Rigg and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

Rigg and Comcare (Compensation) [2015] AATA 781 (8 October 2015)

Division

General Division

File Number(s)

2014/4950, 2014/5542

Re

Joanne Rigg

APPLICANT

And

COMCARE

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Dr Ion Alexander, Member

Date 8 October 2015
Place Sydney

The reviewable decision dated 1 August 2014 and subject of application 2014/4950 is affirmed.

The reviewable decision dated 14 October 2014 and subject of application 2014/5542 is set aside and remitted to the Respondent for reassessment in accordance with the reasons of the Tribunal.

A decision on the matter of costs in relation to application 2014/5542  is reserved. The parties have 14 days from the date of this decision to advise the Tribunal if they wish to make submissions. If they do not, the Tribunal will make an order pursuant to s 67(8) of the SRC Act.

.......................................................................

Dr Ion Alexander, Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – carpal tunnel syndrome – cervical intervertebral disc displacement   – applicant claims injuries a result of workload – applicant claims aggravation of existing undiagnosed condition – whether injury related to employment –  whether respondent liable to compensate applicant – decision under review in respect of carpal tunnel syndrome affirmed – decision under review in respect of cervical invertebral disc displacement set aside and remitted

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 14, 67

CASES

Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey [2001] FCA 266

Commonwealth of Australia v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369

Secondary Materials

REASONS FOR DECISION

Dr Ion Alexander, Member

8 October 2015

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Rigg commenced work as Customer Service Officer (CSO) with the Department of Human Services (DHS) in 2001.

  2. On 13 March 2014 Ms Rigg first claimed compensation for “carpal tunnel syndrome” (CTS). In a reviewable decision dated 1 August 2014 a review officer affirmed an earlier decision which determined that Comcare, the Respondent, is not liable to pay compensation pursuant to s 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988(Cth) ( the SRC Act). (application 2014/4950.)

  3. At the hearing Counsel for Ms Rigg submitted she accepts that the decision subject of application 2014/4950 should be affirmed.

  4. On the 4 August 2014 she lodged a second compensation claim for “cervical intervertebral disc displacement (C5/6, C4/5).” In a reviewable decision dated 14 October 2014 a review officer affirmed an earlier decision which determined that Comcare was not liable to pay compensation pursuant to s14 of the SRC Act. (application 2014/5542.)

  5. In these proceedings Ms Rigg seeks review of the reviewable decision of 14 October 2014 and seeks compensation for injury caused by her employment.

    ISSUES

  6. Ms Rigg submits that in November/December 2013 and February 2014 she experienced symptoms in her right hand and arm while performing her duties as a Customer Service Officer (CSO). She attributes the onset of these symptoms to a significant increase in her workload which began in November 2013 and claims that her employment has contributed to an aggravation of an underlying degenerative cervical spine condition that was previously undiagnosed.

  7. Compensation is payable pursuant to the provisions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rigg and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 781
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Rigg and Comcare (Compensation), the applicant, Ms Rigg, sought compensation from Comcare for injuries she claimed were a result of her employment, specifically increased workload. Ms Rigg argued that her employment contributed significantly to her cervical spondylosis and that her symptoms were aggravated by her employment. The central legal issues revolved around whether Ms Rigg's employment contributed to her cervical spondylosis or caused an aggravation of her pre-existing condition. The case was reviewed under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth).

The court examined the evidence and testimonies provided by Ms Rigg and medical experts. Ms Rigg's evidence indicated that she experienced symptoms of numbness, tingling, and pain in her hands and arms, which she attributed to her work duties. Medical evidence, however, suggested that Ms Rigg's cervical spondylosis was likely asymptomatic for several years and unrelated to her employment. Professor McGill, a medical expert, opined that Ms Rigg's work duties did not contribute to her underlying cervical spondylosis or to any aggravation of the condition.

The court concluded that Ms Rigg's cervical spondylosis was a constitutional condition unrelated to her employment. There was no evidence that the increased workload caused an aggravation of her underlying cervical spondylosis. However, the court found that Ms Rigg's symptoms in the right upper limb in February 2014 were severe enough to require medical intervention and caused some incapacity for work, likely due to an irritation of the C6 spinal nerve. The court considered whether symptoms brought on by work activity could be considered an aggravation of a pre-existing condition without pathological change, guided by the authority in Commonwealth of Australia v Beattie. The court held that pain brought on by work activity could constitute an aggravation of a pre-existing injury, even without pathological change.

The decision affirmed the review in respect of the carpal tunnel syndrome but set aside the review in respect of the cervical intervertebral disc displacement and remitted the matter for further consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, the definitive issues are as follows:(a)has Ms Rigg’s employment contributed, to significant degree, to her cervical spondylosis; or (b)has Ms Rigg suffered an aggravation of her cervical spondylosis, that was contributed to, to a significant degree, by her employment?EVIDENCEMs Rigg’s Evidence Ms Rigg provided the Tribunal with a written statement dated the 1 July 2015 which is summarised as follows:·On 9 January 2001 she commenced work with DHS Wagga as a customer service officer (CSO). Her main duty was processing new claims which involved data entry and management using a keyboard, computer mouse and dual monitors.·At the age of 9 years Ms Rigg had an operation on the right eye which left her with almost no vision in that eye.·On 4 November 2013 Ms Rigg was assigned to an Integrated Work Management (IWM) team so that the number of claims she was required to process increased from approximately 10 to 12 per day to 20 to 36 per day.·On or about 15 November 2013 Ms Rigg began to experience “persistent numbness, tingling pain, pins and needles” in her right hand and arm but continued to work.·On 23 December 2013 Ms Rigg went on recreational leave for four weeks during which her symptoms “gradually subsided.”·On 20 January 2014 Ms Rigg returned to work in the IWM team. Within approximately one week the symptoms in her right hand and arm recurred and she also had pain in her neck.·On 6 February 2014 her symptoms had increased so that she reported them to her team leader and attended her GP, Dr Sedrak, who diagnosed carpal tunnel syndrome.·On 7 February 2014 Ms Rigg was transferred out of the IWT team and assigned different duties.·On the 19 February 2014, in accordance with advice from an Occupational Therapist, Ms Rigg began using a mouse in her left hand. After one week she began to have symptoms in her left hand and arm.·On 3 April 2014 Ms Rigg’s symptoms had become so “unbearable” that her GP certified her unfit for work until 14 April 2014.·On the 14 April 2014 Ms Rigg returned to work on a gradual Return to work (RTW) plan with restricted hours and duties.·On the 5 June 2014 Dr Ow-Yang, Neurosurgeon, diagnosed cervical spine pathology which Ms Rigg described as “a disc protrusion and nerve compression in my neck.”·On the 23 June 2014 Ms Rigg returned to full time hours with restricted duties ·On 25 June 2014 a “CT guided right C6 peri-radicular injection” was performed with some relief of symptoms for about one month.·Current symptoms are described as “pins and needles in my right and left hands, numbness in my right and left hands, intermittent sharp pains in my right and left arms, aching in my right and left arms and pain on the right side of my neck, which increases every time I turn my head.” At the hearing Ms Rigg described the symptoms she experienced in November/December 2013 as “tingling, numbness, pain up the arm into my neck and, again, with the left hand but it was nowhere near as the right hand…[it] was also in my hand as well and it was in all fingers …same in all fingers.” She said that at home at night when she finished work she got a “bit of relief” but when she was on four weeks holiday “I had nothing. It all went. Had no pain whatsoever.” Despite her symptoms she explained that she did not reduce the number of claims she was processing and “just kept going.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

In his oral evidence Professor McGill confirmed his fairly strong opinion that Ms Rigg’s work duties did not contribute to her underlying cervical spondylosis or to any aggravation of the condition including her right arm symptoms.CONCLUSION The evaluation of the evidence in this matter, in my view, has been complicated by a number of factors including the early confusion as to the correct diagnosis, the inconsistencies in Ms Rigg’s self-report of symptoms to the various healthcare practitioners and to the Tribunal, the somewhat atypical nature of Ms Rigg’s symptoms when compared with the identified pathology and her relatively early return to full-time work albeit with a modified workplace and a change in duties. Nevertheless I have reached the following conclusions. I am satisfied that Ms Rigg suffers from a degenerative cervical spine condition, namely, cervical spondylosis, and that the weight of the medical evidence establishes that this condition was likely to have been present, albeit asymptomatic, for several years and is a constitutional condition unrelated to Ms Rigg’s employment. I am satisfied that there is no evidence that the relatively brief period of increased workload described by Ms Rigg caused an aggravation of her underlying cervical spondylosis in the form of pathological change. There is no dispute that Ms Rigg suffered symptoms including pain in the course of her work. The cause of her symptoms In November/December 2013 is, in my view, unclear and may have been associated with her cervical spondylosis. Notwithstanding Ms Rigg’s submissions these symptoms appear to have been relatively trivial in that she did not report them, they did not cause any incapacity for work and resolved fairly quickly when she went on leave. In February 2014 in the course of her work, Ms Rigg suffered symptoms in the right upper limb which were severe enough to require medical intervention and cause some incapacity for work. I am satisfied that the medical evidence suggests that, consistent with the identified pathology at the C5/6 foramen, her symptoms in the right upper limb at that time can be attributed to an irritation of the C6 spinal nerve. This raises the question whether, for the purposes of the SRC Act, symptoms brought on by work activity can be considered an aggravation of a pre-existing condition without evidence of pathological change. In consideration of this question I am guided by the following authorities: In Commonwealth of Australia v Beattie (1981) 35 ALR 369 Evatt and Sheppard JJ considered the meaning of the word “aggravation” in the context of the SRC Act, where a claimant had pre-existing non-compensable injury. Their honours stated with Kelly J agreeing as follows at 378: there can be cases where there will be an exacerbation, and thus in our view an aggravation, of a previously existing injury by activity which increases or precipitates pain.It does not follow in every case that a worker with a pre-existing injury, who carries out work and as a result suffers pain, will have suffered an aggravation of his injury. A worker whose fractured leg is encased in plaster will be unable to put it to the ground without suffering pain and other disability. But that is not a case of aggravation. In such a case any incapacity for work arises only by reason of the pre-existing injury. The evidence earlier recounted shows this to be a very different type of case. Thus each case must depend upon its own facts. For present purposes it is enough to say that pain brought on by work activity may constitute an aggravation of a pre-existing injury, even though no pathological change takes place.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.