In the Estate of WINTER (DECEASED)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction: Application)

In the Estate of WINTER (DECEASED)

[2012] SASC 16

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Gray

9 February 2012

SUCCESSION - WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION - THE MAKING OF A WILL - EXECUTION - INFORMAL DOCUMENT INTENDED TO BE WILL - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - OTHER CASES

SUCCESSION - WILLS, PROBATE AND ADMINISTRATION - THE MAKING OF A WILL - REVOCATION - METHODS OF REVOCATION - OTHER WILLS, CODICILS OR WRITINGS

Referral from Registrar of Probates regarding which testamentary documents of the deceased should be admitted to probate - the deceased executed a formal will in 1999, bequeathing the residuary of her estate equally to her two nephews, her niece and the Holy Cross Lutheran Church Murray Bridge Inc. - a first, formal codicil was executed in 2002, not altering the residuary, but providing for a specific bequest of a dinner set and jewellery to the niece - a second, formal codicil was executed in 2006, revoking the residuary clause of the will and providing for the residue to be distributed equally to the two nephews and niece only - a third, informal document was executed in 2010, on its face bequeathing a cash sum to the Lutheran Community Care Services - where the 2010 document expressed to be an addendum to the last will of the deceased dated 5 December 2002, in circumstances where the last will of the deceased was dated 20 July 1999 and the first codicil dated 5 December 2002 - whether the 2010 document ought to be admitted to probate as a codicil to the will of the deceased pursuant to section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) as an informal codicil - whether the 2010 document impliedly revokes the second codicil, executed in 2006.

Consideration of principles regarding implied revocation of earlier testamentary documents.

Held: Document propounded contains testamentary intentions of the deceased - the deceased intended the document to constitute a codicil to her will - there is nothing in the document propounded, the surrounding circumstances or other evidence before the Court to give rise to an implication that the deceased intended to revoke the second codicil.

Probate Rules 2004 (SA) r 77; Wills Act 1936 (SA) s 3, s 8, s 12(2), s 12(3) and s 22, referred to.
In the Estate of Gall [2008] SASC 349; Re Estate of Gholam (decd) [2011] SASC 125; Re Estate of Davis (decd) [2011] SASC 143; Re Hennekam (2009) 104 SASR 289; Tsagouris v Bellairs [2010] SASC 147; In the Estate of Stewart Arthur Handfield [2010] SASC 22; In the Estate of Schwarzkopff (2006) 94 SASR 465; In the Estate of Torr (2005) 91 SASR 17; In the Estate of Williams (1984) 36 SASR 423; In the Estate of Kroemer (1988) 143 LSJS 160; In the Estate of EC Zimmerman (Unreported, Supreme Court of South Australia, Legoe J, 23 December 1992); In the Estate of Taylor…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of WINTER (DECEASED) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 16
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of the estate of Joyce Adela Winter (deceased), the court was presented with a complex issue regarding the admissibility of testamentary documents to probate. The deceased had executed a formal will in 1999, which was later amended by two formal codicils in 2002 and 2006, respectively. A further document, dated 2010, was executed, purportedly as an addendum to the will. The key legal issues before the court were whether the 2010 document should be admitted to probate as a codicil under section 12(2) of the Wills Act 1936 (SA) and whether this document impliedly revoked the second codicil of 2006.

The court examined the 2010 document and considered its content and the surrounding circumstances. The document was informal, lacking the formalities required for a codicil under the Wills Act 1936 (SA). However, the court recognised that informal documents may still be considered testamentary if they can be shown to express the deceased's intention to alter or revoke their will. In this case, the deceased had expressed a desire to leave a sum of money to a community service organisation conducted by the Lutheran Church. Brenton Watts, one of the executors, offered to draft a document to give effect to this wish, which the deceased agreed to sign. The court acknowledged the informal nature of the document but considered the surrounding circumstances and the absence of any apparent inconsistency with the previous codicils. Ultimately, the court found that there was insufficient evidence to imply that the deceased intended to revoke the second codicil or that the 2010 document should be admitted to probate as a codicil.

The court's reasoning was based on the principle that testamentary documents must be interpreted in light of the deceased's overall intentions and the surrounding circumstances. The court found that the 2010 document did not express an intention to revoke either the first or second codicil and that there was nothing in the document, surrounding circumstances, or other evidence before the court to give rise to an implication that the deceased intended to revoke either codicil. As a result, the court made orders that probate be granted to the will dated 20 July 1999 and the three codicils dated 5 December 2002, 12 October 2006, and 4 March 2010.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is a referral from the Registrar of Probates pursuant to rule 77 of the Probate Rules 2004 (SA), regarding which testamentary documents of the deceased should be admitted to probate. Factual Background The deceased, Joyce Adela Winter, died a spinster on 1 July 2010, aged 85 years. She died at a Resthaven facility in Murray Bridge, where she had moved to from her premises at Charles Street, Murray Bridge. The estate is modest, the net value being approximately $200,000.00. The deceased executed a formal will[1] on 20 July 1999. That will was prepared by solicitors. The will appoints as executors two of the deceased’s nephews, the applicants, Brenton Arthur Watts and Stephen John Watts. The will bequeaths the residuary of the deceased’s estate equally to those two nephews, to a niece of the deceased, Christine Anne Watts, and to the Holy Cross Lutheran Church Murray Bridge Inc. [1] That is, a will meeting the formal requirements of execution contained in section 8 of the Wills Act 1936 (SA). On 5 December 2002, the deceased executed a codicil to her will, confirming the will. The codicil was prepared by the same solicitors who prepared the 1999 will. The codicil does not alter the bequest regarding the residue of the estate, but provides for a specific bequest of the deceased’s dinner set and jewellery to her niece, Christine. On 12 October 2006, the deceased executed a second codicil to her 1999 will, confirming the will, but not making any reference to the 2002 codicil. The codicil was again prepared by solicitors. That codicil revokes clause 4 of the 1999 will, which clause bequeathed the residue of the estate to Brenton, Stephen, Christine and the Holy Cross Lutheran Church Murray Bridge Inc. The codicil provides for the residue of the estate to be divided equally between Brenton, Stephen and Christine only. Both the 2002 and 2006 codicils and the 1999 will are formal testamentary documents, executed in accordance with the formalities required by section 8 of the Wills Act 1936 (SA). By affidavit sworn on 10 September 2010, Brenton deposes to having visited the deceased at Resthaven at Murray Bridge on 26 February 2010, on which occasion the deceased expressed to Brenton the wish to leave the money in her Lutheran Laypersons League passbook account to a community service organisation conducted by the Lutheran Church. The balance of the account at that time was $5,577.10. Brenton deposed to having suggested to the deceased that she arrange for this to be done through her solicitors, to which she expressed a desire not to do so due to the expense involved. Brenton offered to draft a document which he called an “addendum” to the will, in order to give effect to the wish set out above. On that occasion, the deceased indicated that she would be happy to sign such a document. Brenton prepared the document which is relevantly in the following terms: To whom it may ConcernThis document is an addendum to my last will and testament of me, JOYCE ADELA WINTER…which bears the date of the 5th day December, Two thousand and Two. 1. I Direct that my said Will be varied by inserting after paragraph 2A thereof and substituting thereafter the following paragraph:-“2B: I BEQUEATH the sum of FIVE THOUSAND, FIVE HUNDRED and SEVENTY SEVEN DOLLARS and TEN CENTS ($5,577.10) to the LUTHERAN COMMUNITY CARE SERVICES, 309 Prospect Road, BLAIR ATHOL, SOUTH AUSTRALIA 5082, a DIVISION of the LUTHERAN LAYPEOPLES LEAGUE”.My account Number for the bequeath request is…Depositor’s Bank Account Book enclosed2. IN ALL other respects I confirm my said Will[Emphasis in original.]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Taking the whole of the circumstances into account and the matters to which I have already made reference, together with the fact that the codicils sit comfortably together, there being no apparent inconsistency, I do not consider there to be a sufficient intention to revoke the second codicil. The deceased in the third codicil does not express an intention to revoke either the first or the second codicil. There is nothing in the third codicil, surrounding circumstances or other evidence before the Court to give rise to an implication that the deceased intended to revoke either codicil. Conclusion In the above circumstances, I made orders that probate be granted to Brendan and Stephen Watts of the will dated 20 July 1999 and the three codicils dated respectively 5 December 2002, 12 October 2006 and 4 March 2010.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established