REGINA v Chami, M Skaf, Ghanem, B Skaf

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

CITATION:      REGINA v  CHAMI, M SKAF, GHANEM, B SKAF [2004]  NSWCCA 36 revised - 29/04/2004

FILE NUMBER(S):
60314/03
60323/03
60181/03
60402/03

HEARING DATE(S):               20, 21 and 22 October 2003

JUDGMENT DATE: 07/04/2004

PARTIES:
REGINA
Mahmoud CHAMI
Mohammed SKAF
Mohamed GHANEM
Bilal SKAF

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Wood CJ at CL Sully J   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: District Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          DC 01/11/1201, 01/11/0901,
01/11/0974, 01/11/1188

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Finnane DCJ

COUNSEL:
Crown:  D Frearson/ D Arnott
Appellant: (M Chami) P Byrne SC
Appellant: (M Skaf) S Odgers SC/ H Dhanji
Appellant: (M Ghanem) T A Game SC/ M Buscombe
Appellant: (B Skaf) P Zahra SC

SOLICITORS:
Crown: S Kavanagh (Director of Public Prosecutions)
Appellant: (M Chami) Andrews
Appellant: (M Skaf) W H O'Brien
Appellant: (M Ghanem) Murphys Lawyers
Appellant: (B Skaf) Galloways

CATCHWORDS:
Criminal law - sexual offences - refusal to order separate trial - late disclosure of witness statement of co-offender - identification issues - directions as to consciousness of guilt - prosecutor's comment on accused's failure to give evidence - directions on standard of proof - "beyond reasonable doubt" should not be enlarged upon - complainant's reliability - directions about lies - whether verdicts unreasonable.
(D)

LEGISLATION CITED:
Evidence Act, ss 20(2), 44, 135, 137

DECISION:
Mahmoud Chami: Appeal dismissed
Bilal Skaf: Appeal dismissed
Mohammed Skaf: Appeal dismissed
Mohamed Ghanem: Appeal allowed - new trial ordered

JUDGMENT:

IN THE COURT OF
CRIMINAL APPEAL

CCA 60314 of 2003
CCA 60323 of 2003
CCA 60181 of 2003
CCA 60402 of 2003
DC 01/11/1201
DC 01/11/0901
DC 01/11/0974
DC 01/11/1188

MASON P
WOOD CJ at CL
SULLY J

Wednesday 7 April 2004

REGINA v Mahmoud CHAMI
REGINA v Mohammed SKAF
REGINA v Mohamed GHANEM
REGINA v Bilal SKAF

SUMMARY

The appellants appeal against convictions following their joint trial in the District Court before Judge Michael Finnane QC and a jury.  The jury returned guilty verdicts on most of the Counts each appellant was charged with.

The charges relate to a series of sexual assaults at various locations in south western Sydney that occurred in the evening of 30 August 2000.  The victim of these assaults was Ms T, then aged 18.  The appellants were aged between 17 and 18.  The offences took place at the Marion Street car park toilet block, the car park of the Bankstown Trotting Club and an industrial estate at Chullora.

  1. GROUNDS OF APPEAL

MOHAMED GHANEM was charged and convicted of one count of detain for sexual advantage and four counts of aggravated sexual intercourse without consent.  He was convicted on three of these counts and the trial judge directed a verdict of not guilty on the fourth charge. 

He argued seven grounds of appeal (see page 30 for each ground of appeal) including that Judge Finnane should not have allowed telephone intercept evidence to be admitted (Ground 3); and that his directions concerning this evidence were wrong (Ground 4).  He also argued that he should have had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read REGINA v Chami, M Skaf, Ghanem, B Skaf and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCCA 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Regina v Chami, M Skaf, Ghanem, B Skaf was heard in the Court of Appeal of Australia, where the appellants contested their convictions for various sexual offences. The dispute revolved around the adequacy of evidence presented, the handling of witness statements, and the appropriateness of directions given by the trial judge. The appellants argued that the trial judge erred in several respects, including the refusal to order a separate trial, the late disclosure of a co-offender's witness statement, and issues surrounding the identification of the accused and the standard of proof.

The legal issues before the court included whether the trial judge's refusal to order a separate trial was correct, whether the late disclosure of a co-offender's witness statement warranted a mistrial, and whether the judge's directions to the jury on various matters, including the standard of proof and the reliability of the complainant, were appropriate. The court was also asked to consider whether the prosecutor's comments on the appellants' failure to give evidence, and the judge's directions regarding the standard of proof and lies, were prejudicial.

The court found that the trial judge's refusal to order a separate trial was correct, as the evidence against the appellants was largely independent and there was no real risk of prejudice. The late disclosure of the co-offender's witness statement did not warrant a mistrial, as the appellants had not been misled or denied a fair opportunity to respond. The court also determined that the judge's directions to the jury, including those on the standard of proof and the reliability of the complainant, were appropriate. The prosecutor's comments and the judge's directions on consciousness of guilt and lies did not amount to error, and the verdicts were not unreasonable or unsafe.

The final orders of the court were to dismiss the appeals of all four appellants, affirming their convictions for the sexual offences.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Vital pieces of corroborative evidence locating Mohammed Skaf at the industrial complex related to his operation of the complainant’s mobile phone there (using his SIM card), his returning the phone to her there and his making a call to the complainant while she was in the black car being driven from the industrial complex to Lidcombe station after the final assaults (see below).Mobile phone evidence There was a body of documentary and oral evidence tendered to show that phone calls or text messages were sent on the evening in question by the complainant, and by and between young men (including the appellants) involved that evening. Such evidence was also tendered to show the use that Mohammed Skaf made of the complainant’s phone that he took from her. See Ex C2, C23-C31, C35-36 and the evidence of the witnesses Porta, Walke, Dagg, Stark, Hayes and Simmons. Each appellant had each other’s names and numbers stored in the memory of his own phone(s). The Skaf brothers also had the name and number of Tayyab Sheikh. Tayyab Sheikh had the names and numbers of Bilal and Mohammed Skaf as well as Ghanem. “H” had Mohammed Skaf, Tayyab Sheikh and the name and number of the complainant listed. As indicated, the complainant said that Mohammed Skaf took her telephone shortly after their arrival at Bankstown Station. The SIM card from that phone was given back to her by H shortly after she got into the first black car at Bankstown. H had been seen to get it back from Mohammed Skaf. Mohammed Skaf’s SIM card was used in her phone from the Chullora industrial estate area until the phone itself was returned to her there shortly before she was released. On her evidence it was given back to her from the man she identified as Mohammed Skaf who had worn the yellow jumper. The complainant’s evidence was firm that it was “the person with the yellow jumper [who] had returned” (Tr p88) and who committed further offences at the industrial estate. She said that he was the person who had assaulted her in the toilet and that she first met him on the train. She corroborated this by reference to hearing the ring tone of her own phone (“Real Slim Shady” by Eminem) when she was at that location (Tr p88) and by her evidence that the phone that Mohammed Skaf had taken from her at Bankstown was returned to her by him at the industrial estate. Evidence from witnesses employed by Vodafone produced maps (Exx C30, C36 and C39) showing various sectors. Technical evidence was able to demonstrate that particular phone calls were made to and from persons using phones in particular sectors. The critical sector evidence related to calls made or received within the Greenacre cell (2116), that included sectors 21163 and 21168. Sector 21163 served calls made to or from the area that included Valentia Street, the home of Bilal and Mohammed Skaf. Sector 21168 served calls made to or from the Chullora industrial complex. This evidence produced the following information (quoting from the Crown’s amended summary of trial):In respect of 0415 681 064 (the mobile of Mohammed Skaf)•Calls were made from within the 21163 sector at 7:23pm (to Vodafone), 7:24pm and 7:44pm (to Bilal Skaf on 0414 076 468) and at 8:28pm (to Ali Skaf on 0415 889 122).•Calls were made from within the 21168 sector at 8:34pm (to Bilal Skaf on 0414 076 468), at 8:39pm and 8:40pm (to Vodafone) and at 9:03pm (to “H” on 0404 227 642).•Calls were made from within the 21163 sector at 10:04pm (to Ali Skaf on 0415 889 122), 11:06pm (to 0404 155 188) and at 11:11pm (to Tayyab Sheikh on 0415 681 052).The evidence of Justin Stark was that there had been a change in the IMEI identification number for Mohammed Skaf’s SIM card from 7:23pm to 9:03pm on 30 August 2000 (exhibit C31). The IMEI number during this time (and only in this period) matched the number of the complainant’s mobile phone handset. This indicated that the SIM card from Mohammed Skaf’s mobile phone was placed into the complainant’s mobile phone handset for that period of time. Afterwards the IMEI number reverted to Mohammed Skaf’s mobile phone handset.The Crown relied on this evidence to show that Mohammed Skaf had not left after the incident in the toilet block in the Marion Street car park, as he had claimed to police in his final interview on 13 November 2000.In respect of 0414 076 468 (the mobile phone of Bilal Skaf):•A call was made from within the 21168 sector at 6:44pm (to “H” on 0404 227 642).•A call was made to “H” from another sector (28633) at 6:59pm. This was from the Centenary Drive cell.•A call was made from within the 21163 sector at 8:33pm (to Vodafone), though in cross-examination Simmons said that the network may have taken this call on the 900 frequency even though the caller was within the 21168 sector because the duration of the call was short and the network may not have had time to react and place the call on the 1800 frequency.•At 9:02pm there was a text message sent to Ali Skaf on 0415 889 122.•Calls were made from within the 21168 sector at 9:02pm and 9:09pm (to Ali Skaf on 0415 889 122) and at 9:58pm and at 10:37pm (to Nina on 0404 076 763, who was listed in his phone as his girlfriend).•At 9:24pm there was a call to 9703 1468 (the house of Bilal and Mohammed Skaf) from the Chullora cell. This was in sector 22752, which was the same sector in which Ghanem and Chami resided. The Crown relied on this to show that he was involved in dropping his co-offenders home.•Calls were made from within the 21163 sector at 10:17pm and 10:44pm (to Mohammed Skaf on 0415 681 064) and at 10:45pm (to Nina on 0404 076 763)…The records also showed a text message from the mobile of Ghanem to Chami at 5:41pm, calls from the mobile of Chami to the mobile of Bilal Skaf at 3:49pm (from Bankstown), to the mobile of Ghanem at 5:50pm and to the mobile of Bilal Skaf at 6:17 (from South Strathfield).In respect of 0404 227 642 (the mobile of “H”) the phone records (exhibits C2 and C26) showed a series of calls from 9:07pm through to 12:42am from his phone to Bilal Skaf, Mohammed Skaf, Tayyab Sheikh and Tahir Sheikh. The phone records also showed that the complainant’s mobile phone was called from the mobile of “H” twice at 10:30pm on 30 August 2000, and again at 12:28am, 10:32am, 11:55am and at 10:43pm on 31 August 2000.Grounds of appeal

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.