Riccardo Vittiglia and John Holland Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 89 min read

[2012] AATA 212

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2011/2709

Re

Riccardo Vittiglia

APPLICANT

And

John Holland Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S D Hotop
Dr J Chaney, Member

Date 13 April 2012
Place Perth

The decision under review is set aside and, in substitution therefor, it is decided that, pursuant to s 14(1) and Part VIII of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), the respondent is liable to pay compensation, in accordance with that Act, to the applicant in respect of a mental injury, namely, aggravation of depressive/anxiety condition, suffered by him on 29 March 2011.

Application may be made to the Tribunal in relation to the costs of these proceedings within 14 days of the date of this decision. In the event that no such application is made by that date, the Tribunal orders, pursuant to s 67(8) of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), that the costs of these proceedings incurred by the applicant be paid by the respondent in accordance with Section 6.8 of the Tribunal’s Guide to the Workers’ Compensation Jurisdiction.

.................[sgd]..............................

S D Hotop

Deputy President

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – employee of licensed corporation – applicant suffered from depression/anxiety from 2003 – applicant suffered aggravation of depression/anxiety condition at workplace in March 2011 – aggravation of mental ailment – aggravation of mental ailment contributed to, to a significant degree, by applicant’s employment by respondent – aggravation of mental ailment a disease – aggravation of mental ailment an injury – respondent liable to pay compensation to applicant in respect of aggravation of depressive/anxiety condition – decision under review set aside

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), s4(1), s5A, s5B, s7(4) and s14(1)

CASES

Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President S D Hotop
Dr J Chaney, member

13 April 2012

Introduction

  1. Riccardo Vittiglia (“the applicant”), who was born in August 1964, has been employed by John Holland Pty Ltd (“the respondent”) as a Trades Assistant from 8 December 2010.

  2. On or about 20 May 2011 the applicant made a claim for compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“SRC Act”) in respect of a mental condition which he claimed was related to an incident which occurred at his workplace on 29 March 2011.

  3. On 23 June 2011 an officer of the respondent made a “determination” that the respondent was not liable under s 14 of the SRC Act to pay compensation to the applicant in respect of “Major Depressive Illness”.

  4. On 4 July 2011 an officer of the respondent made a “reviewable decision” under s 62 of the SRC Act affirming the determination of 23 June 2011.

  5. On 11 July 2011 the applicant lodged with the Tribunal an application for review of the reviewable decision of 4 July 2011.

    The Evidence

  6. The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:

    ·the “T Documents” (T1-T20, pp 1-89) lodged by the respondent, in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Riccardo Vittiglia and John Holland Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 212
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Riccardo Vittiglia and John Holland Pty Ltd was heard by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. Vittiglia, an employee of John Holland Pty Ltd, sought compensation for an aggravation of his pre-existing mental condition, which included depression and anxiety, that occurred in March 2011. The primary issue before the Tribunal was whether the respondent was liable to compensate Vittiglia for the mental injury he sustained, and whether this injury constituted an aggravation of a pre-existing condition that arose out of and in the course of his employment. The Tribunal was also required to determine if the aggravation of the mental condition met the criteria for being considered an injury under the applicable legislation.

The Tribunal found that Vittiglia's pre-existing mental condition was aggravated by his employment with John Holland Pty Ltd, specifically by an incident on 29 March 2011. The evidence demonstrated that Vittiglia suffered from a panic attack following the incident, which was corroborated by medical reports and witness testimonies. The Tribunal concluded that the aggravation of Vittiglia's mental condition was a disease that arose out of and in the course of his employment, thus qualifying as an injury under the relevant statute. The Tribunal set aside the decision that denied Vittiglia's claim and ruled in his favour, finding the respondent liable for compensation.

The Tribunal's decision established that John Holland Pty Ltd must compensate Riccardo Vittiglia for the mental injury he suffered, specifically the aggravation of his depressive/anxiety condition, on 29 March 2011. The decision was based on the clear evidence that the incident at work significantly contributed to the exacerbation of Vittiglia's pre-existing mental health issues.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1-T20, pp 1-89) lodged by the respondent, in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), on 3 August 2011;·Exhibits A1-A4 tendered by the applicant;·Exhibits R1-R12 tendered by the respondent;·the oral evidence of the applicant and of the following witnesses:−Dr Ernst de Jong and Dr Iryna Oleshko (who were called by the applicant); and−Dr Anthony Mander, Darren McCamish, Stuart McQueen and Ryan Carrington (who were called by the respondent).The Factual Background On 24 November 2010 the applicant completed a Pre-Employment Health Assessment questionnaire in which he indicated that (inter alia):·he had previously been referred to a psychologist/psychiatrist;·he had been diagnosed with depression five years previously (“due to family tragedy”) and also suffers from related anxiety, and continues to take anti-depressant medication;·he had also been diagnosed with “Adult ADHD” soon after the depression diagnosis, and takes medication for that condition. (T6) In a letter dated 26 November 2010 Dr Ernst de Jong, Psychiatrist, confirmed that the applicant was under his care and had been treated for “Depression and ADHD” and was taking Cymbalta, Dexamphetamine and Diazepam, and that he had last seen him on 12 November 2010. (T5) On 30 November 2010 Dr Tim Drew assessed the applicant and determined that he was suitable for the position of Trades Assistant with the respondent “without restriction”. (T7) In an Incident Investigation Report, dated 29 March 2011, regarding an incident which occurred at a worksite of the respondent on that date, that incident is described as follows:“ The supervisor asked the [applicant] to get a drill from the stores. When he arrived back he had no drill bits with the tool. He was asked to get out the way of the sparks that were coming off the grinder. When he said to the supervisor why because I have my mono goggles on and the sparks will not get in. The supervisor said if he were to poke him in the eye with his drill bit his mono goggles would be ineffective.” (sic)The “immediate actions taken” are described as follows:“ Riccardo was taken to the Psychologist by M James. He was visibly shaking and not making any sense. The psych said he had a Panic attack. His doctor wrote a certificate which stated fit for restricted duties from the 29th March.” (T9, p 37) A handwritten statement of the applicant, dated 29 March 2011, is as follows:“ I was asked by Man Poon to get a drill from stores, and when I got back Macca said to me to be careful of my eyes, which confused me. I had all my PPE on and James was grinding on the side but there were no sparks that I could see where Macca and I were standing so I asked what he meant by that. Macca said ‘I wouldn’t want you to get hurt or anything, which again confused me so I said again what do you mean there’s nothing going on. Macca said ‘you’d better be careful around here because some cunt might want to drill your eye out and skull fuck you. While he was saying that he was very close and poking his finger into my mono’s. Again I asked what are you talking about and Macca replied, that I’d better be careful around here because someone might just want to do that to me. He seemed aggressive towards me and was not joking which really upset me. He told me to go and get drill bits from the store so I did but on the way there I couldn’t stop thinking about it, I couldn’t understand why he threatened me like that. When I got back I asked Macca again why he said that to me, and he sarcastically said, I’m just trying to look after you which felt like another threat, so I said I’m going to see Stu. Stu wasn’t in his office so I rang him but he didn’t answer so I went and saw Jeremy Slater”. (sic) (T10)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 11 July 2011 the applicant lodged with the Tribunal an application for review of the reviewable decision of 4 July 2011.The Evidence The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1-T20, pp 1-89) lodged by the respondent, in accordance with s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), on 3 August 2011;·Exhibits A1-A4 tendered by the applicant;·Exhibits R1-R12 tendered by the respondent;·the oral evidence of the applicant and of the following witnesses:−Dr Ernst de Jong and Dr Iryna Oleshko (who were called by the applicant); and−Dr Anthony Mander, Darren McCamish, Stuart McQueen and Ryan Carrington (who were called by the respondent).The Factual Background On 24 November 2010 the applicant completed a Pre-Employment Health Assessment questionnaire in which he indicated that (inter alia):·he had previously been referred to a psychologist/psychiatrist;·he had been diagnosed with depression five years previously (“due to family tragedy”) and also suffers from related anxiety, and continues to take anti-depressant medication;·he had also been diagnosed with “Adult ADHD” soon after the depression diagnosis, and takes medication for that condition. (T6) In a letter dated 26 November 2010 Dr Ernst de Jong, Psychiatrist, confirmed that the applicant was under his care and had been treated for “Depression and ADHD” and was taking Cymbalta, Dexamphetamine and Diazepam, and that he had last seen him on 12 November 2010. (T5) On 30 November 2010 Dr Tim Drew assessed the applicant and determined that he was suitable for the position of Trades Assistant with the respondent “without restriction”. (T7) In an Incident Investigation Report, dated 29 March 2011, regarding an incident which occurred at a worksite of the respondent on that date, that incident is described as follows:“ The supervisor asked the [applicant] to get a drill from the stores. When he arrived back he had no drill bits with the tool. He was asked to get out the way of the sparks that were coming off the grinder. When he said to the supervisor why because I have my mono goggles on and the sparks will not get in. The supervisor said if he were to poke him in the eye with his drill bit his mono goggles would be ineffective.” (sic)The “immediate actions taken” are described as follows:“ Riccardo was taken to the Psychologist by M James. He was visibly shaking and not making any sense. The psych said he had a Panic attack. His doctor wrote a certificate which stated fit for restricted duties from the 29th March.” (T9, p 37) A handwritten statement of the applicant, dated 29 March 2011, is as follows:“ I was asked by Man Poon to get a drill from stores, and when I got back Macca said to me to be careful of my eyes, which confused me. I had all my PPE on and James was grinding on the side but there were no sparks that I could see where Macca and I were standing so I asked what he meant by that. Macca said ‘I wouldn’t want you to get hurt or anything, which again confused me so I said again what do you mean there’s nothing going on. Macca said ‘you’d better be careful around here because some cunt might want to drill your eye out and skull fuck you. While he was saying that he was very close and poking his finger into my mono’s. Again I asked what are you talking about and Macca replied, that I’d better be careful around here because someone might just want to do that to me. He seemed aggressive towards me and was not joking which really upset me. He told me to go and get drill bits from the store so I did but on the way there I couldn’t stop thinking about it, I couldn’t understand why he threatened me like that. When I got back I asked Macca again why he said that to me, and he sarcastically said, I’m just trying to look after you which felt like another threat, so I said I’m going to see Stu. Stu wasn’t in his office so I rang him but he didn’t answer so I went and saw Jeremy Slater”. (sic) (T10)

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal concludes, therefore, that, pursuant to s 14(1) and Part VIII of the SRC Act, the respondent is liable to pay compensation, in accordance with that Act, to the applicant in respect of a mental injury, namely, aggravation of depressive/anxiety condition, suffered by him on 29 March 2011.Decision For the above reasons, the Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and, in substitution therefor, decides that, pursuant to s 14(1) and Part VIII of the SRC Act, the respondent is liable to pay compensation, in accordance with that Act, to the applicant in respect of a mental injury, namely, aggravation of depressive/anxiety condition, suffered by him on 29 March 2011.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established