realT Properties Pty Ltd v Arete Real Estate Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

realT Properties Pty Ltd v Arete Real Estate Pty Ltd & Anor [2024] QDC 180

PARTIES:

realT Properties Pty Ltd

(plaintiff)

v
ARETE REAL ESTATE PTY LTD

(first defendant)

KAREN LEANNE MCDONALD

(second defendant)

FILE NO:

2691 of 2023

DIVISION:

Civil

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

12 November 2024

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

26 and 27 August 2024, 21 October 2024

JUDGE:

Kent KC DCJ

ORDER:

(a)   Leave given to the plaintiff to amend the claim and statement of claim adding a claim in debt, in accordance with the draft attached to the plaintiff’s supplementary submissions.

(b)  Judgment for the plaintiff on liability.

(c)   The parties are to be heard as to

(i)         Final assessment of quantum of the debt as reduced by the defendants’ claim for set off;

(ii)       Interest; and

(ii)      Costs.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACT – SALE OF RENT ROLL – Whether the first defendant lawfully terminated the contract – Where the defendant provided notice of termination before the date of completion – Whether the plaintiff performed its contractual obligations – Whether the plaintiff was in breach or there was anticipatory breach – Whether the plaintiff is entitled to specific performance or damages in the alternative – Where the defendant seeks to impute an implied term – Where the plaintiff seeks contractual remedies and seeks to add a claim in debt based on the same pleaded facts – Where the parties wish to be further heard on calculation of set off and the amount outstanding

LEGISLATION:

Property Occupations Act 2014 (Qld), ss 102, 113, 114, 133

CASES:

BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v Hastings Shire Council [1977] 180 CLR 266

Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW (1982) 149 CLR 337

Commonwealth v Amann Aviation Pty Ltd [1991] 174 CLR 64

Curran v Newpark Cinemas Ltd [1951] 1 All E.R. 295

Heiko Constructions Pty Ltd v Tyson (2020) 282 FCR 297

McDonald v Dennys Lascelles Ltd (1933) 48 CLR

Sunburnt Plaza Pty Ltd v Maloney [1988] 166 CLR 245

Szepesvary v Weston [2018] FCAFC 224

Young v Queensland Trustees Ltd (1956) 99 CLR 560

COUNSEL:

C. Martin for the plaintiff
S. Philippou for the defendants

SOLICITORS:

Law Shared Lawyers for the plaintiff
McCarthy Durie Lawyers for the defendants

Introduction

The contract

  1. The plaintiff claims for specific performance, alternatively damages in lieu thereof or in debt for failure to pay the purchase price concerning a contract for the sale of a rent roll. The plaintiff is a real estate agency which managed 46 properties on a rent roll and contracted to sell it to the first defendant on 15 May 2023. The second defendant is the sole director and secretary of the first defendant. Both defendants were parties to the contract, the second defendant agreeing by clause 14 to be liable for the first defendant’s due performance. Clause 15 provided for a 10 percent interest rate on outstanding purchase money.

  2. The contract provided for a 10…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read realT Properties Pty Ltd v Arete Real Estate Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QDC 180
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of realT Properties Pty Ltd v Arete Real Estate Pty Ltd involves a dispute between the plaintiff, a real estate agency, and the defendants, who had contracted to purchase a rent roll from the plaintiff. The dispute revolves around whether the defendants lawfully terminated the contract and whether the plaintiff was in breach or experienced anticipatory breach. The plaintiff sought specific performance or damages in the alternative, while the defendants attempted to impute an implied term. Additionally, the plaintiff sought contractual remedies and a claim in debt based on the same facts. The case reached the point where both parties wished to be heard on the calculation of set off and the amount outstanding.

The primary legal issues that the court had to address were whether the defendants had the right to terminate the contract due to an alleged breach by the plaintiff, whether there was an anticipatory breach, and whether the plaintiff was entitled to specific performance or damages. The court also had to consider whether an implied term could be added to the contract and if the plaintiff could add a claim in debt based on the same facts as the contractual claim. The evidence presented showed that the contract was conditional on the defendants being satisfied with their due diligence enquiries within 30 days, and that the defendants terminated the contract after learning that 11 of the 46 properties in the rent roll had given notice of revocation.

The court's reasoning concluded that the plaintiff was not in breach of the contract at the time of the purported termination, nor was there an anticipatory breach. The notices of revocation took effect after the completion date, and the plaintiff properly tendered performance. The court found that the defendants did not have a right to terminate the contract as at the date of the purported exercise of that right. The court also rejected the defendants' argument for an implied term, finding that the retention clause already provided for the possibility of some properties leaving the rent roll. The plaintiff was therefore successful on the issue of liability.

The orders made by the court included granting leave to the plaintiff to amend the claim and statement of claim to add a claim in debt. Judgment was entered in favour of the plaintiff on liability. The parties were to be heard on the final assessment of the quantum of the debt, reduced by the defendants' claim for set off, interest, and costs. This case highlights the importance of contractual clauses and the need for parties to carefully consider their obligations and rights under a contract.

Orders

Orders of the court

(a) Leave given to the plaintiff to amend the claim and statement of claim adding a claim in debt, in accordance with the draft attached to the plaintiff’s supplementary submissions.

(b) Judgment for the plaintiff on liability.

(c) The parties are to be heard as to

(i) Final assessment of quantum of the debt as reduced by the defendants’ claim for set off;

(ii) Interest; and

(ii) Costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Apart from the above issues in relation to liability, there are issues as to quantum and how it might be calculated.The evidence Many of the relevant facts are either uncontentious or agreed. The broad narrative is set out above. As at the date of the contract, the plaintiff held 46 appointments as property agent under the Property Occupations Act 2014 (Qld) (“the Act”). The contract was negotiated between the parties. Both were experienced in real estate and the first defendant had purchased rent rolls previously. The purchase price was arrived at by using a conventional multiplier of 2.9 to the income generated by the properties the subject of the rent roll. The result was an agreed purchase price of $278,574.04.Due diligence The agreement pursuant to Clause 5 was subject to and conditional on the first defendant being satisfied with its due diligence enquiries as to the rent roll within 30 days of the contract date. If the first defendant was not satisfied with its enquiries by 5:00pm on the stipulated date, then upon giving notice in writing thereof, the contract would be automatically at an end and all deposit monies paid were to be refunded. Clause 5(ii) provided that in the event the first defendant did not satisfy, waive or terminate the contract by the stipulated date, then the contract would be unconditional. The first defendant conducted its due diligence enquiries and confirmed (somewhat earlier than required) that it was satisfied therewith on 6 June 2023. The contract thereupon became unconditional. The parties agreed to change the completion date from 1 July 2023 to 30 June 2023. Notices of revocation As noted above, on 6 and 7 June 2023 several landlords gave the 30 days written notice of the revocation of their appointments of the plaintiff as their property agent. These related to 11 of the 46 appointments held by the plaintiff but did not take effect until about 6 and 7 July 2023. That is, the notices of revocation did not take effect until after the settlement date, and the plaintiff - on its case - still held 46 appointments as at 30 June. This relates to the plaintiff’s ability to complete.Defendants’ right to terminate The defendants were told of the notices concerning the 11 properties in a conversation between Nicole Dunn of the plaintiff and Amanda Thomas, an employee of the first defendant, on 14 June 2023. Broadly, Ms Dunn said that Rebecca Lane had “gone rogue” and given notice of resignation; she had contacted landlords and landlords had given notice of termination. Thus, the first defendant sent correspondence on 15 June terminating the contract based on what was said to be an anticipatory breach by the plaintiff because the matters stated by Ms Dunn constituted a declaration of inability to perform. This depends on the proposition that the transfer of properties contained in annexure A (a list of the 46 properties, which was intended to be, but was not, annexed to the contract) is an essential term going to the heart and purpose of the contract. It is said that the plaintiff was wholly and finally disabled from performing its contractual obligations (Sunburnt Plaza Pty Ltd v Maloney [1988] 166 CLR 245 at 262, 264 and 280). The defendants alternatively say that even if the appointments which had been terminated could be assigned, there was nevertheless an anticipatory breach because the words spoken gave rise to a reasonable inference that the plaintiff was unable to perform.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The retention clause provided for the possibility of some of the properties leaving the rent roll, with consequent adjustment of the price. The formula provides for an adjustment up to a maximum of ten percent. This was part of the contract negotiated between the parties. The plaintiff points out that the defendants were aware of this when they learned of the notices of revocation and that the negotiated adjustment was to provide for such a situation. Thus, in the plaintiff’s submission, there is no anticipatory breach: it was able to and did perform its obligations; and it appropriately tendered performance and is entitled to enforce its rights under the contract, including recovery of outstanding purchase money as a debt as discussed below.Conclusion as to defendants’ right to terminate My conclusions are that the plaintiff was not in breach of the contract at the time of the purported termination, nor was there an anticipatory breach. The notices of revocation, necessarily - pursuant to statute - taking the minimum 30 days notice period to take effect (i.e. after completion date), did not result in the plaintiff being unable to complete. The appointments were assigned under the Act and the plaintiff properly tendered performance. To the extent that the disappointing events following Ms Lane’s peremptory short notice resignation and her following actions impacted on the parties’ contractual relationship, the impact fell to be dealt with potentially in two ways: firstly, by the parties - including the defendants in a brief window after completion - being able to attempt to convince the landlords to reconsider; and, secondly, by the defendants being compensated under clause 10, which was the agreed mechanism to deal with such situations. For these reasons my conclusion is that the defendants did not have a right to terminate as at the date of the purported exercise of that right. Thus, the plaintiff succeeds on liability. The defendants should have paid the purchase price when due and did not do so.Implied termThe term contended for The defendants argue that clause 10 only applied to loss of management of properties after the date of completion, and thus not to the 11 properties under discussion. This comes about because the retention clause is said to apply from the date of completion to the day 180 days after completion. It is not quite clear what this means, but perhaps it is intended to refer to appointments where the notice of termination is only given after the date of completion. In the present circumstances - where the notices were given before completion - the defendants seek to rely on an implied term to the effect that “should any properties subject to the rent roll provide notice of termination prior to completion, the purchase price shall be reduced by the sum attributable to the price agreed for the subject property (a pre completion adjustment term)”. The point of this is to permit compensation for any appointments “lost” prior to completion (and thus, the defendants argue, not subject to the clause 10 adjustment). The compensation payable would be a sum equal to the purchase price paid for the lost appointment and would be additional to the adjustment under clause 10.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established