SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Full Court: Application)
RIVETT ARBORICULTURAL & WASTE EQUIPMENT HIRE PTY LTD & ORS v CONOR PATRICK EVANS & ORS (No 2)
[2007] SASC 197
Judgment of The Full Court
(The Honourable Chief Justice Doyle, The Honourable Justice Duggan and The Honourable Justice Gray)
30 May 2007
PROCEDURE - COSTS - AGREEMENTS AS TO COSTS
Application by respondents for an order that unsuccessful appellants pay costs of appeal on solicitor client basis - third respondent/cross appellant relies on letter of offer and applies for orders that first and second appellant alone pay costs of appeal, or indemnify third respondent for costs to appellants, or pay third respondent's costs of appeal on party and party basis - departure from general rule unwarranted - appellants pay respondents' costs of appeal as between party and party.
Held: application dismissed.
Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 40; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 263(1), 264(2), referred to.
Pirotta v Citibank Ltd (1998) 72 SASR 259; Tector v FAI General Insurance Co Limited [2001] Qd R 463; Equuscorp Pty Ltd and Anor v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd & Ors [2006] QCA 414, applied.
RIVETT ARBORICULTURAL & WASTE EQUIPMENT HIRE PTY LTD & ORS v CONOR PATRICK EVANS & ORS (No 2)
[2007] SASC 197Full Court: Doyle CJ, Duggan and Gray JJ
DOYLE CJ: In an action in the District Court Conor Evans was awarded damages for injuries that he sustained while operating a wood chipping machine. His brother Christopher Evans was awarded damages for psychological injury that he suffered when he witnesses the incident in question. When convenient I will refer to Conor Evans and Christopher Evans together as the plaintiffs.
Damages were awarded against Rivett Arboricultural & Waste Equipment Hire Pty Ltd (“Rivett”), the manufacturer of the machine and against Arbor Products International (Aust) Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) (“Arbor”), the seller of the machine. Damages were also awarded against WMC (Olympic Dam Corporation) Pty Ltd (“WMC”), the purchaser of the machine from Arbor. The wood chipping machine had been made available by WMC to a group of volunteers who used the machine on WMC’s premises. The machine was maintained and serviced by WMC. The plaintiffs were members of the group of volunteers.
Rivett and Arbor appealed, challenging the finding that they are liable to the plaintiffs. They challenged the apportionment of liability as between them and WMC. WMC also appealed, challenging the finding of liability and the apportionment as between it and Rivett and Arbor.
The appeals were dismissed: Rivett Arboricultural & Waste Equipment Hire Pty Ltd & Ors v Conor Patrick Evans & Ors [2007] SASC 108.
The plaintiffs have applied for an order that Rivett, Arbor and WMC pay the plaintiffs’ costs of the appeal on a solicitor client basis.
They rely on a letter sent by their solicitors to the solicitors for Rivett, Arbor and WMC about two months after the appeals were instituted. In the letter the plaintiffs offered to make…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rivett Arboricultural & Waste Equipment Hire Pty Ltd v Conor... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] SASC 197
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to determine whether the departure from the general rule of costs was justified and whether the appellants should bear the costs of the appeal between parties and parties. The central issue was whether the appellants acted unreasonably in appealing against the apportionment of liability as between defendants and whether they should continue with the appeal despite the offer made by WMC. The court also had to decide on the appropriate allocation of costs considering the unsuccessful nature of the appeals against the apportionment of liability.
The Court of Appeal concluded that Rivett and Arbor did not act unreasonably in appealing against the apportionment of liability as between defendants and in persisting with the appeal despite the offer made by WMC. Given that the appeals against the apportionment of liability were unsuccessful, the court ordered that there be no order regarding the costs of the appeals against the apportionment of liability. The court dismissed the appeals by both Rivett and Arbor, as well as WMC, and ordered that the appellants pay the respondents' costs of appeal as between party and party. There was no order as to the costs of the appeal as between Rivett and Arbor as appellants and WMC as respondent. The judges agreed with the proposed orders and the reasoning provided by the Chief Justice.
Background
Background to the litigation
Initially, Conor Evans contested the claims made by Rivett and Arbor, resulting in a trial where the primary judge apportioned liability between the defendants. The apportionment determined that Conor Evans was liable for part of the claimed damages and unpaid hire charges, while WMC Materials was also found liable for a portion. Dissatisfied with the apportionment of liability, Rivett and Arbor appealed against the decision, arguing that they should bear no liability. WMC Materials, on the other hand, cross-appealed, contending that it should not be held liable at all.
During the appeal process, WMC Materials made a letter of offer to Rivett and Arbor, proposing that they accept the apportionment of liability as determined by the primary judge. However, Rivett and Arbor declined the offer and continued with their appeal. The appeals were ultimately unsuccessful, with the appellate court dismissing both Rivett and Arbor's appeal against the apportionment of liability and WMC Materials' cross-appeal. Following the dismissal of the appeals, the respondents, Conor Evans and Christopher Evans, sought an order that the unsuccessful appellants pay the costs of the appeal on a solicitor-client basis. WMC Materials, as a third respondent and cross-appellant, applied for specific orders regarding the costs, requesting that either Rivett and Arbor alone pay the costs of the appeal or indemnify WMC Materials for the costs incurred by the appellants, or alternatively, that WMC Materials' costs of the appeal be paid by Rivett and Arbor on a party and party basis.
The matter before the court was a second appeal concerning an apportionment of liability in a dispute between the appellants, Rivett Arboricultural & Waste Equipment Hire Pty Ltd and Arboricultural Services (Aust) Pty Ltd, and the respondents, Conor Patrick Evans and Christopher Evans. The case originated from a decision made by the Supreme Court of Western Australia, which had been appealed to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal had dismissed the initial appeal brought by the appellants, and this dismissal was the subject of the current appeal. The third respondent and cross-appellant, WMC, had made a letter of offer to the appellants, which they declined. Following the dismissal of the appeal by the appellants, the respondents applied for an order that the unsuccessful appellants pay the costs of the appeal on a solicitor-client basis. WMC further sought orders that the appellants either pay the costs of the appeal alone, indemnify WMC for the costs incurred by the appellants, or pay WMC's costs of the appeal on a party-and-party basis. The court considered the circumstances of the case, including the unsuccessful nature of the appeals against the apportionment of liability, and found that the appellants did not act unreasonably in pursuing their appeals. The court ruled that there would be no order as to the costs of the appeals against the apportionment of liability. Consequently, the court ordered that the appeals be dismissed and that the appellants pay the respondents' costs of the appeal on a party-and-party basis, while there would be no order as to the costs of the appeal between the appellants and WMC.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application by the respondents for an order that the unsuccessful appellants, Rivett Arboricultural & Waste Equipment Hire Pty Ltd and Arboricultural Services Pty Ltd, pay the respondents' costs of appeal on a solicitor-client basis. The court determined that the unsuccessful appellants should pay the respondents' costs on a party and party basis, following the general rule that the unsuccessful party pays the successful party's costs of appeal. The court reasoned that the unsuccessful appellants' actions in appealing against the apportionment of liability and persisting with the appeal despite the offer by WMC were not unreasonable in the circumstances. Therefore, the unsuccessful appellants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs of appeal as between party and party.
The third respondent/cross-appellant, WMC, argued that the first and second appellants should either pay WMC's costs of appeal from the appeal alone, indemnify WMC for the costs incurred by the appellants, or pay WMC's costs of appeal on a party and party basis. The court rejected the application for the first and second appellants to pay WMC's costs of appeal from the appeal alone or to indemnify WMC for the costs incurred by the appellants. The court held that the departure from the general rule of costs following an unsuccessful appeal was unwarranted in this case. The court further held that the unsuccessful appellants should pay the respondents' costs of appeal on a party and party basis, as previously determined. The court did not order the unsuccessful appellants to indemnify WMC for the costs incurred by the appellants or to pay WMC's costs of appeal from the appeal alone.
The court concluded that the unsuccessful appellants did not act unreasonably in appealing against the apportionment of liability and persisting with the appeal despite the offer made by WMC. The court determined that the appeals against the apportionment of liability were unsuccessful, and therefore, there should be no order as to the costs of the appeals against the apportionment of liability. The court held that the unsuccessful appellants should pay the respondents' costs of appeal on a party and party basis, while there should be no order as to the costs of the appeals against the apportionment of liability.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the unsuccessful appellants should pay the respondents' costs of appeal on a party and party basis, and there should be no order as to the costs of the appeals against the apportionment of liability when the appeals are unsuccessful and the unsuccessful appellants' actions in appealing and persisting with the appeal were not unreasonable in the circumstances. The court did not depart from prior authority on the general rule of costs following an unsuccessful appeal, but rather applied the rule to the specific circumstances of this case.