Revian v Dasford Holdings Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Revian v Dasford Holdings Pty Ltd [2002] FCA 676

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - pleadings - representative action - shopping centre tenants - alleged representations inducing entry into shopping centre leases - misleading or deceptive conduct - fraud - negligent misstatement - statements of a promissory or predictive character - application of s 51A of Trade Practices Act- pleading of many non- material facts - inappropriate pleading of s 51A and implied representations as to statements relating to the future - failure to adequately falsify pleaded misrepresentations - failure to plead material facts supporting fraud and negligent misstatement - unconscionable conduct plea - reliance upon misrepresentations and subsequent conduct - voluminous statement of claim - sufficiently flawed that statement of claim as a whole should be struck out - leave to amend.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth)

Revian v Dasford Holdings Pty Ltd [2001] FCA 777 cited

KANDI LEE REVIAN (FOR AND ON BEHALF OF HERSELF AND AS JOINT TRUSTEE FOR THE GKDK TRUST AND AS A REPRESENTATIVE OF THE GROUP MEMBERS REFERRED TO IN THE APPLICATION) v DASFORD HOLDINGS PTY LTD and ORS
W 101 of 2001

FRENCH J
28 MAY 2002
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

W 101 of 2001

BETWEEN:

KANDI LEE REVIAN (FOR AND ON BEHALF OF HERSELF AND AS JOINT TRUSTEE FOR THE GKDK TRUST AND AS A REPRESENTATIVE OF THE GROUP MEMBERS REFERRED TO IN THE APPLICATION)
APPLICANT

AND:

AND:

KANDI LEE REVIAN AND GRANT WILLIAM THOMPSON AS TRUSTEES FOR THE GKDK TRUST CEASED TRADING AS LEADING EDGE VIDEO CLARKSON (SHOP 17)
FIRST GROUP MEMBER

RICHARD DAWSON FIELDS AND MARY ANNE FIELDS AND ELSIE NOMINEES PTY LTD TRADING AS CLARKSON MINI MART (SHOP 10)
SECOND GROUP MEMBER

FREDERICK FRANCIS TREBLE CEASED TRADING AS FRED'S HARDWARE (SHOP 1)
THIRD GROUP MEMBER

SHAUN NICHOLAS AND ANASTASHIA MARGARITA NICHOLAS AND DEBBIE PTY LTD CEASED TRADING AS CLARKSON INDIAN AND CHINESE CUISINE (SHOP 3C)
FOURTH GROUP MEMBER

PAREE BUCHANAN CEASED TRADING AS SPICY THAI (SHOP 3B)
FIFTH GROUP MEMBER

PATRICK HINKSMAN AND ROBYN JEANETTE HINKSMAN CEASED TRADING AS THE BEST DRESSED IN SECONDS (SHOP 2)
SIXTH GROUP MEMBER

HAYDEE MARTINEZ AND ROBERTO MARTINEZ CEASED TRADING AS NACHOS AND PASTA (SHOP 3A)
SEVENTH GROUP MEMBER

PAUL FREDERICK HOUSTON AND LINDA ANN HOUSTON TRADING AS CLARKSON FISH SUPPLY
(SHOP 11)
EIGHTH GROUP MEMBER

DASFORD HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(ACN 051 224 438)
FIRST RESPONDENT

PENMAN HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(ACN 009 203 105)
SECOND RESPONDENT

THURSTON JOHN PETER SAULSMAN
THIRD RESPONDENT

KEVIN ARTHUR POWNALL
FOURTH RESPONDENT

BRIAN JOSEPH BOWLER
FIFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

FRENCH J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 MAY 2002

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

On the Applicant’s motion filed 1 August 2001:

1.As to paragraph 1, the motion that the applicant’s amended statement of claim do stand as the statement of claim herein be dismissed and the statement of claim filed 9 April 2001 be struck out.

2.The applicant have leave to file a substituted application and statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Revian v Dasford Holdings Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 676
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Revian v Dasford Holdings Pty Ltd, the plaintiff sought to amend their statement of claim against the defendants, who in turn sought to have the plaintiff's claims struck out on various grounds. The primary dispute centred on whether the plaintiff's claims, including those for misleading or deceptive conduct, fraud, and negligent misstatement, were adequately pleaded. The defendants argued that the plaintiff's proposed amended statement of claim was insufficient and should be dismissed, and they further sought to have the entire action struck out on additional grounds.

The legal issues the court had to address included the sufficiency of the plaintiff's pleadings, particularly in light of the proposed amended statement of claim, and whether the entire action should be dismissed on grounds such as insufficiency of group members, limitation periods, and abuse of court process. The court considered whether the proposed amended statement of claim could be salvaged by striking out certain parts, or if the entire statement of claim should be dismissed, with leave to file a substituted statement of claim.

The court ruled that the flaws in the plaintiff's proposed amended statement of claim were so significant that it was not worth attempting to salvage parts of it. Consequently, the existing statement of claim was struck out, and the plaintiff was granted leave to file a substituted statement of claim. The court rejected the motion to strike out the entire action on the grounds that it would be an abuse of court process or because it was brought outside the limitation period, but it did not rule out the possibility of determining these issues at a later stage. The court also did not make a decision on the question of security for costs, leaving that matter for further consideration.

The final orders included dismissing the plaintiff's motion to have their amended statement of claim stand, striking out the existing statement of claim, granting leave for the plaintiff to file a new statement of claim, and ordering the plaintiff to pay the respondents' costs of the motion. The court also dismissed the motion by the fourth and fifth respondents to strike out the proceedings, but left the question of security for costs undecided.

Orders

Orders of the court

On the Applicant’s motion filed 1 August 2001:

1. As to paragraph 1, the motion that the applicant’s amended statement of claim do stand as the statement of claim herein be dismissed and the statement of claim filed 9 April 2001 be struck out.

2. The applicant have leave to file a substituted application and statement of claim.

3. The applicant pay the respondents’ costs of the motion.

4. The motion be otherwise adjourned to the next directions hearing.

On the Fourth and Fifth Respondents’ Motion filed 6 August 2001:

1. The motion is dismissed in so far as it seeks orders striking out the proceedings.

2. The question of security for costs stands for decision.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J
The plea as to unconscionable conduct in effect incorporates by reference the representation or conduct relied upon in support of the claims of misleading or deceptive conduct, fraud and negligent misstatement. Conclusion It seems reasonably likely that viable causes of action will be disclosed in a properly pleaded statement of claim. The flaws in the proposed amended statement of claim are so pervasive however that it is pointless to engage in a blue pencil exercise with respect to what can stand and what cannot leaving the respondents to plead to its tattered remnants. In my opinion the amended statement of claim should not be allowed to stand as the statement of claim, the previous statement of claim, which has a similar structure, should be struck out and there should be leave to file a substituted statement of claim. Strike Out Motion by the Fourth and Fifth Respondents Messrs Pownall and Bowler filed a motion on 6 March 2002 seeking an order that the Court strike out the applicant’s action against them and, alternatively, that it strike out the entire action. In the alternative an order was sought that the Court require the applicant to provide security for costs. The grounds upon which the strike out order in relation to the proceedings against the fourth and fifth respondents was sought concerned the sufficiency of the pleadings against them. I am not prepared at this stage to go further than already indicated. That is to say that the statement of claim as it stands will be struck out and the proposed amended statement of claim will not be permitted to stand in its place. The applicant will be permitted the further opportunity, now that legal representation is available, to properly formulate the Group’s claims. In so far as the motion sought to strike out the entire action, it was based on three grounds:(a) insufficient group members with valid claims for a class action; (b) the action was brought outside the Trade Practices Act limitation period; (c) it is an abuse of the Court process. The first ground really relates to the deficiencies in the pleading and in particular the want of causal connection between the losses claimed by various of the group members and the causes of action which they plead. These matters have already been identified in relation to the statement of claim generally. They are complaints which support the striking out of the statement of claim but not the entire proceedings. As to the second ground, in the ordinary course, time limitation questions are not to be determined on the pleadings. They can depend on issues of fact surrounding the time at which loss crystallises. I therefore would not propose to strike out the action on the basis that it is out of time. The third ground alleged abuse of Court process largely because of the futility of the proceedings against the fourth and fifth respondents, they being impecunious. That is not a basis for treating the proceedings as an abuse of process nor would they be struck out on that basis. The motion of the fourth and fifth respondents, so far as it concerns the strike out of the action will be dismissed. It stands in relation to the question of security for costs which has yet to be determined.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

Full text does not contain this section.