Reches Pty Limited v Tadiran Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Reches Pty Limited v Tadiran Limited [2001] FCA 1486

CONTEMPT – penalty for breach of undertaking to the Court – where contemnors believed other party not intending to rely on the undertaking – where contemnors insolvent.

RECHES PTY LIMITED V TADIRAN LIMITED

NG 606 OF 1996

MOORE J

24 OCTOBER 2001
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 606 OF 1996

BETWEEN:

RECHES PTY LIMITED
APPLICANT

AND:

TADIRAN LIMITED
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 OCTOBER 2001

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        Save for the orders made on 11 April 2001, the application otherwise be dismissed.

2.Mr Isaac Reches and Mrs Yael Reches be jointly and severally liable to pay the costs of the Registrar of prosecuting the contempt proceedings.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 606 OF 1996

BETWEEN:

RECHES PTY LIMITED
APPLICANT

AND:

TADIRAN LIMITED
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MOORE J

DATE:

24 OCTOBER 2001

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. On 11 April 2001 I gave judgment in this matter and declared that Mr Isaac and Mrs Yael Reches had committed a contempt of court.  No orders as to penalty were made.  Rather the matter was stood over until 27 April 2001 to enable the parties to make submissions on penalty.  This occurred on 27 April and 19 July 2001 (Mrs Reches was overseas on the first occasion).

    Background

  2. The Reches committed a contempt by breaching an undertaking to the Court. The undertaking was given on 16 July 1998 and accepted by the Court on 20 July 1998. The Reches breached it by removing from unit 12/442 Edgecliff Road, Edgecliff, New South Wales property listed in the schedule to the bill of sale attached to the undertaking. The undertaking was intended to establish a mechanism for the Reches to provide $120,000 as security for costs in the action of Reches Pty Ltd against Tadiran Ltd (“Tadiran’”). The circumstances in which that undertaking was given and subsequently breached are detailed in the reasons for judgment of 11 April 2001: [2001] FCA 415.

  3. The evidence led by both parties at a hearing on 3 April 2001 was relied on, in so far as it was relevant, both in relation to the question of whether the Reches had breached the undertaking and, in the event it was found they had, in relation to the question of penalty.  Further evidence was adduced by Mr Reches in an affidavit sworn by him on 23 April 2001 on which he was cross-examined on 27 April 2001 and by Mrs Reches in an affidavit sworn by her on 10 July 2001 on which she was cross-examined on 19 July 2001.

    The primary evidence

  4. It has never been in issue that the Reches disposed of property in a manner inconsistent with the undertaking given by them to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Reches Pty Limited v Tadiran Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] FCA 1486
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Reches Pty Limited v Tadiran Limited involved the Reches, Mr Isaac and Mrs Yael, who were found to have committed a contempt of court by breaching an undertaking they had given to the Court. The matter was initially brought before the court on 11 April 2001, where it was declared that the Reches had committed contempt without any penalty being imposed. The court stood over the matter to allow for submissions on penalty, which occurred on 27 April and 19 July 2001. The Reches breached their undertaking by removing property listed in the schedule to the bill of sale attached to the undertaking. The undertaking was intended to establish a mechanism for the Reches to provide $120,000 as security for costs in the action of Reches Pty Ltd against Tadiran Ltd.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Reches had indeed breached the undertaking and, if so, what the appropriate penalty should be. The court had to consider the evidence led by both parties, as well as the affidavits and cross-examinations of Mr and Mrs Reches. The primary evidence showed that the Reches had disposed of property inconsistent with the undertaking, but they claimed they believed they had been effectively released from the undertaking by Tadiran. The court had to weigh the Reches' account of their conversations with Tadiran’s general counsel against the correspondence between Tadiran and the Reches.

In its reasoning, the court found that the contempt committed by the Reches was serious, and their actions had rendered the benefit of the costs order made in Tadiran’s favour substantially illusory. The court acknowledged that there were mitigating factors, such as the Reches' belief that they had been released from the undertaking by Tadiran, but ultimately held that the Reches had acted with a cavalier approach to the court's undertaking. The court decided on a penalty that included the Reches being jointly and severally liable to pay the costs of the Registrar for prosecuting the contempt proceedings. The application was otherwise dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Save for the orders made on 11 April 2001, the application otherwise be dismissed.

2. Mr Isaac Reches and Mrs Yael Reches be jointly and severally liable to pay the costs of the Registrar of prosecuting the contempt proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 11 April 2001 I gave judgment in this matter and declared that Mr Isaac and Mrs Yael Reches had committed a contempt of court. No orders as to penalty were made. Rather the matter was stood over until 27 April 2001 to enable the parties to make submissions on penalty. This occurred on 27 April and 19 July 2001 (Mrs Reches was overseas on the first occasion). Background The Reches committed a contempt by breaching an undertaking to the Court. The undertaking was given on 16 July 1998 and accepted by the Court on 20 July 1998. The Reches breached it by removing from unit 12/442 Edgecliff Road, Edgecliff, New South Wales property listed in the schedule to the bill of sale attached to the undertaking. The undertaking was intended to establish a mechanism for the Reches to provide $120,000 as security for costs in the action of Reches Pty Ltd against Tadiran Ltd (“Tadiran’”). The circumstances in which that undertaking was given and subsequently breached are detailed in the reasons for judgment of 11 April 2001: [2001] FCA 415. The evidence led by both parties at a hearing on 3 April 2001 was relied on, in so far as it was relevant, both in relation to the question of whether the Reches had breached the undertaking and, in the event it was found they had, in relation to the question of penalty. Further evidence was adduced by Mr Reches in an affidavit sworn by him on 23 April 2001 on which he was cross-examined on 27 April 2001 and by Mrs Reches in an affidavit sworn by her on 10 July 2001 on which she was cross-examined on 19 July 2001. The primary evidence It has never been in issue that the Reches disposed of property in a manner inconsistent with the undertaking given by them to the Court. However the Reches have persistently claimed that, when they disposed of the property, they believed they had been effectively released from the undertaking by Tadiran. This belief apparently arose as a result of a series of conversations involving Mr Yakov Shulman, a past employee of Tadiran who had previously been Mr Reches’ primary contact point with the company. The Reches gave evidence, both in their affidavits and repeated orally, that following judgment against Reches Pty Ltd which included a costs order, the Reches contacted Shulman and asked him to approach Tadiran on their behalf with the aim of limiting their liability to pay costs. The Reches said that Shulman subsequently contacted Ms Layla Chertow, Tadiran’s general counsel, who assured Shulman that Tadiran was not interested in the Reches’ property secured by the undertaking. Tadiran only intended to seek payment of an amount of $25,000 paid into court by the Reches pursuant to the security for costs arrangement as satisfaction of their costs. Shulman, who the Reches regarded as a close personal friend, passed on this assurance to the Reches and repeated it on several occasions. As a result, the Reches considered themselves free to disperse the property that was the subject of the undertaking.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The evidence led by both parties at a hearing on 3 April 2001 was relied on, in so far as it was relevant, both in relation to the question of whether the Reches had breached the undertaking and, in the event it was found they had, in relation to the question of penalty. Further evidence was adduced by Mr Reches in an affidavit sworn by him on 23 April 2001 on which he was cross-examined on 27 April 2001 and by Mrs Reches in an affidavit sworn by her on 10 July 2001 on which she was cross-examined on 19 July 2001. The primary evidence It has never been in issue that the Reches disposed of property in a manner inconsistent with the undertaking given by them to the Court. However the Reches have persistently claimed that, when they disposed of the property, they believed they had been effectively released from the undertaking by Tadiran. This belief apparently arose as a result of a series of conversations involving Mr Yakov Shulman, a past employee of Tadiran who had previously been Mr Reches’ primary contact point with the company. The Reches gave evidence, both in their affidavits and repeated orally, that following judgment against Reches Pty Ltd which included a costs order, the Reches contacted Shulman and asked him to approach Tadiran on their behalf with the aim of limiting their liability to pay costs. The Reches said that Shulman subsequently contacted Ms Layla Chertow, Tadiran’s general counsel, who assured Shulman that Tadiran was not interested in the Reches’ property secured by the undertaking. Tadiran only intended to seek payment of an amount of $25,000 paid into court by the Reches pursuant to the security for costs arrangement as satisfaction of their costs. Shulman, who the Reches regarded as a close personal friend, passed on this assurance to the Reches and repeated it on several occasions. As a result, the Reches considered themselves free to disperse the property that was the subject of the undertaking. The Registrar took issue with this account. The Registrar adduced evidence of correspondence (which Mr Reches acknowledges receiving) in which Tadiran, through its Australian solicitors, sought satisfaction of the costs order against Reches Pty Ltd. One piece of correspondence, dated 16 November 1999 and addressed to Mr Reches personally, had attached to it a letter from Chertow (dated 15 November 1999) which stated that Tadiran had not changed its position in relation to the costs order and that Tadiran’s instructions to its Australian solicitors were to seek $100,000 as satisfaction of its costs. The letter said:“Mr. Philip BrandMarshall Marks Kennedy – LawyersFax. No: 00612 9950 2650Dear Philip,The letter is pretty amazing:1.Neither myself nor anyone in my department has ever spoken to Mr. Isaac Reches or anyone acting on his behalf.2.My instructions I have sent to you in writing and they have not been changed or revoked.Best regards,[signed]Layla Chertow, Adv.”This letter from Chertow was in response to a letter dated 8 November 1999 which Mr Reches had sent to Tadiran’s Australian solicitors. In the letter of 8 November Mr Reches wrote:“Advocate David Austin gave me your letter of 13/10/99. [demanding payment of the costs]I would like to advise that upon receiving the judgment, we got in touch with the legal department of Tadiran, and they advised us that the instructions given to you are to collect the $25,000 and not to take any further steps against us.Upon receiving your letter dated – 2/9/99, we again got in touch with the legal department of Tadiran, and they again advised that the instructions given to you have not been changed.Best regards,[signed]ISAAC RECHESManaging Director”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, counsel for the Registrar noted that although the property secured under the undertaking had been dispersed, none of the persons to whom it was given had a legal entitlement to it, and as such, it was asserted that there is no barrier to the Court making an order referrable to that property.Conclusion The contempt committed by the Reches was serious. Reches Pty Ltd has been unable to satisfy the costs order against it and, without recourse to the secured property, Tadiran is unlikely to recover any costs beyond the $25,000 paid into Court by the Reches. Although Tadiran’s costs have not been taxed, they would exceed that amount by a considerable margin. I am satisfied the Reches were aware when they disposed of the property that they had no other immediate means by which to satisfy the costs order made in Tadiran’s favour. In effect, the Reches were aware that their actions in disposing of the property would render as substantially illusory the benefit to Tadiran of the costs order. It was precisely that outcome that the security for costs arrangement ordered by this Court was designed to avoid and for which the undertaking was procured. The Reches have approached compliance with their undertaking with what could be described, at the very least, as a cavalier approach to this Court. They treated compliance with the undertaking as optional or discretionary. However, in determining the appropriate penalty, there are several mitigating factors which must, in my opinion, be taken into consideration. As noted already, the Reches have persistently submitted that Tadiran’s general counsel represented to them, through Shulman, that Tadiran had no interest in satisfying the costs order by forcing the sale of the property to which the undertaking related. I cannot, on the evidence, be affirmatively satisfied about the contents of representations Chertow actually made to Shulman concerning Tadiran’s intentions in respect of the secured property and the costs order which plainly would have impacted on what Shulman then told the Reches. I accept, up to a point, the submission of Mr Reches about the letters from Chertow. The letter of 15 November 1999 was an unequivocal denial by Chertow that she had spoken to Mr Reches or anyone acting on his behalf. It is clear, having regard to her later letter of 7 December 2000, that she had been speaking to Shulman. It is also clear that Shulman discussed with her matters of the type that are consistent with the Reches’ account of their conversations with Shulman. While I would not wish to overstate it, the general tenor of the later letter is not inconsistent with Chertow feeling some embarrassment and difficulty about explaining to Tadiran's Australian solicitors dealings she had had with Shulman which were inconsistent with her dealings with the solicitors. I am left with some real doubt about the contents of the discussions between Chertow and Shulman. Accordingly, I cannot discount the possibility that the Reches did have discussions with Shulman of the type the Reches gave evidence about.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the evidence presented by both parties to determine whether Mr Isaac and Mrs Yael Reches breached their undertaking to the court. It was clear that the Reches disposed of property in a manner inconsistent with their undertaking. The court also considered the Reches' claim that they believed they had been effectively released from the undertaking by Tadiran, based on conversations with Mr Yakov Shulman, a past employee of Tadiran. However, the court found that the Reches' claim was not supported by the evidence, as Tadiran had consistently sought satisfaction of the costs order against Reches Pty Ltd. The court held that the contempt committed by the Reches was serious, as it rendered the benefit of the costs order made in Tadiran's favour substantially illusory. However, the court acknowledged that there were mitigating factors, such as the possibility that the Reches genuinely believed they had been released from the undertaking by Tadiran. The court decided to stand the matter over to enable the parties to make submissions on penalty, and it was later determined that Mr Isaac and Mrs Yael Reches would be jointly and severally liable to pay the costs of the Registrar of prosecuting the contempt proceedings. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a party who breaches an undertaking to the court commits contempt of court, and the court may impose an appropriate penalty based on the circumstances of the case.