CITATION: RELIANCE FINANCIAL SERVICES NSW PTY LIMITED v SOBBI & ANOR [2009] NSWSC 1375 HEARING DATE(S): 28, 29, 30 September, 1, 2 October, 18, 19 November 2009
JUDGMENT DATE :
10 December 2009JURISDICTION: Common Law JUDGMENT OF: Hall J at 1 DECISION: I grant leave to the defendants to amend the cross-claim in terms of paragraphs 6(h)(iv) and 6(k)(vi), (vii) (viii), (ix) and (x) of the Second Further Amended Cross-Claim (MFI 18).
I refuse leave to the defendants to adduce evidence on the matters that are the subject of paragraphs 54 to 122 of Alan Sobbi’s affidavit sworn 12 November 2009.CATCHWORDS: AMENDMENT TO PLEADINGS – Application to amend Cross-Claim by guarantors (defendants) against lenders/mortgagees (cross-defendants) – issue as to whether the cross-claimant guarantors were to receive the benefit of the loan – relevant to relief sought under Contracts Review Act 1980 – true purpose of loan sought to be raised under proposed amendments – contrary to purpose disclosed in principal affidavit of first cross-claimant – APPLICATION RE EVIDENCE – to adduce new or additional evidence to explain circumstances in which a contrary or contradictory version as to the purpose of the loan was given by first cross-claimant in unrelated proceedings at an earlier time – issues of delay and need to recall witnesses and likelihood of a prolonged hearing resulting – application refused – principles enunciated in Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University applied – EVIDENCE – whether certificate under s.128, Evidence Act 1995 may be given where potentially incriminating evidence sought to be led in cross-examination or re-examination – whether such evidence can be considered to be given under objection or willingly by the witness – held a s.128 certificate may not be given with respect to such evidence as foreshadowed on the application for leave LEGISLATION CITED: Civil Procedure Act 2005
Contracts Review Act 1980
Crimes Act 1914 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995
Foreign Acquisitions and Takeovers Act 1975
Listening Devices Act 1984
Telecommunications (Interception and Access) Act 1979 (Cth)CASES CITED: Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University [2009] HCA 27
Chao v Chao [2008] NSWSC 584
Cornwell v The Queen (2007) 231 CLR 260
Ferrall v Blyton; A-G (Cth) (Intervener) [2000] FCA 1442
Meiko Australia Pacific Pty Limited v Adam Samuel Hinchliffe [2009] NSWSC 354
Ollis v Melissari [2005] NSWSC 1016
Regina v Clune and Gergis (1999) 72 SASR 420
Regina v Lavery (No 2) (1979) 20 SASR 430
Regina v Phair [1986] 1 Qd R 136
Regina v Szach (1980) 23 SASR 504 at 568
Samaan bht Samaan v Kentucky Fried Chicken Pty Ltd [2009] NSWSC 1265
Sheikholeslami v Tolcher [2009] NSWSC 920
Ying v Song [2009] NSWSC 1344PARTIES: RELIANCE FINANCIAL SERVICES NSW PTY LIMITED
v Ghandi Faizi SOBBI & ANORFILE NUMBER(S): SC 12224 of 2004 COUNSEL: P: M Ashhurst SC/D Allen
D: P Menzies QC/ C BovaSOLICITORS: P: Proctor & Associates
D: Bowles Lawyers
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAW DIVISION
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Reliance Financial Services NSW Pty Limited v Sobbi and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 1375
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court needed to decide whether the proposed amendments to the cross-claim and the introduction of new evidence were permissible under the relevant rules and statutes. The guarantors argued that the evidence was necessary to explain the discrepancy in the purpose of the loan as previously stated. However, the court considered the principles set out in Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University, which highlighted the importance of finality in litigation and the potential for prejudice and delay. The court was also concerned about the need to recall witnesses and the potential for a prolonged hearing.
The court ultimately refused the application to amend the cross-claim and to adduce new evidence. It reasoned that the proposed amendments and the new evidence would likely lead to significant delay and prejudice to the lenders and mortgagees. The court also noted that the guarantors had not shown sufficient justification for the delay in presenting the new evidence. Consequently, the application for leave to adduce the new evidence was also refused. The court concluded that the principles of finality in litigation and the potential for prejudice outweighed the need for the proposed amendments and the new evidence. The final orders of the court reflected the refusal of both the application to amend the cross-claim and the application for leave to adduce new evidence.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case before the court was an application by the guarantors to amend their cross-claim against the lender. The application sought to introduce new facts and evidence concerning the purpose of the loan, which was different from what had been stated in their original affidavit. The lender opposed the application, arguing that it would cause significant delay and prejudice, and that new evidence should not be admitted as it might require recalling witnesses and prolong the hearing. The matter was also complicated by the potential admissibility of incriminating evidence under the Evidence Act 1995. The court had to determine whether the proposed amendments and new evidence were allowable under the circumstances.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the guarantors' application to amend their cross-claim should be granted to include new facts and evidence concerning the purpose of the loan.
2. Whether new evidence can be adduced to explain the discrepancy between the current position of the guarantors and a prior statement made in unrelated proceedings.
3. Whether a s.128 certificate under the Evidence Act 1995 can be given in respect of evidence that is potentially incriminating and sought to be led in cross-examination or re-examination.
Held
1. The court held that the guarantors' application to amend their cross-claim to include new facts and evidence concerning the purpose of the loan should be refused. The court found that the proposed amendments were not permissible under the relevant legal principles and did not align with the purpose disclosed in the principal affidavit of the first cross-claimant.
2. The court held that new evidence could not be adduced to explain the discrepancy between the current position of the guarantors and a prior statement made in unrelated proceedings. The application was refused based on the principles enunciated in Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University, taking into account issues of delay, the need to recall witnesses, and the likelihood of a prolonged hearing resulting from the proposed new evidence.
3. The court held that a s.128 certificate under the Evidence Act 1995 could not be given in respect of evidence that is potentially incriminating and sought to be led in cross-examination or re-examination. The court determined that such evidence could not be considered to be given under objection or willingly by the witness, and therefore, a s.128 certificate may not be given with respect to such evidence as foreshadowed on the application for leave.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court applied the principles from Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University in assessing the guarantors' application to amend their cross-claim. The court found that the proposed amendments were not permissible as they sought to raise new facts and evidence concerning the purpose of the loan, which was contrary to the purpose disclosed in the principal affidavit of the first cross-claimant. The court considered the issue of delay, the need to recall witnesses, and the likelihood of a prolonged hearing, which supported the refusal of the application. In relation to the new evidence application, the court applied the principles from Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University and found that the proposed new evidence was not admissible as it would have caused significant delay and inconvenience to the proceedings. Regarding the s.128 certificate, the court found that such a certificate could not be given for evidence that is potentially incriminating and sought to be led in cross-examination or re-examination. The court determined that the evidence could not be considered to be given under objection or willingly by the witness, and therefore, a s.128 certificate may not be given with respect to such evidence as foreshadowed on the application for leave. The ratio decidendi of this case is that applications to amend pleadings, adduce new evidence, and obtain s.128 certificates must be assessed on a case-by-case basis, taking into account factors such as delay, inconvenience, and the potential impact on the fairness of the proceedings.