Ltd (the respondent). The applicant operated a Japanese restaurant within the unit, having entered into a lease agreement with the respondent. Over time, the respondent, through its representative Anthony El-Hazouri, engaged in negotiations with other tenants of the shopping centre to either relocate or surrender their leases early to facilitate redevelopment of the property. The leases of two other tenants, Bargain City and Pulse 24-Hour Gym, expired and were not renewed. However, the respondent negotiated with the Australia Post shop to vacate the premises before the lease term ended.

The respondent's actions towards the applicant were different. Despite negotiations, the applicant remained in occupation of the leased premises. Eventually, the respondent initiated proceedings to forfeit the lease, claiming that the applicant had breached the terms of the lease. The applicant, in response, sought relief against forfeiture, arguing that it was not in breach of the lease and that the respondent's actions were intended to force them out of the premises. The applicant also argued that the respondent's conduct in negotiating with other tenants but not pursuing forfeiture against them demonstrated an intention to unjustly target the applicant. The court's trial on November 7 and 8, 2024, focused solely on the claim for relief against forfeiture, with the matter of whether the respondent had breached the lease by blocking access to the carpark being reserved for a later date.

The case of Okami SA Newton Pty Ltd v Newton SC Pty Ltd came before Dart AsJ in the Local Court of New South Wales following an application by the applicant, Okami SA Newton Pty Ltd, for relief against forfeiture of its tenancy. The applicant had previously been in a commercial lease agreement with the respondent, Newton SC Pty Ltd, for a shopping centre in Newton. The dispute arose after the respondent initiated proceedings for forfeiture of the lease due to alleged breaches. The applicant, in turn, sought relief against forfeiture, arguing that the respondent's actions were unconscionable and amounted to a forced eviction. The matter was first heard on an interim basis on 27 September 2024, when Dart AsJ granted an interim order allowing the applicant to resume possession of the premises pending the determination of the relief against forfeiture application. This interim order was subsequently extended until the final judgment on the application. The substantive hearing on the application for relief against forfeiture took place over two days, on 7 and 8 November 2024. Both parties presented evidence, with the applicant calling Fred Jiang, the franchise relationship manager, and Thomas Summakwan, the financial controller, while the respondent called Anthony El-Hazouri to give evidence. The trial focused solely on the issue of relief against forfeiture, with other claims for breach of lease being reserved for another proceeding. Throughout the process, the Court considered various procedural aspects, including the respondent's submission regarding the absence of evidence from the controlling mind of the applicant's Group, Mr Liang Wang, which the Court found did not necessitate an adverse inference against the applicant.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Lease payments have subsequently been brought up to date. The applicant seeks orders for relief against forfeiture. The applicant resumed possession of the premises pursuant to orders made by Dart AsJ on 27 September 2024. The interim order has been extended to operate until the Court has delivered judgment on the application for relief from forfeiture. Evidence The applicant called evidence from its franchise relationship manager Fred Jiang, and Thomas Summakwan, the financial controller of the Group. The respondent called Anthony El-Hazouri to give evidence. I will refer to their evidence where relevant in the course of these reasons. The respondent made a Jones v Dunkel[1] submission in relation to the applicant’s failure to call the controlling mind of the Okami Group, Mr Liang Wang. I do not accept the failure to call Mr Wang gives rise to an inference that his evidence would not have assisted the applicant’s case. The respondent submits that in the absence of evidence from Mr Wang, the controlling mind of Okami Distributions Pty Ltd (Distributions), the Court cannot be satisfied that he is prepared to support the applicant. Mr Summakwan, the financial controller of the Group, gave that evidence and the steps taken by the Group to support the applicant evidences the Group’s commitment of support. I will come back to this matter later in these reasons. In the circumstances, I find it was not necessary for Mr Wang to give evidence. Accordingly, the failure to do so does not give rise to an adverse inference. [1] [1959] HCA 8, (1959) 101 CLR 298.Relevant circumstances The applicant also has a claim against the respondent for breach of the Lease. This claim arises from alleged measures taken to erect fencing around the shopping centre and undertake redevelopment work. The applicant asserts the respondent’s actions derogate from its effective commercial operation of its restaurant, in breach of the covenant of quiet enjoyment, by blocking access to the adjoining carpark and effectively shutting down and closing off the leased property from the adjoining plaza. This claim is said to overlap with the claim for relief against forfeiture. That claim is not a matter I have to decide on this application. The trial which I heard on 7 and 8 November 2024 was limited to the claim for relief against forfeiture. At the time the respondent purchased the Newton Plaza Shopping Centre it had four tenants including the applicant. The remaining businesses were an Australia Post Shop and Newsagent, Bargain City and Pulse 24-Hour Gym. Mr El-Hazouri said that over the course of the following years the respondent negotiated with all of the existing tenants for a relocation or early surrender of each lease to allow for redevelopment of the property.[2] Mr El-Hazouri said that when the terms of the leases with Pulse and Bargain City expired, they were not renewed by the respondent. However, the respondent negotiated with the Australia Post shop to leave prior to their lease expiring.[3] There can be no criticism of the respondent’s conduct in this regard. No doubt this was motivated by Revelop, the respondent’s ultimate holding company, which wants to redevelop the whole site. [2] Affidavit of Anthony El-Hazouri 2 October 2024 (FDN 12) at [12].[3] T.167.11-23.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In any event, I note that none of the third parties have appeared or have sought to pursue their rights. In all of the circumstances I consider it unconscionable that the respondent should insist on its legal rights under the Lease given its clear intention to force the applicant out of its rights as lessee. Conclusion The respondent has not established that the applicant is hopelessly insolvent or that a grant of relief against forfeiture would be futile. Weighing the relevant discretionary considerations, I would grant relief against forfeiture. I would hear the parties as to the terms of the orders I should make and the question of costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary issue before the court was whether the applicant, Okami SA Newton Pty Ltd, had a valid claim for relief against forfeiture under the relevant statute. The court noted that while the applicant had resumed possession of the premises pursuant to an interim order, it was the court’s role to determine whether relief against forfeiture should be granted on a permanent basis. The court considered the statutory framework under which the application was made and found that the applicant had made out a valid claim for relief against forfeiture. This conclusion was based on the applicant’s compliance with the conditions set out in the statute, including its ability to remedy any breaches of the lease terms.

The court also addressed the issue of whether it was unconscionable for the respondent, Newton SC Pty Ltd, to insist on its legal rights under the lease. In examining this issue, the court considered the respondent's conduct and its clear intention to force the applicant out of its rights as lessee. The court found that the respondent's actions, which included negotiating with other tenants for early surrender of their leases, were part of a broader plan to redevelop the shopping centre. The court concluded that it would be unconscionable for the respondent to insist on its legal rights given the circumstances, particularly as the respondent had not demonstrated a genuine intention to honour the terms of the lease with the applicant.

Another significant issue was whether the respondent had established that the applicant was hopelessly insolvent or that a grant of relief against forfeiture would be futile. The court reviewed the evidence provided by both parties and found that the respondent had not provided sufficient evidence to support either of these contentions. The applicant had brought lease payments up to date, which was a crucial factor in the court's consideration. The court noted that the applicant's ability to remedy the breaches and its demonstrated commitment to continuing its business operations undermined the respondent's arguments.

Lastly, the court considered the terms of the orders, including the question of costs. The court decided to grant relief against forfeiture but deferred the determination of the terms of the orders and the question of costs to allow the parties to present their submissions. The court emphasized the importance of considering all relevant factors, including the conduct of both parties and the broader commercial context, in fashioning appropriate orders.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a respondent has engaged in unconscionable conduct aimed at forcing a tenant out of its lease, and the tenant has remedied the breaches and demonstrated a commitment to fulfilling the lease terms, the court may grant relief against forfeiture. This principle underscores the equitable jurisdiction of the court to prevent unjust enrichment and to ensure fair dealing in landlord-tenant relationships. The court also reinforced the importance of considering unconscionability as a significant factor in relief against forfeiture decisions.