Regis Resources Limited v Cleary in Her Capacity as Mining Warden

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CHAMBERS

CITATION:   REGIS RESOURCES LIMITED -v- CLEARY IN HER CAPACITY AS MINING WARDEN [2024] WASC 427

CORAM:   SOLOMON J

HEARD:   19 MARCH 2024

DELIVERED          :   19 NOVEMBER 2024

FILE NO:   CIV 1622 of 2023

BETWEEN:   REGIS RESOURCES LIMITED

Applicant

AND

THE HONOURABLE GENEVIEVE MARIE CLEARY IN HER CAPACITY AS MINING WARDEN

Respondent

WILLIAM ROBERT RICHMOND

Other Party


Catchwords:

Mining Act s 102 – proper construction – Whether Warden and Minister can have regard to conduct prior to grant of tenement – Whether declaration should be made – Objects of Mining Act – Relevance of applicant for exemption from expenditure circumventing objects of the Mining Act – Whether Warden erred in concluding that a positive finding is required that applicant did not circumvent objects of the Act before granting exemption from expenditure – Whether Warden afforded the applicant procedural fairness – Whether Warden's reasons were irrational or illogical

Legislation:

Mining Act 1978 (WA), s 57, s 102, s 111A, s 115A(4)

Result:

Ground 1 upheld
Grounds 2 and 3 rejected
No declaration made
Matter should be remitted back to the Warden

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : S K Dharmananda SC & B Dalitz
Respondent : No appearance
Other Party : E M Heenan SC & J Winton

Solicitors:

Applicant : DLA Piper Australia - Perth
Respondent : State Solicitor's Office
Other Party : Kavenagh Legal

Cases referred to in decision:

Capital Territory Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576

Devant Pty Ltd v Minister for Mines (Unreported, Supreme Court of Western Australia, Kennedy, Pidgeon and Steytler JJ, 18 December 1996)

Haoma Mining NL v Tunza Holdings Pty Ltd [2006] WASCA 19; 31 WAR 270

Hossain v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] HCA 34; (2018) 264 CLR 123

Jankovic v Minister for Imitation and Ethnic Affairs (1995) 56 FCR 474

Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8; 101 CLR 298

Medical Board of Australia v Arunkalaivanan [2023] WASCA 117

Nathanson v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] HCA 26; 276 CLR 80

Re Minister for Resources; Ex parte Cazaly Iron Pty Ltd [2007] WASCA 175; 34 WAR 403

Regis Resources Limited v Richmond [2023] WAMW 5

Samad v District Court of NSW [2002] HCA 24

Siberia Mining Corporation Pty Ltd v O'Sullivan [2020] WASC 214

SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2006] HCA 63; 228 CLR 152

Thompson v Siberia Mining [2021] WASCA 115

Yarri Mining v Eagelfield Holdings [2010] WASCA 132; 41 WAR 134

SOLOMON J:

  1. On 8 March 2023 (supplemented on 19 April 2023), the respondent in her capacity as Warden published reasons and made orders (Decision)[1] recommending to the minister (Minister) the refusal of the applicant's (Regis) applications for exemption from expenditure conditions under s 102 of the Mining Act 1978 (WA) (Act). In this proceeding, Regis seeks judicial review of the Decision, and an order quashing the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Regis Resources Limited v Cleary in Her Capacity as Mining W... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] WASC 427
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Regis Resources Limited v Cleary in Her Capacity as Mining Warden, the applicant, Regis Resources Limited, sought judicial review of a decision made by the respondent, who was the Mining Warden at the time. Regis applied for an exemption from expenditure conditions under section 102 of the Mining Act 1978 (WA). The Warden recommended to the Minister to refuse Regis's applications for exemption, and this recommendation was the subject of Regis's application for review. Regis argued that the Warden and the Minister should not consider conduct prior to the grant of the tenement when deciding on an exemption under section 102 of the Act. The court was tasked with determining whether the Warden and Minister could consider pre-grant conduct, and if the Warden's decision was procedurally fair and rational.

The central legal issue was whether the Warden and Minister could take into account conduct that occurred before the grant of the tenement when deciding on an application for exemption under section 102 of the Mining Act. Additionally, the court had to consider if the Warden's decision-making process was procedurally fair to Regis and whether the Warden's reasons were rational and logical. Regis contended that the Warden should not have considered pre-grant conduct and that her decision was irrational. The Warden argued that pre-grant conduct was relevant to assessing an applicant's capacity and willingness to undertake work on the tenement, which was in line with the Act's objects.

The court held that the Warden and Minister could consider pre-grant conduct when deciding on an exemption under section 102 of the Mining Act. The court reasoned that the broad discretion conferred by section 102 must be exercised in light of the Act's objects, which include promoting prospecting and exploration and ensuring that mining tenement holders carry out work on or in relation to the tenement. The court found that the Warden's consideration of pre-grant conduct was appropriate, as it was relevant to assessing an applicant's capacity and willingness to undertake work on the tenement, which aligned with the Act's objects. The court rejected Regis's argument that pre-grant conduct should be disregarded, as it did not undermine the objects of the Act or discourage expenditure. The court also found that the Warden's decision-making process was procedurally fair and that her reasons were rational and logical.

The court concluded that the Warden's decision to recommend the refusal of Regis's applications for exemption was valid, and therefore, the application for judicial review was dismissed. The court did not find it necessary to make any further orders beyond affirming the Warden's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 8 March 2023 (supplemented on 19 April 2023), the respondent in her capacity as Warden published reasons and made orders (Decision)[1] recommending to the minister (Minister) the refusal of the applicant's (Regis) applications for exemption from expenditure conditions under s 102 of the Mining Act 1978 (WA) (Act). In this proceeding, Regis seeks judicial review of the Decision, and an order quashing the recommendation of the learned Warden. Regis also seeks a declaration that the applicant's conduct prior to the grant of a tenement, to which s 57 and s 111A of the Act could apply, is not relevant to the Warden's function, nor the Minister's discretion to grant an exemption for that tenement under s 102 of the Act. There is no dispute that the Decision is amenable to judicial review on the grounds advanced. [1] See Regis Resources Limited v Richmond [2023] WAMW 5. References in these reasons to statutory provisions are references to the Act, unless otherwise indicated. Regis is a publicly listed company on the Australian Stock Exchange and carries on business as a gold mining and exploration company. In this application, the evidence was constituted by a single affidavit, being that of Louise Holland affirmed on 23 August 2023 (Holland Affidavit). Between 5 October 2020 and 1 July 2021 Regis applied under s 102(1) for a certificate of exemption from the prescribed expenditure conditions to be granted over 10 mining tenements, being a combination of exploration and prospecting licences. Each of the tenements was part of a group of tenements approved under s 115A(4) for combined exploration reports to be filed. The applications were made under s 102(2)(h) on the basis that the aggregate expenditure for the combined reporting tenements would satisfy the expenditure requirements had the aggregate expenditure been apportioned between the tenements in the group. It was agreed between the parties that the aggregate expenditure would in fact have satisfied the expenditure requirements had it been apportioned between the tenements in the group. The applications for exemption were the subject of objection by the other party (Mr Richmond). Mr Richmond contended that even if the requirements of s 102(2)(h) were met, the exemptions should be refused. The relevant focus of Mr Richmond's position was his allegation that Regis had engaged in 'warehousing' of the tenements in a manner that was inconsistent with the underlying policy of the Act that land open for mining should be utilised. Mr Richmond alleged a course of conduct designed to retain control of tenements without carrying out exploration involving collusion with third parties, strategic surrenders and withdrawals of applications. The learned Warden heard the applications on 23 May 2022 and on 8 March 2023 delivered the Decision recommending that the Minister refuse the applications, and brief supplementary reasons and orders on 19 April 2023. To give adequate context to the Decision and the grounds of this application, it is necessary to summarise some aspects of the case presented to the learned Warden. The applications for exemption were initially each based upon each of the grounds in s 102(2)(a) ‑ (h) and upon s 102(3). The objections were initially cast in the broadest of terms: 'There is no valid reason why an exemption should be granted'. In due course, by the provision of particulars,[2] Regis refined its application to rely upon s 102(h). Mr Richmond further particularised his objection. By his provision of particulars,[3] Mr Richmond's objections included the following:(1)Mr Richmond alleged that there was no evidence of any work having been undertaken on the land; and(2)Mr Richmond did not admit that Regis had satisfied the requirements of s 102(h) (although at the hearing this was not contested). Mr Richmond asserted the application for exemption should nevertheless not be granted because Regis had enjoyed more than sufficient time to explore the land. Under the heading 'Warehousing of tenure', Mr Richmond provided details of various transactions and dealings in respect of the land the subject of the tenements. In light of this, Mr Richmond contended that an inference ought to be drawn that various entities had been holding the land through other tenements for Regis's benefit, thus in effect, allowing Regis to maintain its control over the land without meeting the expenditure requirements of the Act. Much of that detail concerned conduct prior to the grant to Regis of the tenements the subject of its applications for exemption.[2] Holland Affidavit, LDH‑15, LDH‑16, LDH‑17.[3] Holland Affidavit, LDH‑18, LDH‑19, LDH‑20.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Notwithstanding its breadth, the discretion conferred by s 102 is not untrammelled. It is necessarily confined by the matter, scope and purpose of the Act.[40] As noted above, the primary purpose or object of the Act is to encourage and promote the prospecting and exploration and that persons who secure a mining tenement should carry out work on or in relation to the tenement if they are to retain title. The parameters of the statutory discretion conferred by s 102 are to be understood in light of that object.[40] See Siberia Mining Corporation Pty Ltd v O'Sullivan [2020] WASC 214[67], and the authorities cited at footnote 59 therein. In my view, taking account of the broad power arising from the text of s 102 and the primary purpose of the Act, it is appropriate for the Warden and the Minister to have regard to conduct of an applicant that may bear upon the applicant's capacity or willingness to undertake expenditure and work on the tenement. There is nothing in the text or the objects of the Act that would mandate limiting that consideration to conduct following the grant of the tenement. On the contrary, both the unconstrained terms of the text of the statute and the well‑established objects suggest that a pre‑grant history of non‑compliance or collusive conduct to circumvent the Act's objects is a matter that the Warden and the Minister may appropriately take into account. I do not accept that the textual indicators referred to by Regis or the decision in Yarri Mining v Eagelfield Holdings lead to a different conclusion. It may be accepted that the statutory power expressed in the provisions regarding the grant of tenements is cast in wider terms than s 102. However, there is nothing in the statutory text that renders impermissible the consideration of pre‑grant conduct. Nor do I accept that such conduct cannot be rationally connected with an assessment of an applicant's likely conduct following the grant of a tenement. I also do not accept that the ability to consider conduct prior to the grant of the tenement undermines the objects of the Act by discouraging expenditure because it would reduce a tenement holder's security of title. The statutory provisions reflect a balance in the objects of the Act, promoting the utilisation of land open for mining while providing reasonable opportunity to hold land in circumstances where work and expenditure can justifiably be excused for a finite period. That balance is not compromised by allowing the Warden and the Minister to have regard to the past conduct of an application for expenditure, whether that be before or after the grant of the tenement the subject of the application for exemption. In my view, the reasons of McLure P in Yarra Mining v Eaglefield Holdings do not serve to advance the construction pressed by Regis. The court in that matter was concerned with the impact on the validity of title where a tenement was granted following an application made in contravention of an express prohibition contained in the Act. The decision does not stand as general authority for the proposition that conduct prior to the grant must be disregarded in an application for exemption under s 102.