Reihana v Mastercare Highrise Cleaning Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Reihana v Mastercare Highrise Cleaning Services Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 353

Citation: Reihana v Mastercare Highrise Cleaning Services Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 353
Parties: TONI COLIN REIHANA v MASTERCARE HIGHRISE CLEANING SERVICES PTY LTD and FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA
File number: QUD 570 of 2013
Judge: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 8 April 2014
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – review of decision of Full Bench of Fair Work Commission – s 39B Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) – application to Fair Work Commission for extension of time to make unfair dismissal application dismissed – s 394(2)(b) Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – appeal to Full Bench of Fair Work Commission dismissed

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – whether jurisdictional error – denial of natural justice – refusal to allow elaboration of submissions at hearing – material not specifically referred to in decision – refusal to admit new evidence on appeal – determination of Fair Work Commission overly harsh – whether circumstances exceptional a question of fact – distinction between jurisdictional error and error of fact

Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 394, 394(2)(b), s 394(3), 394(3)(a), 394(3)(c), 394(3)(e), 400, 577, 605, 607, 607(2)(a), 614
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B
Queensland Industrial Relations Act 1974 (Qld) s 7
Cases cited: Akins v National Australia Bank (1994) 34 NSWLR 155 cited
Linfox Australia Pty Ltd v Fair Work Commission [2013] FCAFC 157 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323 cited
Reihana v Mastercare Highrise Cleaning Services Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 4960 cited
Tonia Shelley v McRoberts Agency [2009] QIRComm 22 considered
WAEE v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs (2003) 75 ALD 630; [2003] FCAFC 184 cited
Date of hearing: 2 April 2014
Place: Brisbane
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 29
Counsel for the Applicant: The Applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Mr H Woods
Solicitor for the First and Second Respondents: Kemp & Co Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

QUD 570 of 2013

BETWEEN:

TONI COLIN REIHANA
Applicant

AND:

MASTERCARE HIGHRISE CLEANING SERVICES PTY LTD
First Respondent

FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 APRIL 2014

WHERE MADE:

BRISBANE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The amended originating application filed on 14 October 2013 be dismissed.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

QUD 570 of 2013

BETWEEN:

TONI COLIN REIHANA
Applicant

AND:

MASTERCARE HIGHRISE CLEANING SERVICES PTY LTD
First Respondent

FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

COLLIER J

DATE:

8 APRIL 2014

PLACE:

BRISBANE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. In his amended originating application filed on 14 October 2013 the applicant, Mr Reihana, seeks the following orders:

    1.That the Federal Court issues a writ of certiorari directed to Fair Work Australia to quash its order or decision of 2 August 2013 in this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reihana v Mastercare Highrise Cleaning Services Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 353
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Reihana v Mastercare Highrise Cleaning Services Pty Ltd, the applicant, Mr Reihana, sought a review of the decision of the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission, which dismissed his appeal against the decision of the Senior Deputy President. The applicant had applied for an extension of time to make an unfair dismissal application, which was dismissed by the Senior Deputy President on the basis that the applicant had not demonstrated exceptional circumstances. Mr Reihana appealed the decision of the Senior Deputy President to the Full Bench, which was also dismissed. The legal issues in this case related to the scope of the court's jurisdiction to review decisions of the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission and whether the Full Bench had made a jurisdictional error in refusing to admit new evidence or information on appeal. The court held that the Full Bench did not make a jurisdictional error in refusing to admit new evidence or information on appeal. The Full Bench had correctly identified that the new evidence or information was not sufficient to lead to satisfaction that there were exceptional circumstances as required by s 394(3) of the Fair Work Act for allowing a further period for the making of the applicant's unfair dismissal remedy application. Moreover, the new evidence or information was available to the applicant at the time the matter was heard by the Senior Deputy President. The court also held that the Full Bench did not make a jurisdictional error in refusing to allow the applicant to elaborate on his submissions at the hearing or in refusing to admit new evidence on appeal. The Full Bench had correctly identified that decision-makers need not refer to every piece of evidence and every contention of a party. The Full Bench had also correctly summarised the applicant's submissions at [5] and [6] of their decision. The court dismissed the application and refused the applicant permission to appeal. The court held that the Full Bench had not made a jurisdictional error in dismissing the applicant's appeal and that it was not in the public interest to grant the applicant permission to appeal. The Full Bench had correctly identified the reasoning process followed by the Senior Deputy President to find that there were no exceptional circumstances to justify extending time for the making of the applicant's application. The applicant had not established that the Senior Deputy President's decision involved a significant error of fact. The court's decision in this case clarifies the scope of the court's jurisdiction to review decisions of the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission and the principles governing the admission of fresh evidence on appeal. It also highlights the importance of decision-makers taking into account all relevant evidence and submissions in making their decisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The amended originating application filed on 14 October 2013 be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In my view the proceedings should be dismissed. In explaining my decision it is appropriate to first turn to the background of this proceeding.Background The background to the present proceeding is summarised in the decision of the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission in Reihana v Mastercare Highrise Cleaning Services Pty Ltd [2013] FWCFB 4960. In summary, the position is as follows. Mr Reihana is a commercial cleaner, formerly employed as a window cleaner by the first respondent (“Mastercare”). He was dismissed from his employment effective 23 December 2012, and paid in lieu of notice. The matter was subject to an unsuccessful conciliation conference. Mr Reihana sought an unfair dismissal remedy in the Fair Work Commission pursuant to s 394 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the Act”). Section 394 provides:Application for unfair dismissal remedy(1)A person who has been dismissed may apply to the FWC for an order under Division 4 granting a remedy.Note 1: Division 4 sets out when the FWC may order a remedy for unfair dismissal.Note 2: For application fees, see section 395.Note 3:Part 6-1 may prevent an application being made under this Part in relation to a dismissal if an application or complaint has been made in relation to the dismissal other than under this Part.(2) The application must be made:(a) within 21 days after the dismissal took effect; or(b)within such further period as the FWC allows under subsection (3).(3)The FWC may allow a further period for the application to be made by a person under subsection (1) if the FWC is satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances, taking into account:(a) the reason for the delay; and(b)whether the person first became aware of the dismissal after it had taken effect; and(c) any action taken by the person to dispute the dismissal; and(d)prejudice to the employer (including prejudice caused by the delay); and(e) the merits of the application; and(f)fairness as between the person and other persons in a similar position. Mastercare objected to Mr Reihana’s application for an unfair dismissal remedy on the basis that his application was made on 13 February 2013, being some 52 days after the dismissal took effect.Proceeding before Senior Deputy President Richards The matter originally came before SDP Richards. At the hearing Mr Reihana sought an extension of time pursuant to s 394(2)(b) in which to make his substantive application. He made submissions and produced evidence in relation to the various matters set out in s 394(3) of the Act, materially as follows:·In relation to s 394(3)(a) and the reason for the delay in making the application, Mr Reihana claimed that he posted by ordinary surface mail an application for an unfair dismissal remedy on 25 January 2013, however he posted the application to the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission (QIRC). On or about 1 February 2013 he was informed in writing by a delegate of the Industrial Registrar that the application should have been despatched to the Fair Work Commission. Mr Reihana had lodged a new application with the Fair Work Commission on 13 February 2013.·In relation to s 394(3)(c), Mr Reihana had informed Mastercare at the time of dismissal that he would challenge the dismissal.·In relation to s 394(3)(e), Mr Reihana pressed the view that his application had merit.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Full Bench then found as follows:[8] Sections 604 of the FW Act states in respect of appeals:“604 Appeal of decisions(1) A person who is aggrieved by a decision:(a)made by the FWC (other than a decision of a Full Bench or the Minimum Wage Panel)…may appeal the decision, with the permission of the FWC.(2)Without limiting when the FWC may grant permission, the FWC must grant permission if the FWC is satisfied that it is in the public interest to do so.Note:Subsection (2) does not apply in relation to an application for an unfair dismissal (see s 400).(3) A person may appeal the decision by applying to the FWC.”[9] Section 607 of the FW Act states:“607 Process for appealing or reviewing decisions(1)An appeal from, or a review of, a decision of the FWC or the General Manager may be heard or conducted without holding a hearing only if:(a)it appears to the FWC that the appeal or review can be adequately determined without persons making oral submissions for consideration in the appeal or review; and(b)the persons who would otherwise, or who will, make submissions (whether oral or written) for consideration in the appeal or review consent to the appeal or review being heard or conducted without a hearing.(2) The FWC may:(a) admit further evidence; and(b) take into account any other information or evidence.(3)The FWC may do any of the following in relation to the appeal or review:(a) confirm, quash or vary the decision;(b)make a further decision in relation to the matter that is the subject of the appeal or review…”.[10] Section 400 of the FW Act, however, states:“400 Appeal rights(1)Despite subsection 604(2), FWA must not grant permission to appeal from a decision made by FWA under this Part unless FWA considers that it is in the public interest to do so.(2)Despite subsection 604(1), an appeal from a decision made by the FWC in relation to a matter arising under this Part can only, to the extent that it is an appeal on a question of fact, be made on the ground that the decision involved a significant error of fact.”[11]The “Part” referred to in s.400 of the FW Act is Part 3-2 of the FW Act concerning unfair dismissal.[12]With respect to Mr Reihana’s application for us to admit or take into account new evidence or information on appeal, s.607(2) of the FW Act concerning such evidence or information was considered by a majority of a Full Bench of the then Fair Work Australia in J.J. Richards & Sons Pty Ltd v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia. The majority in J.J. Richards recognised that s.607(2) confers a discretion on a Full Bench hearing on appeal to “admit further evidence” and “take into account any other information or evidence” and that the principles governing the admission of fresh evidence on appeal in the courts provide a useful guide to the exercise of the discretion. In that regard, in Akins v National Australia Bank, Clarke JA said:“The Court is empowered to receive further evidence upon the hearing of an appeal (s.75A(7) of the Supreme Court Act 1970) but pursuant to subs (8) of that section may not receive further evidence after a trial on the merits ‘except on special grounds’. Although it is not possible to formulate a test which should be applied in every case to determine whether or not special grounds exist there are well understood general principles upon which a determination is made. These principles require that, in general, three conditions need be met before fresh evidence can be admitted. These are: (1) It must be shown that the evidence could not have been obtained without reasonable diligence for use at the trial; (2) The evidence must be such that there must be a high degree of probability that there would be a different verdict; (3) The evidence must be credible.”[13]The new evidence or information Mr Reihana seeks to have us admit or take into account on appeal is evidence or information that was available to Mr Reihana at the time the matter the subject of this appeal was heard by the Senior Deputy President. Moreover, the new evidence or information is not sufficient to lead to satisfaction that there are exceptional circumstances as required by s.394(3) of the FW Act for allowing him a further period for the making of his unfair dismissal remedy application. In the circumstances, we decline to admit or take into account Mr Reihana’s new evidence or information.[14]We are not persuaded the Senior Deputy President made an appealable error in his decision to refuse Mr Reihana an extension of time for the making of his unfair dismissal remedy application.[15]Mr Reihana was dismissed shortly before Christmas 2012 and given pay in lieu of any outstanding notice of dismissal required to be given to him. We were not referred to any authority precluding Mastercare giving Mr Reihana payment in lieu of notice. Further, the Senior Deputy President took into account Mr Reihana’s application to the QIRC and the period within which it was made but did not consider that an exceptional circumstance. That finding was reasonably open to his Honour. The absence of a specific reference to the QIRC website in his Honour’s decision is of no consequence. In addition, under s.394(2)(a) of the FW Act an unfair dismissal application must be made within a certain period after the dismissal took effect. The Senior Deputy President considered Mr Reihana’s delay between him receiving the advice about his application to the QIRC and him making his unfair dismissal remedy application to the FWC but found no meaningful explanation was provided for the delay and no exceptional circumstances were evident. Those findings were also reasonably open to his Honour.Conclusion[16]Mr Reihana has not established that the Senior Deputy President’s decision involved a significant error of fact and, in the circumstances, we do not consider it is in the public interest or otherwise that we grant him permission to appeal. Mr Reihana’s appeal does not raise matters that attract the public interest in granting permission to appeal. We refuse Mr Reihana permission to appeal and, to the extent necessary, dismiss his appeal.(Footnotes omitted.)Submissions of Mr Reihana

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mastercare has also filed submissions in this proceeding. In summary, it contends:·The appellate jurisdiction of the Full Bench required the identification of some error of law or fact on the part of the Commissioner before the Full Bench could intervene, whereas the jurisdiction of the Federal Court to review a decision of the Full Bench requires the identification of a jurisdictional error.·Although a failure to address a submission which is significant and which touches upon the core duty being discharged may in some cases found a conclusion that it has not been taken into account (and therefore expose jurisdictional error), decision makers need not refer to every piece of evidence and every contention of a party.·The Full Bench correctly summarised Mr Reihana’s submissions at [5] and [6] of their decision.·The Full Bench noted that in their view the new evidence was not sufficient to lead to the satisfaction that there were exceptional circumstances as required by s 394(3) of the Act for allowing a further period for the making of the applicant’s unfair dismissal remedy application. It was in those circumstances that the Full Bench declined to admit or take into account the new evidence, noting also that this evidence had been available earlier at the time of the hearing before SDP Richards.·The Full Bench identified the reasoning process followed by SDP Richards to find that there were no exceptional circumstances to justify extending time for the making of Mr Reihana’s application.·The Full Bench dealt with Mr Reihana’s contention that the date of dismissal was actually 13 January 2013 rather than 23 December 2012 as had been accepted at the first hearing before SDP Richards.·The transcript of the hearing before the Full Bench does not support Mr Reihana’s claim that he was “shut down” or stifled in his attempts to elaborate and clarify his submissions.·It is clear that Mr Reihana was given a fair opportunity to make submissions in respect of the matters for which he contended.·It is not in dispute that a party to a proceeding should be given an adequate opportunity to be heard. In this case it is clear that Mr Reihana was given an opportunity to be heard and to present his case.·In the absence of jurisdictional error Mr Reihana’s applications should be dismissed.Consideration Pursuant to the Act, appeals from decisions of the Fair Work Commission can be heard by a Full Bench, in the way of a rehearing (ss 605, 607 and 614). There is no appeal from a decision of the Fair Work Commission (sitting as either a single member or the Full Bench) to this Court, however judicial review of decisions of the Fair Work Commission is available pursuant to s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth). It is in this context that Mr Reihana asks the Court to set aside the decision of the Full Bench of the Fair Work Commission, and has sought orders in the nature of prerogative writs, as well as certain orders against the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission.