Rip Curl International Pty Ltd v Phone Lab Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Rip Curl International Pty Ltd v Phone Lab Pty Ltd [2004] FCA 1215

CONTEMPT – penalty – contempt admitted to be wilful and contumacious – discretion of Court to impose penalties – suspended prison terms imposed

Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) s 134

Federal Court Rules Order 37 r 2(1), r 2(3), r 6

Adlam v Noack [1999] FCA 1606 applied
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v World Netsafe Pty Ltd (2003) 204 ALR 537 cited
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Hughes (2001) ATPR 41-807; [2001] FCA 38 cited
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Australian Taxation Information Services Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1607 cited
Australian Investments & Securities Commission v Eagle Inter-Link Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 1524 cited
Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Matthews (1999) 32 ACSR 404 applied
Australasian Meat Industry Employees’ Union v Mudginberri Station Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 98 applied
BHP Steel (AIS) Pty Ltd v Construction Forestry Mining & Energy Union [2001] FCA 336
Deputy Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Hickey (1999) 99 ATC 5124; [1999] FCA 259 cited
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Uysal [2004] VSC 278 cited
Witham v Holloway (1995) 183 CLR 525 followed
Sony Computer Entertainment Australia v Dannoun [2000] FCA 1634 cited
Sony Computer Entertainment Australia Pty Ltd v Johnston [2001] FCA 912 cited

RIP CURL INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD & ORS v PHONE LAB PTY LTD & ORS
V 394 OF 2004

HELY J
17 SEPTEMBER 2004
SYDNEY (HEARD IN MELBOURNE)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 394 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

RIP CURL INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD
(ACN 006 129 746)
FIRST APPLICANT

MAMBO GRAPHICS PTY LTD
(ACN 002 678 306)
SECOND APPLICANT

AUSTRALIAN RUGBY UNION LIMITED
(ACN 002 898 544)
THIRD APPLICANT

NOKIA CORPORATION
FOURTH APPLICANT

AND:

PHONE LAB PTY LTD
(ACN 091 378 648)
FIRST RESPONDENT

ANDREW CHENG
SECOND RESPONDENT

JEFF WANG
THIRD RESPONDENT

JOAN PHOI MAN VONG TRADING AS D G TEL
FOURTH RESPONDENT

GEORGE DIB
FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

HELY J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 SEPTEMBER 2004

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (HEARD IN MELBOURNE)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        The first respondent pay the sum of $38,500.00 by way of penalty for the contempts of Court on the part of the first respondent specified in par 56 of these reasons, such sum to be paid on or before 28 October 2004 to the District Registrar, New South Wales Registry, Federal Court of Australia.

2.        The third respondent pay the sum of $5,000.00 by way of penalty for the contempt of Court on the part of the third respondent specified in par 58(f) of these reasons, such sum to be paid on or before 28 October 2004 to the District Registrar, New South Wales Registry, Federal Court of Australia.

3.(i)        A warrant addressed to the Governor, Metropolitan Remand and Reception Facilities, issue for the committal of the second respondent to a prison in New South Wales for a period of one month.  Such committal is for contempt of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rip Curl International Pty Ltd v Phone Lab Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] FCA 1215
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rip Curl International Pty Ltd v Phone Lab Pty Ltd involved the first, second and fourth applicants, who are the registered owners of various trademarks, against the first, second and third respondents, who were found to be in contempt of court for breaching orders made by Sundberg J. The dispute arose from the sale of counterfeit goods bearing the trademarks of the applicants by the respondents, despite having been warned and ordered to cease such activities. The applicants sought relief in the form of penalties and costs against the respondents for their contemptuous conduct.

The legal issues before the court were whether the respondents had indeed breached the orders made by Sundberg J and if so, what penalties and costs should be imposed. The respondents admitted to selling goods bearing the applicants' trademarks despite the orders, and therefore, the court had to determine the appropriate sanctions for their contemptuous conduct.

In its decision, the court found that the respondents had indeed breached the orders and were in contempt of court. The court awarded costs to the applicants on a more generous basis than party and party costs, with the exception of the costs for the second day of the hearing. The court also imposed specific penalties on the respondents, including fines and committal to prison, subject to certain conditions.

In conclusion, the court found the first respondent guilty of contempt for breaching the orders made by Sundberg J, and imposed a penalty and ordered the payment of costs. The third respondent was also found guilty of contempt for specific breaches and was ordered to pay a penalty and costs. The second and third respondents were further ordered to be committed to prison for one month each, subject to conditions. The costs of the proceedings were to be taxed and paid forthwith, with the exception of the costs for the second day of the hearing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first respondent pay the sum of $38,500.00 by way of penalty for the contempts of Court on the part of the first respondent specified in par 56 of these reasons, such sum to be paid on or before 28 October 2004 to the District Registrar, New South Wales Registry, Federal Court of Australia.

2. The third respondent pay the sum of $5,000.00 by way of penalty for the contempt of Court on the part of the third respondent specified in par 58(f) of these reasons, such sum to be paid on or before 28 October 2004 to the District Registrar, New South Wales Registry, Federal Court of Australia.

3. (i) A warrant addressed to the Governor, Metropolitan Remand and Reception Facilities, issue for the committal of the second respondent to a prison in New South Wales for a period of one month. Such committal is for contempt of Court in that the second respondent is in contempt of Court in the manner specified in par 57 of these reasons for decision; and

(ii) The warrant lie in the Registry to the intent that it not be executed provided that the second respondent refrains from contravening any of the orders made by Sundberg J on 15 June 2004 for a period of 12 months from today’s date.

4. (i) A warrant addressed to the Governor, Metropolitan Remand and Reception Facilities, issue for the committal of the third respondent to a prison in New South Wales for a period of one month. Such committal is for contempt of Court in that the third respondent is in contempt of Court in the manner specified in par 58(c) – (i) and (k) of these reasons for decision; and

(ii) the warrant lie in the Registry to the intent that it not be executed provided that the third respondent refrains from contravening any of the orders made by Sundberg J on 15 June 2004 for a period of 12 months from today’s date.

5. The first, second and third respondents pay the costs, including reserved costs, of the first, second and fourth applicants of and incidental to the application by Notice of Motion filed on 16 July 2004 for contempt, such costs to be taxed on the basis that the costs include all costs except insofar as they are of an unreasonable amount or unreasonably incurred so that, subject to such exceptions, and to the qualification hereafter appearing, each of the applicants is completely indemnified by the respondents for their costs. This order is subject to the qualification that it does not include the costs of the second day’s hearing on 24 August 2004.

6. The costs the subject of these orders be taxed forthwith, and upon being taxed, be paid forthwith.

Background

Background to the litigation

One of the second respondent’s main tasks is to supervise the stalls at Paddy’s Haymarket, whereas the third respondent principally supervises Phone Lab’s stalls at the Parklea Markets and the Flemington Markets. Background In September 2002 the Australian Customs Service gave notices to Nokia Australia pursuant to subs 134(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) in relation to the seizure of certain goods bearing what appeared to be Nokia trade marks. The designated owners of the goods were either Phone Lab, or the second respondent. Phone Lab and the second respondent consented to the forfeiture of those goods, and on 2 October 2002 Phone Lab wrote to Trade Mark Investigation Services stating:‘We have ceased all trade in counterfeit Nokia accessories in our shop and market stalls. Since October 2001 we have been notified that they are counterfeit accessories, this stock has been returned to local suppliers.’On 11 October 2002 a Deed of Undertaking was signed by the second respondent undertaking that he would cease ‘infringing the intellectual property rights of which Nokia Corporation is the registered owner’. On 30 August 2003 an employee of Trade Mark Investigation Services, Themis Pappas, observed phone covers bearing the trade marks Rip Curl, Mambo and Nokia respectively being displayed for sale at a stall in Parklea Markets operated by Phone Lab. Warning documents were served on the second respondent. The documents related to each of the Rip Curl, Mambo and Nokia trade marks. The warning documents warned the person to whom they were delivered that he or she was selling infringing goods, and made various demands in relation to the goods. The recipient was also warned that failure to comply with the demands in the document could result in legal action being taken. On 24 October 2003 a packing list shows that Phone Lab received phone covers with what appeared to be the Mambo and Rip Curl trade marks which had been supplied by a person by the name of Henry Hong. On 11 November 2003 Phone Lab received some batteries branded with what appeared to be the Nokia trade mark which had apparently been sold to it by a company called Accessories Australia Pty Ltd. On 15 November 2003 an officer of Trade Mark Investigation Services, Mr Taylor, observed numerous phone covers bearing the Mambo and Rip Curl trademarks being displayed at Phone Lab’s stalls in Paddy’s Haymarket. On that occasion he handed a further set of the warning documents referred to above to one of the attendants operating the stall. On 22 November 2003 he returned to one of the Paddy’s Haymarket stalls. He again observed numerous phone covers bearing both the Rip Curl and Mambo trade marks being displayed and offered for sale, and he again handed a set of the warning documents to one of the attendants working at the stall. On 26 March 2004 these proceedings were instituted. On 2 April 2004 Mr Jason Li, solicitor, received instructions from Phone Lab, and from the second and third respondents, admitting that they had infringed the trade marks of the first, second and third applicants ‘albeit unintentionally’. Thereafter correspondence ensued with the solicitor for the first, second and fourth applicants, Corrs Chambers Westgarth (‘Corrs’), which culminated in orders being made by consent by Sundberg J on 15 June 2004 (‘the June orders’). The Further Amended Statement of Charge is with respect to breaches of those orders. The orders were served on Phone Lab on 25 June 2004, upon the second respondent on 28 June 2004 and on the third respondent at 1.03 pm on 3 July 2004. Service on the third respondent was delayed because he had gone overseas on 21 June 2004, and only returned to Australia on 2 July 2004.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

HELY J
In those circumstances, costs should be awarded to the applicants on a more generous basis than party and party costs. This is particularly so because pecuniary penalties have not been imposed on the second and third respondents, except in relation to the third respondent on charge 6(a). There is one qualification to that proposition, and that arises out of the fact that the hearing of the contempt proceedings extended over two days. At the end of the two day hearing the applicants had not materially advanced their case beyond the admissions inherent in the guilty pleas. Two hearing days were consumed in the hearing of the motion, rather than one, because the applicants unsuccessfully attempted to advance their case beyond the admissions. I propose to make orders as sought by the applicants, with the qualification that the applicants are not to receive the costs of the second hearing day.Conclusions I hold that the first respondent is guilty of contempt of this Court by its conduct in disobeying orders made by Sundberg J on 15 June 2004 in that the first respondent knowing of those orders, and in wilful and contumacious disregard for those orders:(a)on or about 20 June 2004 sold a mobile phone cover bearing the Rip Curl trade mark, which trade mark was not applied to the phone cover with or under the licence or authority of the first applicant as alleged in par 2(a) of the Further Amended Statement of Charge (‘the Charge’);(b)on or about 20 June 2004 sold a mobile phone cover bearing the Rip Curl trade mark, which trade mark was not applied to that phone cover with or under the licence or authority of the first applicant as alleged in par 2(b) of the Charge;(c)on or about 4 July 2004 sold a mobile phone cover bearing the Rip Curl trade mark, which trade mark was not applied to that phone cover with or under the licence or authority of the first applicant as alleged in par 2(c) of the Charge;(d)on or about 4 July 2004 sold a mobile phone cover bearing the Rip Curl trade mark, which trade mark was not applied to that phone cover with or under the licence or authority of the first applicant as alleged in par 2(d) of the Charge;(e)as at 16 July 2004 had not:(i)delivered up any goods of to the first applicant bearing the Rip Curl trade mark, as required by par 3 of the June orders, and(ii)made discovery, verified by affidavit to the first applicant, in respect of all purchases and sales of all items bearing the Rip Curl trade mark as required by par 6 of the June orders,as alleged in pars 3(a) and (b) of the Charge;(f)on or about 3 July 2004, sold six mobile phone covers bearing the Mambo trade mark, which trade mark was not applied to that phone cover with or under the licence or authority of the second applicant as alleged in par 6(a) of the Charge;(g)on or about 4 July 2004, sold a mobile phone cover bearing the Mambo trade mark, which trade mark was not applied to that phone cover with or under the licence or authority of the second applicant as alleged in par 6(b) of the Charge;(h)on or about 4 July 2004, sold a mobile phone cover bearing the Mambo trade mark, which trade mark was not applied to that phone cover with or under the licence or authority of the second applicant as alleged in par 6(c) of the Charge;(i)as at 16 July 2004 had not:(i)delivered up any goods to the second applicant bearing the Mambo trade mark as required by par 10 of the June orders, and(ii)made discovery, verified by affidavit, to the second applicant in respect of all purchases and sales of all items bearing the Mambo trade mark, as required by par 13 of the June orders,as alleged in pars 7(a) and (b) of the Charge;(j)on or about 20 June 2004 sold a mobile phone cover and on about 24 July 2004 sold a mobile phone cover and a mobile phone battery, bearing one or more of the Nokia trade marks, which trade marks were not applied to those phone covers and that mobile phone battery with or under the licence or authority of the fourth applicant as alleged in par 10(i) and 10(iii) of the Charge;(k)as at 30 July 2004 had not:(i)delivered up any goods to the fourth applicant bearing the Nokia trade marks, as required by par 24 of the June orders; and(ii)made discovery, verified by affidavit to the fourth applicant in respect of all purchases and sales of all items bearing the Nokia trade marks as required by par 28 of the June orders,as alleged in pars 11(a) and (b) of the Charge.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HELY J

Full text does not contain this section.