Re Zacek and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 473

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No V00/1276

GENERAL  ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION     )          
           Re      SANDRA ZACEK   
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mrs J.R. Dwyer, Senior Member

Date18 June 2002

PlaceMelbourne

Decision      1. The document identified as applicant's document "OO" is not received in evidence. 2. Annexures "B", "C", "D", "E" and "F" to Mrs Zacek's submissions of 26 October 2001 and the document headed "Background History" are not received into evidence. 3. The passage on page 9 of Mrs Zacek's submission, beginning with the words, "At a meeting" down to the bottom of the page is deleted from the submission on the ground that its inclusion would be in breach of s 34(3) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. 4.          The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the only documents or parts of documents which are "exempt documents" under the Freedom of Information Act 1982 are those as to which exemptions are shown as upheld in the following Schedule of Documents.

SCHEDULE OF EXEMPT DOCUMENTS

NO.     EXEMPTIONS          
A1       no exemption upheld – but to be released with deletions agreed to by the applicant namely: (i)          deletion of signature of officer checked on each page except p5; and (ii)    deletion of details of advance holder on pp4 and 5
A7       no exemption upheld 
A11     no exemption upheld 
A12     no exemption upheld 
B1       no exemption upheld 
C1      no exemption upheld 
D2      no exemption upheld 
D2.1    no exemption upheld 
D5      s36(1), s40(1)(c) and s41 exemption upheld for 8 lines on p4 constituting the fourth paragraph of notes of an interview with a respondent to the second complaint.   
D6      s40(1)(c) and s41(1) exemptions upheld for passage starting from first opening bracket in four lines above "ended 2.30" and finishing with the last closing bracket on those lines s40(1)(c) and s41(1) exemptions upheld for last line on p2.      
D7      s40(1)(c) and s41(1) exemptions upheld for last line only.   
D8      s36(1), s40(1)(c) and s41(1) exemptions upheld for two lines of the document below the time the interview ended. s40(1)(c) and s 41(1) exemptions upheld for the last two lines of the document.
D9      s40(1)(c) and s41(1) exemption upheld for two lines above line stating when interview ended.     
D10     s40(1)(c) and s41(1) exemption upheld for 6½ line paragraph on p1. s40(1)(c) and s41(1) exemption upheld for words in brackets on last line on p2.        
D12     no exemption upheld 
D25     s40(1)(c) and s 41(1) exemptions upheld in respect of 4th, 5th and 6th paragraphs on p1. s41(1) exemption upheld for third paragraph on p2.
D26     no exemption upheld 
D29     s41(1) exemption upheld for Ms Layton's home telephone number.          
D30     no exemption upheld 
D31     no exemption upheld 

(Sgd) Joan Dwyer

Senior Member

FORMAL MATTERS………………………………………………………………………..6
THE EVIDENCE……………………………………………………………………………..6
RULING AS TO ADMISSABILITY OF TRANSCRIPT OF CONVERSATION……….7
THE ADMISSABILITY OF THE DOCUMENTS ATTACHED TO MRS ZACEK'S WRITTEN SUBMISSION OF 26 OCTOBER 2001…………………………………….10
BACKGROUND FACTS………………………………………………………………….14
THE DOCUMENTS CLAIMED TO BE EXEMPT………………………………………17
THE FRAMEWORK OF THE…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Zacek and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 473
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involves Mrs Zacek, a former employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, and the Corporation itself, regarding the admissibility of certain documents under the Freedom of Information Act. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether specific documents were exempt from disclosure under the Act. The central issue before the Tribunal was whether the documents in question, which were identified by Australia Post as exempt, indeed qualified for such exemption under the Act. This involved assessing whether the documents contained personal information of a sensitive nature, or if their disclosure would cause unreasonable harm or embarrassment to individuals.

The Tribunal carefully considered the arguments presented by both parties. Mrs Zacek argued for the disclosure of the documents, while Australia Post contended that they were exempt due to the sensitive nature of the information contained within them. The Tribunal examined the content of the documents and the nature of the information they held. It concluded that while some of the documents contained personal information, their disclosure would not cause unreasonable harm or embarrassment to the individuals involved. Therefore, the Tribunal determined that not all of the documents claimed to be exempt by Australia Post were indeed exempt under the Act.

In its decision, the Tribunal upheld certain exemptions for specific documents but found that others were not exempt and should be disclosed. The Tribunal's ruling allowed Mrs Zacek access to the non-exempt documents, while protecting those that contained sensitive personal information from disclosure. The final orders specified which documents were exempt and which were not, thereby balancing the public's right to access information with the need to protect individuals' privacy and sensitive information.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have deleted from Mrs Zacek's submission all the attachments, except annexure A. I have also deleted the document headed Background History, and the second half of page 9, beginning with the words: "At a meeting" down to the bottom of the page. Further, Mr Batskos' submission, at paragraphs 2.14 and 2.15, that the matters stated in paragraphs 11.1 and 11.2 and 12 of Mrs Zacek's submission are not relevant to whether or not the documents in issue are exempt documents is clearly correct. However it is not necessary for those paragraphs to be deleted from the submission.BACKGROUND FACTS It is helpful to have some context in order to understand the discussion as to the issues for determination, namely whether or not certain documents are exempt documents under the Act. Because Mrs Zacek gave evidence only as to the issue of the admissibility of the document identified as "OO", there is no passage of evidence from which those facts may easily be taken. The respondent in its Statement of Facts and Contentions set out the Background Facts as follows:1.1The applicant is a former employee of the Australian Postal Corporation ("Australia Post"). The applicant was at all material times until December 1996 employed by Australia Post as a Postal Services Officer at the Northcote Plaza Retail Shop of Australia Post or at the Northcote Delivery Centre.1.2In November 1995, the applicant complained to Australia Post alleging that she had been subjected to harassment and discrimination by her co-workers at the Northcote Plaza Retail Shop which resulted in her suffering stress and anxiety ("first harassment complaint").1.3A Joint management/Union investigation team was formed in December 1995 to investigate the first harassment complaint. In January 1996 the inquiry into the applicant's first harassment complaint found that complaint not proven. However the inquiry found that the majority of other concerns of a non-harassment nature to be in favour of the applicant. The applicant complained about the manner in which the investigation was carried out and about the findings. (emphasis added)1.4In December 1995 and January 1996 the applicant also made some complaints to the Office of the Minister for Communications and the Arts, Hon Mr Michael Lee in relation to her first harassment complaint, its investigation and the tender processes followed at the Northcote Plaza Retail Shop for the awarding of a cleaning contract for those premises. There was a review conducted of the inquiry. The Deputy General Manager, Victoria and Tasmania, of Australia Post upheld the findings of the inquiry after that review of the inquiry but found even further instances of inappropriate management practices. (emphasis added)1.5Between late 1995 and early May 1996 the applicant was absent from work. After an initial decision by Australia Post to refuse compensation payments, that decision was overturned on internal review and the applicant received workers' compensation payments for the full period (including back payments).1.6In early May 1996 the applicant returned to work at the Northcote Delivery Centre, not the Northcote Plaza Retail Shop. Shortly after commencing the applicant made a complaint of harassment against three persons at the Northcote Delivery Centre. By a written formal complaint dated 29 May 1996 the matter was referred to the Australia Post State Discrimination Review Committee ("second harassment complaint").1.7A joint management/Union inquiry was conducted on behalf of the State Discrimination Review Committee. In July 1996 the State Discrimination Review Committee found the allegations of harassment not substantiated.1.8In about October 1996 the applicant lodged with the Equal Opportunity Commission of Victoria (as agent for the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission) a complaint alleging sex discrimination in employment in relation to both the first and second harassment complaints referred to above.1.9In December 1996 the applicant resigned from her employment with Australia Post.1.10In April 1998 the Equal Opportunity Commission formed the opinion that the applicant's complaint lacked substance and decided not to continue to inquire into the complaint. The applicant sought no review of that decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

After Mrs Zacek had lodged her application for review with this Tribunal, further documents covered by her request were located by Australia Post and some additional documents were released. During the pre-hearing period, a number of further releases were made. As at the commencement of the hearing on 8 October 2001, there were 37 documents in issue as set out in a Supplementary Further Amended Table of [claimed to be] Exempt Documents dated 8 October 2001 ("the Table"). The documents were identified by the prefix A, B, C or D, depending on the file to which they belonged.THE EVIDENCE Mrs Zacek appeared in person. Mr M. Batskos, a solicitor with FOI Solutions, appeared for Australia Post. The Tribunal had before it the documents ("the T documents") lodged pursuant to s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("the AAT Act") and the exhibits received in evidence. The exhibits included a bundle of documents lodged by Mrs Zacek together with her Statement of Facts and Contentions. Those documents were all taken in as exhibit A1 but were separately identified with the letters "A" to "NN" by the Tribunal, in accordance with dates and descriptions specified in Mrs Zacek's statement of facts. Mrs Zacek also sought to tender a transcript of a conversation she had with her former manager Mr Ritchie. The Tribunal identified that document as applicant's document "OO", but reserved its decision as to whether or not it would be received in evidence. Mrs Zacek also attached a number of documents to her final written submission. Mr Batskos, in his answering submission objected to the receipt of those documents, after the evidence in the matter had concluded. That matter also remains to be resolved. Evidence was given by Mrs Zacek, but only to the issue whether document "OO" should be admitted. Mrs Zacek called Ms Cholosznecki, Mr Rafferty and Ms Puri. The respondent called Mr Michael, Ms Dodgson and Mr Paolini. The Tribunal directed that the respondent present its case first, showing why it claimed that the documents in issue were exempt documents. The Tribunal also required, pursuant to s 64 of the Act, that the documents claimed to be exempt be produced for inspection by the Tribunal. Those documents were before the Tribunal.RULING AS TO ADMISSABILITY OF TRANSCRIPT OF CONVERSATION The document identified as applicant's document "OO" contains 13 typewritten pages certified by a fellow of the Institute of Legal Executives (Victoria) to have been transcribed to the best of her ability from a tape marked A". It also includes a handwritten note dated 21 August 2001 from Mrs Zacek to the Registrar and one page transcribed from a tape of another conversation. Mr Batskos prepared detailed written submissions on the issue of the admissibility of those documents. He addressed the Tribunal on the point at the close of evidence on 9 October 2001. Mrs Zacek also gave evidence that day as to when and how the conversation was taped. She said it was taped by her wearing a tape recorder when she arrived at work on Friday 17 May 1996. She said she was doing so in case she should find herself in a situation where she felt threatened by the actions of Mr Neville, who she had perceived to be acting in a threatening fashion on an earlier occasion. She said she had switched the tape on when she went into work so it was on while she had a conversation with her manager, Mr Ritchie.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As to s 41(1) of the Act, I am satisfied that there is no personal information in the document of a sensitive nature, such as to cause embarrassment or distress to the individuals named. I find that disclosure of the document would not involve the unreasonable disclosure of personal information about any person. CONCLUSION The applicant is entitled to have access to those documents which are not exempt documents under the Act. The exemptions upheld are as set out in the Table forming part of the decision in this matter.I certify that the 181 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Senior Member Joan Dwyer.Signed: Grace Carney AssociateDate/s of Hearing 8 and 9 October 2001 Date of Decision 18 June 2002Counsel for the Applicant Nil Solicitor for the Applicant Nil -Self Counsel for the Respondent Nil Solicitor for the Respondent Mr N Batskos, FOI Solutions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.