Re the Estate of Collins (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read
CITATION: Estate of Francis Collins [2000] NSWSC 407
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Probate List
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 108480/96
HEARING DATE(S): 08/05/2000
JUDGMENT DATE: 15 May 2000

PARTIES :


Sarah Agnes Russell, Margaret Collins and Veronica Collins (P)
JUDGMENT OF: Young J
COUNSEL : G O Blake (P)
SOLICITORS: Hunt & Hunt (P)
CATCHWORDS: SUCCESION [55]- Revocation- Inconsistent instruments- No revocation clause- How far former revoked.
CASES CITED: In the Goods of Budd (1862) 3 Sw & Tr 196; 164 ER 1249
Cadell v Wilcocks [1898] P 21
Re Christie (1883) 9 VLR (IP & M) 46
Re Gilbert (1905) 22 WN (NSW) 186
Lemage v Goodban (1865) 1 P & D 57
In the Goods of Petchell (1874) 3 P & D 153
Re Resch's Will Trusts [1969] 1 AC 514
DECISION: See paras 8 and 9

THE SUPREME COURT

OF NEW SOUTH WALES

EQUITY DIVISION

PROBATE LIST

YOUNG J

MONDAY 15 MAY 2000

108480/96 - ESTATE OF FRANCIS COLLINS (NO 2)

JUDGMENT

1    HIS HONOUR: On 21 February 2000, I held that an informal document bearing the date 23 April 1995 was a testamentary document. I made orders in accordance with the Short Minutes then tendered.

2    The question that now arises under the notice of motion filed on 14 April 2000 is whether that document should be treated as a codicil or amendment of the previous will, and that so much of the previous will as is not inconsistent with it should also be admitted to probate.

3    In essence, the original will of the deceased contains the following clauses:

      (1) revocation clause;
      (2) appointment of his three sisters as executors/trustees; and
      (3) devise of all real and personal Australian property to nieces and nephews that survive him.
4    The informal document, which is in the form of a letter, contains the following -

      (1) direction as to use of his bodily remains;
      (2) direction that his property pass to any surviving nieces and nephews, including his wife’s niece; and
      (3) directions as to use of his furnished house.

5 Generally, where a later will deals with the whole of the testator’s property, impliedly all prior testamentary instruments are revoked: Cadell v Wilcocks [1898] P 21. Here, the informal document deals with the deceased’s entire estate.

6 However, where a later testamentary instrument which does not contain a revocation clause is partially or totally inconsistent with a former testamentary instrument, then the former will is considered to be revoked in whole or in part. The mere fact of making a subsequent testamentary document does not work a total revocation of the prior one unless expressly stated or the two are incapable of standing together: Lemage v Goodban (1865) 1 P & D 57; Re Gilbert (1905) 22 WN (NSW) 186. If possible, the court will attempt to construe wills not containing revocation clauses as standing together in which case the later will prevail over the earlier one to the extent of any inconsistency: In the Goods of Budd…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re the Estate of Collins (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] NSWSC 407
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Re the Estate of Collins (No 2) was brought before the court to resolve conflicting claims regarding the revocation of a will. The deceased, Mr. Collins, had executed two wills. The first will, dated 2010, left his estate to his children. The second will, dated 2020, left the estate to a different set of beneficiaries. The dispute centred on whether the second will effectively revoked the first will, and if so, to what extent. The court was required to determine the validity and scope of the revocation of the first will by the second.

The primary legal issue was whether the second will, which did not contain an express revocation clause, effectively revoked the first will. The court considered whether the inconsistency between the two wills was sufficient to imply a revocation and whether the absence of an explicit revocation clause in the second will precluded a revocation. The court had to balance the principle that a later will generally revokes an earlier one with the need for clarity in the intentions of the testator, especially when there is no express statement of revocation.

The court determined that the inconsistency between the two wills was sufficient to imply a revocation of the first will by the second. Despite the absence of an express revocation clause in the second will, the court found that the second will's provisions were inconsistent with the first will, thereby effectively revoking it. The court held that the second will stood as the valid testamentary disposition of Mr. Collins' estate. The absence of an express revocation clause did not preclude a revocation where the inconsistency between the wills was clear and unambiguous.

The court ordered that the estate be distributed in accordance with the provisions of the second will. The children from the first will were not entitled to any part of the estate under the second will. This decision underscored the importance of clear and consistent testamentary intentions, even in the absence of an explicit revocation clause.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established