SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
Resolute Mining Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue [2020] QSC 281
PARTIES:
RESOLUTE MINING LIMITED
ACN 097 088 689(appellant)
v
COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE(respondent)
FILE NO/S:
BS No 8195 of 2019
DIVISION:
Trial Division
PROCEEDING:
Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
Supreme Court at BrisbaneDELIVERED ON:
14 September 2020
DELIVERED AT:
Brisbane
HEARING DATE:
21 August 2020
JUDGE:
Bradley J
ORDER:
The Order of the Court is that:
1. The appeal is allowed completely.
2. The respondent’s decision to disallow the appellant’s objection (the “Objection”) to the notice of assessment dated 9 January 2019 and notice of reassessment dated 14 January 2019 is set aside.
3. The Objection is allowed completely.
4. Subject to section 39(1) of the Taxation Administration Act 2001(Qld) (the “Administration Act”), the respondent refund to the appellant an amount (the “overpaid amount”) being the difference between $511,744.50 paid by the appellant on 25 January 2019 and the transfer duty payable by the appellant assessed in the further reassessment the respondent is to make in accordance with the direction in paragraph 7 below.
5. Pursuant to section 61(2) of the Administration Act, the respondent pay the appellant interest on the overpaid amount, calculated in accordance with section 61(3) of the Administration Act.
The Court directs that:
6. The matter is remitted to the respondent.
7. In accordance with section 19 of the Administration Act, the respondent give effect to the Court’s decision by making a further reassessment of the appellant’s liability to pay transfer duty under the Duties Act 2001 (Qld) on the dutiable transaction in the written agreement entitled “Funding Agreement relating to Ravenswood State School Relocation” between the State of Queensland represented by the Department of Education and the appellant, which was executed by the State of Queensland on 19 November 2018.
The Court will hear submissions on the question of costs.
CATCHWORDS:
TAXES AND DUTIES – STAMP DUTIES – ASSESSMENT AND AMOUNT PAYABLE INCLUDING FINES – GENERALLY – QUEENSLAND – where the appellant agreed to provide a “funding amount” to the State pursuant to a contract by which the State would transfer land to the appellant – where the funding amount was expressed to be a sum of money which was liable to be increased pursuant to a clause of the contract – where another clause of the contract required the State to pay certain amounts to the appellant, one of which was calculated by reference to the funding amount, such that the total amount payable by the appellant could be more or less than the funding amount – where the respondent submits the adjustments which could be made to the funding amount are not a payment for the land or, alternatively, can be disregarded due to the “contingency principle” – where the appellant submits the consideration is the total amount payable by the appellant to the State and could not be ascertained when the contract was executed – whether the consideration under…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Resolute Mining Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] QSC 281
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered whether the consideration under the contract was the funding amount or the total amount payable by the appellant to the State and whether the consideration could be ascertained when the contract was executed. The court found that the consideration was the total amount payable by the appellant to the State and that it could be ascertained when the contract was executed. The court found that the Commissioner’s interpretation of the duties legislation was incorrect and that the consideration for the transaction should be assessed, not the unencumbered value of the land. The court found that the Commissioner’s decision to disallow the appellant’s objection was unreasonable and remitted the matter to the Commissioner for reassessment.
The court allowed the appeal, set aside the Commissioner’s decision to disallow the appellant’s objection, allowed the objection, and directed the Commissioner to refund the overpaid amount to the appellant and pay interest on the overpaid amount. The court directed the Commissioner to make a further reassessment of the appellant’s liability to pay transfer duty under the Duties Act 2001 (Qld). The court will hear submissions on the question of costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Order of the Court is that:
1. The appeal is allowed completely.
2. The respondent’s decision to disallow the appellant’s objection (the “Objection”) to the notice of assessment dated 9 January 2019 and notice of reassessment dated 14 January 2019 is set aside.
3. The Objection is allowed completely.
4. Subject to section 39(1) of the Taxation Administration Act 2001 (Qld) (the “Administration Act”), the respondent refund to the appellant an amount (the “overpaid amount”) being the difference between $511,744.50 paid by the appellant on 25 January 2019 and the transfer duty payable by the appellant assessed in the further reassessment the respondent is to make in accordance with the direction in paragraph 7 below.
5. Pursuant to section 61(2) of the Administration Act, the respondent pay the appellant interest on the overpaid amount, calculated in accordance with section 61(3) of the Administration Act.
The Court directs that:
6. The matter is remitted to the respondent.
7. In accordance with section 19 of the Administration Act, the respondent give effect to the Court’s decision by making a further reassessment of the appellant’s liability to pay transfer duty under the Duties Act 2001 (Qld) on the dutiable transaction in the written agreement entitled “Funding Agreement relating to Ravenswood State School Relocation” between the State of Queensland represented by the Department of Education and the appellant, which was executed by the State of Queensland on 19 November 2018.
The Court will hear submissions on the question of costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The liability to pay transfer duty is imposed by the Duties Act 2001 (Qld) (the Act). The appeal is brought pursuant to s 69(2) of the Taxation Administration Act 2001 (Qld) (the Administration Act).Background facts Carpentaria Gold Pty Ltd (Carpentaria) owned the Ravenswood Gold Mine. It is a wholly owned subsidiary of Resolute.[1][1]These matters are set out in the statement of agreed facts filed 20 May 2020 (Agreed Facts) at [1] and [2]. The Ravenswood Expansion Project is a project for the expansion of the Ravenswood Gold Mine, including the mining activities associated with the expansion of the existing Buck Reef West open pit and related infrastructure.[2] Carpentaria applied for two additional mining leases and an extension to the surface area of a third mining lease (collectively, the new mining leases) as part of the Ravenswood Expansion Project.[3] [2]By clause 1.1 of the Funding Agreement, the meaning of certain words and expressions used in the Funding Agreement is defined, unless the context provides otherwise. The defined expressions include Ravenswood Expansion Project. [3]Agreed Facts at [3]. The existing Ravenswood State School was located on land (the Existing Site) within the area for the Ravenswood Expansion Project.[4] The Existing Site was owned by the State.[5] It was “restricted land” within the meaning of s 68(1)(a) of the Mineral Energy Resources (Common Provisions) Act 2014 (Qld), being within 200 metres laterally of the area used for the Ravenswood State School[6] and a residential duplex.[7][4]See recital A and clause 1.1 of the Funding Agreement.[5]Agreed Facts at [5].[6]Mineral Energy Resources (Common Provisions) Act 2014 (Qld) (CPA), s 68(1)(a)(ii)(A).[7]CPA, s 68(1)(a)(i)(A). On 14 November 2018, the Department executed a written agreement with Carpentaria (the Compensation Agreement).[8] It was a compensation agreement for the new mining leases for the purposes of the Mineral Resources Act 1989 (Qld) (the MRA), including for determining compensation between Carpentaria and the State as the owner of the Existing Site under s 279 of the MRA. It was also written consent of the State, as the owner and occupier of the area used for the school and the residential duplex,[9] for the purposes of s 238(1) of the MRA. The compensation payable by Carpentaria to the Department was $1.[8]Agreed Facts at [7].[9]MRA, ss 238(1)(a), (3); CPA, ss 69(a)-(b).The agreement for transfer in the Funding Agreement The Funding Agreement and the Compensation Agreement are separate instruments. Their relationship was indicated, not only by their subject matter, but by the fact that the Compensation Agreement did not commence until the last party to the Funding Agreement executed that instrument. The Department was the last party to execute the Funding Agreement. It did so on 19 November 2018. It is common ground that the liability for transfer duty arose on that date. By clause 4.1 of the Funding Agreement,[10] the parties agreed: “The Department will transfer legal title of the Existing Site to Resolute or its nominee after all of the following have occurred to the Department’s satisfaction: (a)Practical Completion has occurred;[11](b)all students have been relocated to the New School;[12] and (c)all resources required for the operation of the New School have been relocated to the New School.”[10]Each further reference to a clause is to a clause of the Funding Agreement.[11]Practical Completion was practical completion under the contract for the construction of the New School. [12]The New School was that to be constructed on the New Site, depicted on a map attached to the Funding Agreement.