Re Stuart

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

MENTAL HEALTH COURT

CITATION:

Re Stuart [2015] QMHC 12

PARTIES:

REFERENCE BY THE DEFENDANT’S LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES IN RESPECT OF DEREK GEORGE STUART

FILE NO:

No 0234 of 2014

DELIVERED ON:

16 November 2015

DELIVERED AT:

Mental Health Court at Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

7 October 2015

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ASSISTING PSYCHIATRISTS:

Dr Reddan

Dr Sundin

ORDER:

1.   At the time of the alleged offence, the subject of the reference, the defendant was not of unsound mind as defined in the schedule to the Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld).

2.   The defendant is fit for trial.

3.   The proceedings against the defendant are to continue according to law.

4.   Copies of the reports and of the transcript are to be provided to the parties in the criminal proceedings.

CATCHWORDS:

MENTAL HEALTH - DECLARATION OR FINDING OF MENTAL ILLNESS OR INCAPACITY – where the defendant has a bilateral congenital hearing loss – where the defendant has a brain stem lesion – where the defendant has been diagnosed with Asperger’s Syndrome (now referred to as Autism Spectrum Disorder) – where the defendant has severe impairments in processing speech and recalling information – where the defendant was charged with unlawful stalking – whether the defendant was of unsound mind as at the date of the offence – whether the defendant is temporarily or permanently unfit for trial now

Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld)

Berg v Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld) [2015] QCA 196

R v Presser [1958] VR 45

COUNSEL:

P M Clohessy for the Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland)
S Dullaway for the Director of Forensic Disability
S J Hamlyn-Harris for the Director of Mental Health

J D Briggs for the Defendant

SOLICITORS:

Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Queensland)
Crown Law for the Director of Forensic Disability
Crown Law for the Director of Mental Health

Legal Aid Queensland for the Defendant

  1. BODDICE J: By Reference, filed 2 September 2014, the defendant’s legal representatives referred to this Court the mental condition of the defendant, Derek George Stuart, at the time of one charge of unlawful stalking, alleged to have occurred between 16 March 2014 and 4 April 2014.

  2. Although the question of soundness of mind was referred to this Court, it is accepted by all parties that there is such a dispute of fact within the meaning of s 268 of the Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld) such that this Court cannot make a determination as to the defendant’s soundness of mind as at the date of the index offence. At issue is whether the defendant is fit for trial.

    Background

  3. The defendant was born on 24 August 1983.  As at the date of the index offence, the defendant was 30 years of age.  The defendant is single and has no children.  The defendant drinks alcohol infrequently, and does not take illicit substances.  The defendant does not have any past criminal history.

  4. The defendant resided with his mother, father, elder sister and younger sister until he was 13, at which point his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Re Stuart and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QMHC 12
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Re Stuart, the Queensland Supreme Court was tasked with determining whether the defendant was fit to stand trial for the offence of unlawful stalking. The defendant, who had a bilateral congenital hearing loss, a brain stem lesion, and was diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder, had severe impairments in processing speech and recalling information. The central legal issues were whether the defendant was of unsound mind at the time of the offence and whether he was currently fit for trial. Given the complexity of the case and the dispute of fact regarding the defendant's mental state, the Court found it could not determine the defendant's soundness of mind at the time of the offence. However, the Court concluded that the defendant was fit for trial at the current time.

The Court examined the evidence provided by various medical professionals, including psychologists and psychiatrists, who provided conflicting opinions on the defendant's mental health. Despite the difficulties in reaching a consensus, the Court determined that the defendant's ability to understand the nature and object of the proceedings, to instruct counsel, and to participate in his defence, met the criteria for fitness to stand trial. The Court emphasised the importance of the defendant's current fitness, rather than his state at the time of the offence. The Court also noted the defendant's ability to engage in social interactions, albeit predominantly online, and his capacity to hold employment, albeit on a part-time basis.

Consequently, the Court found that the defendant was fit for trial. The Court ordered that the proceedings against the defendant would continue according to law, and directed that copies of the reports and transcript be provided to the parties involved in the criminal proceedings. This decision underscores the Court's focus on the defendant's present capacity to participate in the trial, rather than his past mental state.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. At the time of the alleged offence, the subject of the reference, the defendant was not of unsound mind as defined in the schedule to the Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld).

2. The defendant is fit for trial.

3. The proceedings against the defendant are to continue according to law.

4. Copies of the reports and of the transcript are to be provided to the parties in the criminal proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

Although the question of soundness of mind was referred to this Court, it is accepted by all parties that there is such a dispute of fact within the meaning of s 268 of the Mental Health Act 2000 (Qld) such that this Court cannot make a determination as to the defendant’s soundness of mind as at the date of the index offence. At issue is whether the defendant is fit for trial.Background The defendant was born on 24 August 1983. As at the date of the index offence, the defendant was 30 years of age. The defendant is single and has no children. The defendant drinks alcohol infrequently, and does not take illicit substances. The defendant does not have any past criminal history. The defendant resided with his mother, father, elder sister and younger sister until he was 13, at which point his parents separated and his father relocated to the United Kingdom. As a child, the defendant had difficulties socialising with other children. In 1997, when aged 14, the defendant was diagnosed with Asperger’s Syndrome (now referred to as Autistic Spectrum Disorder), although one of the reporting psychologists questions this diagnosis.[1][1] Exhibit 7: Report of Dr Lucille Douglas dated 8 June 2015, pages 4-5. In 2007, when the defendant was aged 20, his father offered to care for him in the United Kingdom. The defendant relocated but his relationship with his father and stepmother deteriorated, as did his mental health, and his mother arranged for him to return to Australia in 2009. The defendant apparently participated in some paid bar work while he was residing in the United Kingdom. However, the defendant has not been able to arrange full-time paid employment in Australia. The defendant is currently employed a few days a week delivering pamphlets. Gaining full-time employment is one of the defendant’s major personal goals. The defendant now lives by himself in a studio apartment in Chermside, which is provided as part of an affordable housing scheme. The only immediate family member the defendant maintains regular contact with is his mother. The defendant does have some contact with his younger sister. The defendant has not had contact with his older sister for many years. The defendant describes her as “emotionally unstable”;[2] she is apparently volatile, prone to tantrums and abuses other family members. The defendant was not aware of his older sister, nor any other family members, being formally diagnosed with any mental illnesses.[2] Exhibit 6: Report of Dr Mark Schramm dated 19 March 2015, page 7. The defendant lives a socially isolated life,[3] with much of his social interaction occurring on social networking or dating sites. The defendant’s mother reported that he posts inappropriate material on Facebook, including material which she considers “obscene”, sexually- and socially-inappropriate.[4] The defendant’s relationship with the complainant has been his only lasting romantic relationship. [3] Exhibit 8: Report of the Department of Communities, Child Safety and Disability Services dated 26 June 2015, page 3.[4] Exhibit 1: Report of Dr Michele Andrews dated 24 July 2014, page 3.Medical history

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established