Riccardo Vittiglia and John Holland Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

[2013] AATA 493

Division General Administrative Division

File Number

2012/4894

Re

Riccardo Vittiglia

APPLICANT

And

John Holland Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President S D Hotop

Date 12 July 2013
Place Perth

The decision under review is affirmed.

.......................[sgd].................................................

S D Hotop

Deputy President

  1. Riccardo Vittiglia (“the applicant”), who is presently 48 years of age, was employed by John Holland Pty Ltd (“the respondent”) as a “Trades Assistant” from 8 December 2010 to 25 November 2011.

  2. On or about 20 May 2011 the applicant lodged with the respondent a form of claim for compensation, signed by him and dated 19 April 2011, under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (“SRC Act”) in respect of a mental condition which he claimed was related to an incident which occurred at his workplace on 29 March 2011. The applicant had earlier provided to the respondent a “Workers’ Compensation FIRST Medical Certificate”, issued by Dr Iryna Oleshko on 31 March 2011, which (inter alia):

    ·referred to the applicant’s account of having been “threatened and verbally assaulted” by a senior colleague at work on 29 March 2011;

    ·described the applicant’s presentation as “severely distressed, extremely anxious and depressed”; and

    ·certified that the applicant was totally unfit for work from 29 March 2011 to 5 April 2011.

    The applicant subsequently provided to the respondent various “Workers’ Compensation PROGRESS Medical Certificates”, issued by Dr Oleshko, regarding his incapacity for work in specified periods.

  3. On 13 April 2012 the Tribunal made a decision under s 43(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“AAT Act”) as follows:

    “ … pursuant to s 14(1) and Part VIII of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), the respondent is liable to pay compensation, in accordance with that Act, to the applicant in respect of a mental injury, namely, aggravation of depressive/anxiety condition, suffered by him on 29 March 2011” (see Re Vittiglia and John Holland Pty Ltd [2012] AATA 212).

  4. The respondent subsequently made determinations under s 19 of the SRC Act that it was liable to pay compensation to the applicant in accordance with that section for incapacity for work, resulting from the abovementioned mental injury, from 29 March 2011 to 25 June 2012.

  5. By letter dated 28 August 2012 an officer of the respondent informed the applicant that, on the basis of the medical information provided by him, it could not be determined that the respondent was liable to pay compensation to the applicant for incapacity for work from 26 June 2012.

  6. By letter dated 24 October 2012 an officer of the respondent informed the applicant that she had made a “reviewable decision” under s 62 of the SRC Act in the following terms:

    “ In accordance with the provisions of the SRC Act, I have decided to vary the determination dated 28 August 2012 to the extent that I have found that:

    You are not entitled to compensation for incapacity under section 19(3) of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Riccardo Vittiglia and John Holland Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] AATA 493
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Riccardo Vittiglia against John Holland Pty Ltd, the dispute involved the applicant's claim for compensation for incapacity to work following a compensable injury. The case was heard and decided by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant, Riccardo Vittiglia, was entitled to compensation for his incapacity for work from 26 June 2012 onwards, under Section 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the "SRC Act").

The Tribunal examined the evidence presented, including the applicant's qualifications, work history, and the nature of his injury and subsequent employment attempts. It considered the applicant's claim that he was unfit for work from 29 March 2011 to 16 February 2012, and his subsequent employment history, including positions with Dynea Australia and Protector Fire Services. The Tribunal also took into account the applicant's ongoing efforts to secure employment post-June 2012. The Tribunal concluded that the applicant's incapacity for work did not persist beyond 26 June 2012, and thus, the respondent was not liable to pay compensation for incapacity from that date onwards. The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, finding that the applicant was not entitled to compensation for the specified period.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence before the Tribunal comprised:·the “T Documents” (T1–T24, pp 1–280) lodged by the respondent in accordance with s 37 of the AAT Act;·Exhibits A1–A4 tendered by the applicant;·Exhibits R1 and R2 tendered by the respondent; and·the oral evidence of the applicant and of Dr Iryna Oleshko.The Applicant’s Evidence The applicant confirmed that he had signed a witness statement, dated 1 May 2013, for the purpose of this proceeding and that its contents are true and correct. The applicant’s witness statement is as follows:“ …2. I received an Achievement Certificate at Bunbury Senior High School.3. My qualifications are as follows:3.1 Certificate 2 in Process Plant Operations;3.2 Certificate 3 in Process Plant Operations;3.3 Process Control for Plant Operators;3.4 Confined Space Entry;3.5 Conduct Skid Steer Loader Operations BCCPO3008B (2005);3.6 Construction White Card (2010);3.7 Operate Overhead Crane MNMG236A (2005);3.8 Operate from Elevated Work Platforms MNCG1049A (2005);3.9 Trade Skills Training for Pendant Operated Overhead Crane (2004);3.10 OHS Certification Australia for Class WP, LF (2006);3.11 Forklift Operator Capacity 10T (2003);3.12 Zero Incident Process Training;3.13 Step Star Observer and Coach at Worsley Alumina;3.14 WASP Observer for John Holland Group;3.15 Western Power Induction to enable site entry and onsite work (2004);3.16Woodside Induction to enable site entry and onsite work and gas turbine maintenance for individual onsite work (2004);3.17Marcsta qualified (2004);3.18Fatigue Management;3.19Yellow Belt Business Excellence Six Sigma – Training in problem solving techniques;3.20Western Australia Police and CIB training concerning armed holdup situations; How to determine threatening situations;3.21Security Officer’s Licence (15 years +);3.22Firearm training.4.A brief summary of my work history and experience is as follows:4.1June 2012 to September 2012Protector Fire Services, Bunbury WAPosition: Fire Portables Technician4.2January 2012 to May 2012Dynea Australia, Dardanup WAPosition: Relief Operator and Assistant4.3November 2010 to November 2011John Holland Group, Worsley Efficiency and Growth ProjectPosition: Trades Assistant4.4November 2005 to September 2010BHP Billiton Worsley Alumina Pty Ltd, Collie WAPosition: Process Plant Operator4.5May 2003 to October 2005TGE Energy Services, Bunbury WAPosition: Trade Assistant 4.6October 2001 to May 2003Leschenault Security Services and Mayne Logistics – Armaguard, Bunbury WAPosition: Armed Guard4.7February 1991 to September 2001Mayne Logistics – Armaguard, Bunbury WAPosition: Armed Guard4.8August 1998 to February 2001Rose Hotel Bottle Shop, Bunbury WAPosition: Additional part-time employment as Bottle Shop Attendant/Customer Service4.9August 1989 to January 1991Nightguard Security, Bunbury WAPosition: Security Guard4.10August 1988 (whilst travelling around Australia)TNT Security – Strategic Response Group for the World Expo, BrisbanePosition: Security Guard4.11May 1985 to August 1987Karridale Liquor and General Store, KarridalePosition: Assistant Manager.5.I commenced my employment with John Holland Group in November [sic] 2010.6.My duties and responsibilities as a Trades Assistant with John Holland Group involved both assisting trades and duties in the store.7.I would ensure the equipment and work area was safe both for trades and myself to conduct the work task.8.Other duties included spotting for work groups, working from EWP and also traffic management.9.Working in the stores I had to keep check of all outgoing and incoming equipment, record all their movements and conduct safety checks on all the equipment as they were being returned.10.I am also a member of WASP (Worker Applied Safety Process) which involved doing safety observations on work groups on site.11.I received a letter dated 14 November from John Holland Group advising me that due to operational reasons, my role as Trades Assistant at the Worsley Efficiency & Growth Project was no longer required, and that they were unable to redeploy me.12.Consequently, I would be made redundant from my position at John Holland Group and my employment would terminate with effect at close of business 28 November 2011.13.I was certified as totally unfit for work from 29 March 2011 to 16 February 2012.14.I joined South West Personnel on or about 9 January 2012.15.South West Personnel is an employment agency which provides both permanent and temporary placements.16.South West Personnel placed me with Dynea Australia at Dardanup, WA, as a Relief Operator and Assistant on a temporary basis between January 2012 to May 2012.17.Although Dr Oleshko certified me as unfit until 16 February 2012, I accepted this position in the hope that I would be able to cope and also because of my financial obligations.18.My duties and responsibilities as a Relief Operator and Assistant involved the production of mining coagulant HX 200, HX 300, HX 600 and also Methoxide and the pesticide Determite, all of which include control room operation.19.My other duties included dispatch and inwards if [sic] goods, computer data entry, general contracting, yard work and also trade assisting onsite trade personnel.20.As a result of my applying directly, I gained employment with Protector Fire Services at Bunbury WA as a Fire Portables Technician.21.This employment was for the period between June 2012 to September 2012 when I resigned, as I was not coping.22.My duties as a Fire Portables Technician involved checking, maintaining, servicing and fitting of all fire safety devices to Australian standards throughout the South West and regional areas, and the reconditioning of fire extinguishers including pressure testing and refilling to Australian standards.23.In my role I also carried out all the relevant administrative duties.24.Further, since May 2012 I have applied continuously for jobs, with no success, and I list them below:

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, the Tribunal concludes that the respondent is not liable, pursuant to s 19 of the SRC Act, to pay compensation to the applicant for incapacity for work resulting from the compensable injury, in respect of the period from 26 June 2012 to the present date, and as at the present date.Decision For the above reasons, the decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established