Reynolds v Don Kyatt Spare Parts Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

CITATION:      Reynolds v Don Kyatt Spare Parts Pty Ltd [2013] NTMC 004

PARTIES:   KELLY REYNOLDS

v

DON KYATT SPARE PARTS PTY LTD

TITLE OF COURT:   WORK HEALTH

JURISDICTION:   Work Health

FILE NO(s):   21232333

DELIVERED ON:   11 March 2013

DELIVERED AT:   Darwin

HEARING DATE(s):   22 January 2013

JUDGMENT OF:   Dr John Allan Lowndes

CATCHWORDS:

WORK HEALTH – APPLICATION FOR MEDIATION AND VALIDITY OF SECTION 69 NOTICE OF DECISION – OTHER REASONABLE CAUSE FOR FAILURE TO SEEK MEDIATION

Workers Rehabilitation Compensation Act ss 69, 103D(1), (4) and (5) 

Tracy Village Sports and Social Clubs v Walker (1992) III FLR 32 applied

Van Dongen v NTA [2005] NTCA 6 applied

Murray v Baxter (1914) 18 CLR 622 applied

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Worker:   Mr Crawley

Employer:   Mr Liveris

Solicitors:

Worker:   NT Law

Employer:   Minter Ellison

Judgment category classification:         A

Judgment ID number:   [2013] NTMC 004

Number of paragraphs:   57

IN THE WORK HEALTH COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21232333

BETWEEN:

KELLY REYNOLDS
   Worker

AND:

DON KYATT SPARE PARTS PTY LTD

Employer

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 11 March 2013)

Dr John Allan Lowndes SM:

APPEAL FROM DECISION OF THE JUDICIAL REGISTRAR

  1. This is an appeal by the worker against the decision of the Judicial Registrar delivered on 6 December 2012. On that date the Judicial Registrar dismissed the worker’s application for an extension of time in which to apply for mediation of the dispute triggered by the employer’s Notice of Decision dated 16 August 2011.

  2. The worker seeks to set aside that order and to obtain an order that the time within which she may seek mediation of a dispute arising from the Notice of Decision of the employer dated 16 August 2012 be extended. The worker also seeks orders that the costs of an incidental to the application and hearing before the Judicial Registrar be costs in the cause in any substantive proceedings arising from the dispute, and that she have her costs of and incidental to the appeal.

  3. The appeal is brought pursuant to s 114A of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act and is by way of a hearing de novo: s 114A(3) of the Act.

  4. In support of her appeal the worker relies upon her affidavit sworn 7 November 2012 in support of the original application heard by the Judicial Registrar.

    THE PARTIES’ ARGUMENTS

  5. The worker’s primary position is that the Notice of Decision dated 16 August 2012 was invalid as the s 69(1)(b) statement received by the worker on 27 October 2012 did not comply with the requirements of s 69(1)(b) and (4) of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act ; and therefore was insufficient to constitute a statement under that section. The worker also contends that the medical certificate required to accompany the s 69(1)(b) statement did not comply with the requirements of s 69(3) of the Act. The worker argues that until such time as a proper and valid s 69(1)(b) statement – including the accompanying medical certificate - has been received the time…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reynolds v Don Kyatt Spare Parts Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NTMC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Reynolds v Don Kyatt Spare Parts Pty Ltd, the dispute centred on the validity of a Notice of Decision issued under the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act and whether the worker had reasonable cause for failing to seek mediation within the stipulated 90-day period. The case was heard by the court which was tasked with determining the validity of the Notice of Decision and whether there was reasonable cause for the delay in seeking mediation.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the Notice of Decision was valid and if it was, whether the worker had established reasonable cause for not seeking mediation within the required timeframe. The worker argued that the Notice of Decision was invalid, and therefore, the 90-day period for seeking mediation had not commenced. Conversely, the employer contended that the Notice of Decision was valid, and the 90-day period for mediation began on 27 October 2012. Additionally, the employer asserted that the worker had not provided reasonable cause for the delay in seeking mediation.

The court held that the validity of the Notice of Decision was not a prerequisite for the commencement of the 90-day mediation period. According to the court, the mediation process is designed to address disputes over compensation decisions, including the validity of notices. Therefore, the 90-day period for mediation commences upon receipt of a Notice of Decision, regardless of its validity. The court also concluded that the worker had not demonstrated reasonable cause for the delay in seeking mediation. Consequently, the court upheld the employer’s contention that the Notice of Decision was valid and rejected the worker's argument regarding the commencement of the mediation period.

In light of the court's findings, it dismissed the worker’s application for mediation and upheld the validity of the Notice of Decision. The court further found that the worker had not provided reasonable cause for the delay in seeking mediation, thereby affirming the employer's position.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The employer’s position is that the Notice of Decision was valid, and therefore the time within which to seek mediation commenced to run from 27 October 2012. The employer also contends that the worker has failed to establish “other reasonable cause” for her failure to seek mediation within 90 days from 27 October 201THE VALIDITY OF THE NOTICE OF DECISION I have given considerable thought to the argument advanced by the worker that as the s 69 Notice of Decision was invalid then the time in which to apply for mediation did not commence to run; and therefore it is not necessary for the worker to seek an extension of time. In order to put the argument in proper context, it is useful to refer to the various provisions of the Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act which deal with the pre –court process of mediation. Section 103D (1) of Workers Rehabilitation and Compensation Act provides that a claimant may apply to the Authority to have a dispute referred to mediation. Subsection (2) states that if the dispute relates to a decision specified in s 103 B (a) or (b)[1] the claimant must apply for mediation within 90 days of receiving the statement referred to in s 85(8) or s 69(1)(b). Section 103D(4) provides that a claimant who fails to apply for mediation within the 90 day period may apply to the Court for an extension of the period. The Court may extend the period if it is satisfied that the failure to apply within the prescribed period was occasioned by mistake, ignorance of a disease, absence from the Territory or other reasonable cause: see s103D(5). In my opinion, the worker’s argument is misconceived because it is based on the common fallacy of “putting the cart before the horse”. It is not a pre-condition for the operation of s 103D that a statement referred to in s 85(8) or s 69(1)(b) be valid in order to trigger the compulsory mediation process. The reason for that is that many disputes relate to the cancellation or reduction of compensation, including the validity of notices; and one of the purposes of the mediation process is to attempt to resolve disputes over notices. The prescribed 90 day period runs from the receipt of either a s 85(8) or ss69(1)(b) notice – whether the notice is valid or not. The validity or otherwise of a statutory notice is a matter that is ultimately to be adjudicated upon by the Court, once proceedings have been properly commenced in accordance with s 103J of the Act[2], or, where there has been a failure to seek mediation within the prescribed 90 day period, an extension of time has been granted under s 103D(5) of the Act to ensure compliance with s 103J. If, however, I have erred in reaching that conclusion, and should have accepted the worker’s primary argument, I would have found the employer’s Notice of Decision to be invalid for the following reasons. The Notice of Decision was sent to the worker under cover of a letter dated 16 August 2012 from the Territory Insurance Office (TIO). The covering letter read:We refer to the above mentioned workers compensation claim for an aggravation of right cervico- brachial pain sustained on 11 June 2010.Please find enclosed a “Notice of Decision and Right of Appeal’ ceasing your weekly benefit entitlements. The reasons for this decision are outlined in the “Notice of Decision”.Should you have any questions regarding the above, please contact our office on the details listed below.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established